E. WHITLEY, D. MUIR and W.M. WAITES.2000. The effect of Modified Atmosphere Packaging (MAP) on the growth of Listeria monocytogenes in mould ripened cheeses was studied at refrigeration temperatures (2–8·3 °C) over a storage period of 6 weeks. Control experiments in cling film with no atmospheric modification produced a lag time before growth of up to 1 week and rapid subsequent growth. MAP with a CO2 concentration of less than 20% allowed growth to occur but when O2 was incorporated; the lag time was reduced from 3 to 2 weeks and subsequent growth was also faster, producing an increase in cell numbers of 1·4 log cycles over the incubation period. N2–MAP in the absence of O2 increased the lag time to 3 weeks and slowed growth, while the inclusion of CO2 extended the lag to 3 weeks and slowed subsequent growth even more. In MAP with 80:10:10 (v/v/v) N2:CO2:O2, there was a lag period of 2–3 weeks before growth of L. monocytogenes occurred, while the total viable aerobic count (TVAC) decreased by 2–3 log cycles and the total Lactobacillus count showed little change. It was concluded that MAP was not suitable for preventing the growth of L. monocytogenes in such cheeses.
During the period 1987–1989, there was a significant increase in the numbers of cases of food-borne illness attributed to the micro-organism Listeria monocytogenes ( Newton et al. 1993 ), with a variety of foods identified as sources of infection and with soft cheeses, e.g. Mexican soft cheese ( Linnan et al. 1988 ) and Vacherin Mont D’Or ( Bille 1990), being implicated in several outbreaks. Listeria monocytogenes has also been implicated in outbreaks of human listeriosis from coleslaw ( Schlech et al. 1983 ), prepared salads ( Gellin & Broome 1989) and paté ( Morris & Ribeiro 1989). Of foods tested by the Public Health Laboratory Service (PHLS), some samples of soft cheeses and paté yielded in excess of 10 000 cells g−1 ( Committee on the Microbiological Safety of Food 1990). Subsequently, the number of reported cases in the UK has declined from about 300 to about 100 cases per year. However, the organism continues to be a significant problem and in 1992, for example, there was a major outbreak in France associated with pork tongue en gelée in which there were 279 cases reported and 63 deaths ( Goulet et al. 1993 ).
Changes to the permitted storage temperatures for cheese as a result of the UK Food Safety (Temperature Control) Regulations 1995 (HMSO) mean that storage temperatures which do not inhibit growth of L. monocytogenes may be used. These regulations state that appropriate foods must be stored at a temperature of less than 8 °C or greater than 63 °C. However, certain groups of food are exempt from the regulations; “food which must be ripened or matured at room temperature” is one of these groups. Soft or mould ripened cheeses fall into this category, although once fully ripened or matured, industry must abide by the temperature controls stated. Listeria is a mesophilic genus with a growth range of −1 to 45 °C. This is a significant factor when considering its presence in foodstuffs, as most chilled produce will be stored at 1–5 °C and the Food Safety (General Food Hygiene) Regulations 1995 (HMSO) permit storage at temperatures up to 8 °C. However, the organism is not generally considered to be thermoduric so most pasteurization processes should render foods free from Listeria species ( Donnelly & Briggs 1986).
The use of modified atmosphere packaging (MAP) has increased with a wide range of foods. It has potential as a packaging system for mould ripened cheese, enabling continued growth of the mould during the shelf-life period. Furthermore, with the rapid increase in the sales of prepared sandwiches in recent years, coupled with the increasing use of modified atmospheres in packaging sandwiches for supermarkets, a combination of soft cheese and MAP is likely to be met more frequently in the future. However, the ability of L. monocytogenes to grow as a facultative anaerobe raises the question of its ability to grow under MAP.
The potential for growth of L. monocytogenes in mould ripened soft cheeses is well documented and Ennahar et al. (1994) demonstrated that soft and red smear cheeses (for example, Port Salut) were frequently contaminated with the organism at levels in excess of 105 cfu g−1. Red smear cheeses are characterized by a typical red flora growing on the rind and are commonly produced in France from both pasteurized and unpasteurized milks. In soft and mould ripened cheese, the final pH of the product (ranging from pH 5·3–7·5 at the surface and from 5·0 to 7·3 in the core) may not be inhibitory to L. monocytogenes. As L. monocytogenes has a pH range for growth of 4·1 to 9·6 with an optimum in the region of pH 6, it can be seen that there is a potential for growth in such cheeses.
This work examines whether MAP storage is appropriate for mould ripened cheeses with respect to L. monocytogenes.
MATERIALS and METHODS
A mature (7 weeks) whole Stilton cheese was cut horizontally into eight rings of approximately 5 cm depth. These rings were then cut into eight equal segments, with each portion including the same areas and proportion of areas to ensure reproducible results. The cheese was assessed for the presence of L. monocytogenes prior to commencing the trials, both on the coat and in the core of the cheese, in duplicate, using the standard method described. No L. monocytogenes was detected in 25 g of sample. The trials were conducted over a period of several months so portions of cheese were frozen in a domestic freezer (−20 °C) until needed.
In order to model post-processing contamination, an inoculum of L. monocytogenes serotype 4a (NCTC 5214 01 (ATCC 19114)) was applied evenly to the surface of the cheese by pipetting, drop-wise, the required amount of culture using a Volac micropipetter (John Poulten Ltd, Barking, UK). The inoculum level was changed during the initial experiments ( Table 1). The samples were refrigerated at 5 °C for 2 d to allow the culture to diffuse into the cheese before packaging. The level of inoculum was estimated by making serial dilutions in Oxoid maximum recovery diluent (CM733), subsequently plating on Listeria Oxford agar and incubation for 24 h at 30 °C. The count was checked after a further 24 h, but in no cases were there differences between 24 and 48 h.
Table 1. Increase in cfu of Listeria monocytogenes after 6 weeks of storage in modified atmosphere packaging
Packaging and storage
The inoculated samples were placed in nylon:polyethylene laminate bags of known gas transmission rates and packaged under selected modified atmospheres ( Table 1) using a Multivac A 300 packaging machine (Wolfertschwenden, Germany). Following MAP, the samples were incubated at refrigeration temperatures (2·1–7·2 °C) for the duration of the trials.
Samples were tested in duplicate using the standard Listeria testing method described above and assessed for growth on Listeria selective agar (Oxford formulation) after incubation at 30 °C for 2 d. Plates showing presumptive positive colonies were then examined further for catalase reaction, Gram reaction and motility. If positive reactions were recorded, the presence of Listeria species was assumed and the CAMP test (Oxoid Manual) was carried out to identify the species present.
pH and other measurements
The pH of the cheeses under test was measured by selecting random samples (10 g) of cheese, which were homogenized in a blender with 25 ml distilled water for 2 min, and the pH measured with a portable pH meter (pHep 3; Hanna Instruments, Mauritius), calibrated with pH 4 and 7 buffers.
In addition to L. monocytogenes, the total Lactobacillus and total viable count was also determined using de Man Rogosa Sharpe agar, CM 361 ( Bridson 1995) and milk agar, respectively, after incubation at 30 °C for 3 d. Lactobacillus colonies were confirmed by the catalase test.
Experimental design and trials
The experimental design was varied in experiments 1–3 to assess the difference between the atmospheres in order to select an appropriate incubation level. Two experiments used the same atmospheric conditions thought to represent potential commercial practice for mould ripened cheeses. As a result of these trials, an inoculum of 0·001 ml g−1 was selected for the main trials. The conditions used throughout this investigation are summarized in Table 1.
Trials 4–6 and 7–9 were run as two concurrent batches of trials and therefore, incubation temperatures for these two sets of three trials were the same.
Preliminary experiments 1–3 indicated that an atmosphere of 80:10:10 v/v/v nitrogen:carbon dioxide:oxygen, and an inoculation rate of log 1·5 cells g−1 and 0·001 ml g−1, were appropriate, giving reproducible results.
An increase in the count of L. monocytogenes over the inoculation rate was recorded during all trials with 80:10:10 v/v/v N2:CO2:O2 atmosphere (trials 4–9) ( Fig. 1). In these trials, an initial period of delay, during which the number of viable cells initially declined from the number inoculated, was followed by a period of growth, although some of this apparent growth may have represented recovery of the cells in the initial inoculum. Nevertheless, in all trials with Stilton cheese and an atmosphere of 80:10:10 v/v/v N2:CO2:O2, there was a significant increase in count of L. monocytogenes over the period of storage. The increase for all trials is summarized in Table 1 and ranged between 1 and 2 log cycles for the main trials 4–9.
When compared with the other gas mixtures used, i.e. 80:20 v/v N2:CO2 and 100% N2, and with the control with no modification of atmosphere, there was a greater increase in the number of viable cells when no modification of the atmosphere occurred. In those atmospheres where O2 was included, the increase in viable counts was significantly higher than in the atmospheres deficient in O2.
The general trend over the trials was for the total viable (aerobic) count to decline over the incubation period ( Fig. 2). The Lactobacillus count also showed an overall decrease in numbers ( Fig. 3), but it is interesting that it increased in all trials up to week 4 and then gradually declined. Given the ability of members of the genus to grow under conditions of reduced oxygen tension, initially there would be sufficient O2 for growth. However, other aerobic micro-organisms, such as Penicillium roquefortii, would act as competitors for the O2 and result in the decline in count observed later in the storage period. Anti-microbial agents may also have been present and may have acted as growth inhibitors, or may have produced the cell death observed. All trials showed a very similar pattern, despite the fact that lactobacilli are not included in the starter bacteria of Stilton cheese.
During the trials, the pH values ( Fig. 4) varied in a similar, though inverse, pattern to the Lactobacillus count. The increase in the Lactobacillus count may be linked to this reduction in pH, with the growth of members of the genus resulting in decreased pH due to the end products of the lactose fermentation. The pH values observed during the first set of trials (4–6) were higher than those of the second set, which may be due to the effect of freezing the cheese used in trials 7–9.
The pH levels observed within the cheese were well within the growth range of L. monocytogenes and it was expected that there would be no effect on growth. This was reflected by an analysis of variance, which demonstrated no significant relationship between the pHs observed and the growth of L. monocytogenes (P= 0·23). With respect to the total viable count, the effect of pH was significant (F= 26·1 and P= <0·001) and an even stronger effect between the change in pH and the total Lactobacillus count (F= 27·74 and P= <0·0001) was noted.
During the preliminary trials, L. monocytogenes was sufficiently versatile in its metabolism to grow under conditions of modified atmosphere. An increase in the concentration of CO2 to 20% inhibited growth to a greater extent than a simple reduction in the O2 content of the package. However, the aim of this work was not to establish an atmosphere that would totally prevent growth, but to determine the ability of the species to grow under MAP. Studies by Hudson et al. (1994) , Bell et al. (1995) and Avery et al. (1995) on L. monocytogenes in sliced roast beef, smoked blue cod and raw beef, respectively, centred on the inhibitory effects of CO2. However, these studies produced differing results; Hudson et al. (1994) reported that an atmosphere of saturated CO2 was not inhibitory to growth, while both the other groups found that a 100% CO2 atmosphere was inhibitory.
In atmospheres containing CO2, the numbers of L. monocytogenes after 3 weeks of incubation reached a level at which they remained throughout the rest of the trial. In the atmosphere containing 100% N2, the numbers appeared to be increasing at the end of the trial. This implied that growth was affected to some extent by the addition of CO2, and was consistent with the observations reported by Church & Parsons (1995) that the inhibitory effect of CO2 on bacteria increases linearly up to 50–60% v/v CO2.
Farber (1991) showed that the inhibitory action of CO2 in susceptible species resulted in an increase in the duration of the lag phase and a reduction in growth rate during the logarithmic phase. In the current study, the lag phase was unaffected by the presence of the gas when comparing the 80:20 v/v and 100 (N2:CO2:O2) atmospheres. Thus, the main influence of CO2 is in reducing the growth rate during the logarithmic phase. However, when the atmosphere was not modified, the lag phase was much reduced. This implies that when the concentration of CO2 is as low as 10% (or less), the presence of O2 has more effect on the length of the lag phase than does the CO2. Comparing these results with those of the control samples, it is significant that the lag phase was between 2 and 3 weeks longer in the MAP cheeses.
Listeria monocytogenes occurring in cheese as a result of environmental contamination may be at greater risk of shock when subjected to storage at cold temperatures, low pH and/or MAP. Stress responses appear to be universal and have been detected in all organisms examined. In addition to the well studied heat stress response, cold and acid shock, salt stress, starvation and O2 limitation responses have been demonstrated in bacteria. Such responses make cells more resistant to the stress and there is some overlap between the different responses. For example, in Bacillus subtilis ( Völker et al. 1994 ), some stress response proteins are produced as a result of heat shock, salt stress, oxidative stress and O2 limitation, while others are produced only in response to heat stress. The production of such response proteins may be important in the ability of L. monocytogenes to survive and grow in Blue Stilton cheese.
This study demonstrates (i) that film wrapping is insufficient to control growth of L. monocytogenes in Blue Stilton cheese and (ii) that MAP, whether using atmospheres containing O2 or not, does not control growth in such cheese. It also demonstrates that an atmosphere of 80:10:10 v/v/v N2:CO2:O2 is not suitable where L. monocytogenes may be present.
The decline in TVC during storage was expected as the count is of aerobic micro-organisms and the atmosphere used had a reduced O2 content. With aerobic metabolism of bacteria and the blue mould, P. roquefortii, the ratio of CO2 to O2 could be expected to increase over time, resulting in greater inhibition of the aerobic micro-organisms. The presence of CO2 in the packaging atmosphere and the presence of antimicrobial substances produced by the starter organisms could also be expected to inhibit the growth of aerobic species.
Non-starter lactic acid bacteria (NSLAB), to which the lactobacilli belong, make up a large proportion of most cheeses, reaching levels of 107−109 g−1 ( Fox 1993). The decline in the Lactobacillus count was not anticipated because of their ability to respire anaerobically or aerobically, but a relationship between their growth and the pH values was demonstrated.
Modified atmospheres have not, as yet, been used commercially for the packaging of mould ripened cheeses. Such atmospheres are currently used for packaging of goods, including sandwiches, containing Brie, Camembert and other similar cheeses and chilled recipe dishes. However, the storage time of these sandwiches is relatively short (of the order of day of manufacture + 2 d), although temperature abuse may be significant. In fact, in a study evaluating the microbiological quality of various MAP sandwiches, L. monocytogenes was present in five of 58 samples ( Farber et al. 1990 ). In the current study, the potential for growth has been demonstrated and it is clear that the utmost care must be taken to avoid contamination with the organism and to control other growth parameters carefully. This must be considered during risk analysis of new products. However, the results of this study indicate that even in conditions of controlled temperature and modified atmosphere, L. monocytogenes may eventually grow to high levels.
It is apparent from this study that once CO2 levels are reduced to 10%, and with the incorporation of O2 into the pack, MAP does not inhibit the growth of L. monocytogenes at refrigeration temperatures. In conclusion, it is probable that the use of MAP and controlled atmosphere packaging is likely to increase in the future, and that the range of foods packaged using such a system will expand. Further studies on the type of atmospheres suitable for the inhibition of L. monocytogenes should be carried out in order to assess the suitability of this packaging system for high risk foods.
The authors acknowledge J. Slack for practical assistance during the trials. Long Clawson Dairy is thanked for the Stilton cheese used in the trials.