Regional patterns of radiocarbon and fossil fuel-derived CO2 in surface air across North America

Authors


Abstract

[1] Radiocarbon levels in annual plants provide a means to map out regional and continental-scale fossil fuel plumes in surface air. We collected corn (Zea mays) across North America during the summer of 2004. Plants from mountain regions of western North America showed the smallest influence of fossil fuel-derived CO2 with a mean Δ14C of 66.3‰ ±1.7‰. Plants from eastern North America and from the Ohio-Maryland region showed a larger fossil fuel influence with a mean Δ14C of 58.8‰ ± 3.9‰ and 55.2‰ ± 2.3‰, respectively, corresponding to 2.7 ppm ± 1.5 ppm and 4.3 ppm ± 1.0 ppm of added fossil fuel CO2 relative to the mountain west. A model–data comparison suggests that surveys of annual plant Δ14C can provide a useful test of atmospheric mixing in transport models that are used to estimate the spatial distribution of carbon sources and sinks.

1. Introduction

[2] The radiocarbon (14C) produced by atomic weapons testing in the late 1950s and early 1960s has served as a powerful tracer of atmospheric and ocean transport, air-sea gas exchange, and the age distribution of carbon in terrestrial ecosystems. After reaching nearly 1000‰ in the northern hemisphere troposphere in 1963, Δ14C levels have declined systematically as a result of dilution primarily from carbon exchange with ocean and terrestrial biosphere reservoirs [Nydal and Lovseth, 1983]. Key processes that regulate the contemporary distribution of atmospheric Δ14C include rates of ocean mixing and air-sea gas exchange [Broecker et al., 1985], carbon cycling within terrestrial ecosystems [Trumbore, 2000], cosmogenic production [Lingenfelter, 1963], re-entrainment of older stratospheric air in the troposphere [Hesshaimer and Levin, 2000], and fossil fuel emissions. At a regional scale, the relative importance of these processes varies. In the Southern Hemisphere, for example, upwelling and subduction of intermediate and deep water masses (with low Δ14C levels) causes large latitudinal gradients, with a minimum in atmospheric Δ14C over the Southern Ocean [Levin and Hesshaimer, 2000]. In the Northern Hemisphere, large urban and industrial centers in North America, Europe, and Asia create plumes of fossil fuel-enriched CO2 that are depleted in Δ14C [Randerson et al., 2002; Levin et al., 2003; Turnbull et al., 2006].

[3] The rate at which these fossil fuel plumes are lofted off the northern continents and mixed between the northern and southern hemispheres in atmospheric models critically determines the distribution and magnitude of carbon sources and sinks in ‘top down’ inversions that take advantage of atmospheric observations. Atmospheric models that trap too much fossil fuel CO2 near the surface, for example, may require erroneously large carbon sinks to match surface observations [e.g., Gurney et al., 2004]. Vertical mixing in atmospheric models is challenging to represent, in part because some of the key processes (including convection) occur at spatial resolutions smaller than the size of the average grid cell. Tracers that can serve as potential constraints on atmospheric mixing processes include water vapor, radon, and Δ14C. Past work using radon and Δ14C provides evidence for strong regional and vertical gradients in fossil fuel CO2 across Europe [Levin et al., 2003]. Δ14C is a particularly sensitive tracer of fossil fuel emissions in the contemporary (2006) atmosphere; 1 ppm of CO2 added from fossil fuels causes a depletion of Δ14C by approximately 2.8‰, which is near the precision of contemporary accelerator mass spectrometers [Turnbull et al., 2006].

[4] In this study, we measured the Δ14C of corn plants across North America during the summer of 2004. We had three objectives. First, we wanted to assess whether annual plants could be used to obtain time-integrated atmospheric samples over a period of several months, as a complement to ground and aircraft flask sampling approaches. Second, we wanted to better understand how fossil fuel emissions disperse over the continent. To what extent, for example, do the Rocky Mountains impede the surface flow of fossil fuel CO2 from the west coast to the east coast? Third, by mapping regional variations in atmospheric Δ14C we hoped to improve our ability to use Δ14C as a tracer in ecosystem studies examining rapid turnover pools [e.g., Gaudinski et al., 2001].

2. Materials and Methods

2.1. Sample Collection

[5] We collected samples of corn leaves (Zea mays) from North America during the summer of 2004. A few additional samples were collected from Venezuela, Brazil, and China. We relied on the generosity of colleagues to collect corn samples in places near where they lived or visited. Packets were sent to colleagues with a specific sampling protocol, three paper coin envelopes for the samples, and a larger self-addressed envelope for sample return. To avoid sampling point sources such as highways or power plants, our protocol was to collect samples in remote locations. Specifically, we sampled more than 1.6 km away from highways, more than 45 meters from paved roads, and more than 20 meters away from houses or buildings that used natural gas or fossil fuels for heating. For the most part, we avoided sampling in major cities so that we could detect larger-scale regional patterns of Δ14C. At each site, cross-sections from three top leaves were collected, except in Hawaii and in Carlsbad, Clovis, and Riverside, California, where husks were sampled. In Alaska, an annual forb (Matricaria matricariodes) was substituted for corn because of the difficulty in locating corn in this region. Additional corn samples were also collected directly by the authors during July 17–23 from Alabama, Tennessee, Kentucky, Ohio, West Virginia, Pennsylvania, Maryland and Virginia. Most samples (45 out of 67) were collected in the field before the end of July.

2.2. Sample Preparation and Analysis

[6] Samples were dried at approximately 60–70°C for at least 48 hours, upon arrival at our laboratory. After drying, the plants were ground, and the bulk plant material (without any pretreatment) was converted to graphite using the process described by Santos et al. [2004]. Subsequently, the graphite was analyzed for Δ14C using the W.M. Keck Carbon Cycle Accelerator Mass Spectrometer at UC Irvine. To ensure that we quantified the overall accuracy and to minimize the chance of differences due to running samples in different batches on the AMS, we included approximately 6 primary and 6 secondary standards with each wheel (along with 26 corn samples). We also made repeated measurements at 26 out of 67 sites to further establish continuity across the different AMS runs. Based on an analysis of our secondary standards, we concluded that the accuracy of any individual measurement was ±2.3‰. As a measure of precision, the pooled standard deviation across sites for which we made multiple measurements was 2.4‰.

2.3. Estimating Fossil Fuel CO2

[7] Ambient CO2 that is assimilated by the corn (Cc, with units of ppm) consists of a background component (Cbg) and local anomalies caused by terrestrial biosphere exchange (Cb), ocean exchange (Co), and fossil fuel emissions (Cff). Similarly, the Δ14C of the components are Δc, Δbg, Δb, Δo, and Δff. The mass balance equations are

equation image
equation image

[8] We estimated background CO2 levels (Cbg) using measurements from the NOAA Global Monitoring Division Niwot Ridge station. Niwot Ridge is a high elevation (3475 m.a.s.l.) continental site that is sampled during meteorological conditions representative of the free troposphere. Because most of the corn grew during May, June, and July of 2004, we constructed Cbg from the mean of observations during these three months. Cbg was equal to 378.4 ppm ± 2.7 ppm, based on an average and standard deviation of 41 flask samples. Δbg was assumed to equal the mean of the corn samples from the mountain west region (sample locations are given in the footnote of Table 1). Thus our estimates of Cff were made relative to this clean air region defined by both CO2 and Δ14C measurements.

Table 1. Regional Variability of Δ14C and Fossil Fuel CO2 Across North America
 Mountain WestaEastern U.S.bOhio-Marylandc
  • a

    Includes all samples from Alberta, Idaho, Colorado, and New Mexico.

  • b

    Includes all samples from Nova Scotia, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, New York, Indiana, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Maryland, West Virginia, Kentucky, Tennessee, Virginia, Mississippi, Alabama, Georgia, and Florida.

  • c

    Includes all samples from Ohio, Pennsylvania, West Virginia, and Maryland.

  • d

    Error estimates for Δ14C measurements were computed as the standard deviation of all individual site means within a given region.

  • e

    Error estimates for model-derived terrestrial biosphere, ocean, and stratosphere components are subjective and reflect combined uncertainties from atmospheric transport and surface fluxes. We conducted a sensitivity test of doubling and halving the residence times in the terrestrial biosphere, and report the results in the auxiliary material.

Mean Δ14C, ‰66.3 ± 1.7d58.8 ± 3.955.2 ± 2.3
Number of sites (n)83411
Change in Δ14C relative to the Mountain West, ‰-−7.5 ± 4.3−11.1 ± 2.9
Biosphere + ocean + stratosphere contribution,e-0.0 ± 0.20.8 ± 0.3
Estimated Δ14C change due to added fossil fuel CO2, ‰-−7.5 ± 4.3−11.9 ± 2.9
Added fossil fuel CO2, ppm-2.7 ± 1.54.3 ± 1.0

[9] Regional anomalies of Cb, Co, Δb, and Δo, relative to Niwot Ridge, were taken from an analysis of atmospheric radiocarbon [Krakauer et al., 2006] using the Model of Atmospheric Transport and Chemistry (MATCH) [Mahowald et al., 1997]. MATCH was run with 26 vertical levels, a horizontal resolution of 5.5°, and with meteorological fields from the NCAR Community Climate Model v3 [Olsen and Randerson, 2004].

[10] We modeled fossil fuel releases in MATCH using the map from Andres et al. [1996] for 1995 emissions, scaled uniformly based on the Carbon Dioxide Information Analysis Center time series of global fossil emissions [Marland et al., 2005] to account for the overall increase in emission levels between 1995 and 2004. The fossil emissions had a 1° × 1° resolution that was aggregated to the resolution of our transport model.

[11] To model atmospheric Δ14C gradients from terrestrial biosphere and ocean exchange, we generated regional Green's functions from our transport model. Our Green's functions corresponded to tracer releases over the 22 TransCom regions [Gurney et al., 2004]. The tracer release was constant during each month of the year, allowing us to accurately represent seasonally varying fluxes. The spatial pattern of tracer release within each of the 11 terrestrial regions corresponded to the distribution of NPP predicted by CASA, while tracer release was spatially uniform within the 11 ocean regions. The Δ14C of heterotrophic respiration within each terrestrial region was estimated using pulse-response functions from the Carnegie-Ames-Stanford Approach (CASA) biogeochemical model [Thompson and Randerson, 1999] convolved with the history of atmospheric Δ14C, based on tree ring records [Stuiver and Quay, 1981] and, since the 1950s, on atmospheric measurements [Levin and Kromer, 2004]. This meant that for temperate North America, the heterotrophic respiration flux had the same Δ14C level entering into each tracer model grid cell within the region (a mean of 99.8‰), but the magnitude of this flux was distributed heterogeneously across the continent according to the CASA-derived pattern of NPP (that is equivalent to the pattern of heterotrophic respiration for this purpose). We used sea-surface Δ14C derived from a simulation of bomb radiocarbon uptake with an ocean transport model [Krakauer et al., 2006] and assumed an air-sea gas transfer velocity proportional to the square of wind speed [Dutay et al., 2002] to estimate the spatial pattern of ocean 14C uptake, and with the same set of pulse functions simulated the impact of ocean uptake of 14C on atmospheric Δ14C.

[12] The model simulations also included stratosphere-troposphere exchange effects on regional patterns of CO2 and Δ14C, but across North America, these effects were small (varying by less than 0.3‰). We did this by constructing pulse functions for northern, southern, and equatorial tracer release in the stratosphere (at the 90 mb pressure level) and in the upper troposphere (at 200 mb) to allow us to simulate the effect of cosmogenic 14C production in the upper atmosphere on atmospheric Δ14C gradients near the surface.

3. Results

3.1. Observed Spatial Patterns

[13] In places with elevated levels of CO2 from recently added fossil fuel emissions, Δ14C levels were reduced (Figure 1). We found a decrease of 7.5‰ ± 4.3‰ between the western mountain region of North America and eastern North America (Table 1). This corresponded to a 2.7 ± 1.5 ppm increase in fossil fuel CO2 levels in the east, relative to the west. An even larger Δ14C decrease of 11.1‰ ± 2.9‰ was found between the western mountain region and the Ohio-Maryland region (including Ohio, Pennsylvania, West Virginia, and Maryland), corresponding to 4.3 ± 1.0 ppm of added fossil CO2. Sample locations, individual site Δ14C measurements, and more detailed information about our measurement errors are provided in an auxiliary table.

Figure 1.

Δ14C measurements of corn (Zea mays) across North America during the summer of 2004 (in units of ‰). During this period, a decrease of 2.8‰ corresponded to approximately 1 ppm of added fossil fuel CO2. The background color interpolation was generated using a spline fit based on 15 nearest neighbors with the Geostatistical Analyst tool in ESRI's ArcMap software.

[14] Near urban areas, Δ14C gradients were even larger. In northern California, for example, Δ14C at a coastal site (San Gregorio) was 67.1‰ ± 2.3‰, whereas Δ14C at a site ∼95 km to the east and north (Brentwood) was 37.2‰ ± 2.3‰. The 30‰ decrease at Brentwood, relative to the coast, corresponded to 10.9 ppm of locally-added fossil fuel CO2 that probably originated from cities in the San Francisco Bay Area. Low Δ14C was also observed near Clovis, CA (55.3‰ ± 2.3‰) and Riverside, CA (42.8‰ ± 2.3‰).

[15] Comparison with nearby flask observations showed that the annual plants provided an integrated measure of atmospheric Δ14C during the time of their growth. The mean of annual plants collected from the western mountain region (66.3‰ ± 1.7‰) was the same, within measurement error, as the mean of Δ14C measured by flasks during May, June, and July at Niwot Ridge (64.4‰ ± 3.3‰, n = 12) as reported by Turnbull et al. [2006]. An independent set of 8 flasks collected from Niwot Ridge during April, June, and July of 2004 (extracted and measured at UC Irvine) yielded a similar mean of 67.6‰ ± 3.0‰. Annual plants sampled near Healy in interior Alaska (65.2‰ ± 2.3‰) were similar to flask measurements collected at the same location in June and August (65.6‰ ± 7.5‰, n = 4 (E.A.G. Schuur, unpublished data, 2004)).

3.2. Model-Data Comparison

[16] The dominant driver of regional variation in Δ14C across North America as predicted by our model was fossil fuel emissions (Figure 2). Fossil fuel emissions created two local minima of Δ14C across the continent. One was located over California (Figure 2a). The other was stronger and was located over the northeastern U.S. between 40°N and 45°N and 70°W and 90°W. Respiration of bomb 14C from terrestrial ecosystems caused greater enrichment of surface air in the east (where respiration fluxes were stronger) and thus partly offset the depletion of Δ14C in this region caused by fossil fuels (Figure 2b). Terrestrial ecosystem respiration caused a maximum in surface air Δ14C across the Midwest (Oklahoma, Nebraska, and North and South Dakota). Thus, even though respiration rates were higher in the temperate forests to the east (which would enrich surface CO2 in Δ14C), it is likely that longer residence times of surface air in the middle of the continent, including entrainment of air from Canada, contributed to the Δ14C maximum located there. Ocean exchange contributed only minimally to continental patterns across North America (Figure 2c), although this flux induced variations in excess of 1‰ near coastal zones.

Figure 2.

Contributions to surface atmospheric Δ14C anomalies (with units of ‰) caused by (a) fossil fuel emissions, (b) terrestrial biosphere exchange, and (c) ocean exchange as derived from a global model during May–July of 2004 and (d) the combined influence of these processes, along with the effects of stratosphere-troposphere mixing. The background Δ14C in Figure 2d was adjusted by a single uniform scalar so that the mean of the model was the same as the mean of observations from the western mountain region (defined in Table 1). The MATCH model was used in these simulations with fluxes described in the text. Panels shown here were interpolated from the original model resolution of approximately 5.5°. Stratosphere-troposphere exchange (data not shown) contributed to a small enrichment of surface Δ14C across the western mountains (less than 0.3‰) as compared with other regions closer to sea level.

[17] Overall the model captured some but not the entire pattern of observed Δ14C, perhaps in part because of its coarse spatial resolution and from information loss caused by our use of uniform monthly-mean Green's functions. Between the eastern U.S. region and the mountain west region defined in Table 1, model-predicted Δ14C differences from fossil fuel, terrestrial biosphere, ocean, and cosmogenic production processes were −8.5‰, +0.4‰, −0.3‰, and −0.1‰, respectively. Combined, the difference predicted by the model of −8.5‰ was approximately the same as the observed difference of −7.5‰ ± 2.9‰. Model-predicted differences between the Ohio-Maryland region and the mountain west region were −13.9‰, +0.9‰, 0.0‰, and −0.1‰, and again, the combined model difference of −13.1‰ was similar to the observed difference of −11.1‰ ± 2.9‰.

4. Discussion

4.1. Understanding the Movement of Fossil Fuel-Derived CO2

[18] Turnbull et al. [2006] demonstrate that 14C has several advantages over CO or SF6 as a tracer of local sources of fossil fuel-derived CO2. Both Turnbull et al. [2006] and Potosnak et al. [1999] show that air within the planetary boundary layer over New England during summer has between 0.5 and 5 ppm of CO2 added from nearby fossil fuel emissions. Our analysis provides additional support for a local fossil fuel source of over rural parts of New England and shows that elevated levels of CO2 from fossil fuel emissions existed across most of the eastern U.S. during the summer of 2004 (with a mean of 2.7 ppm ± 1.5 ppm). Similar levels of fossil fuel CO2 have been reported for remote parts of Europe, including at the Schauinsland station in Germany [Levin and Kromer, 1997]. Near cities, our analysis shows that fossil fuel-derived CO2 can be an order of magnitude larger than in nearby rural environments. This finding is consistent with continuous CO2 and δ13C measurements reported from Salt Lake City, Utah [Pataki et al., 2003] and Δ14C measurements from Heidelberg, Germany [Levin et al., 2003].

[19] The high Δ14C values observed across the mountain west imply that fossil fuel emissions from California and other western coastal states are either substantially diluted or lofted off the surface by the time they reach this region or that these emissions leave the continent via another route (e.g., entrainment into a southerly flow around the Pacific high that forms during summer). If the latter is correct, our work suggests that atmospheric sampling strategies designed to measure North American continental outflow [Wofsy and Harriss, 2002] must sample southern as well as eastern borders.

4.2. Strengths and Weaknesses of Sampling Zea Mays

[20] The design of an atmospheric sampling program based on annual plants has advantages and disadvantages. Compared to tree rings, annual plants have the advantage that all of the biomass accumulates during a single growing season. This removes the complication of having to estimate the contribution of multi-year starch reserves to the current year's biomass increment. In boreal forest ecosystems, temporal offsets between gross primary production and bole increment suggest these starch inputs may be substantial [Rocha et al., 2006]. On the other hand, annual plants decompose quickly, so it is challenging to develop time series that extend back more than a few years.

[21] As compared with flasks, annual plants provide an efficient means to capture time-integrated atmospheric Δ14C samples over a period of weeks to months. This offers a unique advantage in terms of rapidly mapping large-scale environmental gradients in both rural and urban settings in a cost-effective manner. Also, the time-integrated samples are particularly valuable for assessing seasonal and annual carbon sources. Possible future applications include testing for leaks from subterranean CO2 sequestration projects, and where CO/CO2 emissions ratios are known, monitoring of atmospheric CO concentrations near industrial sources. Annual plants also provide a unique test of the combined effect of fossil fuel emissions, boundary layer mixing, and atmospheric transport in mesoscale and global atmospheric models used to study the global carbon cycle. Models that trap too much fossil fuel over continental areas will predict regional decreases in Δ14C that are larger than observations. A disadvantage of using annual plants is that the exact timing of plant carbon fixation diurnally and on synoptic timescales is difficult to quantify without investment in other measurement approaches.

[22] The biomass of the C4 and C3 annual plants measured here represents a time-integrated Δ14C value during the day, weighted by factors that control rates of photosynthesis. As a result, our samples measure atmospheric Δ14C levels during periods when the planetary boundary layer was well developed. This diurnal sampling pattern differs substantially from that obtained when canisters with pinhole valves or constant speed pumps are used to collect integrated air samples over a period of days to weeks. These latter sampling approaches capture CO2 in proportion to its atmospheric abundance and thus have the tendency to weight nighttime periods more heavily than daytime periods. These differences in sampling protocol have the potential to influence model-data comparisons, and need to be considered in future studies that use annual plant Δ14C measurements to quantitatively assess model transport.

5. Conclusions

[23] Our measurements provide evidence of large coherent variations in atmospheric Δ14C across the North American continent in excess of 10‰ and of even larger magnitude near urban areas. The highest levels of Δ14C (and the lowest levels of fossil fuel-derived CO2) were observed across the mountain west. The clean air in this region implies that fossil fuel-enriched surface air from the west coast is either substantially diluted or lofted off the surface before reaching the Rocky Mountains, or that it leaves the continent via a separate route. The spatial pattern derived from the observations and model simulations identify fossil fuel emissions as the major driver of regional variability across the continent, with a small contribution from terrestrial biosphere exchange. This analysis, along with other recent work [Levin et al., 2003; Turnbull et al., 2006], implies that a comprehensive survey of Δ14C would serve as a strong constraint on vertical transport and mixing of fossil fuel plumes in mesoscale and global atmospheric models. Important next steps include extending this analysis to Europe, Asia, and South America, and to combine these measurements with aircraft data and higher resolution models to examine inflow and outflow patterns of air over North America.

[24] Over the next few decades, fossil emissions are expected to increase and as a consequence, the regional gradients of Δ14C shown in Figure 1 are likely to strengthen. Simultaneously, the rate of decline of atmospheric Δ14C is expected to remain about the same as 14C uptake by the oceans slows [Caldeira et al., 1998]. Combined, these two effects will make it increasingly critical for ecosystem ecologists to quantify local atmospheric Δ14C in studies that use radiocarbon as a tracer of rapidly exchanging pools.

Acknowledgments

[25] We gratefully acknowledge support from NSF EAR-0402062 and NASA NNG05GD126. We thank the following people for collecting samples: J. E. Anderson, D. Baldocchi, J. C. Beckwith, T. Berggren, J. Chanton, and M. Coakely, G. J. Collatz, M. Conte, P. S. Curtis, K. Dutta, J. Ehleringer, J. Fessenden, L. Flanagan, N. Goulden, J. Harden, S. Hobbie, A. Hoffman, D. Hollinger, R. A. Houghton, J. Hughes Martiny, P. Kasibhatla, J. Y. King, C. T. Lai, D. LeBauer, H. Liu, D. H. Loyd Jr., Y. Luo, L. Masiello, J. E. Munger, J. W. Munger, D. Nowinski, J. Okeefe, T. Perez, A. Rocha, D. R. Sandquist, T. Schimelfenig, T. Schuur, C. Scott, C. Still, A. Trumbore, S. B. Verma, C. Vogel, G. Welp, and L. Ziolkowski. We thank G. dos Santos for advice on laboratory analysis, A. V. Rocha for assistance with fieldwork, S. M. Cheong for assistance with figure design, and J. Miller and S. Lehman for sharing CO2 and Δ14C data from Niwot Ridge.

Ancillary

Advertisement