The copyright line for this article was changed on 29th April 2016 after original online publication.
Swine have been regarded as intermediate hosts in the spread of influenza from birds to humans but studies of the sialylated glycans that comprise their respiratory tract have not been extensively studied in the past. This study analyzed the sialylated N-glycan and O-glycan profile of swine trachea and lung and correlated this with ex-vivo infection of swine explants with avian influenza viruses.
Lungs and tracheal samples were obtained from normal farm and laboratory raised swine and used for ex vivo infection as well as mass spectrometric analysis. Infection of the ex vivo tissues used high pathogenic and low pathogenic avian viruses including the novel H7N9 virus that emerged in China in early 2013.
Main outcome measures
Assessment of successful replication was determined by TCID50 as well as virus immunohistochemistry. The N-glycan and O-glycan profiles were measured by MALDI-TOF and sialylated linkages were determined by sialidase treatment. Lectin binding histochemistry was also performed on formalin fixed tissue samples with positive binding detected by chromogen staining.
The swine respiratory tract glycans differed from the human respiratory tact glycans in two main areas. There was a greater abundance of Gal-α-Gal linkages resulting in a relative decrease in sialylated glycans. The swine respiratory tract also had a greater proportion of glycans containing Neu5Gc and Siaα2-6 glycans than the human respiratory tract. Infection with avian viruses was confined primarily to lung bronchioles rather than trachea and parenchyma.
In contrast to previous studies we found that there was not as much expression of Siaα2-3 glycans on the surface of the trachea. Infection of Siaα2-3 binding avian viruses was restricted to the lower respiratory tract bronchioles. This finding may diminish the ability of the swine to act as an intermediary in the transmission of avian viruses to humans.
Influenza virus infection of the respiratory tract involves the recognition and interaction of the viral hemagglutinin with the Sia receptor present on the host cell. Since 1983, when Rogers and Paulson[1, 2] delineated a difference in affinity between avian and human viruses, there have been detailed investigations on the distribution of different Sia linkages between different species and on the correlation between the receptor preference of influenza virus viz Siaα2-6 and Siaα2-3 and infection or transmission. The Siaα2-6 is preferentially recognized by human and swine viruses, but not by equine or avian viruses. In contrast, avian viruses recognize glycoproteins with Siaα2-3Gal-GlcNAc and Siaα2-3Gal-GalNAc type of sialic acids as shown by carbohydrate binding array and more recently by glycan array.[3-6]
Aquatic birds are the main reservoirs for all influenza viruses. Swine influenza viruses are derived from influenza viruses of avians or humans or reassortants between them. It has been proposed that swine could be intermediate hosts for genetic reassortment between avian and mammalian influenza viruses.[7, 8] The concept of the pig as a “mixing vessel” for new viruses is further supported by the demonstration of Siaα2-6 and Siaα2-3 by lectin binding studies[7, 9] and reports that swine are susceptible to a wide range of influenza viruses. However, more recent studies suggest that swine may not be as readily permissive to a wide range of avian influenza viruses; for example, there is low susceptibility of domestic pigs to highly pathogenic (HP) H5N1 infection under laboratory conditions. Even though surveillance of pigs in Indonesia showed a 7·4% isolation rate of this virus in a defined locality with little clinical symptoms, these reports are the exception than the rule. In addition, virus binding studies by van Riel et al. demonstrated no significant binding of H5N1 to the trachea or bronchi of pigs but to pneumocytes.
Previous research suggested that avian viruses would not transmit directly to humans as lectin binding studies indicated that the human upper respiratory tract was lined mainly by Siaα2-6-terminated glycans, as detected by Sambucus nigra agglutinin binding with only a limited detection of Siaα2-3 glycan on goblet cells, as detected by the binding of Maackia amurensis agglutinin (MAA). However, the infection of humans with HP H5N1 virus in 1997 indicated that Siaα2-3-terminated glycans are present in human respiratory tract as the receptor for virus entry, and this was shown to be the case in the human alveolar epithelium.[15, 16] Infection of H5N1 in humans results in severe disease but little evidence of direct human-to-human transmission. It has been suggested that the lack of Siaα2-3 glycans in the human upper respiratory tract is responsible for the lack of human-to-human transmission.[17, 18] Recent studies have demonstrated that mutations in the virus hemagglutinin that lead to a switch in the H5N1 virus receptor binding preference from Siaα2-3 to Siaα2-6 glycans contributed to the acquisition of airborne droplet transmission in ferrets, a well established correlate for transmission in humans.[17, 19]
In contrast to the Sia distribution in the human respiratory tract, recent lectin binding studies indicated that the presence of Siaα2-3 in the porcine trachea was not as abundant as previously documented[20-22] and this has been explained by the different isoforms of MAA used in these studies.[23, 24] To clarify the distribution of influenza virus receptors in the porcine respiratory tract, Bateman et al. performed ultrasensitive mass spectrometric N- and O-glycan profiles of cultured swine respiratory epithelial cells (SREC) and correlated this with infection by swine influenza viruses. They found that there was more Siaα2-6 than Siaα2-3, and Neu5Ac was more abundant than Neu5Gc, which would explain the relatively rarity of avian influenza virus infections becoming established in swine. However, since the SRECs were obtained from trachea and proximal bronchi, the role of the lung parenchyma in virus infection and replication still remained undecided.
To clarify the discrepancies between studies on the role of pigs in avian influenza virus infection, we explored the sialic acid (Sia) receptor distribution in the swine respiratory tract in order to provide insights into the permissiveness or lack of permissiveness of swine to avian influenza viruses. Furthermore, we performed mass spectrometric analysis on normal, healthy pig lung and trachea and correlated the glycan distribution data with virus tropism ascertained from pig respiratory organ explant infections. The viruses included in this study include the H7N9 avian virus, which has caused an outbreak in Mainland China in 2013, HP H5N1, and low pathogenic avian viruses of other subtypes on which glycan arrays had been previously performed. As miniature pigs have been used in experimental laboratory influenza infection or vaccination,[27-30] in this study, we also compared the mass spectrometric profile of miniature pigs with healthy farm pigs. This comparison is important to reveal the situation in the farm pigs which harbor the swine virus as well as being constantly exposed to the environment and therefore avian influenza viruses.
Materials and methods
A/Shanghai/2/2013 (Sh2/H7N9),A/Hong Kong/483/97 (H5N1), A/Hong Kong/486/97 (H5N1), A/Vietnam/3046/04 (H5N1), A/Vietnam/1203/04 (H5N1), A/Northern pintail/Hong Kong/MP5883/2004 (H5N8), A/Duck/Bavaria/1/1977 (H1N1), A/Quail/Hong Kong/G1/97 (H9N2), A/Chicken/Hong Kong/Y280/97 (H9N2). A/Hong Kong/415742/09 (H1N1pdm), A/swine/HK/4167/99 (H1N1), and A/Oklahoma/1992/05 (H3N2) were used as positive controls.
Swine respiratory organ explant culture
The intact respiratory organs of swine were obtained from pigs being slaughtered in a local abattoir. These tissues were taken from 6-month-old pigs (Sus Scrofa domestica) and delivered within 3 hours after slaughtering in a sterile plastic container at 4°C. Our previous experience with surveillance for swine influenza viruses at this abattoir in recent years has shown an influenza virus isolation rate of around 1%. To screen for evidence of current influenza infection in the animal, a tracheal swab was taken and tested for influenza M gene by real-time qPCR; if a positive result was obtained, those particular set of tissues were discarded.
Tracheobronchial epithelium (TBE)
The tracheobronchial region was removed from the respiratory organ and moisturized by rinsing in transport medium. The cartilage of the tracheobronchial region was pinned on a dissection board while a pair of fine forceps was used together with a sharp scalpel to remove the TBE from the cartilage carefully. The TBE was cut using a disposable 5-mm biopsy and cultured in MEM (Gibco, Carlsbad, CA, USA) with 100 U/ml penicillin, 100 μg/ml streptomycin, 1 μg/ml kanamycin, 0·3 mg/ml glutamine, and 0·02 m HEPES at an air–liquid interface (ALI). The thin TBE explants were placed with the epithelial surface upward on a surgical sponge (Simport) and put inside a 12-well plate. Culture medium was added into each well with the epithelial explants and the surgical sponge floating on the medium.
Lung parenchymal mucosa
We adopted the method of van Poucke et al. with slight modifications. The lung was perfused with cold transport medium using a clear tracheal tube 4·0 mm (Ruschelit, Research Triangle Park, NC, USA) through the bronchiole until the lobe was fully expanded. The transport medium was aspirated and replaced by 1% agarose in PBS (Sigma, St. Louis, MO, USA). Icepacks were then put below and above the lung lobe to solidify the agarose. This tissue was further embedded in 4% agarose and cut in slices, using a cryotome blade with a thickness <1 mm. The thin slices of explant were cut using disposable 5-mm biopsy punch (Miltex, Plainsboro, NJ, USA) and cultured in DMEM (Gibco) with 2·5 μg/ml bovine insulin (Sigma), 0·5 μg/ml hydrocortisone (Sigma), 0·5 μg/ml vitamin A 0·5 (Sigma), 0·1 mg/ml gentamycin, and 50 μg/ml polymycin B.
The medium of these explants was changed every hour in the first four hours and incubated at 37°C in a humidified incubator with 5% CO2 supply and fixed in 10% saline-buffered formalin at 0, 24, 48, and 72 hour after preparation, to evaluate their morphology, viability, and influenza receptor distribution.
Lectin binding and immunohistochemistry
Expression of Sialic acid by lectin histochemistry was performed using lectins SNA, MAA-I, and MAA-II as published previously and obtained from Vector Laboratories. PNA lectin preferentially binds Galß1-3GalNAc. Thomsen-Freidenreich (TF) antibody (A78-G/A7) was purchased from LabVision Thermo Scientific (Waltham, MA, USA), and Neu5Gc antibody staining was performed using a chicken monoclonal antibody from Sialix (San Diego, CA, USA). Sections were pretreated with a sialidase (DAS181, Nex Bio, San Diego, CA, USA) for 2 hours at RT to remove both α2-3- and α2-6-linked Sia.
Immunohistochemical staining and virus titration assay
Immunohistochemical staining of lung and tracheal tissue was carried out using the influenza nucleoprotein. The tissue sections were incubated with 0·1% pronase (Roche, Mannheim, Germany) in 0·1 m Tris (pH7·5) at 37°C for 1 minute and blocked with 3% H2O2 in TBS for 10 minute followed by treatment with an avidin/biotin blocking kit (Vector Lab). After blocking with 10% normal rabbit serum for 10 minute at RT, the sections were incubated with 1/25 (15 μg/ml) HB65 antibody for 1 hour at RT followed by biotinylated rabbit anti-mouse (Dako Cytomation, Carpinteria, CA, USA) diluted 1/100 for 30 minute at RT. After incubation with Elite-ABC kit (Vector Lab PK-6100) diluted 1/50 for 30 minute at RT, the sections were developed with Vector NovaRed substrate kit (Vector Lab SK-4800). To determine productive viral replication from the infected biopsies, the supernatant of the infected cultures was collected at 1, 24, 48, and 72 hour post-infection and stored at −80°C for virus titration using TCID50 assay in MDCK cells as described previously. An increasing virus titer along the time course provided evidence of productive virus replication.
Normal pig trachea and lung
Two 3-month-old pigs from a high health status farm in France that was negative for influenza A viruses were used. The animals were housed together in a HEPA-filtered experimental unit with ad libitum access to water and food. At arrival, they were treated intramuscularly with ceftiofur (Naxcel®, Pfizer-1 ml/20 kg body weight) to clear the respiratory tract from possible infections with Actinobacillus pleuropneumoniae, Pasteurella multocida, Haemophilus parasuis, and Streptococcus suis. Two days later, they were euthanized by intravenous administration of thiopental (Penthotal®, Kela-12·5 mg/kg body weight) and exsanguinated. Miniature pig lung was isolated from adult mini-pigs (45–50 kg, 9–12 months old). All tissues were snap-frozen in liquid nitrogen before glycan extraction. Additional blocks were placed in 10% neutral-buffered formalin for tissue processing.
The lung and trachea N-glycans were prepared for mass spectrometric analysis as previously described. Briefly, the tissues were homogenized and sonicated in a homogenization buffer of 1% CHAPS (v/v) in 25 mm Tris, 150 mm sodium chloride (NaCl), 5 mm EDTA in water, pH 7·4 and subsequently dialyzed in a 50 mm ammonium bicarbonate (Ambic) buffer. The samples were reduced, carboxymethylated, and digested with trypsin (EC 126.96.36.199; Sigma). The N-glycans were released by digestion with PNGase F (EC 188.8.131.52; Roche Molecular Biochemicals) and purified by reverse-phase C18 Sep-Pak (Waters) chromatography. Sialidase cleavage was performed with Sialidase S (recombinant from Streptococcus pneumoniae expressed in E. coli, Glyco, 170 mU) and Sialidase A (recombinant from Arthrobacter ureafaciens expressed in E. coli, Glyco, 170 mU), in 50 mm Sodium acetate, pH 5·5. Sialidase S cleaves α2-3 linkages and Sialidase A cleaves α2-3 and α2-6 linkages. Sialidase specificity and experimental conditions were established by experiments with sialylated glycan standards with known Sia linkages. The products of digestion were determined by mass spectrometry. The digest samples were lyophilized, permethylated, and purified by C18 Sep-Pak (Waters). Matrix-assisted laser desorbtion ionization–time of flight (MALDI-TOF) data were acquired on a Voyager-DE STR mass spectrometer (PerSeptive Biosystems, Framingham, MA, USA) in the reflectron positive mode with delayed extraction. Permethylated samples were dissolved in 10 μl methanol, and 1 μl of dissolved sample was premixed with 1 μl of matrix [20 mg/ml 2,5-dihydroxybenzoic acid (DHB) in 70% (v/v) aqueous methanol before being loaded onto the sample plate. MALDI-TOF/TOF experiments were performed on a 4800 Proteomics Analyzer (Applied Biosystems, Framingham, MA, USA) operated in the reflectron positive ion mode.
The differences of log10-transformed viral titers from infected culture collected at different time points post-infection and different viruses were compared using one-way anova followed by Bonferroni multiple-comparison test. Differences were considered as significant at P < 0·05. The statistical analysis was carried out using GraphPad Prism 5.
Swine lung contains sialylated glycan receptors for influenza viruses
The MALDI-TOF spectra derived from the permethylated N-glycans of control pig lung (Figure 1) contained a diverse range of [M+Na]+ molecular ion signals. Expressed signals consistent with both high mannose type N-glycans (m/z 1579·9, 1783·7, 1987·7, 2191·7 and 2395·8, Hex5-9HexNAc2) and complex type bi-, tri-, tetra-antennary and polylactosamine extended core fucosylated structures (m/z 2243·8- 5959·9, Hex3HexNAc4Fuc-Hex13HexNAc8Fuc) were present. The complex glycans were capped with either the Galα1-3Gal sequence (for example, m/z 2652·3, 3305·7, and 3959·0 highlighted in blue, Hex7HexNAc4Fuc-Hex11HexNAc6Fuc consistent with bi-, tri-, and tetra-antennary core fucosylated structures) or NeuAc (for example m/z 2605·1 and 3054·5 NeuAcHex5HexNAc4Fuc- NeuAcHex6HexNAc4Fuc consistent with mono-sialylated bi- and tri-antennary core fucosylated structures highlighted in red). Complex N-glycans capped with the NeuGc form of Sia were also observed (for example m/z 2635·1, 2839·4, 3084·5, 3492·6 NeuGcHex6HexNAc4Fuc- NeuGcHex8HexNAc5Fuc also highlighted in red). A ratio of 3:2 Ac:Gc was identified comparing the peaks at m/z 2605,2635 and 2809,2839. This ratio appeared reversed for the larger tri- and tetra-antennary structures. The second pig lung that was processed separately had a similar range of glycans present (Figure S1). The glycans detected and their relative abundance are listed in Table S1.
Siaα2-3 and Siaα2-6-linked N-glycans were found in pig lung
The proportion of α2-3- versus α2-6-linked Sia present in the N-glycans of porcine lung was further investigated by comparing sensitivity to digestion with linkage-specific sialidases and control samples without sialidase treatment (Figure 2). Sialidase S was used for the specific release of α2-3-linked Sia, and Sialidase A for release of both α2-3- and α2-6-linked Sia. The MALDI-TOF spectra of porcine lung N-glycans are shown after digestion with Sialidase S (Figure 2B), Sialidase A (Figure 2C), and control undigested (Figure 2A). Digestion of the pig lung N-glycans with Sialidase A (Figure 2C, Table S1) caused a complete loss of all Sia-containing glycans (e.g. m/z 2605·3, 2635·3, 2809·4, 2839·4, 2966·5, 3054·5, 3084·5, 3258·4, 3462·6, 3492·6, and 4146·1). Concurrent with these observations, the glycans at m/z 2244·0 (Hex5HexNAc4Fuc), 2448·1 (Hex6HexNAc4Fuc), 2693·2 (Hex6HexNAc5Fuc1), 3101·4 (Hex8HexNAc5Fuc), 3346·9 (Hex8HexNAc6Fuc), 3550·6 (Hex9HexNAc6Fuc), and 3754·6 (Hex10HexNAc6Fuc), which would be produced by de-sialylating the above glycans, increased in abundance after Sialidase A treatment, confirming the presence of Sia-containing N-glycans in the pig lung. By contrast, digestion of the pig lung N-glycans with Sialidase S (Figure 2B) caused a partial loss of Sia-containing glycans with signals at m/z 2605·5, 2636·5, 2809·6, 2839·6, 3054·7, 3084·7, 3462·9, 3942·9, and 4146·3 still remaining. This confirmed that pig lung N-glycans contained both α2-3- and α2-6-linked Sia.
Sialylated N-linked glycans are also present in swine trachea
The MALDI-TOF spectra of porcine trachea (Figure 3) showed fewer types of sialylated glycans compared with porcine lung. However, it should be noted that a more limited amount of tissue for glycomic analysis was available, which could inhibit the detection of higher molecular weight glycan species. The spectra derived from the control undigested sample indicated that similar to the lung, the pig trachea also expressed signals consistent with both high mannose type N-glycans (m/z 1579·8 1783·9, 1988·0, 2192·1, and 2396·2, Hex5-9HexNAc2) and complex type bi-, tri-, tetra-antennary and polylactosamine extended core fucosylated N-glycans (m/z 1836·2-4245·5, Hex3HexNAc4Fuc-Hex10HexNAc8Fuc). The complex glycans were also capped with either the Galα1-3Gal sequence (for example m/z 2652·3, 3305·6 and 3959·0) or Sia, both NeuAc and NeuGc (for example, m/z 2809·4 and 2839·4). Digestion of the pig trachea N-glycans with Sialidase A (Figure 4C) also caused a loss of most Sia-containing glycans with a concurrent increase in the abundance of their de-sialylated products (m/z 2244·2, 2448·4, 2693·6, and 3102·1), confirming the presence of Sia-containing N-glycans in the pig trachea. By contrast, digestion of the pig trachea N-glycans with Sialidase S (Figure 4B) also caused a partial loss of Sia-containing glycans with signals at m/z 2605·6, 2635·6, 2809·6, 2839·6, 3054·8, 3084·8, still remaining. Also of note is that the reduced complexity caused by the digestion with the sialidases affords the detection of higher MW polylac-containing N-glycans, for example, at m/z 4246 and 4492. This confirmed that pig trachea, such as the pig lung, contains N-glycans with both α2-3- and α2-6-linked Sia.
Siaα2-6 dominancy of N-linked glycans in pig trachea and lung
It has been demonstrated that relative quantitation based on signal intensities of permethylated glycans analyzed by MALDI-TOF MS is a reliable method, especially when comparing signals over a small mass range within the same spectrum. We compared the changes in the intensities of glycans with a single galactose antenna, which will increase with the removal of Sia, with glycans that contained the Gal-α Gal sequence, which will not change with sialidase treatment (e.g. m/z 2652·3 and 3305·8). This gives an indication of the relative activity of the two sialidases and therefore the relative abundance of α2-3- and α2-6-linked Sia. For example (Figures 2 and 4), we compared the relative abundance of the peaks at m/z 2448/2652 and m/z 3102/3306, containing bi- and tri- antennary core fucosylated structures (Hex6HexNAc4Fuc/Hex7HexNAc4Fuc and Hex8HexNAc5Fuc/Hex9HexNAc5Fuc). In both the lung and trachea, there was a greater relative increase in the glycans at m/z 2448 and 3306 with Sialidase A digestion, indicating a higher expression of α2-6-linked Sia N-glycans in the pig lung and trachea.
O-Glycan data of the pig lung (Figure 5) showed the presence of both core 1 and core 2 structures. Low levels of mono-sialylated core 2 structure at m/z 1344·7 were detected. In contrast, the main glycan present was the galactose-terminated core 2 structure at m/z 1187·4
Lung of minipig contained more Sia2-3-linked glycan than normal farm pigs
We compared the two lungs from normal pigs with lung tissue obtained from a minipig (Figure 6). Differences between the normal and minipig lungs were identified. In particular, the minipig lung tissues had a high abundance of monosialylated and disialylated biantennary core fucosylated structures (NeuAcHex5HexNAc4Fuc, NeuAc2Hex5HexNAc4Fuc) at m/z 2605·3 and 2966·5, which was relatively low in the normal pig lung. In contrast, the biantennary glycan with the terminal Galα1-3Gal m/z 2652·3 (Hex7HexNAc4Fuc) was more abundant in the normal pigs than tissues from minipigs. The NeuAc to NeuGc ratio was similar between the normal and minipigs in the biantennary glycans at m/z 2605·3, 2635·3, 2809·4, 2839·4, 3054·5, and 3084·5, but again this ratio appeared reversed for the larger tri- and tetra-antennary structures. In addition, the data from sialidase treatment indicated a greater abundance of α2-3-type linkages in the minipig lung compared with the normal pig lung.
Lectin histochemistry of trachea and lung samples
Lectin binding results showed that there was strong binding of SNA to the tracheal epithelium and bronchiolar epithelium with weak binding to pneumocytes. In contrast, there was no significant binding of MAA-I or MAA-II to the tracheal epithelium but binding to the submucosa (Figure 7). Binding of MAA-I was seen to the bronchiolar epithelium with no significant binding of MAA-II. This binding was removed with sialidase treatment. PNA binding was identified weakly in the tracheal and bronchiolar epithelium but increased marginally after sialidase treatment. There was a medium intense positive staining on the surface of the tracheal epithelium for NeuGc, and this was also present on the surface of alveolar epithelial cells (Figure S2).
Avian influenza A virus infection in pig lung and trachea
Virus replication kinetics of high and low pathogenic avian influenza viruses in tracheal and lung explants of normal pigs is shown (Figure 8). Unlike cell lines derived from a single tissue or tumor, pig explant cultures are more susceptible to donor-to-donor variations as they are from the respiratory organs of different pigs with individual variations. There was minimal replication of H5N1 in the swine trachea compared with the lung apart from one of four samples in which there was a 2 log increase with A/VN/3046/04 and A/VN/1203/04 infection and three of five cases where there was a 1 log increase for A/HK/483/97. In contrast, consistent replication in the swine lung was observed with most of the H5N1 viruses studied apart from A/VN/3046/04 where replication was only seen in two of five samples. Some of the low pathogenic avian viruses, A/Quail/HK/G1/97 (H9N2) and A/Northpintail/HK/MP5883/04 (H5N8), showed limited replication in the trachea, but most of them were able to replicate in pig lung. The recent H7N9 virus that has caused an outbreak in Mainland China in the early part of 2013 showed consistent replication in the bronchioles of the swine lung (Figure 9). The control viruses, A/swine/HK/4167 (H1N1), A/Oklahoma/1992/05 (H3N2), and A/Hong Kong/415742/09 (H1N1pdm), infected and replicated productively in all experiments with more than 2 log increase in trachea and at least 1 log increase in lung (Figure S3).
Immunohistochemistry of the ex vivo tissues was performed on all samples. This showed that at 24, 48, and 72 hours post-infection, there was absent to minimal staining of the tracheal tissues with all viruses tested, even in the H5N1 cases where a 2 log increase in viral titer was seen (Figure S4). As these blocks were serially sectioned through this suggests that the infection is very focal. In contrast, positive antigen was detected in lung tissues infected with H5N1 avian viruses where infection was mainly localized to bronchioles (Figure 10). Pulmonary extension was mainly present in tissues infected with H5N1 in contrast to other avian viruses including H7N9 where infection was confined to bronchioles (Figure 8).
We found minimal infection of ex vivo cultures of swine trachea with H5N1 and other avian Siaα2-3 binding viruses, and this is thus in accord with the virus binding experiments of van Riel and with the lectin binding studies of the trachea where there was no significant binding of MAA-I or MAA-II to the tracheal epithelium. However, the presence of infection in bronchioles by H5N1 does appear to be in contrast to the previously published patterns of viral attachment. As the 2 isoforms of MAA and SNA do not have a strong binding affinity to NeuGc compared with NeuAc, an absence of lectin binding does not necessarily mean that Sia is not present. Indeed, the NeuGc antibody did stain the surface of the bronchi and bronchioles, indicating that NeuGc was present. Most of this staining was abolished with Sialidase A treatment, but not with Sialidase S treatment, indicating that the NeuGc is more 2-6-linked than 2-3-linked.
Using fresh explanted lung tissues from 6-month-old swine, we found that the main site of viral replication of all avian viruses was in the lung rather than the trachea (Figure 8), and immunohistochemistry localized this to bronchioles rather than pneumocytes. Our previous studies, and control H1N1 infection (Figure S1), show that the bronchioles appear to be a common site for replication of seasonal and avian viruses and a switch to an “avian” type of virus led to more lower respiratory tract tropism. In this area, there was binding with SNA and MAA-1 (Figure 7). Binding with MAA-II to the bronchioles was minimal, but there was staining with TF after sialidase treatment to pneumocytes, and PNA binding was also increased after sialidase treatment. These findings would indicate that α2-3-linked N-glycans are the potential receptors for the avian viruses H5N1 and H5N8 in the bronchiolar epithelium. As the mass spectrometric data on the lung tissue demonstrated that there is a low quantity of Sia-core 1 at m/z 895 and a very low level of di-Sia-core 1 at m/z 1256 (Figure 5), this would suggest that the main O-glycan present in the pneumocytes is the sialylated TF glycan. The low abundance of the disialylated TF can be explained by the presence of the α1-3-galactose transferase enzyme in the pig lung which is absent in human tissues as these lack a functional GGTA1 (α1,3-galactosyltransferase) gene. The presence of this enzyme leads to a competition of the terminal Gal in Sia-core 1 for Sia and Gal, and the mass spectrometric findings suggest a greater preference for the Gal rather than the Sia, resulting in a very low level of Sia-core 1. Therefore, this reduces the probability for H5N1 virus to infect the alveolar epithelium by utilizing Sia-TF. Previous mass spectrometric studies have also shown that porcine submaxillary mucin has minimal di-Sia-core 1.
The only previous publication that has addressed the glycan distribution in the porcine respiratory tract was by Bateman et al. who used tissues derived from the trachea. They found a greater abundance of α2-6-terminated glycans than that seen in our MS analysis where we found more α2-3 glycans. This is explainable with the data in Figure 7 where there is no binding of MAA-I or MAA-II to the epithelium but positive binding of MAA-I and -II to the submucosa. Similar findings were also reported by Nelli et al. As we are not currently able to separate the epithelium from the submucosa for our glycan analysis of tracheal tissues, the α2-3 positive tissues most likely represent glycans present in the submucosa. When the MS findings were compared with human lung tissues, the two main differences present in the swine respiratory tract tissues were the high abundance of Galα1-3Gal and relative lack of extended sialylated LacNAc repeats.
Our findings that H5N1 replicates in a similar anatomical site to where swine and human viruses replicate lend credence to evidence that the pig can still be a site for mixing of viruses and where H5N1 can acquire increased affinity to α2-6-terminated glycans. There was replication identified in the lung by H7N9 similar to other avian viruses (Figure 9), supporting data from a previous study that found replication in the respiratory tract by this recent H7N9 using PCR analysis. A recent study using an avian H4N6 has also shown scanty replication of avian influenza virus in alveolar tissues. Lectin binding studies and ex vivo cultures show that the trachea is not likely to be an ideal anatomical site for replication of predominantly α2-3 binding viruses or virus growth but in contrast may be an anatomical region that favors a selection pressure for the emergence of avian viruses with a greater binding preference for α2-6-linked glycans. We found that there is limited evidence of infection of pneumocytes, and this may explain why influenza infection in swine produces few clinical symptoms and is not associated with great mortality. The high abundance of Galα1-3Gal structures identified by our MS analysis leads to a relative decrease in sialylated glycans, especially those with an extended LAcNAc structure. If these extended structures are involved in influenza virus binding, this finding may explain the lack of replication in this anatomical site. The comparative lack of replication in pneumocytes can also be explained by the unique glycosylation features of porcine surfactant protein-D which has greater inhibitory activities against a wide range of influenza A viruses compared with human surfactant proteins.
The minipig has been often used as laboratory animal to study infection in a number of situations, including studies of swine influenza.[28, 29] Our MS findings (Figure 6) show that the lung from these animals has a different glycan profile to that seen in normal pigs with more expression of higher molecular weight tetra-antennary Neu5Gc-containing N-glycans and more α2-3-linked Sia glycans. This may give a bias toward susceptibility to different avian viruses, and so studies on virus tropism, infection, or transmission using these animals might need to be interpreted with caution, in the light of these findings. The pig tissues used for explants were obtained from local slaughter house which probably represents the true population in the farm and environment, as well as pre-existing exposure to respiratory viruses; thus, we consider that these should continue to be utilized in the determination of tropism studies of different influenza viruses to demonstrate the potential public health risk.
In conclusion, our mass spectrometric analysis shows that compared with the human respiratory tract, the swine lung has fewer types of sialylated glycans present owing to the presence of the Galα1-3Gal structures, and of the sialylated glycans present, there are more α2-6 N-glycans present than α2-3 N-glycans. This may account for the relative lack of replication of H5N1 in tracheal tissues. Our ex vivo evidence demonstrates that the lower respiratory tract of the domestic pig, in particular the bronchiolar region, is a site where α2-3-binding H5N1 and α2-6-binding H9N2 avian viruses can efficiently replicate. As this is also an anatomical site where swine and human viruses replicate, this demonstrates that the pig is still a likely candidate for the continuing emergence of novel reassorted viruses.
This work was supported by Grant 082098 from the Wellcome Trust (to S. M. H., A. D. and J.N), Area of Excellence Scheme of the University Grants Committee (grant AoE/M-12/96), Research Fund for Control of Infection Disease (to R.W.Y.C, #12110992), and additional funding was from a grant of the European Commission (FP7- GA258084). We thank Nan Jia for assistance with manuscript preparation.