Health and economic consequences of HCV lookback

Authors

  • Arturo Pereira

    1. From the Service of Hemotherapy and Hemostasis and the Blood Bank, Hospital Cl’nic; and Augusto Pi i Sunyer Memorial Institute for Biomedical Research, Barcelona, Spain.
    Search for more papers by this author

  • Supported in part by Grant FIS 99/0464 from the Ministry of Health of the Government of Spain and Grant ACES 99-33/3 from the Autonomous Government of Catalonia.

Address reprint requests to: Arturo Pereira, MD, PhD, Service of Hemotherapy, Hospital Cl’nic, Villarroel 170, 08036 Barcelona, Spain; e-mail: apereira@clinic.ub.es.

Abstract

BACKGROUND: Several countries have conducted or are considering campaigns of lookback on blood recipients who may have acquired posttransfusion HCV (PT-HCV) before the implementation of anti-HCV screening. There is, however, no estimation of the health and economic consequences of the medical interventions triggered by the lookback.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS: This study used a Monte Carlo simulation of a Markov model representing the natural history of PT-HCV. Unadjusted and quality-adjusted life expectancy and lifetime medical costs were calculated for a cohort of patients in whom PT-HCV is diagnosed through the lookback, and these values were compared with those calculated for a similar cohort on whom lookback is not performed.

RESULTS: The model predicts that 47 percent of people who received transfusions of HCV-infective blood 10 years ago are still alive, carry the infection, and have not yet progressed to end-stage liver failure. In this population, forthcoming complications of PT-HCV will reduce the remaining life expectancy by 1.75 years per patient. Medical interventions triggered by the diagnosis of PT-HCV would salvage 0.123 years of life expectancy, at a net cost of $921 per newly diagnosed patient. The health and economic impact of diagnosing a new case of PT-HCV through lookback was sensitive to the patient's age, the efficacy of antiviral therapies, the time elapsed from transfusion to lookback, and the future inflation of costs of treating end-stage liver disease. Under some plausible assumptions, the intervention could result in net financial savings for the health care system, but it may also produce a net health loss for the majority of patients who will be said to be HCV-positive without being offered an effective therapy.

CONCLUSION: Diagnosis of PT-HCV through HCV lookback has a potential both to increase patients' life expectancy and to reduce health care costs. However, more effective antiviral therapies and a better knowledge of factors predicting the progression of PT-HCV are needed to attain those goals. Meanwhile, care should be taken to avoid pursuing a health gain for a minority that might result in a health loss for the majority.

Ancillary