The Cost of Diversity: The Diversification Discount and Inefficient Investment

Authors

  • Raghuram Rajan,

  • Henri Servaes,

  • Luigi Zingales

    Search for more papers by this author
    • Rajan is from the University of Chicago, Servaes is from the London Business School and University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, and Zingales is from the University of Chicago. Rajan and Zingales acknowledge financial support from the Center for Research on Security Prices at the University of Chicago. Servaes acknowledges financial support from the O'Herron and McColl faculty fellowships, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. Comments from Sugato Bhattacharya, Judy Chevalier, Glenn Ellison, Milton Harris, Steven Kaplan, Owen Lamont, Colin Mayer, Todd Milbourn, Vikram Nanda, Jay Ritter, René Stulz, Robert Vishny, Ralph Walkling, Wanda Wallace, two anonymous referees, and especially Mitchell Petersen are gratefully acknowledged. Comments from participants in seminars at AT Kearney (London), the University of Chicago, Cornell University, the University of Georgia, the University of Florida, the University of Illinois, the London School of Economics, New York University, Northwestern University, Ohio State University, the College of William & Mary, Vanderbilt University, and Yale University were useful.

Abstract

We model the distortions that internal power struggles can generate in the allocation of resources between divisions of a diversified firm. The model predicts that if divisions are similar in the level of their resources and opportunities, funds will be transferred from divisions with poor opportunities to divisions with good opportunities. When diversity in resources and opportunities increases, however, resources can flow toward the most inefficient division, leading to more inefficient investment and less valuable firms. We test these predictions on a panel of diversified U.S. firms during the period from 1980 to 1993 and find evidence consistent with them.

Ancillary