We thank Prateek Jha and Vladimir Kuzovkov for stimulating discussions during development of the model. Numerical simulations were performed using the Northwestern University High Performance Computing Cluster Quest. This work was supported by the Non-Equilibrium Energy Research Center (NERC), which is an Energy Frontier Research Center funded by the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Science, Office of Basic Energy Sciences under Award Number DE-SC0000989. D.A.W. thanks the fellowship from the Northwestern University Materials Research Science and Engineering Center (NU-MRSEC) funded by the NSF under Award Number DMR-1121262.
Accelerated Self-Replication under Non-Equilibrium, Periodic Energy Delivery†
Article first published online: 15 NOV 2013
Copyright © 2014 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
Angewandte Chemie International Edition
Volume 53, Issue 1, pages 173–177, January 3, 2014
How to Cite
Zhang, R., Walker, D. A., Grzybowski, B. A. and Olvera de la Cruz, M. (2014), Accelerated Self-Replication under Non-Equilibrium, Periodic Energy Delivery. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed., 53: 173–177. doi: 10.1002/anie.201307339
- Issue published online: 23 DEC 2013
- Article first published online: 15 NOV 2013
- Manuscript Received: 21 AUG 2013
- U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Science, Office of Basic Energy Sciences. Grant Number: DE-SC0000989
- NSF. Grant Number: DMR-1121262
- kinetic Monte Carlo simulations;
- light switchable systems;
Self-replication is a remarkable phenomenon in nature that has fascinated scientists for decades. In a self-replicating system, the original units are attracted to a template, which induce their binding. In equilibrium, the energy required to disassemble the newly assembled copy from the mother template is supplied by thermal energy. The possibility of optimizing self-replication was explored by controlling the frequency at which energy is supplied to the system. A model system inspired by a class of light-switchable colloids was considered where light is used to control the interactions. Conditions under which self-replication can be significantly more effective under non-equilibrium, cyclic energy delivery than under equilibrium constant energy conditions were identified. Optimal self-replication does not require constant energy expenditure. Instead, the proper timing at which energy is delivered to the system is an essential controllable parameter to induce high replication rates.
From DNA to cells to organisms, self-replication is a carefully orchestrated process spanning multiple length scales and ensuring the sustainability of life on Earth. Not surprisingly, self-replication phenomena have been widely studied, not only by biologists, with several remarkable attempts to construct artificial replicators based on mechanical machines1 or chemical systems.2 Recently, Seeman and co-workers reported an artificial self-replicating material made from synthetic DNA tile motifs3 with self-replication driven by multiple chemical and thermal processing cycles, without the use of biological controls, such as enzymes. Although Seeman’s system does not yet achieve exponential growth in the population of the replicated species, it points to one of the key, yet often overlooked, characteristics of self-replication systems; namely, the need for energy cycling to bind/unbind the system’s components. During self-replication, the monomers have to first assemble onto the template (where they bind to one another), but then must disengage from this template to serve as templates themselves. At equilibrium, such a reversal of interactions can only be facilitated by the random noise of thermal energy, kB T, disrupting the binding between the original template and its assembled copy; even intuitively this scenario is inefficient and, in fact, it is not used in biological system where disassembly is driven by an appropriately synchronized input of chemical energy (for example, DNA helicases powered by ATP separate long DNA strands that would otherwise require temperatures well above biological conditions to melt). Conditions of time-varying energy input necessarily bring us to the realm of non-equilibrium that we consider herein.4, 5 The main question we ask is whether the overall efficiency of self-replication (measured by the rate at which templates are replicated) can be controlled and optimized by the frequency at which energy is supplied to the system. Although the current study is a theoretical one, it is inspired by a recently demonstrated class of colloids in which, the assembly/disassembly can be driven by external impulses, including light.5, 6 In the specific model we consider herein, particle dimers replicate from particle monomers with the interactions between all of these species toggled between attractive and repulsive by external pulses of (light) energy. Based on extensive computer simulations, we demonstrate that the exponential growth rates of this self-replicating system can be significantly enhanced by delivering the energy pulses at specific frequencies. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first indication (naturally, to be verified in future experiments) that the rate of self-replication can be controlled by the periodicity of external stimuli. In other words, optimal self-replication does not necessarily require constant energetic expenditure; instead what matters is the proper timing with which energy is delivered to the system.
Our model self-replicating system is illustrated in Figure 1. Initially, in the absence of light, this system comprises a template (T, a dimer of particles) and a collection of individual particles, P, all of which are weakly repulsive by the so-called Weeks–Chandler–Andersen (WCA) potential.7 When light is turned on (the ON state), the interactions between the dimer and between all particles become attractive, as prescribed by the Lennard-Jones (LJ) pairwise potentials (for experimental realization, see Refs. 5, 8). The strength of the attraction is quantified by the depth of the attraction well ε (the dimensionless parameter ε*=ε/kB T is used in the following discussion, where kB is the Boltzmann constant and T is absolute temperature). If two individual particles and a dimer template move close to one another such that the three interparticle distances r1, r2, and r3 (Figure 1 d) are all smaller than a critical distance rcrit (typically, 21/6 σ, where σ is the diameter of the particles), the two spheres immediately bind to form a new dimer in a reaction T+2P2T. When the light is turned off (OFF state), the interactions between all entities become weakly repulsive and the newly formed daughter templates can disassemble from the original mother templates. In this way, the mother templates self-replicate and in subsequent cycles can promote the formation of more daughter templates from individual nanoparticles (NPs). In the simulations, we assume the light response of these particles is instantaneous, which, incidentally, is a reasonable assumption to model dilute solutions of the experimentally studied azobenzene-covered, photoswitchable nanoparticles.5, 8
With these definitions, we implemented the kinetic Monte Carlo (KMC9–11) algorithm in a cubic box with periodic boundary conditions to study the dynamics of an ensemble initially comprising nT templates and nP individual particles. In a typical run, the total number of spherical units simulated was n=2 nT+nP=1000 with only one template present at time t=0. The (dimensionless) particle density is given by η=nσ3 V, where V is the size of the simulation box. The progress of self-replication was monitored by the number of dimeric templates nT(t) present at time t. Self-replication was driven by energy pulses of duration τon followed by times τoff when no energy was delivered (Figure 1 c). The parameters we used to describe a pulse sequence were the period τ=τon+τoff, and the ratio τon/τ (henceforth, referred to as “on-ratio”; note that τon/τ=1 when energy is continuously delivered). For each ε*, η, τ/τ0, and τon/τ condition we considered, 100 independent KMC simulations were performed, each starting from randomly chosen particle positions, to give the averaged results we discuss below (see the Methods Section and the Supporting Information for more simulation details).
We first consider a limiting case, τon/τ=1, which corresponds to an equilibrium situation of inter-particle interactions not changing and being always attractive. Figure 2 a shows the number of templates, nT(t), semi-logarithmic scale as a function of time for different ε* values and at the density of η=0.008; Figure 2 c–e provides representative simulation snapshots.
Remarkably, the rates of dimer production exhibit a non-monotonic dependence on the strength of interparticle interactions, ε*. For strong interactions, ε*≥2, the initial rates of dimer formation are high, but the newly formed dimers cannot easily disengage from the mother ones, resulting in the formation of large aggregates (Figure 2 c). As the diffusion of these large clusters is slower than that of individual particles, the probability that particles within a cluster would meet a template (in another cluster) is low, and the process of self-replication rapidly slows to a near halt (see the Supporting Information, Movie S1, for a typical simulation run for ε*=5 whereby large clusters fuse and particles can replicate only at long times). The situation is markedly different in the weak-interaction regime (for example, ε*=0.7 curve and Figure 2 e snapshot), whereby the newly formed dimers can easily disengage from the templates and can follow an exponential kinetics of dimer production. In this regime, however, the individual particles reside on the dimers only fleetingly, thus lowering the probability of two particles being found on a template simultaneously (and bonding into a new dimer). The most efficient self-replication is observed between the above described regimes, when the interactions are strong enough to hold the template–particle intermediates for longer times yet weak enough to allow for their disassembly by the thermal energy. In such an intermediate-strength regime, ε*≈1.5 (see Figure 2 d snapshot and Supporting Information, Movie S2), the exponential growth can continue for relatively long times while ensuring the fastest possible conversion of all particles into dimers. Similar trends are observed for different densities (we tested η=0.003, 0.008, 0.016, and 0.037) apart from the fact that as η increases, the strength of inter-particle interactions ε* that yields the fastest rate of self-replication decreases (see Figure 2 b). These variations, however, are modest and the ε* values always remain in a narrow range of about 1–2 kB T (Supporting Information, Section S1). The general conclusion is, therefore, that under conditions of constant energy, replication is the fastest when the magnitude of attractive interactions between the particles is similar to the thermal noise that tries to break these forming aggregates apart.
The equilibrium case discussed above provides a benchmark for self-replication under non-equilibrium conditions of pulsed energy inputs, τon/τ<1. Figure 3 summarizes the results of simulations spanning a wide parameter space across the four variables defining our system (ε*, η, τ/τ0, and τon/τ). There are two distinct regions in the phase space (Supporting Information, Sections S1–S4). In the first region, observed for larger τon/τ, ε*, and η values (pink data points in Figure 3 a–d), the templates become trapped in large, internally disordered aggregates such that self-replication is limited by the diffusion and exchange of particles between these large clusters. Under these conditions, the production dynamics never enters an exponential growth phase (for a typical nT(t) curve in the Supporting Information, Figure S3a). In sharp contrast, in the phase space region corresponding to the blue data points in Figure 3 a–d, the aggregates can fully disintegrate and mix in-between light pulses; self-replication is kinetically controlled by the number of remaining monomers, and all template production profiles contain an exponential growth phase (for a typical nT(t) curve, see the Supporting Information, Figure S3b). To illustrate these features further, Figure 3 e–h provide typical snapshots from simulations just before light is turned on (such that the particles are in their most dispersed state; Figure 3 e,f) and just before it is turned off (such that the particles are in their most aggregated state; Figure 3 g,h). As seen, under the conditions of diffusion limited replication (Figure 3 e,g; pink), the aggregates do not have enough time between light pulses to fully disintegrate and, as such, rarely exchange particles between the clusters (Supporting Information, Movie S3). For the kinetically controlled scenario (Figure 3 f,h; blue), the smaller aggregates can fully break apart, and the exchange of particles is relatively rapid in comparison to the diffusion-limited scenario (Supporting Information, Movie S4).
With the above understanding of the phase-space of the system, we systematically varied the parameters of our system and calculated (Supporting Information, Section S3) the exponential growth constants, k, for each profile within the kinetically controlled domain (as discussed above and shown in Figure 3). The equation describing the exponential growth regime is nT(t)=nT,o exp(k(t−t0)/τ0), where it is convenient to define 1+r=exp(k) such that r gives the percentage increase in the population per unit time (Figure 1 e). The results from these simulations are summarized in Figure 4, where the color maps indicate the magnitudes of r values. The most important finding of our work is that for strong inter-particle interactions (Figure 4) there exists a range of energy pulses (defined by the parameters τ/τ0 and τon/τ) in which the exponential growth rate is higher than the optimized rate under constant energy (as discussed in Figure 2). For example, when the particle density is η=0.037 (see the Supporting Information, Section S2 for discussion of other densities) the optimal/highest possible exponential growth rate for the constant-energy case is r=9.5 % when ε*=1.1. In contrast, when energy is delivered in optimized pulsed sequences, an exponential growth rate of r=17.6 % can be achieved when ε*=10, which is an 85 % increase in the production rate for the non-equilibrium system as compared to the maximal achievable production rate in the equilibrium system. We note that while the optimized growth rate continues to increase for stronger inter-particle interactions or larger densities (Figure 4), such system parameters become unrealistic in their implementation (that is, interaction potentials become stronger than can be achieved in experiments, the periodicity of light pulsing energy becomes smaller than the kinetic time scales of typical molecular switches; packing densities are too high to allow the crystals to sufficiently melt, and so on).
In conclusion, our theoretical considerations suggest that periodic energy delivery to a self-replicating system can increase the rate of self-replication. To develop efficient self-replicating systems, proper timing of energy delivery outside of the confines of thermodynamic equilibrium should be considered. Of course, construction of such systems in the laboratory remains an exciting yet formidable challenge for experimental research, which we hope to stimulate and facilitate.
The interaction between two spherical units that are not in the same dimer template was modeled using shifted-LJ (ON state) or WCA (OFF state) potentials11 (see Figure 1 b). Both potentials can be expressed in the form u(r)=uLJ(r)−uc,r≤rc;u(r)=0,r>rc, where uLJ(r)=4ε[(σ/r)12−(σ/r)6] and r is the distance between the two spherical units. The cut-off distance rc was 2.5 σ and 21/6 σ for the ON and OFF states, respectively; The tail correction was uc=uLJ(rc). Two spherical units in the same dimer template interacted by a harmonic spring potential ubond(r)=ks(r−σ)2/2, where the spring constant ks was fixed at 200 kB T/σ2. If two individual particles and a dimer template moved close to one another such that the three interparticle distances (see Figure 1 d for definition) were all smaller than rcrit=21/6 σ (see Figure 1 b), the two spheres immediately bonded to form a new dimer in which they interacted by the harmonic spring potential defined above.
A recently developed kinetic Monte Carlo (KMC) algorithm10, 11 was implemented to simulate the self-replication process. The algorithm was derived from a renormalization approach in which the Smoluchowski diffusion equations are renormalized to a master equation with transition rates identical to the Glauber definition of transition probabilities.11 In the present work, an NVT ensemble with periodic boundary conditions was used. One dimer template and 998 individual particles (that is, n=1000 spherical units in total) were randomly placed in a cubic box at t=0. For subsequent times, one KMC step consisted of the following: 1) randomly picking one spherical unit S; 2) randomly generating a direction in the three-dimensional space and attempting a move of S along this direction with a fixed step size a; 3) calculating the energy change Δu caused by this move and accepting the move with the Glauber definition of transition probability p=1/[1+exp(Δu/kB T)]; 4) if the move was accepted, checking whether the self-replication condition was satisfied, if so, updating the particle type. A KMC sweep contained n such KMC steps and corresponded to a step in time given by Δt=τ0(a/σ)2/12.11 The step size a was chosen as 0.1 σ, consistent with previous KMC simulations in similar light-switchable nanocolloid systems. See Ref. 11 for a justification of this step size and discussion about the advantages of the KMC method over the traditional Brownian dynamics approach. For each set of system parameters studied, 100 independent KMC simulations were performed giving the averages discussed in the main text.
- 1aSci. Am. 1959, 200, 105–114;,
- 4bÉtude thermodynamique des phénomènes irréversibles, Dunod, Paris, 1947;,
As a service to our authors and readers, this journal provides supporting information supplied by the authors. Such materials are peer reviewed and may be re-organized for online delivery, but are not copy-edited or typeset. Technical support issues arising from supporting information (other than missing files) should be addressed to the authors.
Please note: Wiley Blackwell is not responsible for the content or functionality of any supporting information supplied by the authors. Any queries (other than missing content) should be directed to the corresponding author for the article.