A comparison of metabolite extraction strategies for 1H-NMR-based metabolic profiling using mature leaf tissue from the model plant Arabidopsis thaliana



Metabolite analysis is recognized as an important facet of systems biology, however complete metabolome characterization has not been realized due to challenges in sample preparation, inherent instrumental limitations and the labor intensive task of data interpretation. This work aims to compare several commonly used metabolite extraction strategies for their effect on the 1H nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) metabolic profile of extracts of the model plant Arabidopsis thaliana. Extractions were carried out on aliquots from a pool of homogenized plant tissue using CD3CN/D2O, buffered D2O, perchloric acid in D2O, CD3OD/D2O and CD3OD/D2O/CDCl3 as the extraction solvents. The effects of lyophilization as a sample pretreatment, solvent evaporation and extract fractionation for removal of interfering species were studied. Representative spectra are presented for qualitative interpretation. Analytical reproducibility was evaluated by principal components analysis. Perchloric acid facilitated acid-catalyzed cleavage of sucrose, further complicating biological interpretation of the resulting metabolite profile. The solvent system CD3OD/D2O/CDCl3 gave the least reproducible results in our hands. D2O extracts suffered from poor stability probably due to contamination by soluble enzymes, which were not denatured in this solvent. CD3CN/D2O extracts showed greater stability than D2O alone, but problems were encountered due to degradation of 1H NMR spectral resolution during lengthy acquisitions due to partial phase separation. In addition, this solvent system produced spectra with significant contamination by lipids that obscured spectral regions containing the resonances of the aliphatic amino acids. These problems were solved by speedvacuuming the CD3CN/D2O extract and reconstituting in D2O solution. Copyright © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.