Electrochemical Deuteration of Metastable MgTi Alloys: An Effective Way to Inhibit Phase Segregation
Article first published online: 1 SEP 2013
© 2013 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
Advanced Energy Materials
Volume 4, Issue 1, January 7, 2014
How to Cite
2014). Electrochemical Deuteration of Metastable MgTi Alloys: An Effective Way to Inhibit Phase Segregation. Adv. Energy Mater., 4: 1300590. doi: 10.1002/aenm.201300590, , , , , (
- Issue published online: 6 JAN 2014
- Article first published online: 1 SEP 2013
- Manuscript Revised: 8 JUL 2013
- Manuscript Received: 29 MAY 2013
- Dutch Science foundation
- hydrogen storage;
- phase segregation
Hydrogen is considered to be a promising energy carrier for our future society as it is light-weight and has a high energy density (142 MJ kg−1), almost three times higher than that of natural gas (55 MJ kg−1).[1, 2] However, storing hydrogen in a safe and energy dense way is one of the remaining challenges. The volumetric density of hydrogen in metal hydrides is higher than that in alternative storing methods, such as liquid and compressed hydrogen. In addition, metal hydrides offer a relatively safe storage environment.[3-5] Compared to conventional metal hydrides, such as LaNi5Hx, MgH2 is a potentially attractive hydrogen-storage material because of its high gravimetric storage capacity amounting to 7.6 wt% of hydrogen.[2, 4, 6] However, in its common rutile crystal structure MgH2 suffers from a poor (de)hydrogenation kinetics. In order to improve the thermodynamics and (de)sorption kinetics MgH2 can be modified in different ways, i.e., by forming nanoparticles, alloying Mg with transition metals and adding catalysts.[7-9]
Alloying Mg with a transition metal (TM), such as Sc, Ti, V, or Cr has a remarkable positive effect on the (de)hydrogenation kinetics. Well-mixed MgTM alloys with >20 at% TM tend to adopt the fluorite structure after hydrogenation,[10-12] which increases the hydrogen mobility significantly compared to that in rutile MgH2. Due to its relatively high abundance and low atomic weight, Ti is particularly interesting as alloying element for large-scale applications. Mg and Ti have a positive mixing enthalpy and thus no thermodynamically stable alloys are formed.[14, 15] However, metastable alloys composed of Mg and Ti have been successfully synthesized in thin films by making use of advanced deposition techniques, such as co-sputtering, physical vapor- and electron-beam (e-beam) deposition.[9, 16, 17]
Although the results for thin films[18, 19] are scientifically interesting as a proof of principle, for large-scale applications bulk powders are much more expedient because of the readily available synthesis and processing routes. For economically feasible large-scale production of powders mechanical alloying is a proven method. Ball-milling has been successfully employed for the preparation of metastable Mg-Ti powders.[20-22] Hydrogenation of Mg-Ti alloys can be achieved either via the gas phase at elevated temperatures or via electrochemical reduction in hydrogen/deuterium donating electrolytes at room temperature. Disadvantageously, the elevated temperatures required for H2 gas ab- and desorption induce phase segregation in these metastable alloys.[23, 24] In contrast, electrochemical hydrogenation of thin Mg1-xTix films can be achieved at room temperature without phase segregation and yields a single-phase fluorite-structured compound with favorable materials properties. However, the phase stability of the mechanically prepared Mg1–xTix powders during low temperature electrochemical (de)hydrogenation is yet unclear. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first report which shows that the phase segregation of ball-milled powders can be prevented by electrochemical deuteration instead of gas-phase deuteration.
Here we report a magic-angle spinning (MAS) 2H NMR study on electrochemically deuterated Mg-Ti electrodes at room temperature, leading to the conclusion that phase segregation does not occur under these low temperature conditions. The chemical resolution in 2H NMR spectra of metal deuterides tends to be higher than in 1H NMR spectra of the corresponding metal hydrides.[13, 26, 27] In the present study Mg0.65Ti0.35 was prepared by means of 28 h ball-milling. Subsequently, Pd was added to the homogenous alloy and ball-milling was continued for 90 min in order to create a 5 at% Pd coating at the surface of the Mg0.65Ti0.35 particles. Pd is an essential catalyst to provide excellent electrochemical hydrogenation properties.[28, 29] It also protects the underlying alloy from oxidation.
Electrochemical deuterium loading, also denoted here as charging, was carried out in a conventional three-electrode electrochemical cell, which was thermostated at 25 °C, using alkaline D2O as electrolyte (Figure 1a). The cell consisted of a metal deuteride (MD) working electrode containing the Mg0.65Ti0.35Dx alloy along with silver or carbon black as additive, a Pd counter electrode and a Hg/HgO reference electrode. All electrode potentials are referring to this reference electrode. Charging of the working electrode is initiated by electrochemical reduction of D2O according to
resulting in the adsorption of deuterium atoms (MDad) at the electrode surface. Subsequently, the adsorbed deuterium atoms diffuse into the bulk of the electrode, forming a metal deuteride. Two neighboring deuterium atoms adsorbed at the electrode surface can also recombine to D2, which is released from the electrode surface as a gas. Obviously, this parasitic reaction competes with the deuteride-forming reaction. The absorbed deuterium can also be oxidized during electrochemical discharging.
Powder electrodes, made with silver as conducting material, resulted in mechanically stable electrodes, revealing well-defined voltage plateaus and low electrochemical over-potentials. From an electrochemical point of view this electrode configuration is therefore preferred. However, the use of silver (heavy and highly conductive) causes unstable sample rotation and radio-frequency skin depth problems in MAS NMR. To overcome these problems carbon black (CB) was used as additive instead of Ag. This electrode configuration was found to be excellent for the NMR measurements. The constant-current charging (Figure 2A, curve a) of the Mg0.65Ti0.35/Ag electrode clearly exhibits three voltage plateaus. The first two can be attributed to the deuteration of Ti and Mg, respectively.
After the deuteration is complete, the voltage saturates at more negative potentials where D2 gas evolution becomes visible at the electrode. The amount of deuterium absorbed in the material can be calculated from the transition between the second and third voltage plateau. This position is defined by the gravimetric capacity where the voltage derivative is at maximum (Figure 2B). The amount of deuterium absorbed in Mg0.65Ti0.35-deuteride is equivalent to 825 mAh g−1. Since the formation of deuterons involves 1 electron per atom (Equation (1), the electrochemical charge capacity Q (mAh g−1) can be converted into a deuterium weight fraction νD (wt%), according to
where F is Faraday's constant (9.65 × 104 C mol−1) and MD is the molar mass of deuterium (2.01 g mol−1). Thus, the deuterium storage capacity of Mg0.65Ti0.35 in the present study corresponds to 6.2 wt% D. This is equivalent to overall composition Mg0.65Ti0.35D1.12. Curve b of Figure 2A shows the result of the same experiment but now with a Mg0.65Ti0.35/CB electrode. Since the electrode voltages are more negative in this case, the charge transfer kinetics is poorer than for the electrode with Ag. As a result of the higher overpotentials the distinction between the plateaus has vanished. However, the purpose of this experiment is not to investigate the electrochemistry of the deuteration reaction in detail, but to electrochemically deuterate the metastable Mg0.65Ti0.35 alloy, and characterize its nano-structure and deuterium mobility with NMR afterwards. To check whether the Mg0.65Ti0.35/CB has indeed absorbed deuterium, the electrode was discharged in two current steps, i.e. with a high and low current (curves c and d, respectively in Figure 2A), until the cut-off voltage of 0 V vs the Hg/HgO reference electrode had been reached. The total charge extracted from the electrode was 630 mAh g−1. This is in good agreement with the extracted charge (600 mAh g−1) measured for the Ag electrode. The extracted charge is smaller than the loaded charge which is likely due to the stronger fixation of deuterium in TiD2 nanodomains than the MgD2 nanodomains. The non-extracted deuterium is strongly bound in TiD2 nanodomains. Evidence for this is that the formation enthalpy of TiH2 (144 kJ mol−1) is much higher than that of MgH2 (77 kJ mol−1).
Selected area electron diffraction (SAED) of electrochemically deuterated Mg0.65Ti0.35D1.12 (Figure 2C) shows three reflections corresponding to d-spacing values of 4.78, 2.75 and 2.38 Å. This suggests close similarity to the Ca7Ge-type fcc super structure reported for the high-pressure phase of Mg7TiHx these corresponding reflections have been labeled 200, 222, and 400. The d-spacing derived from the strongest 222 reflection (2.38 Å) is close to the reported value from the 111 reflection observed for Mg0.70Ti0.30Hx thin films, for which a simple fcc structure was assumed.
The nanostructure of Mg0.65Ti0.35D1.12 was further investigated with 2H NMR (Figure 3). In order to fully understand the NMR spectra of this complex material also NMR spectra of the separate elemental metal hydrides have been investigated. Moreover, spectra were recorded for both electrochemical or gas-phase deuterated samples, which will be distinguished below by the superscripts (e) or (g), respectively. Magic angle spinning (MAS) increases the chemical resolution in the 2H NMR spectra by removing the quadrupolar line broadening. The spinning sideband patterns, which are visible at moderate sample rotation rates, reflect the deuterium-coordination symmetry in the respective crystal structures. The 2H NMR spectrum of MgD2(g) exhibits an extensive sideband pattern over a wide frequency range (Figure 3a). This is consistent with the threefold coordination of deuterium by Mg atoms in rutile MgD2. In contrast, TiD2 has a fluorite structure with deuterium atoms located at tetrahedral interstitial sites. The high coordination symmetry results in weak sidebands surrounding the centerband at –150 ppm for gas-phase deuterated TiD2(g) (Figure 3d). The large, negative Knight shift for TiD2(g) is typical for the conductive bulk material.
Figure 3b shows the 2H NMR spectrum of electrochemically deuterated Mg0.65Ti0.35D1.12(e). The overall deuterium content estimated from the total spectral integral, 5.7 wt%, is in good agreement with the electrochemically determined content. The fact that no typical bulk TiD2 signal is present at –150 ppm (Figure 3d) shows that no strong phase segregation takes places during electrochemical deuteration. Instead, the signal at approximately –70 ppm signifies TiD2 nanodomains similar to that of co-sputtered Mg0.65Ti0.35D1.1. As is the case for pure MgD2(g) there is a centerband signal at ≈4 ppm, which is therefore assigned to MgD2 nanodomains. However, the corresponding sideband pattern extends over a less broad range than that of the pure MgD2(g) (Figure 3a), and is very similar to that of the melt-cast Mg0.65Sc0.35D2.2 and co-sputtered Mg0.65Ti0.35D1.1 reported before.[31, 32] The latter two materials were shown to have a single-phase fluorite structure with the deuterium atoms at tetrahedral positions. Indeed, the tetrahedral coordination of deuterium in the fluorite structure leads to weaker spinning sidebands than the threefold coordination in rutile MgD2. Unlike in fcc TiD2, however, deuterium atoms in fcc Mg0.65Ti0.35 may well have mixed (Mg, Ti) coordination, or the fcc crystal structure may be otherwise distorted by the co-presence of Mg and Ti. The resulting symmetry distortion is reflected by the spinning sidebands stronger than those for TiD2(g) (Figure 3d).
In contrast to the Mg0.65Ti0.35D1.12(e), the sideband pattern of Mg0.65Ti0.35D0.65(g) (Figure 3c) is similar to that of rutile MgD2(g) (Figure 3a). The spectrum also reveals a signal at the bulk TiD2 position –150 ppm, similar to TiD2(g) (Figure 3d). In addition there is a third signal at –43 ppm, which has been earlier assigned to TiD1.5 nanodomains in close contact with the MgD2 phase. High temperature gas phase loading of Mg0.65Ti0.35D0.65(g) induces partial phase segregation into rutile MgD2 nanodomains with interdispersed TiD1.5 layers and a separate fcc TiD2 phase. This phase segregation was also confirmed by Neutron diffraction and XRD.
The 2H NMR spectrum of Mg0.65Ti0.35D1.12(e) can be decomposed into four overlapping line shape components, positioned at 7, 4, –30 and –73 ppm (Figure 4a). Only the 4 ppm component has spinning sidebands, which helps to define its lineshape in the centerband as well. Both signals at 4 and 7 ppm are assigned to deuterium with tetrahedral MgnTi4-n coordination in Mg-rich nanodomains. The components at –30 and –73 ppm are comparable to those attributed to the Ti-rich nanodomains found in co-sputtered Mg0.65Ti0.35D1.1. Electrochemically discharging has a remarkable effect on the component distribution as Figure 4b shows. The intense 4 ppm component and its accompanying side-bands are now completely absent whereas the 7, –30 and –73 ppm components are more or less unaffected. Apparently, the intense 4 ppm component with its sidebands can be entirely correlated to the reversible deuterium stored in Mg0.65Ti0.35D1.12(e). The other, less intense, components must then be related to the strongly bound deuterium staying behind in the discharged material.
Using 2D exchange NMR spectroscopy we have studied the deuterium mobility between Mg-rich and Ti-rich sites. More precisely, 2D Exsy correlates the chemical shift of deuterium atoms before and after a selected mixing time interval tmix, during which the deuterium atoms have the chance to move between different sites. Deuterium atoms which are stably bound or deeply buried within a separate phase do not undergo a chemical-shift change during tmix and will give rise to peaks at the spectral diagonal only. In contrast, deuterium atoms which exchange between, e.g. Mg-rich and Ti-rich sites during tmix will change their chemical shift, which shows up as off-diagonal “cross-peaks” in the 2D spectrum. For tmix = 0.01 s (Figure 5a) only peak intensity along the diagonal appears, indicating that no deuterium exchange occurs at this timescale. For tmix = 2 s, cross-peaks are observed (Figure 5b), indicating extensive deuterium exchange between Mg-rich and Ti-rich sites. A measure for the “unrestrictedness” of the exchange is the similarity between projections P and cross-sections S as plotted above the 2D spectra in Figure 5a,b. The projections reflect the deuterium distribution over the various sites, while the particular cross-sections shown in Figure 5 indicate how deuterium atoms, which were initially located in Mg-rich domains, become redistributed during the mixing time. For tmix = 2 s the cross-section is similar to the projection. Thus, at this timescale deuterium has become evenly redistributed over all sites. The fact that this occurs in seconds proves that no macrophase segregation occurs in the electrochemically deuterated alloy.
The exchange between Mg-rich and Ti-rich sites was studied systematically as a function of mixing time with one-dimensional exchange spectroscopy. Our 1D exchange experiments involve selective polarization inversion of deuterium spins at the Mg-rich sites followed by a varied mixing time tmix. Deuterium atoms with perturbed polarization initially at Mg-rich sites will replace unperturbed deuterium at the Ti-rich sites and vice versa. As a result, the signal intensity of the originally non-perturbed sites will decrease, and that of the initially perturbed sites will increase as function of tmix (see Figure 6a,b). Figure 6c illustrates the development of the intensity IMg of the 4 ppm component combined with its sidebands, and ITi of the combined –30 and –73 ppm components versus tmix at 280 K. IMg shows a two-step increase, whereas ITi initially decreases and then increases. The combined behavior of IMg(tmix) and ITi(tmix) is well described by a coupled bi-exponential model
where the thermal-equilibrium intensities (and ) are proportional to the respective densities of Mg- and Ti-rich sites, and and are the signal intensities in the intermediate state, when the combined initial polarization is homogeneously distributed over the Mg- and Ti-rich sites by deuterium exchange. Herewith it is assumed that the deuterium exchange is fast compared to the spin-lattice relaxation (τex < T1) and averages out any intrinsic T1 differences between deuteriums at Mg- and Ti-rich sites. The spin-lattice relaxation times (T1) can also be independently determined by making use of inversion-recovery relaxometry. The obtained relaxation times nicely match the T1Z values extracted from the 1D Exsy curves at the corresponding temperatures.
To estimate the activation barrier for deuterium mobility in Mg0.65Ti0.35D1.12(e), 1D Exsy was carried out at various temperatures. The observed deuterium exchange becomes faster with increasing temperature. For instance, the zero crossing of the initially inverted 4-ppm signal during the recovery process occurs earlier at 355 K (Figure 6b) than at 280 K (Figure 6a). Such temperature trend is indeed to be expected for chemical exchange of deuterons between different sites. In principle, polarization exchange between deuterium spins could also give rise to cross-correlation in 1D and 2D Exsy. However, such 2H-2H spin diffusion would essentially be temperature independent. The observed exchange in 1D and 2D Exsy is indeed dominated by deuterium mobility. From 280 to 355 K, the effective deuterium residence time τex in Mg- and Ti-rich nanodomains decreases from 0.48 to 0.10 s (Figure 6d), which corresponds to an activation energy of 16.8 kJ mol−1, comparable to the barrier energy estimated from the 1D Exsy of co-sputtered Mg0.65Ti0.35D1.1.
The T1 values extracted from the 1D Exsy curves also contain information about deuterium mobility. In contrast to τex, directly reflecting deuterium exchange between the NMR –distinguishable Mg- and Ti-rich sites, T1 is an indirect measure for the correlation time τc of deuterium exchange between any neighboring sites. The overall T1 relaxation is the weighted average between the intrinsic relaxation at the Mg-rich sites controlled by quadrupolar-coupling fluctuations, and the intrinsic relaxation at the Ti-rich sites controlled by Knight-shift fluctuations
where and represent the average size of the quadrupolar-coupling and Knight-shift fluctuations, respectively, ω0 the 2H NMR frequency and τc the motion correlation time. For very fast deuterium mobility (ω0τc << 1), T1 is inversely proportional to τc, whereas for less fast mobility (ω0τc >> 1), T1 is directly proportional to τc. The spin lattice relaxation time T1 of deuterium in Mg0.65Ti0.35D1.12(e) decreases from 6.2 s at 280 K to 2.0 s at 355 K (Figure 6d) showing an Arrhenius temperature dependence with an activation energy of 13.6 kJ mol−1. This indicates that the deuterium mobility is relatively slow on the NMR frequency scale (ω0τc >> 1) as is consistent with the timescale of the hydrogen (1H) mobility in the related Mg0.65Sc0.35Hx. The comparable temperature dependence of τc and τex in our present study of Mg0.65Ti0.35D1.12(e) suggests that the mobility underlying the T1 relaxation and the Exsy correlation are related. A possible explanation is that τc reflects the hopping of the deuterium atoms between neighboring sites within the Mg-rich and Ti-rich nanodomains, whereas τex reflects the (longer) average time it takes for deuterium to diffuse in multiple steps from sites within Mg-rich nanodomains across the Mg-Ti interphase to sites within Ti-rich nanodomains, and vice versa.
In summary, although thin-film electrodes are scientifically interesting, bulk powders are more favorable for large-scale practical applications. Ball-milled Mg-Ti alloy powders do not undergo phase segregation during electrochemical loading at low temperatures, whereas gas-phase loading at the required elevated temperatures induces the alloys to phase segregate. 2D and 1D Exsy shows that Mg-rich and Ti-rich nanodomains in Mg0.65Ti0.35D1.12(e) are closely connected. Therefore electrochemical hydrogenation at room temperature is an excellent alternative to hydrogenate metastable alloys, which phase segregate at the elevated temperatures required for gas-phase hydrogenation. These economically feasible ball-milled metastable Mg-Ti alloy powders are therefore interesting to be applied in next generation of light-weight rechargeable Nickel Metal Hydride batteries.
This research work in TU/e was financially supported by the Dutch Science foundation (NWO) as part of the Sustainable Hydrogen program of Advanced Chemical technologies for sustainability (ACTS). The authors would like to take this opportunity to thank their funding agency for supporting this research activity.
- 4Mater. Today 2003, 6, 24.,
- 5Hydrogen as A Future Energy Carrier, Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim, Germany 2008., , ,
- 15Cohesion in Metals: Transition Metal Alloys, North-Holland, Amsterdam, 1988., , , , ,
- 33Experimental Pulse NMR. A Nuts and Bolts Approach, Addison-Wesley Publishing Company, Boston, MA 1981., ,
As a service to our authors and readers, this journal provides supporting information supplied by the authors. Such materials are peer reviewed and may be re-organized for online delivery, but are not copy-edited or typeset. Technical support issues arising from supporting information (other than missing files) should be addressed to the authors.
Please note: Wiley Blackwell is not responsible for the content or functionality of any supporting information supplied by the authors. Any queries (other than missing content) should be directed to the corresponding author for the article.