This is not the most recent version of the article. View current version (21 AUG 2013)

Intervention Review

Midwife-led versus other models of care for childbearing women

  1. Marie Hatem2,
  2. Jane Sandall1,*,
  3. Declan Devane3,
  4. Hora Soltani4,
  5. Simon Gates5

Editorial Group: Cochrane Pregnancy and Childbirth Group

Published Online: 8 OCT 2008

Assessed as up-to-date: 2 MAY 2008

DOI: 10.1002/14651858.CD004667.pub2


How to Cite

Hatem M, Sandall J, Devane D, Soltani H, Gates S. Midwife-led versus other models of care for childbearing women. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2008, Issue 4. Art. No.: CD004667. DOI: 10.1002/14651858.CD004667.pub2.

Author Information

  1. 1

    King's College, Health and Social Care Research Division, London, UK

  2. 2

    Université de Montréal, Département de médecine sociale et préventive, Montréal, Québec, Canada

  3. 3

    National University of Ireland Galway, School of Nursing and Midwifery, Galway, Ireland

  4. 4

    Sheffield Hallam University, Faculty of Health and Wellbeing, Sheffield, UK

  5. 5

    Warwick Medical School, University of Warwick, Warwick Clinical Trials Unit, Coventry, UK

*Jane Sandall, Health and Social Care Research Division, King's College, Waterloo Bridge Wing, 150 Stamford Street, London, SE1 9NH, UK. jane.sandall@kcl.ac.uk.

Publication History

  1. Publication Status: Edited (no change to conclusions)
  2. Published Online: 8 OCT 2008

SEARCH

This is not the most recent version of the article. View current version (21 AUG 2013)

Cited in:

CrossRef

This article has been cited by:

  1. 1
    Cathryn M. Josif, Lesley Barclay, Sue Kruske, Sue Kildea, ‘No more strangers’: Investigating the experiences of women, midwives and others during the establishment of a new model of maternity care for remote dwelling aboriginal women in northern Australia, Midwifery, 2014, 30, 3, 317

    CrossRef

  2. 2
    Jenny Kelly, Roianne West, Jennifer Gamble, Mary Sidebotham, Vicki Carson, Elaine Duffy, ‘She knows how we feel’: Australian Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander childbearing women's experience of Continuity of Care with an Australian Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander midwifery student, Women and Birth, 2014, 27, 3, 157

    CrossRef

  3. 3
    Jenny Browne, Maureen O’Brien, Jan Taylor, Rebekah Bowman, Deborah Davis, ‘You've got it within you’: The political act of keeping a wellness focus in the antenatal time, Midwifery, 2014, 30, 4, 420

    CrossRef

  4. 4
    Jenny Browne, Penny J. Haora, Jan Taylor, Deborah L. Davis, “Continuity of care” experiences in midwifery education: Perspectives from diverse stakeholders, Nurse Education in Practice, 2014,

    CrossRef

  5. 5
    Yu Gao, Lisa Gold, Cath Josif, Sarah Bar-Zeev, Malinda Steenkamp, Lesley Barclay, Yuejen Zhao, Sally Tracy, Sue Kildea, A cost-consequences analysis of a Midwifery Group Practice for Aboriginal mothers and infants in the Top End of the Northern Territory, Australia, Midwifery, 2014, 30, 4, 447

    CrossRef

  6. 6
    Rose McCarthy, Janet Nuttall, Joyce Smith, Caroline J. Hollins Martin, A method of teaching critical care skills to undergraduate student midwives using the Maternal-Acute Illness Management (M-AIM) training day, Nurse Education in Practice, 2014,

    CrossRef

  7. 7
    Mandie Scamell, Childbirth Within the Risk Society, Sociology Compass, 2014, 8, 7
  8. 8
    Denis Walsh, Kerry Evans, Critical realism: An important theoretical perspective for midwifery research, Midwifery, 2014, 30, 1, e1

    CrossRef

  9. 9
    Erin Brock, Karen E. Charlton, Heather Yeatman, Identification and evaluation of models of antenatal care in Australia – A review of the evidence, Australian and New Zealand Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, 2014, 54, 4
  10. 10
    Eleni Hadjigeorgiou, Kirstie Coxon, In Cyprus, ‘midwifery is dying…’. A qualitative exploration of midwives' perceptions of their role as advocates for normal childbirth, Midwifery, 2014, 30, 9, 983

    CrossRef

  11. 11
    Shahnaz Anwar, Rafat Jan, Rahat Najam Qureshi, Salma Rattani, Perinatal women's perceptions about midwifery led model of care in secondary care hospitals in Karachi, Pakistan, Midwifery, 2014, 30, 3, e79

    CrossRef

  12. 12
    María del Rosario Ruiz, Joaquín T. Limonero, Professional attitudes towards normal childbirth in a shared care unit, Midwifery, 2014, 30, 7, 817

    CrossRef

  13. 13
    Mary G. Jenkins, Jane B. Ford, Angela L. Todd, Rowena Forsyth, Jonathan M. Morris, Christine L. Roberts, Women׳s views about maternity care: How do women conceptualise the process of continuity?, Midwifery, 2014,

    CrossRef

  14. 14
    William F. McCool, Mamie Guidera, Jaclyn Janis, ‘The Best Health Care Delivery System in the World’? Women's health and maternity/newborn care trends in Philadelphia, PA, United States—1997–2011: A case report, Midwifery, 2013, 29, 10, 1158

    CrossRef

  15. 15
    Maura Dowling, Michelle Beauchesne, Frances Farrelly, Kathy Murphy, Advanced practice nursing: A concept analysis, International Journal of Nursing Practice, 2013, 19, 2
  16. 16
    Padhraig Ryan, Paul Revill, Declan Devane, Charles Normand, An assessment of the cost-effectiveness of midwife-led care in the United Kingdom, Midwifery, 2013, 29, 4, 368

    CrossRef

  17. 17
    Lynn Kemp, Elizabeth Harris, Catherine McMahon, Stephen Matthey, Graham Vimpani, Teresa Anderson, Virginia Schmied, Henna Aslam, Benefits of psychosocial intervention and continuity of care by child and family health nurses in the pre- and postnatal period: process evaluation, Journal of Advanced Nursing, 2013, 69, 8
  18. 18
    Sally K Tracy, Donna L Hartz, Mark B Tracy, Jyai Allen, Amanda Forti, Bev Hall, Jan White, Anne Lainchbury, Helen Stapleton, Michael Beckmann, Andrew Bisits, Caroline Homer, Maralyn Foureur, Alec Welsh, Sue Kildea, Caseload midwifery care versus standard maternity care for women of any risk: M@NGO, a randomised controlled trial, The Lancet, 2013, 382, 9906, 1723

    CrossRef

  19. 19
    Sarah Beake, Luisa Acosta, Pauline Cooke, Christine McCourt, Caseload midwifery in a multi-ethnic community: The women's experiences, Midwifery, 2013, 29, 8, 996

    CrossRef

  20. 20
    Maree Stenglin, Maralyn Foureur, Designing out the Fear Cascade to increase the likelihood of normal birth, Midwifery, 2013, 29, 8, 819

    CrossRef

  21. 21
    Helen Cheyne, Purva Abhyankar, Christine McCourt, Empowering change: Realist evaluation of a Scottish Government programme to support normal birth, Midwifery, 2013, 29, 10, 1110

    CrossRef

  22. 22
    Jim Campbell, Luc de Bernis, Soo Downe, Helga Fogstad, Caroline Homer, Holly Powell Kennedy, Zoe Matthews, Mary Renfrew, Petra ten Hoope-Bender, Maternal health post-2015, The Lancet, 2013, 381, 9879, 1717

    CrossRef

  23. 23
    Bharati Sharma, Eva Johansson, M. Prakasamma, Dileep Mavalankar, Kyllike Christensson, Midwifery scope of practice among staff nurses: A grounded theory study in Gujarat, India, Midwifery, 2013, 29, 6, 628

    CrossRef

  24. 24
    Yaeko Kataoka, Hiromi Eto, Mariko Iida, Outcomes of independent midwifery attended births in birth centres and home births: A retrospective cohort study in Japan, Midwifery, 2013, 29, 8, 965

    CrossRef

  25. 25
    Lucie L.M. Martijn, Annelies J.E. Jacobs, Irma I.M. Maassen, Simone S.E. Buitendijk, Michel M. Wensing, Patient safety in midwifery-led care in the Netherlands, Midwifery, 2013, 29, 1, 60

    CrossRef

  26. 26
    Valerie J. Slavin, Jennifer Fenwick, Jenny Gamble, Pregnancy care and birth outcomes for women with moderate to super-extreme obesity, Women and Birth, 2013, 26, 3, 179

    CrossRef

  27. 27
    Joanne Gray, Nicky Leap, Annabel Sheehy, Caroline S.E. Homer, Students' perceptions of the follow-through experience in 3 year bachelor of midwifery programmes in Australia, Midwifery, 2013, 29, 4, 400

    CrossRef

  28. 28
    P. Pligt, J. Willcox, K. D. Hesketh, K. Ball, S. Wilkinson, D. Crawford, K. Campbell, Systematic review of lifestyle interventions to limit postpartum weight retention: implications for future opportunities to prevent maternal overweight and obesity following childbirth, Obesity Reviews, 2013, 14, 10
  29. 29
    Chunyi Gu, Xiaodan Wu, Yan Ding, Xinli Zhu, Zheng Zhang, The effectiveness of a Chinese midwives’ antenatal clinic service on childbirth outcomes for primipare: A randomised controlled trial, International Journal of Nursing Studies, 2013, 50, 12, 1689

    CrossRef

  30. 30
    Melanie Brown, Elaine Dietsch, The feasibility of caseload midwifery in rural Australia: A literature review, Women and Birth, 2013, 26, 1, e1

    CrossRef

  31. 31
    Kate Brintworth, Jane Sandall, What makes a successful home birth service: An examination of the influential elements by review of one service, Midwifery, 2013, 29, 6, 713

    CrossRef

  32. 32
    Helen Stapleton, Rebecca Murphy, Ignacio Correa-Velez, Michelle Steel, Sue Kildea, Women from refugee backgrounds and their experiences of attending a specialist antenatal clinic. Narratives from an Australian setting, Women and Birth, 2013, 26, 4, 260

    CrossRef

  33. 33
    Ingegerd Hildingsson, Helen Haines, Maddalena Cross, Julie F. Pallant, Christine Rubertsson, Women's satisfaction with antenatal care: Comparing women in Sweden and Australia, Women and Birth, 2013, 26, 1, e9

    CrossRef

  34. 34
    Jocelyn Toohill, Erika Turkstra, Jenny Gamble, Paul A. Scuffham, A non-randomised trial investigating the cost-effectiveness of Midwifery Group Practice compared with standard maternity care arrangements in one Australian hospital, Midwifery, 2012, 28, 6, e874

    CrossRef

  35. 35
    Insaf Shaban, Nicky Leap, A review of midwifery education curriculum documents in Jordan, Women and Birth, 2012, 25, 4, e47

    CrossRef

  36. 36
    Donna L. Hartz, Maralyn Foureur, Sally K. Tracy, Australian caseload midwifery: The exception or the rule, Women and Birth, 2012, 25, 1, 39

    CrossRef

  37. 37
    Katy Sutcliffe, Jenny Caird, Josephine Kavanagh, Rebecca Rees, Kathryn Oliver, Kelly Dickson, Jenny Woodman, Elaine Barnett-Paige, James Thomas, Comparing midwife-led and doctor-led maternity care: a systematic review of reviews, Journal of Advanced Nursing, 2012, 68, 11
  38. 38
    Charlotte Overgaard, Morten Fenger-Grøn, Jane Sandall, Freestanding midwifery units versus obstetric units: does the effect of place of birth differ with level of social disadvantage?, BMC Public Health, 2012, 12, 1, 478

    CrossRef

  39. 39
    Tekoa L. King, Russell K. Laros, Julian T. Parer, Interprofessional Collaborative Practice in Obstetrics and Midwifery, Obstetrics and Gynecology Clinics of North America, 2012, 39, 3, 411

    CrossRef

  40. 40
    Anita C. Jaynes, Kathleen E. Scott, Intrapartum Care the Midwifery Way: A Review, Primary Care: Clinics in Office Practice, 2012, 39, 1, 189

    CrossRef

  41. 41
    Laura Wick, Sahar Hassan, No safe place for childbirth: women and midwives bearing witness, Gaza 2008–09, Reproductive Health Matters, 2012, 20, 40, 7

    CrossRef

  42. 42
    Ingvild Aune, Unn Dahlberg, MSc, Oddbjørn Ingebrigtsen, Parents’ experiences of midwifery students providing continuity of care, Midwifery, 2012, 28, 4, 432

    CrossRef

  43. 43
    Tekoa L. King, Preventing Primary Cesarean Sections: Intrapartum Care, Seminars in Perinatology, 2012, 36, 5, 357

    CrossRef

  44. 44
    Ivy Lynn Bourgeault, Rebecca Sutherns, Margaret MacDonald, Jacquelyne Luce, Problematising public and private work spaces: Midwives' work in hospitals and in homes, Midwifery, 2012, 28, 5, 582

    CrossRef

  45. 45
    Joanne E. Gray, Nicky Leap, Annabel Sheehy, Caroline S.E. Homer, The ‘follow-through’ experience in three-year Bachelor of Midwifery programs in Australia: A survey of students, Nurse Education in Practice, 2012, 12, 5, 258

    CrossRef

  46. 46
    Christine Chang Pecci, Julie Mottl-Santiago, Larry Culpepper, Linda Heffner, Therese McMahan, Aviva Lee-Parritz, The Birth of a Collaborative Model, Obstetrics and Gynecology Clinics of North America, 2012, 39, 3, 323

    CrossRef

  47. 47
    Andrea Nove, Ann Berrington, Zoë Matthews, The methodological challenges of attempting to compare the safety of home and hospital birth in terms of the risk of perinatal death, Midwifery, 2012, 28, 5, 619

    CrossRef

  48. 48
    Lesley Barclay, Jo Longman, Virginia Schmied, Athena Sheehan, Margaret Rolfe, Elaine Burns, Jennifer Fenwick, The professionalising of breast feeding—Where are we a decade on?, Midwifery, 2012, 28, 3, 281

    CrossRef

  49. 49
    Rhona J. McInnes, Colette Mc Intosh, What future for midwifery?, Nurse Education in Practice, 2012, 12, 5, 297

    CrossRef

  50. 50
    Jason D. Hans, Claire Kimberly, An Educational Intervention to Change Planned Behavior Concerning Midwife-Assisted Out-of-Hospital Childbirth, Journal of Midwifery & Women’s Health, 2011, 56, 4
  51. 51
    Elaine Dietsch, Tanya Martin, Pamela Shackleton, Carmel Davies, Margaret McLeod, Margaret Alston, Australian Aboriginal kinship: A means to enhance maternal well-being, Women and Birth, 2011, 24, 2, 58

    CrossRef

  52. 52
    Tekoa L. King, Can a Vaginal Birth After Cesarean Delivery be a Normal Labor and Birth? Lessons from Midwifery Applied to Trial of Labor After a Previous Cesarean Delivery, Clinics in Perinatology, 2011, 38, 2, 247

    CrossRef

  53. 53
    Paula J Laws, Carylyn Lim, Sally K Tracy, Hannah Dahlen, Elizabeth A Sullivan, Changes to booking, transfer criteria and procedures in birth centres in Australia from 1997–2007: a national survey, Journal of Clinical Nursing, 2011, 20, 19-20
  54. 54
    Ingegerd Hildingsson, Linnea Cederlöf, Sara Widén, Fathers’ birth experience in relation to midwifery care, Women and Birth, 2011, 24, 3, 129

    CrossRef

  55. 55
    Athena Hammond, Joanne Gray, Rachel Smith, Jennifer Fenwick, Caroline SE Homer, Same… same but different: expectations of graduates from two midwifery education courses in Australia, Journal of Clinical Nursing, 2011, 20, 15-16
  56. 56
    Beverley O’Brien, Beverley Chalmers, Deshayne Fell, Maureen Heaman, Elizabeth K. Darling, Pearl Herbert, The Experience of Pregnancy and Birth with Midwives: Results from the Canadian Maternity Experiences Survey, Birth, 2011, 38, 3
  57. You have free access to this content57
    Sigridur Halldorsdottir, Sigfridur Inga Karlsdottir, The primacy of the good midwife in midwifery services: an evolving theory of professionalism in midwifery, Scandinavian Journal of Caring Sciences, 2011, 25, 4
  58. 58
    Mandie Scamell, The swan effect in midwifery talk and practice: a tension between normality and the language of risk, Sociology of Health & Illness, 2011, 33, 7
  59. 59
    Lyn Ebert, Alison Ferguson, Helen Bellchambers, Working for socially disadvantaged women, Women and Birth, 2011, 24, 2, 85

    CrossRef

  60. You have free access to this content60
    Denis J. Walsh, Childbirth embodiment: problematic aspects of current understandings, Sociology of Health & Illness, 2010, 32, 3
  61. 61
    Jill Mallory, Integrative Care of the Mother-Infant Dyad, Primary Care: Clinics in Office Practice, 2010, 37, 1, 149

    CrossRef

  62. 62
    Lesley Barclay, Sally K. Tracy, Legally binding midwives to doctors is not collaboration, Women and Birth, 2010, 23, 1, 1

    CrossRef

  63. 63
    Joseph R. Wax, Michael G. Pinette, Angelina Cartin, Jacquelyn Blackstone, Maternal and newborn morbidity by birth facility among selected United States 2006 low-risk births, American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology, 2010, 202, 2, 152.e1

    CrossRef

  64. 64
    Joseph R. Wax, F. Lee Lucas, Maryanne Lamont, Michael G. Pinette, Angelina Cartin, Jacquelyn Blackstone, Maternal and newborn outcomes in planned home birth vs planned hospital births: a metaanalysis, American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology, 2010, 203, 3, 243.e1

    CrossRef

  65. 65
    Nadia Zanon Narchi, Lúcia Cristina Florentino Pereira da Silva, Dulce Maria Rosa Gualda, Maria Helena Bastos, Reclaiming direct-entry midwifery training in Brazil: context, challenges and perspectives, Midwifery, 2010, 26, 4, 385

    CrossRef

  66. 66
    Jocelyn DeJong, Chaza Akik, Faysal El Kak, Hibah Osman, Fadi El-Jardali, The safety and quality of childbirth in the context of health systems: mapping maternal health provision in Lebanon, Midwifery, 2010, 26, 5, 549

    CrossRef

  67. 67
    Susanna Finlay, Jane Sandall, “Someone's rooting for you”: Continuity, advocacy and street-level bureaucracy in UK maternal healthcare, Social Science & Medicine, 2009, 69, 8, 1228

    CrossRef

  68. 68
    Judith P. Rooks, Judy Norsigian, Berghella et al's review of evidence-based labor and delivery management, American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology, 2009, 201, 3, e10

    CrossRef

  69. 69
    Nancy Hewer, Geertje Boschma, Wendy A. Hall, Elective caesarean section as a transformative technological process: players, power and context, Journal of Advanced Nursing, 2009, 65, 8
  70. 70
    Lareen Newman, Heather Hancock, How Natural Can Major Surgery Really Be? A Critique of “The Natural Caesarean” Technique, Birth, 2009, 36, 2
  71. 71
    Jenny Browne, Alison Chandra, Slow midwifery, Women and Birth, 2009, 22, 1, 29

    CrossRef

  72. 72
    Carrie E. Neerland, A Supportive Approach to Prenatal Care,
  73. 73
    Cecily M Begley, Gillian ML Gyte, Declan Devane, William McGuire, Andrew Weeks, Active versus expectant management for women in the third stage of labour, The Cochrane Library,
  74. 74
    Cecily M Begley, Gillian ML Gyte, Deirdre J Murphy, Declan Devane, Susan J McDonald, William McGuire, Active versus expectant management for women in the third stage of labour, The Cochrane Library,
  75. 75
    Ellen D Hodnett, Soo Downe, Denis Walsh, Alternative versus conventional institutional settings for birth, The Cochrane Library,
  76. 76
    Ellen D Hodnett, Soo Downe, Denis Walsh, Julie Weston, Alternative versus conventional institutional settings for birth, The Cochrane Library,
  77. 77
    Denis Walsh, Birth Environment,
  78. 78
    Denis Walsh, Evolution of Current Systems of Intrapartum Care,
  79. 79
    Caroline SE Homer, Clare Ryan, Nicky Leap, Maralyn Foureur, Alison Teate, Christine J Catling-Paull, Group versus conventional antenatal care for women, The Cochrane Library,
  80. 80
    Chris McCourt, How Midwives Should Organise to Provide Intrapartum Care,
  81. 81
    Jane Sandall, Hora Soltani, Simon Gates, Andrew Shennan, Declan Devane, Midwife-led continuity models versus other models of care for childbearing women, The Cochrane Library,
  82. 82
    Leanne Jones, Mohammad Othman, Therese Dowswell, Zarko Alfirevic, Simon Gates, Mary Newburn, Susan Jordan, Tina Lavender, James P Neilson, Pain management for women in labour: an overview of systematic reviews, The Cochrane Library,
  83. 83
    Leanne Jones, Mohammad Othman, Therese Dowswell, Zarko Alfirevic, Simon Gates, Mary Newburn, Susan Jordan, Tina Lavender, James P Neilson, Pain management for women in labour: an overview of systematic reviews, The Cochrane Library,
  84. 84
    Leanne Jones, Lixia Dou, Therese Dowswell, Zarko Alfirevic, James P Neilson, Pain management for women in labour: generic protocol, The Cochrane Library,
  85. 85
    Roz Ullman, Lesley A Smith, Ethel Burns, Rintaro Mori, Therese Dowswell, Parenteral opioids for maternal pain management in labour, The Cochrane Library,
  86. 86
    Vigdis Aasheim, Anne Britt Vika Nilsen, Mirjam Lukasse, Liv Merete Reinar, Perineal techniques during the second stage of labour for reducing perineal trauma, The Cochrane Library,
  87. 87
    Ole Olsen, Jette A Clausen, Planned hospital birth versus planned home birth, The Cochrane Library,