Managing ‘minor’ disorders: pathways to a hospital accident and emergency department



Empirical research examining the decision-making processes involved in the management of problematic signs and symptoms has either focused on a specific condition or examined more general decision rules. The problem with these approaches is the difficulty in identifying which elements are specific to certain complaints and which are more generally applicable. The study presented here shows a comparison of the processes involved in the decision to seek medical care for sufferers with different types of complaint. This comparison identified various different elements in the decision-making processes which were shown to have considerable implications for their pattern of help-seeking behaviour and their pathways to the hospital accident and emergency department.


  • 1

    D. Locker, Symptoms and Illness, London: Tavistock, 1981, p. 7.

  • 2

    H. Fabrega, ‘Towards a model of illness behaviour’, Medical Care, XI, 6 (1973), pp. 472–85.

  • 3

    R. Dingwall, Aspects of Illness. London: Martin Robertson, 1976, p. 100.

  • 4

    M, Blaxter, ‘Concepts of causality: lay and medical models’, in Osborne et al., Social Aspects, Attitudes, Communication, Care and Training. London: Academic Press, 1980, pp. 154–61. D. Robinson, The Process of Becoming Ill. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1971, p. 27.

  • 5

    . B. Cowie, ‘The cardiac patient's perceptions of a heart attack’, Soc. Sci. and Med., 10 (1976), pp. 8796.

  • 6

    . C.G. Helman, ‘Feed a cold, starve a fever - folk models of infection in an English suburban community and their relation to medical treatment’, Culture, Medicine and Psychiatry, 2 (1978), pp. 10737. M. Calnan and B. Johnson. Understanding Non-compliance with Cancer Education Campaigns. UICC Technical Report Series on Public Education about Cancer, Geneva, 1983 (in press).

  • 7

    D. Locker, Symptoms and Illness. London: Tavistock, 1981, p. 133.

  • 8

    . W.C. Stratmann and R. Ulmann, ‘A study of consumer attitudes about healthcare - the role of the emergency ward’, Medical Care, 13 (1975), pp. 1220.

  • 9

    W. Morgan et al., ‘Casual attenders: a socio-medical study of patients attending A and E departments in Newcastle’, Hospital and Health Services Review (1974), pp. 189–94.

  • 10

    . M. Cainan, ‘The hospital Accident and Emergency department: what is its role?’, Journal of Social Policy, 11, 4 (October, 1982), pp. 483503.

  • 11

    . M. Kleiman, ‘Emergency room use and access to alternative sources of care’, Sociology of Health and Illness, 1, 3 (1979), pp. 31830.

  • 12

    . J. Roth, ‘Utilization of the hospital emergency department’, J. of Health and Social Behaviour, 12 (1971), pp. 31220.

  • 13

    M. Calnan, ‘Coping with Accidents and Emergencies: a Study of how the Community uses the Hospital Accident and Emergency Department'. Unpublished PhD thesis, University of Kent at Canterbury, 1981, p. 128.

  • 14

    National Provincial Hospitals Trust, Casualty Departments and their Setting. Oxford University Press, 1960, p. 60.

  • 15

    . E.H. Albert, ‘Appealing for treatment: a cognitive analysis’, Soc. Sci. and Med., 14A (1980), pp. 24351.

  • 16

    D. Locker, Symptoms and Illness, London: Tavistock, 1981, p. 154.

  • 17

    . M. Calnan, ‘Social networks and help-seeking behaviour’, Soc. Sci. and Med., 17, 1 (1983), pp. 258.

  • 18

    . A. Alonzo, ‘Everyday illness behaviour: a situational approach to health status deviations’, Soc. Sci. and Med., 13A (1979), pp. 397404.

  • 19

    I. Russell and A. Holohan. Newcastle Accident Survey: Report on Phases I and III, the Choice of Care for Minor Trauma. Medical Care Research Unit, University of Newcastle, 1974.

  • 20

    In the study as a whole 22 per cent of the patients (N = 628) reported an attempt to contact a general practitioner. 41 per cent of patients with suspected fractures attempted to contact their general practitioner. See M. Calnan, E. Abson and J. Butler, Path ways to the Hospital Accident and Emergency Dept. Health Services Research Unit Report, University of Kent, 1979, p. 150.

  • 21

    R. Dingwall, Aspects of Illness. London: Martin Robertson, 1976, p. 103.

  • 22

    M.J. Bloor, ‘On the Routinised Nature of Work in People-Processing Agencies: the Case of Adeno-Tonsillectomy Assessments in ENT Out-Patient Clinics’ in A. Davis (ed.), Relationships between Doctors and Patients. Farnborough: Gower, 1978, pp. 29–47.

  • 23

    M. Calnan, E. Abson, J.R. Butler, ‘In case of emergency?’, Health and Social Service Journal (20 May 1982), pp. 615–17.

  • 24

    . J. Roth, ‘Utilization of the hospital emergency department’, Journal of Health and Social Behaviour, 12 (1971), pp. 31220.