SEARCH

SEARCH BY CITATION

Keywords:

  • methotrexate;
  • aminopterin;
  • dihydrofolate reductase;
  • malformations;
  • teratology;
  • ectopic pregnancy;
  • abortion

Abstract

  1. Top of page
  2. Abstract
  3. INTRODUCTION
  4. EXPERIMENTAL ANIMAL STUDIES
  5. HUMAN REPORTS
  6. DISPROPORTIONALITY ANALYSIS
  7. DISCUSSION
  8. REFERENCES

Methotrexate and aminopterin are folic acid antagonists that inhibit dihydrofolate reductase, resulting in a block in the synthesis of thymidine and inhibition of DNA synthesis. Methotrexate has been used for the treatment of malignancy, rheumatic disorders, and psoriasis and termination of intrauterine pregnancy. Recently, methotrexate has become a standard treatment for ectopic pregnancy. The misdiagnosis of an intrauterine pregnancy as an ectopic pregnancy can result in exposure of a continuing pregnancy to dose levels of methotrexate of 50 mg/m2 (maternal body surface area). Experimental animal studies have associated methotrexate therapy with embryo death in mice, rats, rabbits, and monkeys. Structural malformations have been most consistently produced in rabbits at a maternal dose level of 19.2 mg/kg. Abnormalities in rabbits include hydrocephalus, microphthalmia, cleft lip and palate, micrognathia, dysplastic sacral and caudal vertebrate, phocomelia, hemimelia, syndactyly, and ectrodactyly. Based on human case reports of methotrexate exposure during pregnancy, a methotrexate embryopathy has been described that includes growth deficiency, microcephaly, hypoplasia of skull bones, wide fontanels, coronal or lambdoidal craniosynostosis, upswept frontal scalp hair, broad nasal bridge, shallow supraorbital ridges, prominent eyes, low-set ears, maxillary hypoplasia, epicanthal folds, short limbs, talipes, hypodactyly, and syndactyly. This syndrome may be associated with exposures between 6 and 8 weeks after conception and dose levels of 10 mg/week or greater. More recent case reports of methotrexate exposure for the misdiagnosis of ectopic pregnancy involve treatment before 6 weeks after conception and have raised the suggestion of a distinct syndrome due to such early exposures. Tetralogy of Fallot and perhaps other neural crest cell-related abnormalities may be features of this early syndrome. A disproportionality analysis of methotrexate and aminopterin case reports and series provides support for pulmonary atresia, craniosynostosis, and limb deficiencies as reported more often than expected in methotrexate-exposed children. Denominator-based data will be welcome to better define elements of a methotrexate embryopathy and possibly to distinguish an early exposure syndrome from anomalies traditionally associated with methotrexate exposure. Birth Defects Research (Part A), 2012. © 2012 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.


INTRODUCTION

  1. Top of page
  2. Abstract
  3. INTRODUCTION
  4. EXPERIMENTAL ANIMAL STUDIES
  5. HUMAN REPORTS
  6. DISPROPORTIONALITY ANALYSIS
  7. DISCUSSION
  8. REFERENCES

Methotrexate is a folic acid analog that inhibits dihydrofolate reductase, thereby decreasing the availability of tetrahydrofolate (Fig. 1). Because tetrahydrofolate is an important cofactor in thymidylate synthesis and de novo purine synthesis, methotrexate inhibits the synthesis of DNA and has antiproliferative activity.

thumbnail image

Figure 1. Methotrexate blocks the reduction of dihydrofolate to tetrahydrofolate, a step in the cycle that results in transfer of a methyl group from serine to deoxyuridine monophosphate (dUMP) to produce deoxythymidine monophosphate (dTMP), which is necessary for DNA synthesis. The bottom panel shows that N5, N10-methylene tetrahydrofolate serves as a shuttle for the transfer of a methyl group (dashed circle) from serine to dUMP to produce dTMP

Download figure to PowerPoint

Methotrexate has been used clinically in the treatment of malignancy, psoriasis, rheumatoid arthritis, and other autoimmune and inflammatory disorders. Methotrexate has also been used with misoprostol for voluntary abortion (Moreno-Ruiz et al., 2007) and in the treatment of ectopic pregnancy (American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, 2008; Barnhart, 2009). Typical doses for the treatment of psoriasis or rheumatoid arthritis are 7.5 to 20 mg/week. The methotrexate dose used in the treatment of ectopic pregnancy is 50 mg/m2, often given intramuscularly and repeated at intervals depending on the protocol used and the patient response. A 60-kg (132-lb) woman who is 168 cm (5 feet, 6 inches) tall has a body surface area of 1.67 m2. Her methotrexate dose for ectopic pregnancy will be 83.5 mg or 1.4 mg/kg.

Methotrexate therapy is associated with nausea, vomiting, mucositis, immunosuppression, alopecia, pneumonitis, and liver injury. Cotreatment with leucovorin (also called citrovorum factor and 5-formyltetrahydrofolate) is used in some treatment regimens to reduce the toxicity of methotrexate. One of the accepted protocols for ectopic pregnancy treatment includes the use of methotrexate (1 mg/kg) on days 1, 3, 5, and 7 with administration of leucovorin on days 2, 4, 6, and 8 (American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, 2008).

The therapy of ectopic pregnancy with methotrexate results in the administration of this medication to a woman known to be pregnant. The misdiagnosis of ectopic pregnancy in a woman with an intrauterine pregnancy or treatment of a woman with a coexisting ectopic and intrauterine pregnancy can result in methotrexate exposure of a continuing pregnancy.

EXPERIMENTAL ANIMAL STUDIES

  1. Top of page
  2. Abstract
  3. INTRODUCTION
  4. EXPERIMENTAL ANIMAL STUDIES
  5. HUMAN REPORTS
  6. DISPROPORTIONALITY ANALYSIS
  7. DISCUSSION
  8. REFERENCES

Embryotoxicity has been described after methotrexate treatment in mice, rats, rabbits, cats, and monkeys; however, the studies reporting these effects predate modern embryofetal toxicity study design. These older studies typically reported results on a per fetus basis and did not report statistical analyses. Despite these limitations, it appears that in the rat and monkey, embryolethality was more common than teratogenesis, which was relatively unusual. Mouse and rabbit produced clear malformation syndromes, albeit at exposure levels much higher on a milligram per kilogram basis than dose levels used in human therapy.

Mouse

Skalko and Gold (1974) administered methotrexate intraperitoneal (ip) to ICR mice on gestation day (GD) 10 (plug = GD 0) at dose levels of 0.3 to 50 mg/kg. There was an increase in resorptions at 10 mg/kg, with no reported adverse effect at 5 mg/kg. Malformations were increased at 25 and 50 mg/kg and consisted predominantly of ectrodactyly and cleft palate. Darab et al. (1987) also produced median facial clefts in fetuses after treatment of pregnant C57Bl/6J mice with methotrexate 20 mg/kg ip on GD 9 (plug = GD 0). Elmazar and Nau (1992) treated Han:NMRI mice with ip methotrexate on GD 8 (24 hours after detection of vaginal plug = GD 0) at dose levels of 1.25 to 20 mg/kg. There was increased embryolethality at 2.5 mg/kg, but no increase in exencephaly or any other external malformation at any dose level. Skeletal and visceral malformations were not evaluated.

Sutton et al. (1998) used a transgenic mouse with a mutation in dihydrofolate reductase that did not bind to methotrexate and was, therefore, not inhibited by it. This dihydrofolate reductase mutation resulted in protection from methotrexate teratogenicity. Methotrexate was administered at 30 mg/kg ip on GD 10 (plug = day 0 or day 0.5, depending on time of mating) to pregnant mice after hemizygous mating. Some fetuses in each litter carried resistant dihydrofolate reductase, whereas other fetuses had the wild type dihydrofolate reductase. Fetuses were evaluated on GD 14, with the exception of two litters that were permitted to go to term. Facial clefts and limb defects, the only malformations evaluated, occurred in 37% of transgenic fetuses compared with 77% of nontransgenic siblings. Resorptions were not genotyped.

None of the mouse studies showed an increase in malformations at ip methotrexate dose levels lower than 20 mg/kg.

Rat

Wilson (1971) reported that methotrexate given ip to an unspecified rat strain on GD 9 (GD 0 not defined) caused 64% resorptions and 30% malformations. Additional details were not provided. In a subsequent publication from Jordan et al. (1977), Wistar rats treated on GD 9 (positive smear = GD 0) with ip methotrexate were described as showing an increase in resorptions at a dose level as low as 0.1 mg/kg, although effects were not evaluated statistically. Treatment with methotrexate (2.5 mg/kg) before implantation on GD 4 had little effect on implantation failure or resorption, but embryo death or resorption increased with treatment on each subsequent day until GD 6, when 100% resorptions occurred after treatment. Malformations occurred in 75% of surviving fetuses after treatment with methotrexate (0.3 mg/kg on GD 9). The nature of the malformations was not discussed, but in another publication (Wilson et al., 1979) methotrexate 0.3 mg intravenously (iv) on GD 11 in Wistar rats produced malformations confined largely to the caudal vertebrae. Peak embryo concentration after this treatment was 7.7 ng/g.

Berry (1971) administered methotrexate ip to Wistar rats on GD 12 (positive smear = GD 1) and evaluated uterine contents on GD 14. There was an increase in resorptions with increasing dose of methotrexate, beginning at 1 mg/kg, and with increasing delay before the administration of folinic acid. Administration of methotrexate on GD 17 or 18 produced delayed ossification and bipartite vertebral bodies when fetuses were examined 1 day later, but no abnormalities when fetuses were examined on GD 21. One fetus treated on GD 18 and evaluated on GD 19 had an encephalocele, and an additional fetus in this group had a bifid rib. It is unlikely that treatment as late as GD 18, a week or more after anterior neuropore closure, could have been responsible for the encephalocele noted in this study.

Tshibangu et al. (1975) cohabited Sprague-Dawley rats for 36 hours. On day 14 “after coupling” (not otherwise defined), one group of dams was treated with methotrexate ip at dose levels of 1.6 mg/kg (single dose). Another group was treated with methotrexate 2 mg/kg daily on days 18 to 20. A third group was treated on days 14 to 18 with 0.5, 1.5, or 2 mg/kg/day. Similar dosing schedules were used in experiments with Wistar rats. The authors reported maternal weight reduction, maternal mortality, and decreases in fetal weight with methotrexate treatment at any of the dose levels on GD 14 to 18. They concluded that decreased body weight is the main adverse effect of methotrexate treatment during pregnancy.

Woo et al. (1978) treated Charles River CD rats with ip methotrexate on GD 9 (plug = GD 0) at 0.1, 0.2, or 0.3 mg/kg. Fetuses were evaluated on GD 20. There was an increase in resorptions and a decrease in fetal body weight beginning at a methotrexate dose level of 0.2 mg/kg. There were no statistically significant effects on resorptions or fetal body weight with methotrexate treatment up to 3 mg/kg on GD 12. There were few external, visceral, or skeletal malformations with methotrexate. This study evaluated cotreatment with aspirin, and it is not possible to tell from the report whether any malformations could be attributed to methotrexate treatment alone.

The rat studies suggest embryotoxicity at methotrexate dose levels lower than those used in mice. A convincing malformation syndrome in rats has not been described.

Rabbit

New Zealand White rabbits were treated ip or iv on GD 10 (copulation = GD 0) with methotrexate at 0.3 to 19.2 mg/kg (Jordan et al., 1977). Embryo death or resorption appeared to be increased at iv dose levels of 0.3 mg/kg and higher; the author conclusions were not supported by statistical analysis, which was not described. The percent surviving fetuses that were malformed at evaluation on GD 30 increased with methotrexate dose and reached 80% after the highest dose of 19.2 mg/kg. When the day of treatment was varied, malformations occurred in 100% of survivors after treatment with a methotrexate dose of 19.2 mg/kg iv on GD 12, 13, and 14. Treatment on any of GDs 10, 11, or 12 resulted in hydrocephalus, microphthalmia, cleft lip and palate, micrognathia, dysplastic sacral and caudal vertebrae, and forelimb phocomelia, hemimelia, and ectrodactyly. The later treatments resulted in defects primarily confined to the paws. Treatment on GD 15 produced hind limb syndactyly in approximately one quarter of surviving offspring.

Another publication from this laboratory described treatment with methotrexate 19.2 mg/kg iv on GD 12 as producing cleft palate, micrognathia, hydrocephalus, short tail, ectrodactyly, syndactyly, and pedunculated thumb (DeSesso and Jordan, 1977). This study was the doctoral dissertation of future Teratology Society president John DeSesso, who went on in subsequent papers to describe the ultrastructural features of methotrexate damage in the fetal rabbit limb (DeSesso, 1981) and the amelioration of methotrexate teratogenicity by leucovorin and 1-(p-tosyl)-3,4,4-trimethylimidazolidine, both of which can provide 1-carbon transfer in the presence of dihydrofolate reductase inhibition (DeSesso and Goeringer, 1991, 1992). These papers confirm that inhibition of dihydrofolate reductase is likely to be responsible for much of the teratogenicity of methotrexate in the rabbit.

Cat

Khera (1976) treated shorthaired European and Persian cats with methotrexate 0.5 mg/kg/day by gavage on GD 11–14, 14–17, or 17–20 (first day of mating = GD 1; mated for 2 days). Fetuses were evaluated on GD 44 (term = GD 63 or 64). Maternal toxicity including death occurred in 8 of 55 methotrexate-treated females. There were no statistically significant effects of treatment on live fetuses or litters, fetal weight, or viability. There was an increase in malformations in litters exposed to methotrexate on GD 11 to 14 and 14 to 17. Malformations consisted primarily of umbilical hernia, reported in 12 of 114 fetuses in the study. Other malformations reported in one or two fetuses each across all dose groups included hydrocephalus, spina bifida, and malformed limbs.

Monkey

Wilson (1971) reported that 13 rhesus monkeys treated with iv methotrexate at various doses between GD 17 and 45 had three abortions, nine normal outcomes, and one infant with gut malrotation when evaluated on GD 100. The highest methotrexate dose used was 3 mg/kg/day for 4 days. In a study reported in more detail (Wilson et al., 1979), 20 pregnant rhesus monkeys were given methotrexate 30 mg/kg/day iv on GD 29 to 32 (positive smear = GD 0). Hysterotomy was performed within 24 hours of the last treatment. There were three dead and seven growth-restricted embryos. None of the remaining embryos were malformed. The peak embryo methotrexate concentration was 199 ng/g. The authors concluded that methotrexate was more likely to cause embryolethality than teratogenicity in the monkey. The authors cited a prior study that appeared in a book chapter and showed that methotrexate treatment of pregnant rhesus monkeys on GD 17–45 with iv dose levels as high as 4 mg/kg/day produced embryolethality and ossification impairment but not malformations.

HUMAN REPORTS

  1. Top of page
  2. Abstract
  3. INTRODUCTION
  4. EXPERIMENTAL ANIMAL STUDIES
  5. HUMAN REPORTS
  6. DISPROPORTIONALITY ANALYSIS
  7. DISCUSSION
  8. REFERENCES

Aminopterin

Aminopterin is a folic acid antagonist that is a close structural analog of methotrexate. Farber and Diamond (1948) described the use of what they called “the most powerful folic antagonist we have yet encountered” in the treatment of 16 children with leukemia. Ten of the children showed some improvement after therapy. Aminopterin was marketed thereafter for the treatment of malignancy. Aminopterin was subsequently abandoned because methotrexate was considered to have a more favorable therapeutic index. Aminopterin and methotrexate are viewed as nearly identical in their effects, although aminopterin is more potent.

Aminopterin is an important part of the methotrexate story, because aminopterin gave rise to the first report of human malformations after use during pregnancy of a folic acid antagonist (Thiersch, 1952). This report described 12 pregnancies in which abortion was considered indicated for maternal tuberculosis, mental illness, cancer, muscular dystrophy, rheumatic mitral valve disease, or Rh sensitization. The women were given 8 to 15 mg aminopterin orally depending on maternal body weight and gestational age in an attempt to cause fetal death. Three women received a second course of treatment because the urine pregnancy tests in use at the time remained positive. Treatment was given in small doses every 12 hours until the desired dose was achieved over 2 to 5 days. Ten of the 12 women aborted within 5 to 17 days of the last dose of aminopterin, and two women underwent surgical evacuation of the uterus because fetal expulsion did not occur. In most instances, the pregnancy tissue could not be examined for malformations, presumably because of autolytic changes; however, in three cases, including the two surgical abortions, malformations were identified, including one instance each of hydrocephalus, meningomyelocele, and cleft lip with cleft palate.

The use of aminopterin in the 1950s for therapeutic abortion and the use of methotrexate today for the termination of ectopic pregnancies are similar scenarios. There is also a less apparent similarity in the experiences with these two antifolate agents, namely the tendency to attribute all birth defects in exposed embryos or fetuses to the drug. In the Thiersch (1952) report, the hydrocephalus, meningomyelocele, and facial clefts were believed to have been due to aminopterin exposure; however, the meningomyelocele case was not exposed until an estimated 49 days after conception—3 weeks after neural tube closure was complete. Although pregnancy dating was inexact at the time, when the fetus was expelled, it was estimated to be 2 to 3 weeks older than anticipated. It is likely, then, that the meningomyelocele in this fetus was not due to the aminopterin treatment but was coincidental, leading us to wonder which of the malformations described subsequently in methotrexate-exposed children may have been coincidental and which were due to the medication exposure.

Other case reports involving aminopterin and congenital malformations during the years after the Thiersch (1952) report led to the specification of an aminopterin syndrome of malformations. According to one reviewer, these malformations include meningoencephalocele, anencephaly, brachycephaly, hydrocephaly, incomplete skull ossification, mental retardation, cleft lip and palate, low-set ears, micrognathia or retrognathia, syndactyly, short forearms, hypoplasia of the thumb and fibula, and positional abnormalities of the extremities, including talipes (Briggs et al., 2011).

Methotrexate

Case reports and case series of methotrexate exposure during pregnancy began appearing in the 1960s. Eight such publications were reviewed by Feldkamp and Carey (1993), who presented the methotrexate and aminopterin literature as part of their analysis of the potential risk to a patient who consulted them about exposure during early pregnancy. Based on the reports of six malformed infants, Feldkamp and Carey (1993) proposed that the sensitive period for the production of malformations by methotrexate is 6 to 8 weeks after conception. They further suggested that the methotrexate dose necessary to produce malformations is 10 mg/week or greater.

Additional studies and studies published since Feldkamp and Carey (1993) are summarized in Table 1. Some of these publications can be characterized as denominator-based samples in which exposure appears to have been ascertained before pregnancy outcome was known. These papers will be presented in more detail here.

Table 1. Human Reports of Methotrexate Exposure during Pregnancy Since Feldkamp and Carey (1993)
ReferenceDiseaseGestational age at exposureWeekly methorexate doseGestational age (weeks)Weight at birth (g)OutcomeComments
  • a

    Dating could not confidently be determined to be based on last menstrual period or conception.

Adam et al., 2003Abortion7-5/7 weeks postconception50 mg/m2, once34 weeks induction of labor due to low amniotic fluid index1619Narrow bifrontal diameter, upslanting palpebral fissures, small eyes, flat nasal bridge, pectus excavatum, hypospadias, partial 4-5 syndactyly, absent fourth and fifth digits on the feet bilaterally, nail hypoplasiaMother had hypertension; also treated with misoprostol 800 μg
Abortion6 weeks postconception50 mg/m2, once40-3/71951Large fontanels, bicoronal craniosynostosis, right cleft lip/palate, folding of the right ear helix, undescended right testis, mesomelic shortening of the forearms with single bone, bilateral antecubital pterygia, three-digit hands with absent fourth and fifth rays, talipes equinovarus, hypoplastic nails, tetralogy of Fallot with pulmonary atresia, atrioventricular canalAlso treated with misoprostol 800 μg
Abortion4 weeks postconception50 mg/m2, once26574Low-set ears; short, downslanting palpebral fissures; broad nasal root; small, downturned mouth with smooth philtrum; micrognathia; radial deviations of the wrist; absent fifth digits bilaterally; single leg bone; talipes equinovarus; mild 3-4 syndactyly; hypoplastic toesPlacental abruption, foul-smelling amniotic fluid, infant expired at 5 hours of life; mother also treated with misoprostol 800 μg
 Suspected ectopic pregnancy8 and 10 weeks (6 and 8 weeks postconception)50 mg/m2, twice331508Narrow flattened cranium, with occipital plagiocephaly; patent sagittal suture; three fontanels; ocular hypertelorism; epicanthal folds; low nasal bridge; small mandible; grade I germinal matrix hemorrhage 
Addar, 2004Suspected ectopic pregnancy5 weeksa95 mg, onceAmbiguous genitalia, bifid scrotum, micropenis 
Avilés et al., 1991Leukemia1st trimesterNot given363200Healthy childAlso exposed to vincristine, prednisone, doxorubicin, 6-mercaptopurine, cyclophosphamide
Leukemia1st trimesterNot given362500Healthy childAlso exposed to cytosine arabinoside, doxorubicin, prednisone, 6-mercaptopurine, cyclophosphamide
Leukemia2nd trimesterNot given383100Healthy childAlso exposed to vincristine, prednisone, doxorubicin, 6-mercaptopurine, cyclophosphamide
Leukemia1st trimesterNot given373000Healthy childAlso exposed to vincristine, doxorubicin, 6-mercaptopurine, cyclophosphamide
Leukemia2nd trimesterNot given403200Healthy childAlso exposed to cyclophosphamide, doxorubicin, vincristine, prednisone, etoposide
 Leukemia1st trimesterNot given372850Healthy childAlso exposed to cyclophosphamide, epidoxorubicin, vincristine, prednisone, bleomycin, cytosine arabinoside, etoposide
 Leukemia3rd trimesterNot given393100Healthy childAlso exposed to cyclophosphamide, nflammato, vincristine, prednisone, cytosine arabinoside
 Leukemia2nd trimesterNot given404000Healthy childAlso exposed to cyclophosphamide, nflammato, vincristine, prednisone, bleomycin, cytosine arabinoside, etoposide
 Leukemia1st trimesterNot given402800Healthy childAlso exposed to cyclophosphamide, epidoxorubicin, vincristine, prednisone, bleomycin, cytosine arabinoside, etoposide, dexamethasone
Bawle et al., 1998Abortion6 weeks postconception or after last menstrual periodNot givenNot givenHypertelorism, ptosis, short palpebral fissures, prominent nose, low-set ears, widow's peak, short stature, subluxation of radial heads, severe hypoplasia of the phalanges of the toes, only four metacarpals, gynecomastia at pubertyNo mental impairment
 Breast cancer9.5 weeks (7.5 weeks post conception)80 mg on 6 occasions29820Normal karyotype, short stature, underweight, small head circumference, hypertelorism, upswept frontal hairline, microcephaly, low set ears, micrognathia, simian crease, intelligence quotient of approximately 70Lumpectomy for breast cancer, radiation (14 rad) to breast and chest wall area 15.5—25 weeks after conception; treated with fluorouracil from 7.5 weeks
 Abortion11–25 weeks (9–23 weeks postconception)50–100 mg291160Short stature, underweight, bulging forehead, bitemporal narrowing, upslanting palpebral fissures, sparse hair on temporal area, low-set ears, broad nasal tip, high arched palate, normal psychomotor developmentAttempted medical abortion followed failed curettage
Buckley et al., 1997Rheumatoid arthritisUp to 8 weeksa10–12.5 mg (100 mg over 8 weeks)351790Growth restriction, skeletal abnormalities, double outlet right ventricle, ventricular septal defect, transposition of the great vessels, pulmonic stenosis, atrial septal defect, brachycephaly, coronal ridging, small anterior fontanel, shallow orbits with hypertelorism, retrognathia, bifid ear lobule, folded helix, closed or stenotic canal, umbilical hernia, dorsal kyphosis, right thumb deformity, syndactyly of 4th and fifth toes, bilateral simian creases, hypoplastic nailsMother took folic acid, but possibly inconsistently
Brudie et al., 2011Choriocar-cinoma24–28 weeksaNot givenLabor induced at 32 weeks1383HealthyAlso treated with etoposide, actinomycin D, cyclophosphamide, vincristine
Chakravarty et al., 2003Rheumatoid arthritis, n = 39Not givenNot givenNot given21 healthy term infants, 3 infants with congenital malformations (no details given), 8 elective abortions, 7 spontaneous abortions, 1 ongoing pregnancy1 spontaneous abortus had unspecified malformations
Chapa et al., 2003Abortion6 weeksa75 mg, once27-week elective abortion918Asymmetric length of upper extremities, absent fibulae bilaterally, right foot polydactyly, small head, prominent eyes, low set ears, micrognathia, two-vessel umbilical cordAlso treated with misoprostol 400 μg
Corona-Rivera et al., 2010Systemic lupus erythematosis5–7 weeks postconception35 mg342200Hydrocephalus, oxycephalus, large fontanels, wide forehead, deficient skull ossification, absent parietal and frontal bones, semilobar holoprosencephaly, sparse hair, absent lateral eyebrows, hypertelorism, blepharophimosis, prominent eyes, upslanting palpebral fissures, vertical nystagmus, epiblepharon, trichiasis, wide nasal bridge, broad and bifid nasal tip, microtia, absent earlobes, low-set posteriorly rotated ears, micrognathia, short thorax, hypoplastic nipples, umbilical hernia, lateral penile curvature, coronal hypospadias, cryptorchidism, mesomelic micromelia, brachydactyly, clinodactyly, absent palmar creases, hypoplastic nails, absent middle phalanx of 4th and fifth toes, hydronephrosisAlso exposed to ampicillin and acetaminophen in the first trimester and folic acid beginning in the fifth month, 46XY 16q karyotype
Del Campo et al., 1999Severe psoriasisFirst 8 weeks post conception37.5 mg401645Widely separated sutures, large fontanels, bilateral epicanthal folds, sparse eyebrows, broad nasal bridge, anteverted nares, smooth long philtrum, hypoplastic nipples, small umbilical hernia, diastasis recti, shawl scrotum, decreased extension at the elbows, short proximal phalanges, hypoplastic fingernails, normal karyotype, delayed developmental milestones, flat affect, irritability
Donnenfeld et al., 1993Intraductal breast carcinoma37–38 weeks postconception42 mg413350Healthy at birth; pneumonia at 1 month of age
Bacterial infection5–6 weeks postconceptionNot given423560Healthy
Rheumatoid arthritis3–5 weeks postconceptionNot given364036Healthy
Not givenUp to 2 weeks postconception7.5 mg403885HealthyAlso treated with aspirin and hydroxychloroquine
Rheumatoid ArthritisUp to 3 weeks postconception7.5 mg403220HealthyAlso treated with aspirin and hydroxychloroquine
Georgiou et al., 2011Heterotopic pregnancy with persistent ectopic trophoblast13 weeksa150 mg27830Infant required resuscitation but no malformations were diagnosed
Giannakopoulou et al., 2000Breast cancer6–24 weeks (4–22 weeks postconception)Not given301000Inguinal hernia, respiratory distress syndrome of prematurity, 3rd percentile, normal development at 22 months of ageAlso treated with cyclophosphamide and 5-fluorouracil; infant karyotype 46 XY
Goffman et al., 2006Abortion6 weeks (4 weeks postconception)70 mg during week 1, 30 mg during week 239 weeks: induction of labor for growth restriction2370Large fontanel, hypertelorism, broad nasal bridge, micrognathia, short torso, missing ribs, scoliosis, micropenis, shortened proximal long bones, bilateral fifth finger clinodactyly, bilateral second toe clinodactylyAlso treated with diclofenac 50 mg and misoprostol 200 μg daily for 4 days
Granzow et al., 2003Molar pregnancy8 weeksaUnknownUnknownCleft of the soft palate, agenesis of fifth toe on right foot with short second toe, left foot: fusion of third, fourth and fifth toes with clinodactyly of the second toe 
Hahn et al., 2001Abortion attempt“2 months pregnant”Not known; estimated at 25–150 mg/m2Not givenHealthyLeucovorin given every 6 hours for 6 doses
Kozma and Ramasethu, 2011Abortion7 weeks (5 weeks postconception)75 mg35-6/7981Growth restricted (<3rd percentile), wide anterior fontanel, shallow orbital ridges, depressed nasal bridge, micrognathia, posterior cleft palate, low-set ears, hypoplastic chest, syndactyly, clinodactyly, absent palmar creases, gap between first and second toes, ectrodactyly of toes, rib anomalies, brachycephaly, coronal and possibly sagittal craniosynostosis, arrhinencephalyAlso exposed to misoprostal 1600 μg vaginally; became positive for human immunodeficiency virus during the pregnancy
Krähenmann et al., 2002Rheumatoid arthritis4-6/7 and 5-6/7 weeks (probably 2-6/7 and 3-6/7 weeks postconception)10 mg, twice18-week elective abortion170Atrioventricular septal defect, diaphragmatic herniaFolic acid 1 mg taken irregularly, increased nuchal translucency identified at 12-3/7 weeks
Lewden, et al., 2004Rheumatic/ chronic inflammatory disorders; n = 28 pregnancies with follow-upVariousMean 30.7 ± 23.3 mg (SD)16 were at full term (mean 39.2 ± 1.2 weeks [SD])3179 ± 465 g (SD)5 elective abortions, 4 spontaneous abortions, 19 live births, 1 child with bilateral metatarsus varus, right eyelid angiomaIn the child with minor anomalies, mother was taking methotrexate 7.5 mg/week and sulfasalazine 3 g/day until 8.3 weeks; women also used nonsteroidal antiinflammatory drugs
Mulholland and Pollock, 2011Rheumatoid arthritisFirst 8 weeksa15 mgNot givenPeter's anomaly (dysgenesis of the anterior segment of the eye)Folic acid 5 mg/week and hydroxychloroquine 400 mg/day also taken
Nguyen et al., 2002Psoriasis5.5 weeks (3.5 weeks postconception)15 mg, twice20240Two-vessel umbilical cord, choroid plexus cysts, low-set ears, micrognathia, abnormal position of the hands, absent left radius, occipital flattening, craniofacial abnormalities, absent auditory canals, micrognathiaMaternal depression, sertraline treatment until 3.5 weeks
Nurmohamed et al., 2011Suspected ectopic pregnancy5 weeks (3 weeks postconception)50 mg37Tetralogy of Fallot with pulmonary atresia, scoliosis, abnormal number of ribs,
Suspected ectopic pregnancy6 weeks (4 weeks postconception)50 mg, twice30Tetralogy of Fallot, horseshoe kidney, single umbilical artery
Suspected ectopic pregnancy5 weeks (3 weeks postconception)83 mg6Spontaneous abortion
Suspected ectopic pregnancy4 weeks (2 weeks postconception)80 mg6Spontaneous abortion
Suspected ectopic pregnancy6 weeks (4 weeks postconception)50 mg8Spontaneous abortion
Suspected ectopic pregnancy4 weeks (2 weeks postconception)50 mg6Elective abortion
Suspected ectopic pregnancy6 weeks (4 weeks postconception)85 mg9Elective abortion
Suspected ectopic pregnancy8 weeks (6 weeks postconception)92 mg9Elective abortion
Østensen et al., 2000Psoriatic arthritisUp to 5 weeks (3 weeks postconception)7.5 mg362600Healthy
Juvenile chronic arthritisUp to 6 weeks (4 weeks postconception)2.5 mg8 Spontaneous abortionAlso exposed to naproxen
Rheumatoid arthritisUp to 3 weeks (1 week postconception)15 mg383230HealthyFolate supplementation
Rheumatoid arthritisUp to 3 weeks (1 week postconception)7.5 mg392960HealthyAlso exposed to naproxen and folate supplementation
Østensen et al., 2007Rheumatic diseases, n = 81st trimesterNot givenNot given1 healthy infant, 2 elective abortions, 2 spontaneous abortions, 3 unknown outcomesCases ascertained from questionnaires given to patients and to rheumatologists
Piggott et al., 2011Systemic lupus erythematosis1st trimesterNot given351700Pulmonary atresia, ventricular septal defect, absent left auditory canal, micrognathia, dysplastic multicystic kidney, hydronephrosis, intestinal malrotation
Suspected ectopic pregnancy1st trimesterNot given26Tetralogy of Fallot, clubfoot, accessory digits, micrognathia, abnormal kidney position, renal parenchymal disease, “aminopterin syndrome” (apparently referring to craniofacial dysmorphology)
Not given1st trimesterNot givenNot givenTetralogy of Fallot, pulmonary atresia, prominent renal pelvisAbsence of “aminopterin syndrome”
Poggi and Ghidini, 2011Suspected ectopic pregnancy5-6/7 weeks (3-6/7 weeks postconception)87 mg, once30 (stillbirth) Single umbilical artery, tetralogy of Fallot, horseshoe lung; normal karyotype, negative testing for 22q11 deletion or duplication.Started on folic acid 4000 mg/day at 6-4/7 weeks
Seidahmed et al., 2006Abortion6th week postconception52.5 mg“Term”1310Prominent eyes, long eyelashes, epicanthic folds, shallow orbits, beaked nose, long philtrum, cleft palate, micrognathia, low-set malformed ears, narrow forehead, metopic and coronal craniosynostosis, wide posterior fontanel, low anterior hairline, mesomelia, hypoplastic first toes and nails, alobar holoprosencephalyParents were cousins, infant had normal female karyotype
Usta et al., 2007Suspected ectopic pregnancy5 weeksa75 mg, once382115Lag in fetal growth after 29 weeks, hypertelorism, facial nerve palsy, right microtia, scoliosis, wide spaced nipples, perimembranous ventricular septal defect, patent foramen ovale, increased pulmonary artery pressure 
Wheeler et al., 2002Abortion8 weeks and 4 days from last menstrual period (6 weeks and 4 days postconception)75 mg, once392050Mild dolichocephaly, tall forehead, prominent nose, lateral fullness, hypertelorism, small mouth, micrognathia, fifth finger and toe clinodactyly, hypoplastic toenails, hypotoniaMother had severe preeclampsia, also treated with misoprostol 800 μg
Yedlinsky et al., 2005Abortion7 weeksa50 mg/m2, once351681No dysmorphic features; magnetic resonance imaging at 6 weeks of age: right lateral intraventricular cyst, dilation of lateral ventricle; at 5 months: anisocoria, slight bowing of the tibias, bilateral transverse palmar creases, third rib hypoplasia, shortening of the limbs, poor weight gain, linear growth <5%Mother with preeclampsia
 Abortion6 weeksa50 mg/m2, once38 (twins)2686 and 2570Hyperextensible joints, overlapping second and third toes of both feet, bilateral fifth finger clinodactyly, bony foot abnormalities; both twins affectedSome features suggestive of Dubowitz syndrome (autosomal recessive); also treated with misoprostol 800 μg
Zand et al., 2003AbortionNot givenNot givenNot givenElective abortion: shortened radius and ulna, absent femurs, hypertelorism, microcephaly, double outlet right ventricle 
AbortionNot givenNot givenNot givenElective abortion: bilateral absence of radius and fibula, asymmetric frontal bones, large parietal foramina, absent thymic isthmus, accessory spleens, hypertelorism, bulbous nasal tip, high arched, prominent eyebrows, ectrodactyly 

Avilés et al. (1991) reported pregnancy outcome in women treated during gestation for acute leukemia. Nine of the women received methotrexate as part of their regimens. There were no reported malformations, but only five of the women were treated during the first trimester. Details of dosing and gestational weeks of exposure were not reported.

Donnenfeld et al. (1994) surveyed 63 teratology information services and identified 21 prospectively ascertained cases of methotrexate exposure before or during pregnancy. Five exposures occurred during pregnancy, four of which occurred between 0 and 6 weeks after conception and one of which occurred in the third trimester. All babies exposed during pregnancy were normal, although the child with third-trimester exposure was diagnosed with pneumonia at 1 month of age. Four of nine women with methotrexate exposure during the year preceding pregnancy had spontaneous abortions and one child had a cavernous hemangioma. The authors concluded that the normal outcomes in the four children with first-trimester exposure were consistent with the report by Feldkamp and Carey (1993), because the exposures were less than 10 mg/week or because the treatment was discontinued by 6 weeks after conception.

Østensen et al. (2000) presented four women referred to their rheumatology center for methotrexate exposure during early pregnancy. One woman spontaneously aborted and three women had normal infants. One of these children was born at 36 weeks' gestation. All the exposures had been discontinued before 6 weeks after conception.

Chakravarty et al. (2003) used a questionnaire sent to rheumatologists to solicit information about pregnancies exposed to disease-modifying antirheumatic drugs. Among 38 methotrexate-exposed pregnancies with known outcomes, there were two children and one abortus with unspecified malformations. There was only a 29% response rate to the questionnaire, and it is not clear how and by whom the pregnancy outcomes were ascertained.

Lewden et al. (2004) sent a questionnaire to 31 French pharmacovigilance centers and two teratology information services. Only 10 centers recorded a pregnancy exposed to methotrexate during the 9-year study period; methotrexate was given in these instances for the treatment of rheumatologic or chronic inflammatory disorders. There were 28 pregnancies with follow-up among 27 women. Only two women took methotrexate after 8 weeks' gestation (i.e., 6 weeks after conception). There were five elective and four spontaneous abortions. There were no major malformations among the 19 liveborn infants. One of the pregnancies exposed after 8 weeks' gestation was electively terminated, and the other pregnancy resulted in a child with an eyelid angioma and bilateral metatarsus varus. Although none of the exposed children had major malformations, this study does not contradict the conclusions of Feldkamp and Carey (1993), inasmuch as only one continuing pregnancy was exposed during the sensitive period proposed by them.

There have been suggestions that the embryopathy attributable to methotrexate should be expanded beyond the original aminopterin embryopathy based on the appearance of additional kinds of malformations with exposures outside the sensitive period proposed by Feldkamp and Carey (1993). Poggi and Ghidini (2011) reported a case of tetralogy of Fallot in a child after methotrexate was used for a misdiagnosis of ectopic pregnancy at less than 6 weeks' gestation (4 weeks after conception). Methotrexate treatment after misdiagnosis of ectopic pregnancy can involve higher doses during the 2 or 3 weeks after implantation than have been used historically for the treatment of rheumatic disorders, and the claim by Poggi and Ghidini (2011) is worth considering. Indeed, a case series of eight intrauterine pregnancies with methotrexate treatment for misdiagnosis of ectopic pregnancy reported tetralogy of Fallot in both pregnancies that continued to viability (Nurmohamed et al., 2011). These pregnancies had been exposed to methotrexate at 3 and 4 weeks after conception.

DISPROPORTIONALITY ANALYSIS

  1. Top of page
  2. Abstract
  3. INTRODUCTION
  4. EXPERIMENTAL ANIMAL STUDIES
  5. HUMAN REPORTS
  6. DISPROPORTIONALITY ANALYSIS
  7. DISCUSSION
  8. REFERENCES

The Problem

Major congenital malformations have been associated with aminopterin and methotrexate in the literature for more than 60 years. The historical prominence of these dihydrofolate reductase inhibitors in the field of teratology and the compelling mechanism of action have resulted in the acceptance of the existence of a methotrexate embryopathy. Because the list of features of the methotrexate embryopathy was derived from case reports, we wonder whether any malformation in a methotrexate-exposed infant was necessarily caused by methotrexate. If, for example, congenital heart disease occurs in nearly 1% of newborns, it might reasonably be expected that congenital heart disease will occur in nearly 1% of methotrexate-exposed newborns, even if methotrexate does not cause congenital heart disease. This problem was articulated in a previous Teratogen Update in these pages by Dr. C.G.H. Newman, one of the physicians charged with determining what defects should be included in the thalidomide embryopathy. Newman (1985) wrote, “When a drug is very widely used and fails to prevent other types of defect, sporadic defects will at times coincide, and infants who might have been affected but escaped the effects of the drug can continue to be affected by whatever other factors operate.”

Methotrexate is not as widely used as thalidomide was at its peak, but methotrexate may be more widely used than recognized by many teratologists. Before the advent of the so-called biologic agents (e.g., drugs acting to block tumor necrosis factor alpha), methotrexate was commonly recommended for the treatment of rheumatoid arthritis, a disorder that affects many women of childbearing potential. At present, methotrexate is routinely used for ectopic pregnancies, which occur in 1 to 2% of pregnancies and which are suspected in a larger number of pregnancies, representing a substantial opportunity for continuing intrauterine pregnancies to be exposed because of diagnostic error. We would expect some spontaneously occurring congenital malformations to be identified by chance in infants who have been coincidentally exposed to methotrexate.

Findings

We evaluated whether a malformation or closely related group of malformations occurred more often in case reports and case series than would be expected by chance. We compared the proportion of all malformations represented by each specific malformation with the same proportion derived from the Metropolitan Atlanta Congenital Defects Program (MACDP) (Correa et al., 2007). We used reports of malformations occurring after either aminopterin or methotrexate; removal of the aminopterin cases made little difference in our analysis.

The MACDP is an active surveillance program, and reporting of congenital malformations to this program can be expected to be different from reporting malformations in a published case report; therefore, these two sources of information are only roughly comparable. Moreover, we evaluated the proportion of total malformations represented by individual malformations, rather than the proportion of malformed children with a particular malformation, because the MACDP report does not permit identification of multiple malformations within the same child. Using a proportion of total malformations rather than a proportion of malformed children inflates the number of observations and may lead to spurious associations. We used chi-square or Fisher exact testing in making the comparison and reported defects for which methotrexate reports contained a disproportionate number of instances (Table 2). This analysis supported pulmonary atresia, craniosynostosis, and limb deficiencies as possibly associated with methotrexate exposure.

Table 2. Disproportionality Analysis
 MethotrexateGeneral population
Malformationsn%a%b
  • a

    (n/343) × 100.

  • b

    Derived from Correa et al. (2007) as (n/23855) × 100 for cardiac malformations and (n/32938) × 100 for other malformations.

  • Bolded rows indicate statistically significantly higher proportion of defect in methotrexate than control population, p < 0.05 by chi-square or Fisher exact test.

TOTAL HEART144.08 
Conotruncal defects92.623.56
 Tetralogy of Fallot61.751.67
 Double outlet right ventricle20.58 
 Transposition of great arteries10.291.01
Two-vessel cord30.87 
PULMONARY ATRESIA30.870.17
Pulmonary stenosis10.291.53
Increased pulmonary artery pressure10.29 
Atrial septal defect20.583.06
TOTAL VENTRAL SEPTAL DEFECT20.5810.44
Perimembranous ventral septal defect10.292.96
Complete atrioventricular canal10.290.85
Patent foramen ovale10.29 
Dextrocardia10.29 
TOTAL NEURAL TUBE20.58 
Meningomyelocele10.29 
Anencephaly10.291.35
TOTAL BRAIN72.04 
Hydrocephalus51.461.74
Holoprosencephaly20.58 
Hypoplastic cerebellum, prominent cisterna magna10.29 
Absent corpus callosum10.29 
Anterior horn of left lateral ventricle > right10.29 
Forebrain malformation10.29 
Missing olfactory bulbs10.29 
TOTAL CRANIAL277.87 
Large fontanels, separated sutures113.21 
TOTAL CRANIOSYNOSTOSIS102.921.46
 Oxycephaly, coronal suture fusion51.46 
 Brachycephaly, coronal ridging20.58 
 Craniosynostosis10.29 
 Bicoronal synostosis10.29 
 Dolichocephaly (scaphocephaly)10.29 
Narrow bifrontal diameter20.58 
Narrow flattened cranium10.29 
Absent parietal bone20.58 
Parietal foramina10.29 
Skull anomalies20.58 
Absent sutures10.29 
Delayed or minimal ossification of skull30.87 
No ossification of parietal bone10.29 
Ossification defect in frontal bone10.29 
Absent or hypoplastic frontal bone61.75 
Microcephaly30.87 
Occipital flattening10.29 
Bulging forehead, bitemporal narrowing10.29 
Wide forehead10.29 
TOTAL EAR205.83 
Absent auditory canals20.58 
Bifid ear lobule10.29 
Stenotic auditory canal10.29 
Low-set ears154.37 
Abnormal ears10.29 
Posteriorly rotated ears10.29 
Folded helix20.58 
Microtia30.87 
Absent earlobes10.29 
TOTAL FACE298.45 
Cleft lip or palate102.925.61
High arched palate10.29 
Small mouth20.58 
Long philtrum10.29 
Short or smooth philtrum30.87 
Micrognathia, retrognathia, small mandible195.54 
Facial palsy10.29 
Craniofacial abnormalities10.29 
Sparse hair, lateral eyebrow absence10.29 
High arched, prominent eyebrows10.29 
Low hairline covering entire forehead10.29 
Posteriorly combed hair appearance20.58 
Unspecified dysmorphic facies10.29 
TOTAL EYE277.87 
Shallow orbits or supraorbital ridges30.87 
Prominent eyes30.87 
Hypertelorism205.83 
Ptosis10.29 
Blepharophimosis10.29 
Upper and lower lid epiblepharon10.29 
Trichiasis10.29 
Short palpebral fissure20.58 
Upslanting palpebral fissure30.87 
Vertical nystagmus10.29 
Microphthalmia10.29 
Epicanthal folds41.17 
Long eyelashes10.29 
Anterior segment dysgenesis10.29 
TOTAL NOSE164.66 
Broad nasal tip41.17 
Bifid nasal tip10.29 
Prominent nose20.58 
Beaked nose10.29 
Flat or broad nasal bridge113.21 
Anteverted nares10.29 
TOTAL GENITAL82.33 
Hypospadias20.5811.32
Undescended testicle30.87 
Micropenis20.58 
Lateral penile curvature10.29 
Bifid scrotum10.29 
Shawl scrotum10.29 
Absent pubic bone10.29 
Ambiguous genitalia10.29 
TOTAL LIMB277.87 
TOTAL INTERCALARY LIMB DEFICIENCIES113.210.09
 Absent radius20.58 
 Absent fibula20.58 
 Missing metacarpal10.29 
 Unspecified intercalary limb shortening72.05 
TOTAL TRANSVERSE LIMB DEFICIENCIES226.410.85
 Missing middle or proximal phalanges on fingers or toes20.58 
 Short proximal phalanges10.29 
 Unspecified limb shortening10.29 
 Short or missing distal phalanges of fingers or toes20.58 
 Nail hypoplasia92.63 
 Hypoplastic toes61.75 
 Missing digits51.46 
Total longitudinal limb deficiencies20.580.53
Absent palmar proximal creases20.58 
Wide gap between first and second toes10.29 
Overlapping toes10.29 
Polydactyly30.874.30
Syndactyly82.33 
Clinodactyly61.75 
Bony foot abnormalities10.29 
Antecubital pterygia10.29 
Wrist deviation20.58 
Bradydactyly (brachydactyly)30.87 
Right thumb deformity10.29 
Clubfoot51.464.72
Metatarsus varus10.29 
Subluxation of radial head10.29 
Hyperextensible joints10.29 
Decreased extension of elbow10.29 
Absent knee ossification centers10.29 
TOTAL TRUNK113.21 
Scoliosis or kyphosis41.17 
Pectus excavatum10.29 
Skeletal abnormalities10.290.51
Short torso10.29 
Short thorax20.58 
Partial or absent ribs30.87 
Absent thymic isthmus10.29 
Hypoplasia of scapulae10.29 
Intestinal malrotation10.29 
Inguinal hernia10.29 
Umbilical hernia30.87 
Diaphragmatic hernia10.290.63
Diastasis recti10.29 
Accessory spleens10.29 
Hypoplastic nipples20.58 
Wide-spaced nipples10.29 
TOTAL RENAL61.75 
Multicystic dysplastic kidney10.291.14
Hydronephrotic kidney20.58 
Abnormal kidney position10.29 
Chronic renal parenchymal disease10.29 
Left renal pelvis prominence10.29 
TOTAL PULMONARY30.87 
Anterior airway20.58 
“Horseshoe” lung10.29 
Pulmonary hypoplasia10.29 
OTHER51.46 
Short stature30.87 
Angioma10.29 
Pancytopenia10.29 
TOTAL DEFECTS343  

Our comparison was limited to malformations specifically reported by the MACDP. We were unable to evaluate the cranial and facial dysmorphology findings that have been reported with aminopterin and methotrexate, because of the lack of a counterpart in the MACDP report. We found it interesting that some malformations that have often been considered part of the aminopterin and methotrexate syndromes (e.g., neural tube defects, facial clefts) were not supported by our evaluation as being disproportionately associated with aminopterin or methotrexate. The limb malformations associated with methotrexate are likely to explain the description of short limbs reported with this exposure. The hypoplastic skull bones in the methotrexate case reports do not have a counterpart in the MACDP report and could not be evaluated in our analysis.

DISCUSSION

  1. Top of page
  2. Abstract
  3. INTRODUCTION
  4. EXPERIMENTAL ANIMAL STUDIES
  5. HUMAN REPORTS
  6. DISPROPORTIONALITY ANALYSIS
  7. DISCUSSION
  8. REFERENCES

The question of what malformations are part of a methotrexate embryopathy is difficult to answer, in part because the case reports and case series that have been used to address the question involve different clinical settings, different methotrexate dose levels, and different times of administration. The description by Jones (2006) includes malformations that have arisen and continue to be reported in many children with methotrexate exposure and includes growth deficiency, microcephaly, hypoplasia of skull bones, wide fontanels, coronal or lambdoidal craniosynostosis, upswept frontal scalp hair, broad nasal bridge, shallow supraorbital ridges, prominent eyes, low-set ears, maxillary hypoplasia, epicanthal folds, short limbs, talipes, hypodactyly, and syndactyly. In their seminal paper, Feldkamp and Carey (1993) suggested that methotrexate embryopathy may be associated with exposure between 6 and 8 weeks after conception to dose levels of 10 mg/week or greater. Although most case reports conform to this formulation, occasional reports appear to present exceptions (e.g., Adam et al., 2003).

Poggi and Ghidini (2011) raised the intriguing possibility that treatment of misdiagnosed ectopic pregnancies produces a different spectrum of malformations. Ectopic pregnancies are commonly treated by 6 weeks after conception, and dose levels are much higher than those traditionally used for rheumatic disorders. We note that in the seven cases of suspected ectopic pregnancy in Table 1 in which malformations were evaluated, five included conotruncal heart defects, four of which were tetralogy of Fallot and one of which was perimembranous ventricular septal defect (Usta et al., 2007; Poggi and Ghidini, 2011; Nurmohamed et al., 2011; Piggott et al., 2011). The two cases without conotruncal heart defects included a case exposed at 6 to 8 weeks after conception in which micrognathia, another neural crest defect, may have occurred (Adam et al., 2003). Neural crest malformations, or at least conotruncal heart defects, may be a feature of pregnancy exposure to high dose levels of methotrexate before 6 postconception weeks. The findings of cleft palate and micrognathia in the rabbit (DeSesso and Jordan, 1977) are consistent with a neural crest mechanism; however, we can only speculate about whether this mechanism would apply to the reported human cases.

Case reports involving the use of methotrexate for abortion or for cancer therapy may be limited by cotreatment with misoprostol for abortion and other antimetabolites for cancer. Some of the malformations in these reports could be due to methotrexate. As a result, we included these malformations in our disproportionality analysis; however, we were unable to determine whether the other exposures contributed to the outcomes.

The experimental animal literature has not been concordant with reported human experience, with the exception of studies performed in the rabbit in which abnormalities are suggestive of those seen in the case reports and case series (DeSesso and Jordan, 1977; DeSesso and Goeringer, 1991, 1992). The dose level used to produce abnormalities in the rabbit (19.2 mg/kg) is considerably higher than dose levels used in human therapy. We are not aware of pharmacokinetic comparisons between rabbits and human beings, which might explain the large difference in apparently effective dose levels. Embryolethality is a common finding in all species. We note that conotruncal heart defects have not been identified in any experimental animal model.

Our disproportionality analysis supported pulmonary atresia, craniosynostosis, and limb deficiencies as associated with methotrexate exposure. This analysis did not distinguish early from later first trimester exposures. The lack of comparability of numbers of malformations in case reports and case series with the numbers reported from an active surveillance program is an important limitation of our analysis, and we welcome the reporting of denominator-based experience with prospectively ascertained pregnancies.

REFERENCES

  1. Top of page
  2. Abstract
  3. INTRODUCTION
  4. EXPERIMENTAL ANIMAL STUDIES
  5. HUMAN REPORTS
  6. DISPROPORTIONALITY ANALYSIS
  7. DISCUSSION
  8. REFERENCES