Dr. Ernste owns stock or stock options in Amylin Pharmaceuticals.
The lifetime risk of adult-onset rheumatoid arthritis and other inflammatory autoimmune rheumatic diseases
Article first published online: 25 FEB 2011
Copyright © 2011 by the American College of Rheumatology
Arthritis & Rheumatism
Volume 63, Issue 3, pages 633–639, March 2011
How to Cite
Crowson, C. S., Matteson, E. L., Myasoedova, E., Michet, C. J., Ernste, F. C., Warrington, K. J., Davis, J. M., Hunder, G. G., Therneau, T. M. and Gabriel, S. E. (2011), The lifetime risk of adult-onset rheumatoid arthritis and other inflammatory autoimmune rheumatic diseases. Arthritis & Rheumatism, 63: 633–639. doi: 10.1002/art.30155
- Issue published online: 3 FEB 2011
- Article first published online: 25 FEB 2011
- Accepted manuscript online: 28 DEC 2010 04:02PM EST
- Manuscript Accepted: 9 NOV 2010
- Manuscript Received: 13 JUL 2010
- NIH (National Institute of Arthritis and Musculoskeletal and Skin Diseases). Grant Number: R01-AR-46849
- Rochester Epidemiology Project from the National Institute on Aging. Grant Number: R01-AG-034676
Understanding of the personal risks for rheumatoid arthritis (RA) and other rheumatic diseases remains poor, despite advances in knowledge with regard to their pathogenesis, therapeutics, and clinical impact, in part because the personal lifetime risk of developing these diseases is unknown. This study was undertaken to estimate the lifetime risk of RA, as well as other inflammatory autoimmune rheumatic diseases, including systemic lupus erythematosus, psoriatic arthritis, polymyalgia rheumatica (PMR), giant cell arteritis, ankylosing spondylitis, and Sjögren's syndrome, and to provide an overall estimate of the risk of developing inflammatory autoimmune rheumatic disease over a lifetime.
Using the incidence rates obtained from our population-based studies of rheumatic diseases among residents of Olmsted County, Minnesota, and mortality rates from life tables for the general population, we estimated the sex-specific lifetime risk of rheumatic disease.
The lifetime risk of RA developing in US adults was 3.6% for women and 1.7% for men, and the lifetime risk of rheumatoid factor–positive RA was 2.4% for women and 1.1% for men. The second most common inflammatory autoimmune rheumatic disease was PMR, with a lifetime risk of 2.4% for women and 1.7% for men. The overall lifetime risk of inflammatory autoimmune rheumatic disease was 8.4% for women and 5.1% for men.
One in 12 women and 1 in 20 men will develop an inflammatory autoimmune rheumatic disease during their lifetime. These results can serve as useful guides in counseling patients regarding their lifetime risk of these conditions and have important implications regarding disease awareness campaigns.
Despite the increased visibility of rheumatoid arthritis (RA) and other rheumatic diseases resulting from the advent of new pharmacotherapies, understanding of the personal risk and public health impact of rheumatic disease remains poor. Rheumatic diseases are numerous, with risks that vary in magnitude and differ by age and sex. Among the most common inflammatory autoimmune rheumatic diseases, in addition to RA, are systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE), psoriatic arthritis (PsA), polymyalgia rheumatica (PMR), giant cell arteritis (GCA), ankylosing spondylitis (AS), and Sjögren's syndrome (SS). Estimates of incidence or prevalence are available for these diseases, providing valuable public health information regarding the burden of disease at the population level (1, 2). However, prevalence rates underestimate the individual risk for diseases that have increased mortality, and incidence rates report only yearly risk.
From an individual's perspective, the absolute risk of developing disease over a lifetime, such as the well-known lifetime risk of breast cancer among women of 1 in 8, is a more useful and understandable measure of risk than these summary rates (3, 4). In addition, such estimates provide a useful framework for quantification of the absolute risk of disease attributable to risk factors such as genetic variants. However, no estimates of lifetime risk of rheumatic diseases, separately or collectively, are available. The purpose of the present study was to estimate the lifetime risk of RA and other rheumatic diseases, including SLE, PsA, PMR, GCA, AS, and SS, as well as the lifetime risk of developing any one of these rheumatic diseases.
PATIENTS AND METHODS
Study subjects and design.
This retrospective population-based study of residents of Olmsted County, Minnesota, which includes the city of Rochester, was conducted using the resources of the Rochester Epidemiology Project, a medical records linkage system that allows ready access to complete medical records from all community medical providers (5). Cohorts of incident cases of RA, SLE, PsA, PMR, GCA, AS, and SS in this population were previously assembled (Table 1). Approval for this study was obtained from the Mayo Clinic and Olmsted Medical Center Institutional Review Boards, and the requirement for informed consent was waived.
|Disease||No. of cases (% female)||Time period|
|Primary SS||53 (93)||1976–1992|
The RA cohort included all 1,179 residents age ≥18 years who first fulfilled the 1987 American College of Rheumatology (ACR) classification criteria for RA between January 1, 1955 and December 31, 2007 (6–8). In 1995–2007, the age-adjusted incidence per 100,000 was 53.1 (95% confidence interval [95% CI] 47.3–58.9) in women and 27.7 (95% CI 23.1–32.2) in men. Results of rheumatoid factor (RF) tests were obtained for all patients. RF testing was performed by nephelometry (Beckman Auto ICS System; Beckman Coulter), which primarily measures IgM-RF, or latex agglutination assay (Dade RapiTex kit) for IgG-RF. Positive results were defined as ≥15 IU/ml or a semiquantitative titer of 1:80 or greater.
The SLE cohort included all 65 Rochester, Minnesota residents age ≥18 years who fulfilled the 1982 ACR criteria for the classification of SLE between January 1, 1950 and December 31, 1992 (9, 10). The incidence of SLE tripled in 1980–1992 compared to 1950–1979. The age- and sex-adjusted incidence of SLE was 5.6 (95% CI 3.9–7.2) per 100,000, with rates among women being 5–6–fold higher than those among men.
The PsA cohort included 147 Olmsted County, Minnesota residents age ≥18 years who first fulfilled the Classification of Psoriatic Arthritis (CASPAR) criteria between January 1, 1970 and December 31, 1999 (11, 12). The CASPAR criteria are defined as the presence of inflammatory articular disease (spinal, joint, or entheseal) and a score of 3 or more from the following 5 areas (each of which was assigned a score of 1, except for current psoriasis, which was assigned a score of 2): current psoriasis, personal history of psoriasis or family history of psoriasis, nail dystrophy, RF negativity, current dactylitis, and radiographic evidence of psoriatic bone changes. The age-adjusted incidence per 100,000 was higher in men (9.1 [95% CI 7.1–11.0]) than in women (5.4 [95% CI 4.0–6.9]). The age- and sex-adjusted incidence of PsA per 100,000 increased from 3.6 (95% CI 2.0–5.2) in 1970–1979 to 9.8 (95% CI 7.7–11.9) in 1990–1999.
The PMR cohort included 378 Olmsted County, Minnesota residents with incident PMR between January 1, 1970 and December 31, 1999 (13). Cases fulfilled the following 3 criteria: age ≥50 years; bilateral aching and morning stiffness (lasting ≥30 minutes) persisting for ≥1 month and involving ≥2 areas (neck or torso, shoulders or proximal regions of the arms, and hips or proximal aspects of the thighs); and erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR) >40 mm/hour (determined by the Westergren method). However, patients who fulfilled only the first 2 criteria and had documentation of a prompt response to corticosteroid therapy were also included. The incidence of PMR remained relatively stable over time, with an age-adjusted incidence per 100,000 of 69.8 (95% CI 61.2–78.4) in women and 44.8 (95% CI 37.0–52.6) in men.
The GCA cohort included 207 Olmsted County, Minnesota residents with incident GCA between January 1, 1950 and December 31, 2004 (14, 15). Cases fulfilled the 1990 ACR criteria for GCA, which require 3 of the following 5 criteria: age ≥50 years, new headache, temporal artery abnormality, elevated ESR ≥50 mm/hour (determined by the Westergren method), and abnormal artery biopsy findings (16). The age-adjusted incidence of GCA per 100,000 was 24.4 (95% CI 20.3–28.6) in women and 10.3 (95% CI 6.9–13.6) in men for 1950–1999. The incidence was similar for 2000–2004 (25.1 per 100,000 in women and 8.6 per 100,000 in men).
The AS cohort included 158 Rochester, Minnesota residents with incident AS between January 1, 1935 and December 31, 1989 (17). Cases fulfilled the modified New York criteria for definite AS (radiographic evidence of sacroiliitis, together with at least one of the following: inflammatory low back pain of 3 months' duration, limitation of lumbar spine movement in sagittal and frontal planes, or reduced chest expansion) (18). The age-adjusted incidence per 100,000 in men (11.7 [95% CI 9.6–13.8]) was 4 times that in women (2.9 [95% CI 2.0–3.9]), and the incidence declined significantly over time.
The SS cohort included 53 Olmsted County, Minnesota residents with a physician diagnosis of primary SS (i.e., those without a previous diagnosis of RA or SLE) between January 1, 1976 and December 31, 1992 (19). The overall age- and sex-adjusted incidence of primary SS was 3.9 per 100,000 (95% CI 2.8–4.9).
Using the most recent 10-year period available for each cohort, age- and sex-specific incidence rates were calculated by dividing the number of incident cases by the population estimates based on decennial census counts, with linear interpolation between census years (20). Poisson regression models for each sex with smoothing splines for age were used to model the incidence rates, allowing interpolation for individual years of age and decreasing the effects of variability in the rates. For PMR and GCA, which only occur at age ≥50 years, this reduced age range was used for Poisson modeling, and rates for age <50 years were set to 0. Primary inflammatory autoimmune rheumatic disease incidence rates were obtained by excluding from each cohort patients who had previously experienced another inflammatory autoimmune rheumatic disease and adding together the incidence rates for each of these primary disease cohorts.
Lifetime risk was estimated using established methods (21). Using a hypothetical cohort of 100,000 persons of age 18 years and a particular sex, the age- and sex-specific incidence rates for disease and the age- and sex-specific mortality rates from the year 2000 for the US were used to determine the numbers of persons expected to develop disease and expected to die for each year of age up to age 100 years. Cumulative lifetime risk refers to the percentage of persons who develop disease from age 18 years to a particular age. The lifetime risk is the percentage of persons who develop disease at any age. Residual lifetime risk, which is the risk for persons who reach a given age without yet developing the disease, was similarly estimated beginning with a hypothetical cohort of a particular age (e.g., 30 years). To examine the impact of changes in incidence and mortality rates, the lifetime risk of RA was estimated using only incidence rates from 1965–1974 with mortality rates from 1970 and also using only incidence rates from 1975–1984 with mortality rates from 1980. Finally, 95% CIs for lifetime risk estimates were obtained based on 1,000 bootstrap samples from each incidence cohort, using bias-corrected methods (22).
The cumulative lifetime risk of developing adult-onset RA in the year 2000 was higher for women (3.6% [95% CI 3.4–3.9%]) than for men (1.7% [95% CI 1.4%–1.9%]) (Figure 1). The cumulative risk was <1% before age 50 years, reflecting the small incidence of RA at those ages. The cumulative risk of RA increased steeply in both sexes at ∼60 years of age, where the incidence of RA was highest, and flattened after age 80 years.
The residual lifetime risk of RA is the risk of developing RA for persons at various ages who have not yet developed RA. Figure 2 displays the residual lifetime risk of RA for women (top panel) and men (bottom panel) who were alive and had not yet developed RA at ages 30, 40, 50, 60, 70, or 80 years. The residual lifetime risks for individuals ages 30, 40, and 50 years were similar because the risk of RA is small in younger ages. Thus, the risk of developing RA for persons who live to age 50 years without developing RA was only minimally reduced (2.7% for women and 1.4% for men) compared to the overall lifetime risk shown in Figure 1.
Sensitivity analyses of the lifetime risk of RA in 1970, when both the incidence and mortality rates were substantially higher than current rates, revealed similar lifetime risks among women (3.8%) and men (1.6%) compared to those in the year 2000. Estimates for 1980, when RA incidence rates and the general population mortality rates were declining, were also very similar to those for the year 2000 (3.6% among women and 1.5% among men).
Table 2 displays the lifetime risk of adult-onset RA (as shown in Figure 1) and other rheumatic diseases for women and men. The lifetime risk of developing RF-positive RA was 2.4% for women and 1.1% for men. The lifetime risk of SLE was much higher for women (0.9%) compared to men (0.2%). The lifetime risk of PsA was slightly higher for men (0.6%) than for women (0.5%).
|Disease||Lifetime risk in women||Lifetime risk in men|
|RA||3.64 (3.37–3.90)||1.68 (1.41–1.94)|
|RF-positive RA||2.39 (2.18–2.60)||1.13 (0.91–1.33)|
|SLE||0.91 (0.75–1.06)||0.21 (0.06–0.42)|
|PsA||0.46 (0.33–0.59)||0.62 (0.51–0.72)|
|PMR||2.43 (2.15–2.72)||1.66 (1.32–2.00)|
|GCA||1.04 (0.90–1.16)||0.51 (0.27–0.64)|
|AS||0.08 (0.00–0.19)||0.63 (0.53–0.74)|
|Primary SS||0.75 (0.67–0.83)||0.04 (0.00–0.10)|
|Primary inflammatory autoimmune rheumatic disease†||8.42 (7.98–8.83)||5.13 (4.64–5.64)|
The lifetime risk of PMR was slightly higher for women (2.4%) than for men (1.7%), as was the lifetime risk of GCA (1.0% for women and 0.5% for men). The lifetime risk of AS was almost entirely among men (0.63% for men compared to 0.08% for women), whereas the lifetime risk of SS was almost exclusively among women (0.75% for women compared to 0.04% for men).
The lifetime risk of primary inflammatory autoimmune rheumatic disease, defined as the first inflammatory autoimmune rheumatic disease per person, was estimated as 8.42% (95% CI 7.98–8.83%) for women and 5.13% (95% CI 4.64–5.64%) for men (Table 2). This estimate was obtained by removing the overlap between cohorts caused by the occurrence of more than one rheumatic disease during a person's lifetime. The most common co-occurrence of inflammatory autoimmune rheumatic diseases occurred between patients with PMR and GCA, with 3.8% of PMR patients having GCA previously and 8.2% of GCA patients having PMR previously. Among RA patients, 2.4% had SS, and 1.2% had PMR or GCA prior to developing RA. The incidence rates for each rheumatic disease and for primary inflammatory autoimmune rheumatic disease for women and men are shown in Figure 3. The incidence of primary inflammatory autoimmune rheumatic disease was greater for women than for men and peaked near age 80 years in both sexes. Sensitivity analyses revealed that estimates of lifetime risk ignoring the overlap (8.96% among women and 5.21% among men) were not much larger than those for primary inflammatory autoimmune rheumatic disease.
The residual lifetime risks of RA and other rheumatic diseases are shown in Table 3 (and in Figure 2 for RA). For PMR and GCA, the largest residual risks occur for those alive at age 60 years without disease. Since there is no risk of PMR or GCA prior to age 50 years, the chance of dying before reaching age 50 years affects the lifetime risk and results in lower lifetime risk estimates at age 18 years compared to the residual risk at age 50 years.
|Age, years||RA||RF+RA||SLE||PsA||PMR||GCA||AS||Primary SS||Primary inflammatory autoimmune rheumatic disease†|
The overall lifetime risk of developing an inflammatory autoimmune rheumatic disease in US adults is 8.4% for women and 5.1% for men, which is equivalent to 1 in 12 for women and 1 in 20 for men. The lifetime risk of developing RA is 3.6% (or 1 in 28) for women and 1.7% (or 1 in 59) for men, and the lifetime risk of developing RF-positive RA is 2.4% for women and 1.1% for men. The second most common rheumatic disease was PMR, with a lifetime risk of 2.4% for women and 1.7% for men.
The lifetime risks of RA and other rheumatic diseases have not been estimated previously. The lifetime risk of RA is commonly misunderstood and miscommunicated as a risk of ∼1 in 100 based on the prevalence of RA, which is 0.5–1%. The overall prevalence is a poor estimate of individual risk, particularly for diseases like RA that occur more frequently at older ages and are associated with increased mortality. The overall prevalence is an average across all ages, whereas the age-specific prevalence of RA increases with age (to >2% among women age >65 years). In addition, prevalence includes only persons living with the disease, so prevalence underestimates disease occurrence in diseases with increased mortality. For example, the age-adjusted prevalence of breast cancer in US women in 2006 was 1.1%, which is comparable to the prevalence of RA among women, whereas the lifetime risk of breast cancer is much larger (12%, or 1 in 8) (4).
While the lifetime risks of RA and primary inflammatory autoimmune rheumatic disease are greater than generally understood, they are still smaller than lifetime risks for diseases that are considered to be common. The residual lifetime risk of hip fracture at age 50 years in the US, which is reported to be 15.8% for women and 6% for men (23), is greater than the residual lifetime risk of rheumatic disease at age 50 years of 7.0% for women and 4.1% for men. Many rheumatic diseases are known to be more common at older ages; thus, the residual risk of rheumatic disease remains high at age 70 years (4.7% for women and 3.1% for men). In comparison, dementia, another disease that occurs predominantly in older ages, has a residual lifetime risk of ∼10% at age 70 years (24).
Lifetime risk estimates are averages that are generally applicable to persons of a particular age and sex. An individual's risk could be higher or lower than these estimates depending on his or her personal set of risk factors (e.g., smoking, family history, genetics). For example, persons with a family history of RA in a first-degree relative have a 3–5 times higher risk of developing RA (25). For these persons, the lifetime risk of RA could be as high as 18% (or 1 in 6) for women and 8.5% (or 1 in 12) for men. Similarly, these lifetime risk estimates can be used to translate relative risks for rare genetic polymorphisms associated with development of RA into absolute risks, which are more easily understood (3).
Strengths of our study include the use of multiple well-characterized cohorts from the same underlying population. Each cohort was defined using established classification criteria, where available, applied during a comprehensive review of all inpatient and outpatient medical records for all persons in the community with relevant diagnoses. The population-based nature of our study is an advantage over lifetime risk estimates obtained from cohorts composed of longitudinally tracked volunteers, which are influenced by participation bias and temporal trends in disease risk.
Our estimates of the lifetime risk of primary inflammatory autoimmune rheumatic disease are likely conservative because our reliance on classification criteria excluded patients with undifferentiated spondylarthritides or polyarthritis. In addition, several rare rheumatic diseases (e.g., dermatomyositis, polymyositis, scleroderma, non-GCA vasculitides, and other undifferentiated connective tissue diseases) were not included in our study. Further, the SS cohort was based on physician diagnosis and may underestimate the true incidence, as well as the lifetime risk, of SS. A few more common rheumatic diseases, namely osteoarthritis, fibromyalgia, and gout, were intentionally excluded since they are not autoimmune rheumatic diseases.
Potential limitations of our study include the assumption that the most recent incidence rates for each disease will remain stable into the future. This assumption is questionable for cohorts that have not demonstrated stable incidence rates in the past, such as RA, SLE, AS, and PsA. However, sensitivity analyses for RA revealed that estimated lifetime risks for 1970 and 1980 were reassuringly similar to those for 2000. In addition, the cohorts for SLE, AS, and SS did not include the most recent decade. While the population of Olmsted County, Minnesota has historically been predominantly white, the proportion of minorities has steadily increased and is now >10%; however, our results may not be generalizable to other more diverse populations. The incidence rates for rheumatic diseases are similar in North America and Northern Europe, but are generally smaller in Southern Europe and the rest of the world, with the exception of higher rates of SLE among persons of African ancestry (26–30). Therefore, our lifetime risk estimates are likely generalizable to Northern European populations, but may overestimate the lifetime risks for rheumatic diseases in the rest of the world. In addition, evidence of geographic variation in RA within the US suggests that the issue of generalizability is complex as both genetic and environmental exposures likely impact the development of rheumatic diseases (31). Finally, changes in life expectancy in the future cannot be anticipated. If advances in other diseases, such as cardiovascular disease or cancer, significantly impact the life expectancy of this population, the lifetime risks for rheumatic diseases could increase.
In conclusion, the lifetime risk of inflammatory autoimmune rheumatic disease development is substantial at 1 in 12 for women and 1 in 20 for men. The lifetime risk of RA is larger than previously thought, at 1 in 28 for women and 1 in 59 for men. These results can serve as useful guides in counseling patients regarding their lifetime risk of these conditions and have important implications regarding disease awareness campaigns such as those of the Arthritis Foundation (US) and the National Rheumatoid Arthritis Society (UK). These findings underscore the need for further investigations to determine whether identification of persons with high genetic risk for RA might justify early detection and intervention to prevent progression to overt clinical disease.
All authors were involved in drafting the article or revising it critically for important intellectual content, and all authors approved the final version to be published. Dr. Gabriel had full access to all of the data in the study and takes responsibility for the integrity of the data and the accuracy of the data analysis.
Study conception and design. Crowson, Matteson, Myasoedova, Gabriel.
Acquisition of data. Matteson, Ernste, Warrington, Hunder, Gabriel.
Analysis and interpretation of data. Crowson, Matteson, Myasoedova, Michet, Ernste, Warrington, Davis, Therneau, Gabriel.
- 4SEER Cancer Statistics Review, 1975–2006. National Cancer Institute, Bethesda, MD. URL: http://seer.cancer.gov/csr/1975_2006/ based on November 2008 SEER data submission, posted to the SEER web site, 2009., , , , , , et al.
- 20Calculating incidence, prevalence and mortality rates for Olmsted County, Minnesota: an update. Rochester (MN): Department of Health Sciences Research, Mayo Clinic; Technical Report Series 1992;No. 49, April., , , , , .