Comparison of negative pressure wound therapy and secondary intention healing after excision of acral lentiginous melanoma on the foot


  • Funding sources

  • Conflicts of interest
    None declared.

Kee-Yang Chung.


Background  Melanoma in dark-skinned individuals often develops in an acral lentiginous fashion on the foot and wide excision usually results in a substantial defect. Various repair methods, including free flap, full-thickness skin graft and secondary intention healing (SIH), are used to repair these defects. Recently, use of negative pressure wound treatment (NPWT) has been shown to accelerate wound healing in different types of wound.

Objectives  To compare the functional and cosmetic results of NPWT and SIH in patients who underwent wide excision of melanomas on the foot.

Methods  The wound defects of 22 patients after wide excision of melanoma on the foot were treated using SIH (= 13) or NPWT (= 9).

Results  There was no significant difference in time to complete wound healing between the two groups. However, evaluation using the Vancouver Burn Scar Assessment Scale at the time of complete healing showed that the mean score of the NPWT group was significantly lower than that of the SIH group. The NPWT group also had significantly better results than the SIH group in terms of total score, vascularity and height of the scars. As for complications, no wound infection was encountered in the NPWT group, whereas eight of the 13 patients in SIH group had wound infections during the course of treatment despite frequent and meticulous aseptic dressing changes.

Conclusions  These results show that, despite the drawback of rather prolonged healing time, NPWT is an excellent therapeutic option for wounds after wide excision of melanoma on the foot, with acceptable functional and cosmetic outcomes.