S.C., N.W., J.C. and J.V. acknowledge the support of the Research Foundation Flanders (FWO-Vlaanderen) and the UHasselt Methusalemproject 08M03VGRJ for financial support. J.J. and H.V. are funded by the Institute for the Promotion of Innovation through Science and Technology in Flanders (IWT-Vlaanderen).
Cultivable bacterial strains associated with field-grown Brassica napus L. (soil, rhizosphere and roots) from a trace elements (Cd, Zn and Pb) contaminated field and a non-contaminated control field were characterized genotypically and phenotypically. Correspondence analysis of the genotypic data revealed a correlation between soil and rhizosphere communities isolated from the same field, indicating that local conditions play a more important role in influencing the composition of (rhizosphere) soil bacterial communities than root exudates. In contrast, endophytic communities of roots showed a correlation between fields, suggesting that plants on the two fields contain similar obligate endophytes derived from a common seed endophytic community and/or can select bacteria from the rhizosphere. The latter seemed not very likely since, despite the presence of several potential endophytic taxa in the rhizosphere, no significant correlation was found between root and rhizosphere communities. The majority of Cd/Zn tolerant strains capable of phosphorus solubilization, nitrogen fixation, indole-3-acetic acid production and showing 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylate deaminase capacity were found in the rhizosphere and roots of plants growing on the contaminated field.
In our industrialized world, toxic trace elements (TEs) pose a serious concern. Due to atmospheric deposition from four zinc ore smelters in the Dutch-Belgian border region, soils in the Campine region got enriched with cadmium (Cd), zinc (Zn) and lead (Pb) (Sonke et al., 2002). Close to the zinc smelters soils contain 3–10 mg Cd per kg dry soil, while at 30 km, background concentrations below 0.5 mg Cd per kg dry soil are found (Koopmans et al., 2008). A large portion of this diffusely contaminated region is in agricultural use (Ruttens et al., 2010; Witters et al., 2011). Increased Cd levels in fodder plants grown on these soils, can lead to increased Cd levels in cattle and hence in the human food chain (Römkens et al., 2007). Since Cd is potentially cytotoxic, mutagenic and carcinogenic, farmers are encouraged to remediate their land to ultimately prevent bioaccumulation of toxic TEs in food products (Lim and Schoenung, 2010).
An often suggested remediation strategy for vast areas with diffuse TE contamination is the use of plants and their associated microorganisms to extract TEs from soils and accumulate them in harvestable plant parts (phytoextraction) (Vangronsveld et al., 2009). However, low TE availability, uptake, translocation, accumulation and tolerance of plants are still limiting full scale application of phytoextraction (Vangronsveld et al., 2009; Weyens et al., 2009a). To improve the efficiency of phytoextraction, plant-associated microorganisms with plant growth promoting (PGP) properties and a natural capacity to cope with TEs could be exploited (Weyens et al., 2009b). PGP bacteria can stimulate root development (Weyens et al., 2011) resulting in an enhanced soil volume explored by roots. Most of the published reviews on PGP bacteria focus on their direct PGP effects in soil (Glick, 2010), rhizosphere (Zhuang et al., 2007; Khan et al., 2009; Ma et al., 2011) and plant (Rajkumar et al., 2009; Ma et al., 2011). Direct PGP effects can be achieved by the production of phytohormones, 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylate (ACC) deaminase and siderophores, by nitrogen fixation and phosphates solubilization. Plant-associated bacteria that produce siderophores and/or organic acids can also enhance TE availability in soils and by consequence their uptake by plants (Li and Wong, 2010; Rajkumar et al., 2010). To assist their host plants to cope with these increased amounts of TEs, endophytic bacteria equipped with a TE sequestration system are of special interest since they can reduce phytotoxicity and increase TE translocation to aerial plant parts (Lodewyckx et al., 2001; Sessitsch and Puschenreiter, 2008). Exploiting these bacterial skills, plants with higher biomass and increased tolerance to TEs can be obtained, eventually resulting in a more efficient phytoextraction.
We investigate Brassica napus L. (rapeseed) as a candidate phytoextraction crop because it combines high biomass production with a good tolerance to Cd and Zn (Marchiol et al., 2004). At the same time it is a valorizable oil producing crop (Vangronsveld et al., 2009), mainly used in food applications and biofuel production (Grispen et al., 2006). Combining phytoextraction and biofuel production sounds economically attractive, especially since oil prices are increasing and environmental standards are high (Stephenson et al., 2008). Moreover, oil and seed meal with acceptable Cd and Zn concentrations could be used to enrich fodder with carbohydrates, proteins and phytosterols (Gül and Şeker, 2006; Iqbal et al., 2008). Combining the phytoextraction and economic potentials of B. napus could become the decisive factor for a successful remediation in diffusely contaminated areas, like the Campine region, especially when rapeseed-associated bacteria could enhance Cd phytoextraction efficiency.
Since the natural habitat is considered as an interesting model for the evolution of TE tolerant PGP microorganisms (Ma et al., 2009), we characterized the cultivable bacterial communities associated with bulk soil, rhizosphere soil and roots of B. napus grown on a Cd, Zn and Pb-contaminated field in Lommel [Belgium; trace element field (TE-F)] and a non-contaminated field in Alken [Belgium; control field (CO-F)]. The main objectives of this study were to extend our knowledge on the poorly known bacterial communities associated with B. napus and to identify PGP, Cd tolerant and Cd solubilizing bacteria which might increase biomass production and Cd uptake by rapeseed growing under the unfavourable environmental conditions occurring on contaminated fields.
Isolation of B. napus-associated bacteria
Bacteria were isolated from bulk soil, rhizosphere soil and roots of B. napus, grown on an uncontaminated control field (CO-F) and a contaminated field (TE-F) (Table 1).
Table 1. Mean total numbers of colony-forming units (cfu) per gram fresh weight of the compartments (COMPT) bulk soil (BS), rhizosphere soil (RS) and B. napus root tissue (R) isolated on the control field (CO-F) and the contaminated field (TE-F)
cfu g−1 fresh weight
Values are mean ± standard error of three biological independent replicates. Numbers of different bacterial genera are marked between parentheses. Letters between parentheses in the COMPT column refer to statistical significances in cfu g−1 fresh weight (P-value < 0.10).
99.7 × 105 ± 51.8 × 105 (6)
23.7 × 108 ± 21.2 × 108 (17)
10.4 × 105 ± 23.4 × 104 (15)
20.5 × 106 ± 22.4 × 105 (20)
78.1 × 107 ± 30.8 × 107 (25)
22.4 × 105 ± 19.8 × 105 (18)
For both fields, the number of cultivable strains recovered from the bulk soil and roots were significantly lower compared with the rhizosphere soil. Significantly more cultivable strains were isolated from the bulk soil compared with the roots at the contaminated field. Considering compartments, no differences in the amount of isolated strains between fields were observed. At both fields, the number of different bacterial genera was higher in the rhizosphere soil than in bulk soil and root.
After isolation and purification, five purified replicates of all morphologically different bacterial strains isolated from bulk soil, rhizosphere soil and roots of B. napus were characterized by amplified 16S rDNA restriction analysis (ARDRA) using the restriction enzyme HpyCH4IV. One representative member of all strains with identical fingerprints was sequenced for identification by means of Sequence Match at the Ribosomal Database Project II. All (except ChryseobacteriumDQ337589) strains have a sequence match score higher than 0.900, which indicates a confident identification to the genus level (Appendix S1). Also the neighbour-joining tree clustered strains belonging to the same genus together, confirming the results of the 16S rRNA genes-based identification procedure (Appendix S2). The identification resulted in 37 different bacterial genera recovered from the contaminated field and 29 from the control field (Fig. 1).
Eighteen of the identified genera were found at both fields. To visualize the diversity and abundance of cultivable B. napus-associated bacteria, pie diagrams were prepared (Fig. 2). Each colour (number) represents a bacterial genus; subdivided colours represent genera with different accession numbers. The relative abundance of each genus was expressed as a percentage of the total number of cultivable isolates per gram fresh weight bulk soil, rhizosphere soil and roots (Table 1).
The cultivable soil bacteria at the control field were dominated by the genera Micromonospora (50%), Bacillus (38.7%) and Leifsonia (5.8%) and at the contaminated field by Arthrobacter (26.9%), Leifsonia (15.7%), Staphylococcus (10.0%), Burkholderia (7.4%), Variovorax (6.4%) and Rhodopseudomonas (5.6%). The major part of the cultivable rhizosphere bacteria at the control field consisted of Bacillus (43.2%), Pseudomonas (19.3%), Variovorax (13.7%) and Staphylococcus (8.3%) and at the contaminated field of Leifsonia (29.3%), Staphylococcus (22.7%), Plantibacter (12.3%), Serratia (6.9%) and Microbacterium (6.0%). Variovorax (34.5%), Pseudomonas (29.4%), Bacillus (12.4%), Caulobacter (8.6%) and Pantoea (6.5%) dominated the cultivable root endophytes at the control field, while at the contaminated field it were Pseudomonas (33.0%), Rhizobium (16.1%), Caulobacter (14.9%), Pedobacter (14.7%) and Variovorax (7.8%) (Fig. 2).
Bacterial strains exclusively occurring in one of the investigated compartments at the control respectively the contaminated field are underlined in Fig. 1. From the strains shown in the intersection (= occurring at both fields) of Fig. 1C, only Mycobacterium (FJ719354), Pedobacter (GU385862), Pseudomonas (FN377713) and Variovorax (GQ861460) were exclusively found in the roots. Pantoea (EU598802), Plantibacter (AM396918) and Rhizobium (DQ337581) were isolated from roots at both fields; at the control field they were not found in bulk neither rhizosphere soil, like at the contaminated field Caulobacter (DQ337549), Labrys (DQ337554) and Pseudomonas (FJ772042) did not occur in other compartments. Other root endophytes were also found in bulk and/or rhizosphere soil [CO-F: Bacillus (AB188212), Bacillus (FJ263042); TE-F: Leifsonia (AB278552), Plantibacter (AM396918), Staphylococcus (GQ222398)]. Bacterial strains restricted to the bulk and rhizosphere soil at the control field were Bacillus (GU321095) and Leifsonia (AB278552) and at the contaminated field Agrobacterium (GQ428123), Arthrobacter (AB288059), Bacillus (AB188212), Brevundimonas (EF088675), Methylobacterium (AB220076) and Variovorax (EF419341).
Based on the correspondence analysis (CA) of these data (Fig. 3), we can conclude that the bacterial communities isolated from bulk and rhizosphere soil at both fields are correlated within field [correlation coefficients: 0.48 (TE-F) and 0.50 (CO-F)]. Also root bacterial communities at both fields are correlated (correlation coefficient: 0.59).
All purified isolates were screened for their TE tolerance (Table 2A). Percentages of strains from the rhizosphere and from the roots tolerant to 0.8 mM Cd were similar at both fields. At the contaminated field, higher percentages of bulk soil bacteria were tolerant to 0.8 and 1.6 mM Cd, also the rhizosphere soil and the roots contained much higher percentages of strains tolerant to 1.6 mM Cd compared with the control field. The highest percentages of Cd tolerant strains at the contaminated field were found in the roots, while at the control field highest Cd tolerance was occurring in the rhizosphere and roots. Contaminated bulk and rhizosphere soil contained higher percentages of Zn tolerant strains for all tested Zn concentrations (0.6, 1.0 and 2.5 mM Zn). Roots from both fields harboured similar percentages of 0.6 mM Zn tolerant bacteria, while percentages of root strains tolerant to 1.0 and 2.5 mM Zn were higher at the contaminated field. The highest percentages of Zn tolerant strains at the contaminated field were found in the rhizosphere soil, while at the control field this was in the roots. The two-way analysis of variance (anova) test indicated a significant field effect especially when considering tolerance to the highest Cd and Zn concentrations (P-values: 0.03 and 0.00007 respectively).
Table 2. Phenotypic characterization of all purified bulk soil, rhizosphere soil and B. napus root isolates collected at the control field (BS-CO, RS-CO and R-CO respectively) and the contaminated field (BS-TE, RS-TE and R-TE respectively)
Data are shown as relative abundances, expressed in percentages, of the total number of cultivable bacterial isolates per gram fresh weight bulk soil (BS), rhizosphere soil (RS) and roots (R) at both fields which were tolerant to different concentrations of Cd (0.8 and 1.6 mM) and Zn (0.6, 1.0 and 2.5 mM) (A); and were capable of phosphorus solubilization (P sol), nitrogen fixation (N2 fix) and the production of siderophores (SID), organic acids (OA), ACC deaminase (ACC), indole-3-acetic acid (IAA) and acetoin (B). Values are mean ± standard error of three biological independent replicates.
Cd (0.8 mM)
1.8 ± 1.8
10.8 ± 5.9
14.5 ± 7.4
13.1 ± 6.6
28.1 ± 11.7
22.7 ± 3.2
Cd (1.6 mM)
1.8 ± 1.8
9.2 ± 5.8
3.0 ± 3.0
12.5 ± 6.4
2.2 ± 2.0
14.7 ± 6.3
Zn (0.6 mM)
25.8 ± 25.8
95.3 ± 2.0
43.1 ± 28.5
99.2 ± 0.8
66.8 ± 14.4
52.2 ± 17.5
Zn (1.0 mM)
10.5 ± 10.5
61.0 ± 6.2
2.4 ± 1.7
71.5 ± 13.4
17.6 ± 7.7
32.8 ± 12.0
Zn (2.5 mM)
8.8 ± 8.8
58.0 ± 5.8
1.1 ± 0.6
65.5 ± 10.2
16.7 ± 8.0
32.6 ± 11.8
21.2 ± 21.2
52.6 ± 8.0
79.1 ± 10.6
26.3 ± 7.3
80.8 ± 6.1
41.5 ± 26.8
6.0 ± 6.0
4.9 ± 2.9
39.8 ± 29.9
23.6 ± 12.0
10.6 ± 8.1
19.3 ± 15.5
0.0 ± 0.0
39.2 ± 8.3
18.3 ± 12.9
37.1 ± 12.9
33.1 ± 13.1
37.3 ± 22.3
26.8 ± 26.8
32.9 ± 2.5
31.7 ± 20.7
36.4 ± 6.9
36.4 ± 12.3
61.5 ± 12.6
17.3 ± 17.3
2.8 ± 1.6
49.2 ± 25.3
8.6 ± 8.6
17.0 ± 5.3
2.5 ± 2.5
11.6 ± 11.6
44.3 ± 3.2
19.6 ± 10.8
58.1 ± 5.2
50.1 ± 3.4
49.2 ± 24.5
2.0 ± 2.0
3.7 ± 2.3
6.2 ± 6.1
30.4 ± 9.0
8.7 ± 3.2
10.8 ± 7.8
All strains were screened for their potential PGP characteristics (Table 2B). The percentage of siderophore producing strains in the bulk soil was more than two times higher at the contaminated field, while in the rhizosphere and roots more siderophore producing strains were present at the control field. At both fields similar low percentages of organic acid producing strains were isolated from the bulk soil, while rhizosphere soil and root samples from the control field contained higher respectively lower percentages of these bacteria compared with the contaminated field. All compartments at the contaminated field contained higher percentages of ACC deaminase producing strains as compared with the control field. Moreover similar percentages were found in all compartments at the contaminated field while percentages increased from bulk soil to the root at the control field. Phosphorus solubilization capacity showed a similar distribution pattern. The relative abundance of indole-3-acetic acid (IAA) producing strains was similar in the bulk and rhizosphere soil from both fields and in the control roots, while proportionally twice as much IAA producing strains were isolated from roots at the contaminated field. The percentages of acetoin producing bacterial strains at the control field were higher in all studied compartments; at the contaminated field this was the case for nitrogen fixating strains.
The highest percentages of strains able of solubilizing phosphorus, fixating nitrogen and producing siderophores, ACC deaminase and IAA at the control field were found in the roots, while proportionally the most organic acid and acetoin producing strains were detected in the rhizosphere soil. At the contaminated field, percentages of siderophore and ACC deaminase producing strains were highest in the bulk soil, while percentages of phosphorus solubilizing, nitrogen fixating and organic acid/acetoin producing strains were proportionally highest in the rhizosphere soil. The most IAA producing strains at the contaminated field were found inside the roots. The two-way anova test indicated a significant field effect considering phosphorus solubilization, nitrogen fixation and siderophore and acetoin production (P-values: 0.05, 0.06, 0.08 and 0.05 respectively).
TE concentrations in soils and plants
Total TE concentrations were determined in bulk soil and plant parts (root, stem, leaf and seed) (Table 3). In addition, plant available TE concentrations in bulk soil were estimated using a Ca(NO3)2 selective extraction.
Table 3. Soil and plant trace element (TE) concentrations; Ca(NO3)2-extractable (extr) essential (Zn, Cu, Fe) and non-essential (Cd, Pb) TE concentrations [mg (kg dry weight)−1] measured in bulk soil and total essential and non-essential TE concentrations [mg (kg dry weight)−1] in bulk soil and B. napus plants (root, stem, leaf and seed) from the control field (CO-F) and the contaminated field (TE-F)
Bulk soil (extr)
Bulk soil (total)
Values are mean ± standard error of three biological independent replicates. Trace element concentrations in soil and plant compartments were compared between fields (significance levels: * P < 0.05; ** P < 0.01; *** P < 0.001; **** P < 0.0001). Trace element contents which were too high or too low to be detected are indicated by ‘saturated’ (sat) and ‘not detected’ (nd) respectively.
Amounts of both total and Ca(NO3)2-extractable Cd, Zn and Pb in the bulk soil were significantly higher at the contaminated field as compared with the control field, like also the Cd and Zn concentrations measured in the roots, stems, leaves and seeds. Lead concentrations in plant parts were below detection limit while total and Ca(NO3)2-extractable Pb concentrations in the soil at the contaminated field were significantly higher than at the control field. Plants grown at the contaminated field contained significantly more Cd and Zn in their leaves compared with the roots and stems, their seeds accumulated acceptable Cd concentrations (< 1.14 mg Cd kg−1) according to the European standards for animal feed (Appendix S3). At both fields, plants contained adequate tissue levels of Ca, K, Mg, Na and Zn (data not shown). The Cu and Fe concentrations in plant tissues were just below the prescribed levels for adequate growth but are not expected to be limiting. Total bulk soil Cu and Fe concentrations were significantly higher at the contaminated field whereas the Ca(NO3)2-extractable concentrations were similar at both fields. When plant parts were compared between fields, total Fe concentrations were significantly higher in roots from the control and seeds from the contaminated field.
Agricultural soils in the Campine region are diffusely contaminated with Cd, Zn and Pb (Table 3). Since the contamination is due to past atmospheric deposition of these TEs from Zn smelters it is concentrated in the upper soil layer (Sonke et al., 2002). Therefore, accumulating plant species developing their root system in this soil layer might be interesting candidates for phytoextraction in this region. An ideal plant for TE phytoextraction should produce high biomass and should take up and translocate to its shoots a significant part of the TEs of concern (Kärenlampi et al., 2000). Since the calculated time periods for phytoextraction of toxic TEs are long, it is necessary that the selected crop can be valorized (Vassilev et al., 2004; Vangronsveld et al., 2009; Meers et al., 2010).
Brassica napus, a high biomass oil delivering crop, has a good potential to meet most of these criteria. Indeed, roots of B. napus are abundantly developing in the upper soil layer (Marchiol et al., 2004). Moreover, rapeseed translocates assimilated TEs to its leaves at the end of the growing season (Table 3 and Appendix S3). In case rapeseed can be used as a crop for phytoextraction of toxic TEs, farmers can make profit out of the cultivation by valorizing the seeds (biofuel versus fodder) and other plant parts (biogas). Rapeseed oil can be utilized as alternative fuel whereas intact seeds can be used as animal fodder. Seeds of plants grown on the contaminated field contained acceptable Cd and Pb concentrations (< 1.14 mg Cd kg−1 and < 11.4 mg Pb kg−1) according to the European standards for animal feed, unlike the other plant parts harvested on the contaminated field (Table 3 and Grispen et al., 2006). Fermentation processes can be adopted to reduce the quantity of contaminated biomass while producing biogas (Van Ginneken et al., 2007).
However, the amounts of toxic TEs that can be extracted by B. napus are still much too low to allow significant reductions of these TE contents in the soil in realistic periods of time (Vangronsveld et al., 2009). To improve the applicability and efficiency of phytoextraction, plant-associated bacteria could be exploited to enhance biomass production and to increase TE availability, uptake, translocation and tolerance of plants (Weyens et al., 2009a,b). Therefore, we investigated the diversity of cultivable bacteria associated with B. napus from plants grown on a non-contaminated (control) and a contaminated field as well as the characteristics of the isolated bacterial communities that might contribute to improve biomass production and TE uptake and translocation. Approximately 500 morphologically different bacterial strains were isolated from bulk soil, rhizosphere soil and roots of B. napus at both fields and identified based on 16S rDNA sequencing (Figs 1 and 2).
The higher amount of cultivable bacteria in the rhizosphere than in bulk soil (Table 1) can be explained by the ‘rhizosphere effect’ (Rouatt et al., 1960). Growth and activity of soil microorganisms are mainly limited by organic carbon (Demoling et al., 2007). Poor decomposability of soil organic matter in contrast with easily decomposable root exudates results in higher microbial density/diversity in the rhizosphere (Soderberg and Bååth, 1998). The numbers of cultivable rhizosphere bacteria and root endophytes are in accordance with literature (Benizri et al., 2001; Hallmann, 2001); bacterial density/diversity decreased from the rhizosphere to the roots (Table 1 and Fisher et al., 1992). The rapeseed-associated bacterial populations that we characterized were dominated by Bacillus, Pseudomonas, Variovorax, Leifsonia, Micromonospora, Staphylococcus, Arthrobacter and Caulobacter (Fig. 2). Some of these genera were already reported in earlier studies on rapeseed-associated populations (see below), while others are mentioned for the first time in our study. This might be due to (i) differences in isolation protocols (Siciliano and Germida, 1999), growth media and identification procedures (Germida and Theoret, 1997; Kaiser et al., 2001) and (ii) the environmental growing conditions of the plants (Lemanceau et al., 1995; Song et al., 1999).
Germida and colleagues (1998) and Siciliano and Germida (1999) were the first to investigate bacterial communities associated with field-grown B. napus using fatty acid methyl ester (FAME) profiles, a tentative identification method (Haack et al., 1994). They concluded that the rhizosphere and root interior were colonized mainly by the genera Bacillus, Flavobacterium, Micrococcus, Rathayibacter, Pseudomonas, Variovorax and Arthrobacter. Larcher and colleagues (2008) isolated similar genera from the rhizosphere (Serratia, Stenotrophomonas, Microbacterium, Paenibacillus, Arthrobacter, Variovorax and Pseudomonas) and roots (Serratia, Pseudomonas, Stenotrophomonas and Microbacterium) of field-grown B. napus. Additionally, Kaiser and colleagues (2001) and Granér and colleagues (2003) demonstrated that greenhouse and field grown B. napus showed corresponding genera in the rhizosphere, root, stem and/or seed, including Agrobacterium, Paenibacillus, Bacillus, Pseudomonas, Chryseobacterium, Pantoea, Caulobacter, Variovorax, Stenotrophomonas, Arthrobacter, Microbacterium, Streptomyces and Staphylococcus.
Common bacterial genera identified during our research and not yet mentioned in earlier work on B. napus are Burkholderia, Labrys, Leifsonia, Lysinibacillus, Micromonospora, Mycobacterium, Pedobacter, Plantibacter, Rhizobium, Rhodopseudomonas and Sphingobacterium (Fig. 2). Many bacterial strains appeared in both soil compartments (Fig. 1) and based on the correspondence analysis of the genotypical information (Fig. 3), we conclude that at both fields the rhizosphere communities correlate well with the bulk soil communities. This observation can be explained by the fact that bacterial rhizosphere colonization is driven by the production of root exudates (Lugtenberg and Dekkers, 1999) to which soil microorganisms are chemo-attracted (Lugtenberg and Kamilova, 2009; Compant et al., 2010). Consequently, root exudates control rhizosphere populations like Grayston and colleagues (1998) postulated, but also field-specific soil factors play a significant role since rhizosphere communities at both fields were not identical. Accordingly, Lundberg and colleagues (2012) and Bulgarelli and colleagues (2012) reported that soil type defines the composition of bacterial rhizosphere and root communities of Arabidopsis thaliana plants.
A second remarkable observation was that endophytic root communities from both fields were similar (Fig. 3). Lundberg and colleagues (2012) as well as Bulgarelli and colleagues (2012) observed that the host plant determined to a limited extent the bacterial ribotype profiles in roots. We suggest that plants grown from the same seed stock at different fields possess similar obligate endophytes originating from their common seed endophytic community. This statement is based on the exclusive presence of several strains in the roots of plants grown at both fields including Mycobacterium (FJ719354), Pedobacter (GU385862), Pseudomonas (FN377713) and Variovorax (GQ861460) (Fig. 1). Other strains exclusively present in the roots at the control field respectively the contaminated field may also be considered as potential seed endophytes since we hypothesize that some of them flourish more than others depending on the local environmental conditions. Root endophytes also isolated from the bulk and/or rhizosphere soil assent with Kobayashi and Palumbo (2000) who mentioned that many endophytic taxa also occur in the rhizosphere. However, in our study, no significant correlation was found between root endophytic and rhizosphere communities within the same field, despite the fact that eight root endophytic strains at the control field and six at the contaminated field were also detected in the rhizosphere soil (Fig. 1). Based on these genotypical data, we presume that plants are capable of favouring the dominance of some specific seed endophytes as obligate endophytes and that the isolated facultative endophytes systemically colonized the inside of the plant via the rhizosphere soil (cfr. Compant et al., 2010). Probably, most of these facultative endophytes are selected from the soil by plant root exudates that have pronounced selective and promoting effects on specific soil microbial populations (Hartmann et al., 2009).
All isolated strains were tested for their Cd and Zn tolerance. The highest numbers of strains tolerant to 1.6 mM Cd and 2.5 mM Zn originated from the contaminated field (Table 2A). Most likely, the significantly higher Cd and Zn concentrations in bulk soil and roots, compared with the background concentrations at the control field (Table 3), caused a selective pressure in favour of Cd and Zn tolerant bacteria at the contaminated field. Moreover, it seems that in this case Zn exerts a higher selective pressure than Cd on bacterial communities since multiple bacterial strains isolated at the contaminated field tolerate the highest Zn concentration, while strains isolated from the control field could hardly survive (Table 2A). Chemical similarity between Cd and Zn and their association in the environment can lead to interactions between these two elements (McKenna et al., 1993), resulting in a lowering of Cd toxicity (Wajda et al., 1989). Cadmium is, at least partially, taken via the root Zn transporter; therefore high Zn concentrations inhibit Cd uptake and translocation (Polle and Schützendübel, 2003). Further, the uptake and translocation of Zn by plants is higher than Cd (Shrivastava and Singh, 1989) since Cd is a non-essential element and toxic at a lower concentration than Zn (Chakravarty and Shrivastava, 1994).
A high number of bacterial strains isolated from the control rhizosphere and roots could produce siderophores (Table 2B). This might explain why the Fe content in roots of plants grown on the control field was about eight times higher, while the Ca(NO3)2-extractable Fe concentrations in the soils from both fields were not significantly different (Table 3). Iron deficiency (< 100 mg kg−1) was noticed in all parts of plants from the contaminated field; this might inhibit chlorophyll synthesis and chloroplast development and increase ethylene production in plant tissues, eventually leading to decreased remediation efficiency (Glick, 2003). Bacterial siderophore production can promote plant growth, especially in case of iron deficiency by sequestering Fe in siderophore–Fe complexes which plants can use as Fe source (Wang et al., 1993). In addition siderophores may also enhance Cd availability since Cd can also be sequestered by siderophores (Rajkumar et al., 2010). At both fields the highest amounts of organic acid producing bacteria were found in the rhizosphere (Table 2B). Plant roots exude organic acids into the rhizosphere for the mobilization of poorly soluble nutrients in the soil (Ström et al., 2002). An increased acidity in the rhizosphere will also increase TE solubility and eventually phytoextraction potential (Li and Wong, 2010). Most likely, only part of the secreted organic acids will effectively mobilize TEs and nutrients. Further, mobilization is mostly due to both the complexing action of the organic acid anion and the dissolution properties of the released protons. Jones and Darrah (1994) also stated that organic acids can be expected to be of little consequence in high pH soils, while in acid soils (which is the case on the TE-F) they may be involved in a more general uptake mechanism.
At the contaminated field, more bacterial strains showed potential for phosphorus solubilization, nitrogen fixation and production of ACC deaminase and IAA (Table 2B). This might be an indication for bacterial selection by plants during stress conditions. Increased availability of nutrients, bacterial production of plant growth hormones and breakdown of the immediate precursor of the plant stress hormone ethylene can be crucial for plant survival in adverse conditions. In contrast, more acetoin producing bacteria were found at the control field (Table 2B). Higher amounts of organic matter may favour the activity of fermentative bacteria using acetoin as an external energy store (Xiao and Xu, 2007).
This phenotypic information suggests that the TE contamination generates a selective pressure in favour of Cd/Zn tolerant, phosphorus solubilizing, nitrogen fixating and ACC deaminase/IAA producing bacteria since their amounts are consistently higher in all studied compartments at the contaminated field (Table 2).
In conclusion, genotypic and phenotypic characteristics of rapeseed-associated bacterial populations can be affected by environmental conditions (e.g. soil contamination) as well as by their host plant (i.e. selection from the rhizosphere/bulk soil and present seed endophytes). The environmental conditions at the contaminated field seem inductive for the occurrence of rapeseed-associated bacteria with potential to enhance Cd phytoextraction. Enriching the rhizosphere with these PGP, siderophore and/or organic acid producing bacteria might enhance TE uptake while endophytes equipped with a TE sequestration system might reduce Cd phytotoxicity. In future inoculation experiments, the in planta potential of promising strains to enhance phytoextraction efficiency will be tested (Sheng and Xia, 2006; Dell'Amico et al., 2008; Sheng et al., 2008). Once the most appropriate plant-associated bacteria will be identified, they can be exploited to accelerate the TE extraction process, adjusting the high biomass producing B. napus into a reasonable Cd phytoextractor that at the same time can be economically valorized.
In order to isolate the cultivable bacteria associated with field grown B. napus, soils and plants were sampled after the flowering stage (June 2010). Sampling was performed on a TE (Cd, Zn and Pb)-contaminated former maize field in Lommel (TE-F; see Ruttens et al., 2010) and on a non-contaminated field in Alken (Belgium) (CO-F). On both fields the sampling area was subdivided into three subareas. One plant, with its surrounding rhizosphere soil and bulk soil, from each subarea (three in total) made up a mixed bulk soil, rhizosphere soil, root, stem and leaf sample. Sampling was repeated three times using each time three other plants (one per subarea). Bulk soil was sampled at a depth of 30 cm. Roots were stored in sterile Falcon tubes containing 20 ml of sterile 10 mM MgSO4.
Isolation of B. napus-associated bacteria
All cultivable bacterial strains were isolated from bulk soil, rhizosphere soil and roots according to Weyens and colleagues (2009c), but using less active chloride solution (1%) and time (1 min) during root surface sterilization. All plated samples were incubated for 7 days at 30°C and colony-forming units (cfu) were counted and calculated per gram soil or fresh plant weight. Morphologically different strains were purified using five replicates and subsequently stored at −70°C in a glycerol solution [15% (w:v) glycerol; 0.85% (w:v) NaCl].
Total genomic DNA was extracted from all purified morphologically different bacterial strains by the DNeasy® Blood and Tissue kit (Qiagen, Valencia, CA, USA). Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) amplification of the 16S rRNA genes was performed on aliquots of the extracted DNA using the universal primers, 16S-prokaryotic-R (5′-ACGGGCGGTGTGTRC-3′) and 16S-prokaryotic-F (5′-AGAGTTTGATCCTGGCTCAG-3′) as described previously by Weyens and colleagues (2009c).
For amplified 16S rDNA restriction analysis (ARDRA), 20 μl of the PCR products were digested with the HpyCH4IV enzyme and visualized by gel electrophoresis as described by Weyens and colleagues (2009c). Bacterial strains from bulk and rhizosphere soil with the same ARDRA patterns were grouped; strains isolated from plant tissue were grouped separately. The 16S rDNA PCR products of one representative strain per group were purified according to the QIAquick 96 PCR Purification Kit (Qiagen, Valencia, CA, USA). Subsequently, purified 16S rRNA genes were sent for sequencing by Macrogen (Korea) with an Automatic Sequencer 3730XL. Consensus sequences, sequence matches and sequence alignments used for constructing a neighbour-joining tree to verify identification were obtained as in Weyens and colleagues (2009c).
All purified bacterial isolates were screened for TE tolerance (Cd and Zn) and potential PGP characteristics (phosphate solubilization, nitrogen fixation and production of siderophores, organic acids, IAA, acetoin and ACC-deaminase). Before screening, strains were grown in 869 medium (Mergeay et al., 1985) and subsequently washed twice with sterile 10 mM MgSO4. Strains, not able to grow in the test media (pH 7) during incubation [5 (liquid media) to 7 days (solid media) at 30°C], were considered as not detectable (nd). Media without cell suspension were used as controls.
All isolates were plated on selective 284 medium with a carbon mix and 0.0, 0.8 and 1.6 mM Cd (CdSO4) or 0.0, 0.6, 1 and 2.5 mM Zn (ZnSO4), tolerance was rated visually (Weyens et al., 2009c).
National Botanical Research Institute's phosphate growth solid medium was used for screening phosphate-solubilizing microorganisms (Nautiyal, 1999), 50 μl aliquots of washed strains were inoculated in holes (Ø: 0.5 cm). Strains capable of producing a clear zone were considered positive. Bacterial nitrogenase activity was tested in a semi-solid malate-sucrose medium modified from Döbereiner (1989) (Xie et al., 2006). Three millilitres of bromothymol blue per litre of medium was used as a pH indicator (Nabti et al., 2007). Anaerobic nitrogenase activity was visually rated as a colour change from blue to yellow which indicated the acidification of sugars and therefore growth. Siderophore secretion was qualitatively evaluated by the ‘universal’ colorimetrical method of Schwyn and Neilands (1987) after inoculating strains in 800 μl of selective 284 medium with a carbon mix and 0, 0.25 and 3 μM Fe (respectively deficient, optimal and oversupply Fe conditions). Bacterial organic acid production was detected according to the colorimetric method of Cunningham and Kuiack (1992) after inoculating strains in 800 μl of sucrose tryptone medium. Bacterial IAA production capacity was tested in 1 ml of 1/10 869 medium with 0.5 g l−1 tryptophan. After incubation, a colorimetric reaction was induced to find positive strains (Gordon and Weber, 1951). To detect strains that utilize the butylene glycol pathway and produce acetoin, strains were inoculated in Methyl Red-Voges Proskauer (MRVP) medium containing per litre 17 g of MRVP medium (Sigma-Aldrich). After 48 h of incubation, a colorimetric reaction was induced according to Romick and Fleming (1998), in order to observe positive strains. ACC deaminase activity was evaluated by a slight modified protocol according to Belimov and colleagues (2005). Washed bacterial pellets were resuspended in 1 ml salts minimal medium with 10 mM ACC as sole nitrogen source. After 3 days at 30°C, bacterial cells were resuspended in 0.1 ml of Tris-HCl buffer (pH 8.5) and disrupted by 15 μl of toluene. Subsequently, 15 μl of 0.5 M ACC and 100 μl of 0.1 M Tris-HCl buffer (pH 8.5) were added to induce ACC deaminase activity, which was stopped by adding 0.5 ml of 0.56 N HCl. An aliquot of the supernatant was used as described in Belimov and colleagues (2005) to check the presence of ACC deaminase visually.
Trace element (Na, Mg, K, Fe, Cu, Zn, Cd, Pb) (TE) concentrations in soils and plants
The plant available fractions of TEs present in the bulk soil were estimated using 0.1 M Ca(NO3)2 extraction (Mench et al., 1994). Total soil TE contents were determined by aqua regia digestion (Van Ranst et al., 1999). To measure total TE concentrations in plant organs (root, stem, leaf and seed), samples collected in the field were treated as described by Weyens and colleagues (2010). TE concentrations were determined using inductively coupled plasma optical emission spectrometry (ICP-OES). All mixed soil and plant samples were tested in triplicate.
Percentages of genotypic and phenotypic different strains per mixed sample and their mean percentages per compartment were calculated but not appropriate for anova analysis. Genotypic information was subjected to correspondence analysis (CA), a principal component analysis related ordination technique based on chi-square distances, illustrating correlations between compartments. A logit transformation was performed on the proportional data gathered during the phenotypic analyses before analysing them using a two-way anova and post hoc multiple comparison testing (Tukey Kramer). The same method (without the logit transformation) was used to test the bacterial amounts isolated from the different compartments at both fields. TE concentrations were statistically compared between both fields using one-way anova. Transformations were applied when necessary to approximate normality and/or homoscedasticity. In case normality could not be reached, data were analysed using Kruskal–Wallis multiple comparisons test.
We thank Magda Ieven and Marc Withofs for their graphical assistance.