Von Economo Neurons in the Elephant Brain
Article first published online: 16 DEC 2008
Copyright © 2008 Wiley-Liss, Inc.
The Anatomical Record
Volume 292, Issue 2, pages 242–248, February 2009
How to Cite
Hakeem, A. Y., Sherwood, C. C., Bonar, C. J., Butti, C., Hof, P. R. and Allman, J. M. (2009), Von Economo Neurons in the Elephant Brain. Anat Rec, 292: 242–248. doi: 10.1002/ar.20829
- Issue published online: 28 JAN 2009
- Article first published online: 16 DEC 2008
- Manuscript Accepted: 19 SEP 2008
- Manuscript Received: 27 JUN 2008
- James S. McDonnell Foundation
- Von Economo neuron;
- frontoinsular cortex;
- large brains
Von Economo neurons (VENs), previously found in humans, all of the great ape species, and four cetacean species, are also present in African and Indian elephants. The VENs in the elephant are primarily found in similar locations to those in the other species. They are most abundant in the frontoinsular cortex (area FI) and are also present at lower density in the anterior cingulate cortex. Additionally, they are found in a dorsolateral prefrontal area and less abundantly in the region of the frontal pole. The VEN morphology appears to have arisen independently in hominids, cetaceans, and elephants, and may reflect a specialization for the rapid transmission of crucial social information in very large brains. Anat Rec 2009. © 2008 Wiley-Liss, Inc.
The Von Economo neurons (VENs) are large, bipolar neurons located in layers 3 and 5 of frontoinsular (FI) and anterior cingulate cortex (ACC) in great apes and humans, but not in other primates (Allman et al.,2005; Nimchinsky et al.,1999). The VENs have also been discovered in regions corresponding to FI and ACC in the humpback, fin, sperm, and killer whales (Hof and Van der Gucht,2007). Morphological, biochemical, and neuropathological evidence suggests that VENs are part of the neural circuitry involved in social awareness and may participate in fast, intuitive decisions in complex and rapidly changing social situations (Allman et al.,2005). The VENs are more numerous in humans than in apes and may be part of the neural circuitry supporting complex social behavior in hominids (great apes and humans). The large size of the VENs, the morphological simplicity of their dendritic architecture, and many other features suggest that they are specialized for rapid transmission of information over long distances (Hofman et al.,1987; Nimchinsky et al.,1995; Allman et al.,2002). The bipolar dendrites of VENs are shaped and positioned to integrate information from an entire cortical minicolumn and to rapidly relay output to other brain structures (Watson et al.,2006). The VENs are selectively affected in a variant of frontotemporal dementia (FTD) that causes the loss of social awareness and the capacity to self-monitor in social situations (Seeley et al.,2006), and thus are implicated in social functioning. We sought to determine whether a similar neuronal morphological specialization was present in elephants, which have independently evolved large brain size and the capacity for highly complex social behavior (Balfour and Balfour,1997; Moss,2000; Sukumar,2003).
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The African elephant brains were obtained from the Cleveland Metroparks Zoo. Elephant 1 was a female of ∼42 years of age at the time of death. This individual was wild-born and was acquired from Africa in 1955. At death, she had a pheochromocytoma (tumor of her adrenal medulla). She probably died of a sudden hypertensive crisis from hormone release by the tumor (Bonar et al.,2005). Elephant 2 was a female of 16 or 17 years of age, wild-born and acquired from Africa around 1980. Probable cause of death was a sudden cardiac arrhythmia. Histologic examination of every major organ was negative, as was serologic testing for encephalomyocarditis virus. Cortical samples were obtained from the brain of an adult female Indian elephant (Elephas maximus) that died of natural causes in a zoologic park. The brain was fixed at necropsy by immersion in a large volume of formalin. The specimen was kept in formalin in the collection of the Department of Anatomical Sciences, University of Adelaide, Australia.
The African elephant brains were cut into ∼20-mm-thick coronal slabs at necropsy and fixed in 10% formalin. Each slab through the frontal lobes of the right and left hemispheres of Elephant 1 and the left hemisphere of Elephant 2 was placed on a specially machined microtome stage containing a large reservoir of dry ice. The slabs were frozen and cut with a sliding microtome into 120-μm-thick coronal sections. The exposed block face was photographed before each section was sliced from the frozen slab. Every 20th section through the frontal lobes was mounted on a gelatin-coated slide. Sectioning photographs were used to ensure the sections were mounted in the correct orientation. For higher resolution in the region of FI, every 4th section was mounted. The sections were dried, stained with a cresyl violet Nissl stain, and protected with a coverslip. The entire frontal cortex was examined for the presence of VENs. The plotting of the VENs in Figs. 2 and 4 was done at 400× using the program Neurolucida (MBF Bioscience, Williston, VT). The stereological counting was performed using StereoInvestigator (MBF Bioscience).
We also studied histological sections made in the 1960s from the brains of three adult male bottlenose dolphins (Tursiops truncatus, brain weights 1420–1585 g) that had been gravity-perfused in situ through the descending aorta with 40 L of heparinized Windle's fluid following lethal anesthesia (McFarland et al.,1969). Mantee, rock hyrax, tenrec, and armadillo brains examined are part of the Welker Collection at the National Museum of Health and Medicine. These brains were celloidin embedded, sectioned at 35 μm, and stained with a thionin Nissl stain.
From the brain of the Indian elephant, we collected 5- to 6-mm-thick surface samples from the anterior and posterior cingulate cortex, the frontal polar region, various sites over the temporoparietal convexity, and the hippocampal formation. These blocks were cryoprotected, sectioned at 40 μm on a cryostat, and 1:20 series of sections were stained with cresyl violet.
The brains of the bottlenose dolphins were embedded in celloidin, sectioned at 35 μm on a large specimen microtome, and every 5th and 6th sections were stained with either the Loyez-Weigert method for myelin or the Bielchowsky-Plien cresyl violet for cellular architecture (Jacobs et al.,1971; Hof et al.,2005).
Whole brains of rock hyrax (N = 2), giant elephant shrew (N = 1), two-toed sloth (N = 2), lesser anteater (N = 1), giant anteater (N = 1), and bontebok (N = 1) were obtained from the Cleveland Metroparks Zoo or the Philadelphia Zoo and came from animals that had died of natural causes. Considering the species-specific age of sexual maturity, the giant anteater and one of the two-toed sloths were juveniles; all other specimens were from adults. The entire left cerebral hemisphere of each brain was sectioned for histology and a 1:10 series of sections was stained for Nissl substance with a solution of 0.5% cresyl violet. In addition, immunohistochemistry was performed on an adjacent series of sections in these brains with a monoclonal antibody against a nonphosphorylated epitope on the neurofilament H protein (NPNFP) (dilution 1:2,000; SMI-32 antibody; Covance International, Princeton, NJ). Immunostaining with the SMI-32 antibody labels the soma and dendrites of a subset of projection neuron types, including VENs in humans (5).
We sectioned the brains of two female African elephants (Loxodonta africana). We examined a series of Nissl-stained sections from both hemispheres of the brain of one elephant (Elephant 1) and the left hemisphere of the other elephant (Elephant 2). In several locations in these brains we discovered neurons with the same morphology as the VENs seen in humans, great apes, and cetaceans (Nimchinsky et al.,1999; Allman et al.,2005; Watson et al.,2006; Hof and Van der Gucht,2007). These large neurons have an elongated, spindle-shaped soma, a single large apical dendrite, and a single large basal dendrite with no branching near the soma. In hominids they are found primarily in layer 5 of area FI and anterior ACC, but smaller numbers are also present in dorsolateral prefrontal cortex in humans (Fajardo et al.,2008). Cetaceans have VEN populations in FI and ACC, but mysticetes also have numerous VENs in frontopolar cortex (Hof and Van der Gucht,2007). Figure 1 shows photomicrographs of VENs in area FI (Fig. 1A,D) and a dorsolateral frontal area (Fig. 1B) in the African elephant. We also have evidence for VENs in ACC of an Indian elephant (Elephas maximus) (Fig. 1C).
The main concentration of VENs in the elephant brain is in a cortical domain similar in location to area FI of humans and apes. Figure 2 illustrates a section through area FI of the right hemisphere of Elephant 1. We plotted the location of each VEN in the area corresponding to FI in this section. The inset tracing of Fig. 2A shows the VEN distribution map. Note that the VENs are more numerous at the crowns of the gyri and are nearly absent in the cortex below the fundus of each sulcus. This is a characteristic pattern that we have also observed in FI in human, ape, and cetacean brains. The location of the FI VENs was similar in all three hemispheres examined. Figure 3 uses section outlines to illustrate the locations of right and left FI in Elephant 1, as well as the locations of smaller number of VENs in the subgenual anterior cingulate cortex (SG), and in a dorsolateral frontal area (DL). We additionally observed VENs in a dorsomedial area (DM) in the right hemisphere of Elephant 1, but not in the left. There were a small number of VENs located near the frontal pole, a region in which a more substantial amount of VENs have also been observed in the humpback whale (Megaptera novaeangliae), in the fin whale (Balaenoptera physalus), in the sperm whale (Physeter macrocephalus), and in the killer whale (Orcinus orca) (Hof and Van der Gucht,2007). The VENs in elephant ACC occur at lower density than in humans and great apes (Nimchinsky et al.,1999).
As has been observed in humans, great apes, and cetaceans, the VENs of the elephant are primarily found in layer 5 of the cortical regions that contain them, along with populations of other large pyramidal neurons with distinctive morphologies such as the compass cells, which were also described by Von Economo (Von Economo and Koskinas,1925). This typical layering can be seen in Fig. 4, which shows a magnified portion of area FI. As in Fig. 2, the tracing indicates the locations of all the VENs in the photographed region. In this region of FI, there are a series of dense clusters of cells in the subcortical white matter (see Fig. 2B). We believe these clusters may possibly correspond to the claustrum, and we suggest the term “claustral islands” to refer to them.
To quantify the number of VENs in area FI in the African elephant, we performed stereological counts on a series of sections through area FI from the left and right hemisphere of Elephant 1. Table 1 contains the results of these counts. The number of VENs found in Elephant 1 (19,310) is lower than the number in adult humans (average total 193,000 VENs), but is higher than the average number found in great apes (average total 6,950 VENs) (Allman et al.,2005). We also counted the total number of neurons in the VEN-containing region and found that VENs make up 0.78% of the total neurons in layers 3 and 5 of FI in the right hemisphere and 2.6% of total neurons in these FI layers in the left hemisphere, reflecting a smaller but more densely populated left FI.
|VENs in FI||VEN CE Gunderson m = 1||VEN CE Schmitz-Hof 1st||Neurons in FI||Neuron CE Gunderson m = 1||Neuron CE Schmitz-Hof 1st||VEN %|
|Elephant 1 right hemisphere||10,200||0.05||0.05||1,300,000||0.05||0.04||0.78%|
|Elephant 1 left hemisphere||9,110||0.08||0.08||348,000||0.06||0.09||2.6%|
Whereas humans and great apes have VENs, monkeys and strepsirhine primates do not (Nimchinsky et al.,1999). VENs are also present in areas corresponding to FI and ACC in humpback, fin, sperm, and killer whales. We have recently found them in the bottlenose dolphin (Tursiops truncatus) as well (see Fig. 1E). To determine whether any of the closest relatives of the elephant have VENs, we examined brains from the rock hyrax (Heterohyrax brucei), manatee (Trichechus manatus latirostris), and giant elephant shrew, as well as xenarthrans (one species of sloth, one of armadillo, two species of anteaters, and three species of tenrec). We also examined an ungulate, the bontebok (Damaliscus pygargus), because some alternative phylogenies maintain a close relationship between ungulates and elephants (Eisenberg,1981). No VENs can be found in the cortex of these animals except for manatee, in which an occasional isolated VEN-like cell can be observed, but without significant VEN populations in either FI or ACC. Two species of rodents, the brown rat (Rattus norvegicus) and the paca (Cuniculus paca), were also found to lack VENs. These data are summarized in Fig. 5, a cladogram based on extensive molecular genetic evidence showing the relationship of various mammalian groups to the elephant (Murphy et al.,2001).
The VEN morphology appears to have arisen independently in hominids, cetaceans, and elephants. The VEN specialization may parallel the emergence of very large brain size in these mammals. The evolution of large brain size may place a special premium on overcoming geometric constraints to maintain rapid transmission of crucial information, and this need may explain the independent emergence of the VENs in these species. There are a few mammals apart from hominids, cetaceans, and elephants that have brains somewhat larger than the apes. It would be interesting to determine whether or not these mammals, such as the giraffes and hippopotamuses, have VENs in parts of the brain corresponding to FI and ACC. If they are present, it would suggest that the VEN morphology may be primarily related to absolute brain size. If not, it would suggest that the VENs may be related to behavioral specializations common to hominids, whales, and elephants. One such behavioral specialization could be mirror self-recognition (Reiss and Marino,2001; Plotnik et al.,2006). However, this awaits confirmation from further studies.
From a functional viewpoint, in humans, FI is strongly activated by negative social feedback in the form of frowning faces and by the command to end an ongoing activity (Ullsperger and von Cramon,2003; Aron and Poldrack,2006). FI is activated in a number of social situations in which empathy, guilt, embarrassment, and resentment are strongly present (Shin et al.,2000; Berthoz et al.,2002; Sanfey et al.,2003; Singer et al.,2004). Each of these situations involves negative feedback with respect to some aspect of the social network in which an individual is participating. FI is activated when subjects scrutinize a face to determine the intentions of another individual (Baron-Cohen et al.,1999). The anterior insula and adjacent cortex is involved in many aspects of self-awareness of bodily states including heart rate and pain (for review see Craig,2003) and in the conscious awareness of having committed an error (Klein et al.,2007). Thus the VENs and related insular circuitry may be involved in monitoring changes in the physiological network of an individual's own body and that individual's social network. In each case, the VENs may be involved in initiating homeostatic corrections to changes in network states. This conceptualization resembles the “somatic marker hypothesis” of Damasio (1994) in linking bodily awareness to social functioning, although it places more emphasis on specialized circuitry within FI, ACC, and related brain structures and the role of this circuitry in initiating error-correcting responses.
There are well-documented instances in which elephants appear to respond empathically to situations in which other group members are threatened (Poole and Moss,2008). In one incident, a drowning elephant calf was saved when the matriarch and another adult female climbed into a lake, positioned themselves on each side of calf, and, using their tusks and trunks, lifted the calf to safety on the shore (Reflections on Elephants, 1994, National Geographic Video). In another example, a male elephant was observed for several hours providing care to a dying companion by trying to force him to stand when he fell down and bringing him water to drink (Balfour and Balfour,1997). The VENs may enhance the functioning of the circuitry within FI, ACC, and related structures involved in social awareness, heightening alertness to the distress of others and resulting in such instances of empathy and other complex social behaviors.
We thank Virginie Goubert for her assistance in preparing the histological sections and Herb Adams for machining the microtome stage for the sectioning of the elephant brains. We thank Jason Surace for his assistance in preparing the African elephant brains for transport. We thank Cheryl Stimpson and Amy Garrison for assistance with histological preparation of other mammalian brains. We are grateful to Dr. Alisa Newton of the Philadelphia Zoo for providing access to the giant elephant shrew brain. We thank Prof. Maciej Henneberg for providing the Indian elephant brain samples, and Drs. Peter J. Morgane and Ilya I. Glezer for the histologic materials from the bottlenose dolphin brains.
- 2002. Two phylogenetic specializations in the human brain. Neuroscientist 8: 335–346. , , .
- 2005. Intuition and autism: a possible role for Von Economo neurons. Trends Cogn Sci 9: 367–373. , , , .
- 2006. Cortical and subcortical contributions to stop signal response inhibition: role of the subthalamic nucleus. J Neurosci 26: 2424–2433. , .
- 1997. African elephants. New York: Abbeville Press. , .
- 1999. Social intelligence in the normal and autistic brain: an fMRI study. Eur J Neurosci 11: 1891–1898. , , , , , , .
- 2002. An fMRI study of intentional and unintentional (embarrassing) violations of social norms. Brain 125: 1696–1708. , , , .
- 2005. Pheochromocytoma in an aged female African elephant (Loxodonta africana). J Zoo Wildlife Med 36: 719–723. , , , .
- 2003. Interoception: the sense of the physiological condition of the body. Curr Opin Neurobiol 13: 500–505. .
- 1994. Descartes error. New York: Grosset-Putnam. .
- 1981. The Mammalian radiations. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. .
- 2008. Von Economo neurons are present in the dorsolateral (dysgranular) prefrontal cortex of humans. Neurosci Lett 435: 215–218. , , , , , , .
- 2005. Cortical complexity in cetacean brains. Anat Rec 287: 1142–1152. , , .
- 2007. Structure of the cerebral cortex of the humpback whale, Megaptera novaeangliae (Cetacea, Mysticeti, Balaenopteridae). Anat Rec 290: 1–31. , .
- 1987. Neurofilament gene expression: a major determinant of axonal caliber. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 84: 3472–3476. , , , , , .
- 1971. The anatomy of the brain of the bottlenose dolphin (Tursiops truncatus). Rhinic lobe (rhinencephalon) I. The paleocortex. J Comp Neurol 141: 205–272. , , .
- 2007. Neural correlates of error awareness. Neuroimage 34: 1774–1781. , , , , , .
- 1969. Ventricular system of the brain of the dolphin, Tursiops truncatus, with comparative anatomical observations and relations to brain specializations. J Comp Neurol 135: 275–368. , , .
- 2000. Elephant memories. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. .
- 2001. Resolution of the early placental mammal radiation using Bayesian phylogenetics. Science 294: 2348–2351. , , , , , , , , , , .
- 1999. A neuronal morphologic type unique to humans and great apes. Proc Nat Acad Sci USA 96: 5268–5273. , , , , , .
- 1995. Spindle neurons of the human anterior cingulate cortex. J Comp Neurol 355: 27–37. , , , .
- 2006. Self-recognition in an Asian elephant. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 103: 17053–17057. , , .
- 2008. Elephant sociality and complexity: the scientific evidence. In: WemmerC,ChristenC, editors. Elephants and ethics: toward a morality of coexistence. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press. p 69–98. , .
- 2001. Mirror self-recognition in the bottlenose dolphin: a case of cognitive convergence. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 98: 5937–5942. , .
- 2003. The neural basis of economic decision-making in the ultimatum game. Science 300: 1755–1758. , , , , .
- 2006. Early frontotemporal dementia targets neurons unique to apes and humans. Ann Neurol 60: 660–667. , , , , , , .
- 2000. Activation of anterior paralimbic structures during guilt-related script-driven imagery. Biol Psychiatry 48: 43–50. , , , , , , , , .
- 2004. Empathy for pain involves the affective but not sensory components of pain. Science 303: 1157–1162. , , , , , .
- 2003. The living elephants. Oxford: Oxford University Press. .
- 2003. Error monitoring using external feedback: specific roles of the habenular complex, the reward system, and the cingulate motor area revealed by functional magnetic resonance imaging. J Neurosci 23: 4308–4314. , .
- 1925. Die cytoarchitectonik der hirnrinde des erwachsenen menschen. Berlin: Springer. , .
- 2006. Dendritic architecture of the von Economo neurons. Neuroscience 141: 1107–1112. , , .