- Top of page
- Materials and Methods
- Conflict of Interest
Climate variability and the rapid warming of seas undoubtedly have huge ramifications for biological processes such as reproduction. As such, gametogenesis and spawning were investigated at two sites over 200 km apart on the south coast of Ireland in an ecosystem engineer, the common cockle, Cerastoderma edule. Both sites are classed as Special Areas of Conservation (SACs), but are of different water quality. Cerastoderma edule plays a significant biological role by recycling nutrients and affecting sediment structure, with impacts upon assemblage biomass and functional diversity. It plays a key role in food webs, being a common foodstuff for a number of marine birds including the oystercatcher. Both before and during the study (early 2010–mid 2011), Ireland experienced its two coldest winters for 50 years. As the research demonstrated only slight variation in the spawning period between sites, despite site differences in water and environmental quality, temperature and variable climatic conditions were the dominant factor controlling gametogenesis. The most significant finding was that the spawning period in the cockle extended over a greater number of months compared with previous studies and that gametogenesis commenced over winter rather than in spring. Extremely cold winters may impact on the cockle by accelerating and extending the onset and development of gametogenesis. Whether this impact is positive or negative would depend on the associated events occurring on which the cockle depends, that is, presence of primary producers and spring blooms, which would facilitate conversion of this extended gametogenesis into successful recruitment.
- Top of page
- Materials and Methods
- Conflict of Interest
It is evident that changes are ongoing in the marine environment in terms of temperature, wind patterns, and sea levels orchestrated by climate change, with the swift nature of such changes causing much concern (Philippart et al. 2011). These changes are being seen globally, but not equally and the seas around Europe are disparately affected and were included as “rapid warming” seas in recent studies of warming in large marine ecosystems (Belkin 2009; Philippart et al. 2011). The period 1965–2004 in the North Atlantic has been a time of net heat accumulation and yields from European fisheries have also shown changes, with decreases in the Celtic Biscay Sea area, but increases in the Norwegian Seas (Philippart et al. 2011). Trends in the Irish Sea indicate warming of sea surface temperatures by 0.5–1°C from 1870 to 2007, as well as a tendency for increases in air temperature, sea level, and acidification (UKMMAS 2010). The sea surface temperature around the United Kingdom and Ireland has increased at six times the rate of the global average (Frost et al. 2012). For the preceding 30 years, there have been increased of 0.2–0.6°C in sea temperature per decade around the United Kingdom and Ireland, and the mean surface ocean pH has reached 8.14 in comparison with 8.25 in the 18th century (Heath et al. 2012). The mean annual air temperature recorded in Ireland has increased by 0.7°C in the period 1890–2004 and the northern hemisphere has been warmer since 1980 than at any time in the last 2000 years (Philippart et al. 2011). However, in 2010, Ireland experienced its coldest winter in 50 years (http://www.met.ie/climate-ireland/major-events.asp), related to the negative phase of the North Atlantic Oscillation (NAO), whose variability could be related to anthropogenic warming (Goodkin et al. 2008). It is predicted that sea levels around Ireland will increase by 18–59 cm in the 21st century; water quality is expected to be impacted deleteriously by the re-entry of contaminants that had previously been sediment-bound in lowlands and estuaries during extreme events that generate run off (Schiedek et al. 2007). As a result, species which have small thermal tolerance windows will be jeopardized (http://www.epa.ie/downloads/pubs/climatechange/EPAandClimateChangeFinal.pdf).
Cerastoderma edule is a common infaunal bivalve whose range spans from the Barents Sea to West Africa and is less commonly found in the southwest Mediterranean (Reise 2003; Cardoso et al. 2009). Preferred habitats of C. edule include sandy bays and estuaries, but it can also be found in gravel and mud (http://www.fao.org/fishery/species/3535/en; André et al. 1999; Reise 2003). Cockles can comprise up to 60% of the biomass of an area (Dabouineau and Ponsero 2009) and they play an important role in the ecosystem (Fig. 1). They are a link between primary producers (plankton) and higher trophic levels as cockles are predated upon by crabs, for example, Carcinus maenas, shrimp, for example, Crangon crangon, fish, for example, Pleuronectes platessa, and birds, for example, Haematopus ostralegus. Indeed C. crangon and P. platessa may consume up to 90% of juvenile cockles in an area (Cesar 2009). Carcinus maenas, C. crangon, and P. platessa are themselves subject to fisheries, as is the cockle and therefore create a link between marine and terrestrial food webs, in addition to being commercially important. Cockles themselves provide a habitat for up to 16 species of digenean trematode (de Montaudouin et al. 2009), turbellaria, and various other parasites, acting as a first and second intermediate host. Cockles too are responsible for a range of other ecosystem services, such as recycling nutrients, acting as a carbon store, cycling energy, and increasing ammonium concentrations, which in turn increases primary producers. They add to the overall diversity of an area and it is thought that increased biodiversity may increase ecosystem resilience and by their movements in the sediment they facilitate the exchange of dissolved nutrients to the water column and may increase the depth to which oxygen dissipates into the sediment (Cesar 2009). It has been suggested that estuarine and coastal areas are prime candidates for the study of climate change as they are shallow, and alterations in thermal regimes will be readily apparent (Moore et al. 2011; Madeira et al. 2012). Therefore, cockles were identified as an ideal candidate to evaluate the effects of climate variability on biological processes and in the case of this study: reproduction.
Figure 1. Simplified diagram of ecosystem including services of cockles in its habitats showing its appropriateness as a model species for climate variability studies.
Download figure to PowerPoint
Previous research has shown that recruitment in cockles can vary markedly in success between years and sites, with large increases in density occurring over a short period of time (Ramόn 1996; Honkoop et al. 1998; Sauriau and Kang 2000; Cardoso et al. 2009). Although cockles are known to be sensitive to colder conditions, experiencing mortalities during cold spells (Ramόn 1996; Strasser et al. 2001; Flach 2003; Reise 2003; Tyler-Walters 2007), greater recruitment has been seen in many areas, for example, Burry Inlet, following severe winters (Yankson 1986; André and Rosenberg 1991; Lindegarth et al. 1995). A decline in recruitment among C. edule and other bivalves (Mytilus edulis, Mya arenaria, Macoma balthica) in the Dutch Wadden Sea and Sweden has been linked to warming winters for the previous 15 years (Cardoso et al. 2009). It has been shown that following warmer winters, smaller, less viable eggs, with less lipids, are produced (Cesar 2009) and gametogenesis can extend further in the year and not allow for a sufficient rest period for recovery, prior to the beginning of the next reproductive cycle (Guillou and Tartu 1992). If conditions for optimal spawning (cold winters) are rarer, short lived species, such as the cockle, may not experience them in their life time (Cardoso et al. 2009). This could lead to an overall decrease in cockle biomass, which would have serious ramifications for not only cockles, but the ecosystem as a whole, because they as previously stated are an integral part of their habitats.
Cerastoderma edule is a dioecious, broadcast spawner (Boyden 1971; Dabouineau and Ponsero 2009); therefore, fertilization in cockles is external with males and females producing gametes, which are released into the water column (Lindegarth et al. 1995; André et al. 1999). It is an income breeder, acquiring energy as it produces gonads. Growth of cockle planktonic larvae proceeds quickly, and they persist in the water column for at least 2–3 weeks, but perhaps up to 5 weeks (Boyden 1971; Lindegarth et al. 1995; Honkoop and van der Meer 1998; André et al. 1999; Bouma et al. 2001; Reise 2003). Sexual maturity is usually reached when cockles are 18 months old or of shell length of 15–20 mm (Seed and Brown 1977; Dabouineau and Ponsero 2009), but Cardoso et al. (2009) recorded gonads in cockles >12 mm in shell length in cockles from the Dutch Wadden Sea. Settlement of cockles at Strangford Lough, Ireland has been described in August and September (Seed and Brown 1977), but in France between September and October (Guillou and Tartu 1994). External parameters such as temperature are known to affect gametogenesis and onset of spawning in bivalves (Gosling 2003; Drummond et al. 2006). Temperature acts to synchronize internal processes in bivalves, such as nutrient storage and the endocrine system (Brown 1984).
The aims of this study were to examine the reproductive cycle of C. edule, using it as a model species to assess the effects of climate variability on an a r – selected, ecosystem engineer, which is integral to food webs, provides habitat for other organisms and has commercial importance. The study was undertaken at two sites, which are classed as Special Areas of Conservation – SACs which are areas created under Article 3 of the EU Habitats Directive, and their purpose is to aid in the conservation of species and habitats on Annex I and Annex II of the Habitats Directive, by having conservation sites of good quality (http://www.epa.ie/licences/lic_eDMS/090151b2803baf8e.pdf; http://www.epa.ie/downloads/pubs/water/waterqua/waterrep/; http://jncc.defra.gov.uk/page-23). Two sites were chosen as great variation can be seen in cockles separated by a few meters on the same bed – so this study aimed to determine whether there was a general pattern apparent in reproduction (e.g., initiation of gametogenesis/spawning), despite local variation (e.g., in temperature, water quality) by examining two sites at the same latitude, but 215 km apart. Cockle reproduction has been assessed previously, but rarely using histology, the previous study performed in Ireland was in 1977, and the last study published from Europe was in 1989 and used gamete volume fraction (GVF). So, a histological study was deemed appropriate, which, although labor intensive, gives a much clearer picture than just assessing presence of larvae in the plankton, etc. The alterations in Ireland's weather patterns and climate, due to possible climate change, were especially apparent during this study with two extremely cold winters, the coldest in 50 years (http://www.epa.ie/downloads/pubs/water/waterqua/waterrep/); therefore, this offered a unique opportunity to evaluate the effects of an unusually cold winter on gametogenesis and recruitment in the cockle after a period of prolonged warming.
- Top of page
- Materials and Methods
- Conflict of Interest
The cockle plays a significant role in soft sediments and bays where it is found in abundance and climate is one factor, mainly through temperature variation, that can impact on both reproductive capacity and recruitment, and therefore overall biomass of the bivalve. Other parameters such as competition and food availability that were not measured in this study may also impact upon reproduction and growth; however, long-term changes in climate may alter these too. Results would indicate that climate variability is impacting on reproduction of this bivalve by prolonging the period over which spawning extends. Whether in the long term, this translates into more recruitment will depend on the external factors that contribute to this process, for example, plankton blooms and how they are affected by this climate change in terms of when they occur and which particular species will dominate.
Temperatures recorded over the study period were anomalous for Ireland; the winters of 2009–2010 and 2010–2011 were exceptional for several reasons: the winter of 2009–2010 was the coldest winter since 1962–1963. Additionally, it was the sunniest winter on record and had a lower frequency of strong winds. Although the winter of 2010–2011 was noteworthy as the cold spell began earlier in November 2010 than in previous years, it also had the coldest day measured in Ireland and nine uninterrupted days during which the temperature did not rise above 0°C (http://www.npws.ie/en/SPA/004081/). Summer temperatures in 2011 were also lower than normally experienced. This period of extreme cold was in comparison to warming trends on land and sea in Europe, with the average land temperature from 2002 to 2011 being 1.3°C higher than pre-industrial levels (http://www.eea.europa.eu/data-and-maps/indicators/global-and-european-temperature/global-and-european-temperature-assessment-5). It is believed that the cold temperatures were as a result of the negative phase of the NAO, which was at its most negative value (for which there are data) continuing and North Atlantic atmospheric blocking conditions (Cattiaux et al. 2010; Sillmann et al. 2011; Vicente-Serrano et al. 2011). Whether the NAO index is positive or negative is not thought to be impacted by anthropogenic warming; however, it may influence multidecadal variability, with extended time spans of extreme positive or negative NAO index possibly becoming more common if temperature increases persist (Goodkin et al. 2008). Temperatures recorded in 2010 were higher than the corresponding months in 2011 at both sites and there were site differences in temperature. There are differences in the tidal cycle (its duration) between the sites, which could have contributed to the differences observed in temperature.
Cockles from Bannow Bay had a higher weight than cockles from Flaxfort Strand, but a greater number of cockles at Bannow Bay was younger generally, having less growth rings, indicating that overall cockles at this site grew faster than at Flaxfort Strand. The difference in cockle lengths and CI (although not significant) and weights between the two sites could be linked first to immersion duration, second the detrimental effects of prolonged emersion, and finally to the extent of macroalgal growth (de Montaudouin 1996); all of which are factors, which differ between the sites. Previous studies of cockle pathology at Flaxfort Strand have shown that the frequency of digenean trematodes and disseminated neoplasia is highest in intermediately (18.0–23.9 mm) sized cockles; so many cockles may die before attaining maximum size (Morgan et al. 2012).
There was a significantly greater number of cockles with two or less growth rings at Bannow Bay than Flaxfort Strand, which could be related to site differences in water quality. Under stressful conditions, it has been shown that another bivalve – Mytilus edulis produces less viable larvae (Bayne et al. 1978) and bivalve larvae themselves are highly susceptible to the effects of pollutants such as heavy metals. Flaxfort Strand, unlike Bannow Bay, is surrounded by roads and there may be run off of hydrocarbons during rains and these pollutants may affect the recruitment of cockles in this area (Beiras and His 1985). Despite having less older cockles, there are higher densities of cockles at Flaxfort Strand than at Bannow Bay (preliminary study); therefore, high densities of larvae could be filtered out of the water column before settlement.
More females were identified than males, but no significant deviation from a 1:1 ratio was observed in agreement with previous Irish and English studies (Boyden 1971; Morgan et al. 2012). A number of indeterminate cockles and one possible hermaphrodite were seen at Flaxfort Strand. Cockles of all size classes were collected, leading to the gathering of sexually immature cockles; additionally, some cockles' gonads upon examination were castrated by trematodes (pers. obs.). In all, 22% of cockles in a study from the Crouch Estuary, England were of indeterminate sex (Boyden 1971). One hermaphrodite was also found in the study on the Kent coast, but this was a mixed study of C. edule and C. glaucum and the species was not stated.
Gonads were observed in cockles of 8.9 mm in length in Bannow Bay and 9.9 mm in Flaxfort Strand or in cockles with one growth ring. Gametogenesis in cockles has previously been recorded in animals with one growth ring (Cardoso et al. 2009). However, this precocious development was rare, with most not developing gonads until >11 mm. In another study of cockle reproduction in the Dutch Wadden Sea, gonads were identified in cockles >12 mm (Cardoso et al. 2009). At Strangford Lough, initial development of gonads was recorded in cockles from 15 to 20 mm (Seed and Brown 1977). According to Dabouineau and Ponsero (2009) size, not age of cockles, could be of greater importance to cockle sexual maturity. The majority of spawning cockles had three or four growth rings in this study. This is in contrast to cockles from the Burry Inlet where precocious spawning occurred with the majority of cockles with one growth ring spawning and subsequently dying, perhaps as a reaction to high densities (Elliot et al. 2012). One or 2-year classes disproportionately contributing to the overall cockle population has been described previously in the Wadden Sea (Cardoso et al. 2009) and greater production by older cockles has also been described in the Mundaca Estuary (Iglesias and Navarro 1991).
In this study, there were differences observed between the sites and between the sexes in peaks of gonadal maturity, spawning duration, and period. Two peaks in spawning were observed at both sites, which were also previously recorded in Ireland (Morgan et al. 2012). Cockles were ripe in both sites from April 2010, but in March in 2011. Advancement of gonadal maturity was seen in male soft shell clams, Mya arenaria in March and April 2011 in comparison with 2010 when most males developed in May, at Bannow Bay, which was studied over the same time period (Cross et al. 2012). Ripe gonads have been described previously in cockles from May in the southeast of England (Kingston 1974) and in another study in Strangford Lough; males were described as ripe from April, but females not until May (Seed and Brown 1977). This study may be demonstrating that previous severe winters may be accelerating gametogenesis with ripe individuals being observed earlier in the year. Yankson (1986) measuring fecundity with GVF reported an earlier peak in fecundity among cockles in the Burry Inlet in 1982 after a severe winter compared to the previous year.
The spawning period extended until November in Bannow Bay, but ceased in September in Flaxfort Strand. The spawning period in intertidal cockles in the Dutch Wadden Sea continued until October (Cardoso et al. 2009), but in an earlier study in Ireland, the majority of cockles were in a spent condition from August/September (Seed and Brown 1977). Differences in spawning period could be due to site conditions, cockles at Bannow Bay were heavier than at Flaxfort Strand and there may be a greater supply of nutrients for gonad production in Bannow Bay (Cotter et al. 2010). If there is a greater amount of gonads, it may take a longer time period to spawn. It has been suggested also that reproductive strategy of a species may not be set, but could vary, with the prevailing conditions influencing the strategy adopted (Yankson 1986).
Partial spawning was observed in this study, with a low number of individuals remained partially spent over winter with residual gametes apparent; this was particularly evident at Bannow Bay. Complete spawning was found among C. edule in the Crouch Estuary and the Dutch Wadden Sea (Boyden 1971; Cardoso et al. 2009). Gametogenesis was seen in both sites over winter, but at both sites, the sexes were not in synchrony. Navarro et al. (1989) proposed that gametogenesis begins again over winter if sufficient glycogen reserves have been amassed during the previous summer. Rapid gonadal development initiated in spring at Strangford Lough, Northern Ireland has been described at the beginning of the growing season after over wintering in spent condition (Seed and Brown 1977; Cardoso et al. 2009); however, slow gonad development has been described in the Crouch Estuary, Essex and in the Burry Inlet (Boyden 1971; Yankson 1986). In the latter scenario, growth begins in autumn and continues over winter with increased impetus in spring and spawning commences in late spring/early summer (Boyden 1971; Yankson 1986; Twomey 1987) (Table 1).
It has been stated that in cockles, temperature does not have a coordinating effect on reproduction, either by a minimum threshold required or by temperature change (Navarro et al. 1989). However, changes in the CI of cockles from St-Pol-de-Léon, France, from 1987 to 1989, reflected alterations in temperature, with lows during the colder year of 1987 in comparison with highest CI during 1989, which was warmer than average (Guillou and Tartu 1992). Other studies indicate increases in temperature, not its absolute value, influence cockle reproduction (Dabouineau and Ponsero 2009). In this study, ripening and spawning of cockles at both sites occurred at different temperatures between years as was also observed in the Mundaca Estuary, North Spain (Navarro et al. 1989) and prevailing environmental conditions altering gametogenesis and physiology in cockles has been suggested (Iglesias and Navarro 1991). Gonadal maturity could be attributed to not only temperature but also the animal's condition and food availability (Yan et al. 2010). This study coincided with two severe winters, anomalous to Ireland (http://www.epa.ie/downloads/pubs/water/waterqua/waterrep/). Particularly, cold winters may additionally aid reproductive success in cockles by ensuring that male and female gametes are released in unison (Dabouineau and Ponsero 2009). A study of cockle gametogenesis in the Burry Inlet in 1981–1982 corresponded as well with an unusually cold winter. Their findings (Yankson 1986) included incomplete spawning, followed by redevelopment and spawning again, which was in agreement with the incomplete spawning seen in this study.
Milder winters experienced in the Wadden Sea area have been linked to on-going reductions in bivalve recruitment (Philippart et al. 2003), whereas several studies have reported greater bivalve recruitment after severe winters (Honkoop et al. 1998; Philippart et al. 2003; Beukema and Dekker 2005). Less severe milder winters are thought to allow for gametogenesis to occur for a longer period, therefore, not allowing for a cessation in gonad production and a rest period for the bivalve, but colder winters provide a rest period between cycles, which may be advantageous for redevelopment in spring (Guillou and Tartu 1992). Levels of interannual variation can be observed nonetheless in many marine invertebrates and this phenomenon is not totally understood (Honkoop et al. 1998). Direct (variation in egg numbers) and indirect (predator–prey mismatch) effects of climate change are thought to be responsible for this occurrence (Flach 2003). Cardoso et al. (2009) believe that C. edule may be more affected by climate change than other more long-lived bivalves such as Mya arenaria as the possibility of them experiencing a cold winter during their short lifespan is low.
Moore et al. (2011) postulate that comparing historical and contemporary data has limitations, but may be informative in relation to species responses to climate change in particular, if baseline data are absent. Although different methods of assessment were used, it appears that the spawning period of cockles has extended throughout the last century (Table 3), with an earlier starting time and continuing later into autumn. This could be linked to the change in environmental conditions, orchestrated by global climate change, with globally oceans warming on average by 0.6°C in the last 100 years (Wiltshire et al. 2008) and European seas are thought to be especially affected by climate change (Philippart et al. 2011). Alterations in phenological relationships due to sea temperature will have consequences modifying many trophic interactions such as food webs (Edwards and Richardson 2004; Wiltshire et al. 2008). Indeed, marine temperate areas could be especially susceptible to changes in the cycle of plankton production as recruitment is contingent upon it and spring plankton blooms are occurring earlier (Edwards and Richardson 2004; Heath et al. 2012). Therefore, earlier spawning in cockles and longer spawning period could be as a consequence of amendments to plankton pulses. Extension of the breeding season could reduce the chances of a mismatch with peaks in primary production and prevent the chances of overpopulation by mass spawning, as has been described in Cerastoderma glaucum (Guillou and Tartu 1992). This could be exacerbated in cockles, as previously stated, as income breeders; they can quickly utilize food resources for gonad manufacture (Cardoso et al. 2009). Other invertebrates such as the brown shrimp Crangon crangon have altered their spawning regime in response to warmer temperatures by having two spawning periods in the southern North Sea, compared with one in the northern North Sea (Heath et al. 2012). Similarly, the boreal limpet Patella vulgata spawns further into the autumn in the 2000s than it did during the 1940s (Moore et al. 2011).
Table 3. Previous study locations and methods of assessing Cerastoderma edule gametogenesis arranged by latitude
|Trondheim, Norway||Gonad smears|| ||Early July began||Rygg 1970; |
|Western Wadden Sea||Gonadal mass ratio|| ||April–October||Cardoso et al. 2009; |
|Strangford Lough, Ireland||Gonad classification||Spring||Midsummer–August||Seed and Brown 1977; |
|Cardigan Bay, Wales||Histology||October–March||May began||Creek 1960; |
|Crouch Estuary, England||Gonadal smears||Early Spring||May–July||Boyden 1971; |
|Burry Inlet, Wales||Gonad smears|| ||June began||Hancock and Franklin 1972; |
|Kent Coast, England||Histology||September and October||May and June||Kingston 1974; |
|Plymouth, England||Sieving|| ||May–August||Lebour 1938; |
|Mundaca Estuay, Basque Country, Spain||Gamete volume fraction||November||May–September||Navarro et al. 1989|
In spite of trends in the Wadden Sea and western Sweden toward milder winters, this study was conducted during a time of uncharacteristically cold winters in Ireland, which appears to bode well for cockle recruitment success. However, this was followed by a mild winter in 2011–2012, so it is difficult to predict future winter conditions. Although previously in Ireland gametogenesis has been described from spring only, this study found that cockles begin to develop gonads over winter. The duration of spawning time reported in this study also contrasts with previous studies, starting earlier and continuing until later in autumn. Males and females in both sites, additionally, were not entirely synchronous in terms of gametogenesis and spawning, which if the time span widens could impact negatively upon spawning success (for a summary of the main results refer to Table 4). The lack of younger year classes of cockles present at Flaxfort Strand could have serious ramifications for the many birds that rely upon them as a food source. Particularly, birds classified as Annex 1 on the EU Birds Directive, for example, bar-tailed godwits and golden plovers frequent this area.
Table 4. Summary of main results
|Temperature||No significant difference between sites, but 2010 was warmer than the corresponding months in 2011.|
|General cockle biology||Cockles from Bannow Bay greater in length, width, and shell height (but not significantly so).|
|Significantly greater whole weight, shell weight, and tissue weight in Bannow Bay.|
|Greater condition index at Bannow Bay (but not significantly so).|
|Sex ratio adhered to 1:1, but females were more common at both sites.|
|Significantly more young cockles (with less than two growth rings) at Bannow Bay|
|Reproduction||Five stages of gonadal maturity identified.|
|After a severe winter, gonad ripening and spawning began earlier.|
|Ripening and spawning were recorded at different temperatures.|
|The smallest cockle with gonads was 8.9 mm (Flaxfort Strand) and 9.9 mm (Bannow Bay).|
|Most cockles (90%) did not develop gonads until they were above 11 mm in length.|
|Cockle gametogenesis appears to have extended in duration, especially when compared with other studies.|
|Gametogenesis began over winter, in contrast to previous study in Ireland.|
Alterations in cockle gametogenesis, spawning and subsequent settlement are not only dependent on temperature but also the effect that climate variability has on plankton and previously appropriate habitats may no longer be suitable due to changes in oxygen levels or thermal regime. Reductions in cockle numbers would have concurrent effects on water chemistry, sediment oxygenation, and structure and the species richness of an area. Further studies using other intertidal organisms such as mussels or barnacles could be beneficial, to see if changes in spawning or larval release timing is widespread in marine shallow water invertebrates.