M.J.L. thanks the EPSRC for a DTA studentship. O.A.B. and T.L. thank the European Research Council for funding under the European Union’s Framework Program (FP7/2007-2013) ERC Advanced Grant Agreement no. 267426.
Nitrite-Templated Synthesis of Lanthanide-Containing Rotaxanes for Anion Sensing†
Article first published online: 2 JUL 2014
© 2014 The Authors. Published by Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA. This is an open access article under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Angewandte Chemie International Edition
Volume 53, Issue 43, pages 11463–11466, October 20, 2014
How to Cite
Langton, M. J., Blackburn, O. A., Lang, T., Faulkner, S. and Beer, P. D. (2014), Nitrite-Templated Synthesis of Lanthanide-Containing Rotaxanes for Anion Sensing. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed., 53: 11463–11466. doi: 10.1002/anie.201405131
- Issue published online: 14 OCT 2014
- Article first published online: 2 JUL 2014
- Manuscript Received: 9 MAY 2014
- Funded Access
- European Research Council. Grant Numbers: FP7/2007-2013, 267426
- supramolecular chemistry;
- template synthesis
The first anion-templated synthesis of a lanthanide-containing interlocked molecule is demonstrated by utilizing a nitrite anion to template initial pseudorotaxane formation. Subsequent stoppering of the interpenetrated assembly allows for the preparation of a lanthanide-functionalized rotaxane in high yield. Following removal of the nitrite anion template, the europium rotaxane host is demonstrated to recognize and sense fluoride selectively.
Interlocked molecular architectures, such as rotaxanes and catenanes, have been the subject of intense recent research, driven by proposed utilization in molecular machines and nanotechnological applications.1–5 Furthermore, the unique topological cavity formed between the interlocked components can be exploited for molecular recognition.6 Whilst metal cations have been used extensively as templates for interlocked molecule synthesis,7–12 employing anions as templates is less well developed. Discrete anion templation has, however, been demonstrated as an efficient route to interlocked molecule formation,6 with the resulting host structures displaying enhanced selectivity for binding the templating anion. Although a range of templating anions have been utilized for rotaxane and catenane synthesis, including halides,13, 14 sulfate,15, 16 and most recently nitrate,17 the use of the nitrite anion as a template in synthesis is, to the best of our knowledge, unprecedented. Incorporating redox- or photo-active reporter groups within interlocked host architectures enables the development of sensors which exhibit selective electrochemical or optical responses upon guest binding.18 However, while phosphorescent transition metal complexes and organic fluorophores have been extensively utilized in such optical anion sensors, the integration of lanthanide reporter groups within the binding cavity of such interlocked hosts has not been achieved,19 despite the usefulness of emissive lanthanide complexes in imaging, sensing, and assay.20, 21
We describe herein the first anion-templated synthesis of a lanthanide-containing interlocked molecule, by the unprecedented use of a nitrite anion template. The rotaxane host system, isolated in high yields, is capable of sensing fluoride anions selectively by means of the luminescent europium center integrated within the rotaxane’s macrocycle component.
The nitrite anion templation synthetic strategy used to prepare the target lanthanide-rotaxane is shown in Scheme 1. The bidentate nitrite anion templates the formation of an initial pseudorotaxane, by simultaneously coordinating to the lanthanide cation bound within a kinetically stable DOTA-derived (DOTA=1,4,7,10-tetraazacyclododecane-1,4,7,10-tetraacetic acid) macrocycle, and to the hydrogen bonding bis-amide pyridinium motif of the axle precursor. Stoppering of this interpenetrated assembly affords the rotaxane, which after removal of the templating nitrite anion, reveals an anion-binding cavity formed between the interlocked lanthanide macrocycle and the axle bis-amide pyridinium motif.
Macrocycle 1⋅OTf11 and the chloride salt of azide-functionalized bis-amide pyridinium axle precursor 2+ 22 were prepared as previously described. 2⋅NO2 was prepared by anion exchange from the chloride salt using a nitrite-loaded Amberlite anion-exchange resin. The synthesis of the target lanthanide rotaxanes was achieved using a copper(I)-catalyzed cycloaddition azide–alkyne (CuAAC) click stoppering reaction as shown in Scheme 2.
A solution of 1 equivalent of 2⋅NO2 with 1.5 equivalents of the appropriate macrocyclic lanthanide complex (1 a⋅OTf and 1 b⋅OTf) in dry 3:2 CH2Cl2/CH3CN was stirred in the presence of a catalytic amount of [Cu(CH3CN)4]PF6 and 1 equivalent of stopper alkyne 3 at room temperature for 48 h. Following purification by size exclusion chromatography, to remove the non-interlocked macrocycle and axle byproducts, rotaxanes 4 a⋅NO2⋅OTf and 4 b⋅NO2⋅OTf were isolated in impressive yields of 51 % and 45 %, respectively, and characterized by NMR spectroscopy, mass spectrometry, and HPLC (see Supporting Information (SI) and Figure 1). The 1H NMR spectrum of 4 a⋅NO2⋅OTf was broad, even in [D6]DMSO at 353 K (see SI). However, the upfield shift and splitting of the hydroquinone protons of the macrocycle is clearly observed and is diagnostic of aromatic donor–acceptor interactions between the electron-rich hydroquinone groups of the macrocycle and the electron-deficient pyridinium axle motif, consistent with the interlocked nature of the rotaxane. HPLC analysis was used to establish the purity of rotaxanes 4 a⋅NO2⋅OTf and 4 b⋅NO2⋅OTf, which exhibited marked differences in retention times to the non-interlocked axle and macrocycle components, providing further evidence as to the interlocked nature of the rotaxane species (see SI). In addition, mass spectrometry provided further structural characterization of the interlocked rotaxane systems (see Figure 1 and SI for further details).
Importantly, the rotaxanation reaction was also attempted using the non-coordinating hexafluorophosphate salt of axle precursor 2⋅PF6, however, no rotaxane was detected in the reaction mixture, highlighting the crucial role of the nitrite anion in templating rotaxane formation. The rotaxane synthesis was also attempted using Cl− and F− as the templating anion: when the reaction was conducted with 2⋅Cl only a trace amount of rotaxane was observed by mass spectrometry and could not be isolated, whilst with F−, added as the tetrabutylammonium (TBA) salt to 2⋅PF6, no evidence of rotaxane formation was detected.
In order to investigate the anion binding properties of rotaxane 4 b2+, it was necessary to remove the nitrite anion template by exchanging to the weakly coordinating triflate salt. Luminescence anion binding titrations were conducted with 1 b⋅OTf and 4 b⋅(OTf)2 in 99:1 acetone/water solution, by adding aliquots of anions as their TBA salts and monitoring changes in emission intensity from the europium center.23 Association constants were determined by fitting intensity changes to a 1:1 stoichiometric binding model using the Dynafit program;24 the values obtained are given in Table 1. Representative data are shown in Figure 2; all other spectra and binding isotherms are provided in the Supporting Information. Addition of fluoride to rotaxane 4 b⋅(OTf)2 resulted in a drastic decrease in emission intensity from the europium center, down to 10 % of its original value at the end of the titration (Figure 2). In contrast, addition of acetate and nitrite led to more modest quenching, whilst no response was observed upon addition of chloride. Likewise, addition of anions to macrocycle 1 b⋅OTf resulted in similar quenching of the europium emission, but to a lesser extent than in rotaxane 4 b⋅(OTf)2. The effect of fluoride on the europium emission of 1 b⋅OTf and 4 b⋅(OTf)2 is also evident by inspection of the luminescence lifetimes (Table 2). The significant lengthening of the lifetimes of 1 b⋅OTf and 4 b⋅(OTf)2 upon addition of fluoride is indicative of displacement of water from the inner coordination sphere of the metal, and is consistent with binding of fluoride at the lanthanide center. Further evidence for this can be gleaned from the marked change in the intensity of the hypersensitive ΔJ=2 bands relative to the other bands in the spectra (see SI), which signifies a change in environment about the metal. By comparison, nitrite has apparently no effect on the luminescence lifetimes of 1 b⋅OTf or 4 b⋅(OTf)2, and there is no significant change in the ratios of ΔJ=2 vs. ΔJ=1 or ΔJ=4 over the course of the titrations. The quenching of europium emission in this case can be assigned to an attractive association of the anion with the organic moieties of the interlocked architecture, which leads to less efficient energy transfer from the chromophore to lanthanide, while the latter remains hydrated. Acetate presents an intermediate case in which the lifetimes are increased, but to a lesser degree than with fluoride. This infers a combination of effects resulting from anion binding at the metal and interaction with the organic host framework.
|Anion[b]||Rotaxane 4 b⋅(OTf)2||Macrocycle 1 b⋅OTf|
|F−||2.42×105 [1.08–8.15×105]||9.69×104 [7.75–12.5×104]|
|AcO−||2.42×104 [1.94–3.08×104]||1.55×103 [1.11–2.13×103]|
|NO2−||4.33×103 [3.30–5.62×103]||1.10×104 [0.67–1.76×104]|
|Anion[a]||Rotaxane 4 b⋅(OTf)2||Macrocycle 1 b⋅OTf|
|no anion||0.69, 0.16||0.51|
The anion association constants obtained (Table 1) suggest superior binding of fluoride to both macrocycle 1 b⋅OTf and rotaxane 4 b⋅(OTf)2 compared with nitrite and acetate. Bearing in mind the above discussion, this implies that anion association at the europium metal center is most effective. For fluoride and acetate, the rotaxane system 4 b⋅(OTf)2 displays stronger binding than the macrocycle 1 b⋅OTf. This indicates that formation of the interlocked structure with additional hydrogen bond donor groups augments anion binding at the lanthanide center. In the case of nitrite, the anion is unable to displace the coordinated water molecule at the lanthanide center, and the additional hydrogen bond donors confer no enhancement of nitrite association in the interlocked structure. Indeed, binding is marginally weaker than in the macrocycle alone, presumably due to steric constraints.
With the aim of developing functional anion sensory assemblies that exploit both the advantageous properties of lanthanide luminescence and the unique recognition properties of mechanically bonded architectures, the first anion-templated synthesis of a lanthanide-containing interlocked structure has been demonstrated. The bidentate coordination behaviour of a nitrite anion is used to template the formation of a pseudorotaxane assembly, by simultaneous coordination to a lanthanide cation incorporated within a macrocycle and a hydrogen-bond donor threading component. The novel rotaxanes are prepared in high yield by stoppering of these interpenetrated assemblies. Crucially, the nitrite anion template is essential for rotaxane formation, with no product formed in its absence. It is noteworthy that, to the best of our knowledge, nitrite has not previously been used in template-directed synthesis. Luminescence anion binding investigations with the europium containing rotaxane host reveals its selectivity for fluoride over acetate, nitrite and chloride anions.
- 19Our previously reported lanthanide-appended rotaxane exhibited chloride responsive behavior, however, binding of the anion at the peripheral lanthanide, as determined by luminescence changes, was independent and essentially unaffected by binding within the interlocked recognition site. (See: Chem. Sci. 2012, 4, 489–493)., , , , , , , , ,
- 23To avoid excitation of the solvent, the compounds were excited into the tail of the organic chromophore absorption, using 360 nm light.
As a service to our authors and readers, this journal provides supporting information supplied by the authors. Such materials are peer reviewed and may be re-organized for online delivery, but are not copy-edited or typeset. Technical support issues arising from supporting information (other than missing files) should be addressed to the authors.
Please note: Wiley Blackwell is not responsible for the content or functionality of any supporting information supplied by the authors. Any queries (other than missing content) should be directed to the corresponding author for the article.