Exploring the Limits of Autonomy
Article first published online: 3 MAY 2012
© 2012 by The Hastings Center
Hastings Center Report
Volume 42, Issue 3, pages 16–18, May-June 2012
How to Cite
Volpe, R. L., Levi, B. H., Blackall, G. F. and Green, M. J. (2012), Exploring the Limits of Autonomy. Hastings Center Report, 42: 16–18. doi: 10.1002/hast.46
- Issue published online: 3 MAY 2012
- Article first published online: 3 MAY 2012
Mr. Galanas, an eighty-six-year-old man, intentionally shot himself in the chest and abdomen. Surprisingly, the bullet damaged only his distal pancreas and part of his colon, requiring a diverting colostomy to prevent leakage of bowel fluids into his abdomen. After being admitted, he lies intubated in the intensive care unit awaiting surgery to repair his colon. He is responsive but does not demonstrate clear decision-making capacity. He grudgingly accepts pain medications but refuses antibiotics and antidepressants. He has a living will that gives his wife durable power of attorney and also explicitly states a desire to refuse all medical interventions if he is permanently unconscious or in an end-stage condition. Mrs. Galanas reports frequent conversations in which her husband said he would not want to be sustained on life support. She also says that he often mentioned he would not want an ostomy bag—a likely, albeit temporary, outcome of the proposed surgery.
His physicians are nervous about withholding medical interventions when Mr. Galanas's injury is the result of a suicide attempt and his prognosis is good. Should the care team surgically repair his injured colon, regardless of the patient's capacity, his advance directive, and his wife's statement that he would not want surgery or other life-sustaining treatment?