Activating and inhibitory killer immunoglobulin-like receptors (KIR) in haploidentical haemopoietic stem cell transplantation to cure high-risk leukaemias
Department of Experimental Medicine and Center of Excellence for Biomedical Research, University of Genova,
A. Moretta, Head Molecular Immunology Laboratories, Dipartimento di Medicina Sperimentale, Sezione di Istologia, School of Medicine, University of Genova, Via G.B. Marsano 10, 16132 Genova, Italy. E-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org
A number of experimental studies have shown that natural killer (NK) cells can eliminate cancer cells and the mechanisms involved in this effect have been uncovered during the last two decades. Clinical data from haploidentical haematopoietic stem cell transplantation (haplo-HSCT) revealed that NK cells were responsible for remarkably favourable effects in both adult and paediatric high-risk leukaemias. NK receptors specific for major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I molecules, including killer immunoglobulin (Ig)-like receptors (KIR) and CD94/NKG2A, play a major role in the anti-leukaemia effect (mediating either inhibitory or activating signals). Haplo- HSCT requires a heavy conditioning regimen for the patient and the use of large numbers of T cell-depleted HSC to be grafted. After transplantation, natural killer cells develop from HSC shortly after engraftment and may include ‘alloreactive’ NK cells that kill leukaemic cells and prevent graft-versus-host disease (GvHD). Alloreactive NK cells are characterized by the expression of KIR that are not engaged by any of the human leucocyte antigen (HLA) class I alleles expressed by the patient. Their generation is dependent upon the existence of a KIR/HLA class I mismatch between donor and recipient. Novel important information on the function and specificity of different KIR has been obtained recently by the analysis of donor-derived alloreactive NK cells in a cohort of paediatric patients given haplo-HSCT to cure acute, high-risk leukaemias.
Recognition of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) by human natural killer (NK) cells
NK cells, discovered originally in the early 1970s [1,2], represent a specialized arm of the innate immune system that possess potent perforin- and interferon-γ-dependent effector functions and participate in early defence mechanisms against intracellular microbial infections and different types of tumours [3–5]. Distinct from B and T cells, NK cells forego the process of rearranging genes to produce a repertoire of antigen receptors. Instead, they assemble different combinations of germline-encoded receptors that do not undergo somatic recombination. Some of these NK receptors inhibit, while others trigger, NK cell effector function. A portion of these receptors bind specifically to major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I or class I-like molecules that were thought to be dedicated uniquely to T cell-mediated adaptive immune responses [6–10].
The ‘missing self’ mode of NK cell recognition, proposed originally by Ljunggren and Karre , refers to a functional mechanism by which NK cells keep target cells in check for surface expression of MHC class I. This function is possible thanks to the expression at the NK cell surface of a series of MHC class I-specific inhibitory receptors that prevent NK cell activation, thus protecting potential target cells from NK cell-mediated attack. However, sensing the absence of self-MHC class I molecules is not sufficient for inducing NK cell activation. NK cells also require stimulation by ligands on target cells recognized by activating receptors including natural cytotoxicity receptors (NCRs), DNAX accessory molecule-1 (DNAM-1) and NK group 2 member D (NKG2D) [12–15]. Thus, NK cell recognition of target cells is regulated tightly by a process involving the integration of multiple signals delivered by both activating and inhibitory receptors.
In humans, a relatively large family of NK cell receptors for MHC is represented by killer Ig-like receptors (KIR) . KIR are characterized by two (KIR2D) or three (KIR3D) extracellular immunoglobulin domains. In addition, they have either short (S) or long (L) intracytoplasmic tails which transduce activating or inhibitory signals, respectively [17–20]. The known ligands for inhibitory KIRs are all represented by MHC class I molecules: thus, HLA-C is recognized by KIR2DL1, KIR2DL2 and KIR2DL3 [21–24]; HLA-B by KIR3DL1 [25,26] and HLA-A by KIR3DL2 [27,28], while HLA-G is recognized by KIR2DL4 . The HLA determinants that bind to inhibitory KIRs are known as KIR epitopes. In particular, HLA-C allotypes have either the C1 epitope (shared by HLA-Cw alleles characterized by Ser77Asn80, including HLA-Cw1, -Cw3, -Cw7, -Cw8, -Cw12, -Cw13, -Cw14 and -Cw16 alleles), recognized by KIR2DL2/3, or the C2 epitope (Asn77Lys80 shared by HLA-Cw2, -Cw4, -Cw5, -Cw6, -Cw15, Cw*-1602, -Cw17 and -Cw18), the ligand for KIR2DL1 [30,31]. Similarly, all HLA-B allotypes have either the Bw4 or Bw6 epitope, but only the Bw4 epitope is a ligand for KIR, its cognate inhibitory receptor being KIR3DL1 [32–34].
Regarding the comparison between inhibitory and activating KIRs, they are characterized by highly homologous codon sequences in the extracellular domain, namely KIR2DL2/3-KIR2DS2, KIR2DL1-KIR2DS1 and KIR3DL1-KIR3DS1. In contrast to the inhibitory KIR, in most instances the ligands for the activating KIR are poorly defined despite the fact that activating KIRs possess similar extracellular regions. In addition to KIRs, another mode of MHC recognition by NK cells is mediated by the CD94-NKG2A (lectin-like) inhibitory receptor [35,36], specific for complexes of HLA-E and peptides derived from the leader sequences of many, but not all, HLA-A, HLA-B and HLA-C polypeptides [37–39].
Each individual differs in the number and type of inherited KIR genes and KIR gene products are distributed clonally in the NK cell repertoire [21,40,41]. Importantly, individual NK cells express only one or few inhibitory KIRs, while some NK cells do not express KIR but express CD94-NKG2A. In addition, inhibitory KIR and CD94-NKG2A receptors may be co-expressed by subsets of NK cells. Thus, in most cases, every NK cell expresses one or more inhibitory receptors, which through the interaction with autologous HLA class I molecules prevent NK cells from killing autologous normal cells.
The KIR gene family exhibits extensive variations in gene number and content, as well as allelic polymorphism [42,43]. Fourteen KIR genes, located in the leucocyte receptor complex on human chromosome 19, encode the various inhibitory and activating KIRs. These genes segregate independently of HLA, with the important consequence, in unrelated allogeneic transplantation, that matching for HLA does not match for KIR. The KIR repertoire in NK cells is determined primarily by the KIR genotype, although the HLA genotype also has a subtle, modifying influence . Diverse KIR haplotypes can be simplified into two biologically distinct groups, A and B. Group A haplotypes have a fixed number of genes that encode inhibitory receptors, with the exception of the activating 2DS4, while group B haplotypes have variable gene content including several additional activating receptor genes. All individuals can be categorized as having one of two KIR genotypes: A/A, which is homozygous for group A KIR haplotypes, or B/x, which contains either one (A/B heterozygous) or two (B/ homozygotes) group B haplotypes [16,40,45].
Alloreactive NK cells in haploidentical haemopoietic stem cell transplantation
Loss of HLA molecules is a common event in cells undergoing tumour transformation or infection with some viruses. When NK cells expressing KIR with specificity for a particular allotypic determinant shared by some HLA class I alleles interact with target cells lacking these alleles (i.e. sensing the ‘missing-self’), they are not inhibited and kill the potentially harmful target cell.
In settings of clinical stem cell transplantation (SCT), the term ‘KIR-ligand mismatch’ is often used to describe such ‘missing-self’ recognition. In this case, a fraction of NK cells from the donor may display the ability to kill target cells from the recipient. These NK cells are referred to as ‘alloreactive’. Remarkably, the presence of alloreactive donor-derived natural killer (NK) cells have been correlated with highly improved survival after HSCT for acute myelogenous leukaemia (AML). Indeed, alloreactive NK cells appear to promote engraftment, reduce graft-versus-host disease (GvHD) and, more importantly, decrease leukaemic relapses [46–49]. NK cell alloreactivity occurs when a subset of NK cells express KIR specific for an allelic epitope that is absent on (recipient) allogeneic cells. Under these conditions, these NK cells would kill allogeneic cells (at least those expressing ligands recognized by activating NK receptors). The existence of human ‘alloreactive’ NK cells was discovered originally by our group two decades ago [21–23]. It should be stressed that an HLA class I mismatch between NK cells and target cells does not lead necessarily to NK-mediated target cell killing. As indicated above, KIRs recognize allotypic determinants that are shared by groups of HLA class I alleles. Thus ‘alloreactive’ NK cells must not only express KIR that are not engaged by any of the HLA class I alleles present on allogeneic target cells  but also should not express CD94/NKG2A, as HLA-E is present on all HLA class I+ cells .
The majority of patients, particularly of paediatric age, have a family member who is identical for one HLA haplotype. One hundred per cent of parents and 50% of siblings fulfil this criterion. In most instances, haploidentical transplants are mismatched at all the HLA class I and II loci, a situation that would lead to severe GvHD and poor clinical outcome. However, a promising approach to HLA-mismatched haploidentical haematopoietic cell transplantation (HCT) has been developed which may prevent graft rejection and eliminate leukaemic cells . First, patients are given an intense conditioning regimen involving total-body irradiation, cytotoxic drugs and polyclonal anti-thymocyte antibodies . Moreover, in order to facilitate engraftment, the numbers of CD34+ haematopoietic stem cells (HSC) infused are 5–20 times greater than in the setting of HLA-matched transplants. The use of such ‘megadoses’ of HSC has been made possible thanks to the use of peripheral blood as a source of mobilized CD34+ HSC [52,53]. Megadoses of CD34+ cells are also important because they can generate much larger numbers of NK cells, thus contributing to the maintenance of donor's KIR repertoire, efficient alloreactivity and anti-leukaemic effect.
In this transplantation setting, alloreactivity is mediated by NK cells provided the existence of KIR–ligand mismatches. Notably, two groups of haploidentical transplants can be identified. The first is represented by donor–recipient combinations in which NK cells of the donors express KIRs that do not recognize HLA class I molecules expressed by the patient (i.e. ‘alloreactive’ NK cells). In the second category of donor–recipient combinations all the KIR expressed by NK cells recognize the HLA class I alleles of the patient (‘NK matched’). Selection of the most appropriate donor is based on the assessment of the degree of ‘alloreactivity’ of NK cells. This can be determined by the phenotypic identification of the alloreactive NK cell subset by flow cytometric analysis (revealing its size) and by evaluation of the ability to kill leukaemic cells [revealing the potential graft-versus-leukaemia (GvL) effect]. The same experimental approach allows identification and evaluation of the functional capability of alloreactive NK cells in the recipient after transplantation . Indeed, in view of the key role of alloreactive NK cells in eradicating leukaemias in haplo-HSCT, it is important to ask whether such NK cells are originated and persist in the recipient for a significant time interval .
In the early studies, the presence of alloreactive NK cells in the recipients was documented up to 1 year after transplantation. In some patients, the proportions of alloreactive NK cells were larger in the recipient than in the donor, thus suggesting that they had been selected/expanded preferentially in vivo[46,56]. More recent studies have confirmed and extended these findings, showing that alloreactive NK cells can be detected for a period of more than 3 years after transplantation in several paediatric patients with high-risk leukaemias ( and Locatelli et al., in preparation).
Previous studies have shown that patients with AML had greatly improved disease-free survival and reduced leukaemia relapses when a KIR–ligand mistmatch was present [46,56]. Remarkably, patients transplanted from an NK alloreactive donor also benefited from higher rates of engraftment and reduced incidence of GvHD. A recent study on high-risk paediatric acute lymphoblastic leukaemia (ALL) refractory to chemotherapy provided further evidence of the key role of alloreactive NK cells in haploidentical HSC transplantation. This study represents a major breakthrough in the cure of otherwise fatal leukaemias, as the estimated 3-year survival in children with ALL transplanted from an NK alloreactive relative is ∼75% (Locatelli et al., in preparation).
As indicated by a murine model and suggested by clinical results, the GvL effect correlates with the generation of alloreactive NK cells characterized by potent anti-leukaemia activity. The reduced rate of GvHD is also likely to be the result of the NK cell-mediated killing of recipient antigen-presenting cells (APC) . In agreement with this concept, in vitro studies, using selected NK cell clones, showed that alloreactive NK cells are capable of killing both immature and mature monocyte-derived DCs . Conversely, autologous NK cells kill only immature DCs while sparing the mature ones. This, together with the release of proinflammatory cytokines , represents a major event in the process (‘DC editing’) of NK cell-mediated control of DC maturation. Indeed, NK cell-mediated editing  is necessary for selecting optimal DC, capable of priming naive T cells towards T helper type 1 (Th1) responses within secondary lymphoid compartments . Notably, alloreactive NK cells cannot mediate a DC editing process because they kill all DCs of the host, independent on their stage of maturation. This, in turn, would be essential to prevent donor T cell priming and subsequent generation of GvHD.
Generation and tissue specificity of alloreactive NK cells
It is now well established that, during maturation, NK cells require recognition of self-MHC class I to acquire full effector function, a phenomenon referred to as ‘licensing’ or ‘education’[62–64]. However, NK cells lacking MHC-specific inhibitory receptors can also be generated in the absence of this interaction, but they would remain virtually anergic or hyporesponsive. One may ask how donor NK cell precursors undergoing maturation in the mismatched recipient can give rise to alloreactive NK cells capable of killing leukaemic cells? A probable explanation is that, in haplo-HSCT, the infusion of ‘megadoses’ of CD34+ cells may provide a bone marrow (BM) microenvironment (i.e. where NK cells undergo maturation) predominantly of the donor type. Under these conditions, the process of NK education would be similar to that occurring normally in the donor and would allow the generation of NK cells displaying alloreactivity towards the recipient.
However, why do alloreactive NK cells in vivo not cause GvHD? A number of experimental data have demonstrated clearly that NK cells attack haematopoietic cells of the host while sparing other tissues that are, instead, common targets for T cell-mediated GvHD. For example, in the hybrid resistance phenomenon in mouse, alloreactive NK cells caused rejection of the BM graft but did not attack other tissue . Moreover, Ruggeri et al. obtained direct evidence in mice that alloreactive NK cells do not cause GvHD , while infusion of allogeneic T cells killed all the mice. The probably molecular basis of the resistance of recipient normal tissues to the NK cell-mediated attack is the lack of ligands for the activating NK receptors. Indeed, these ligands are expressed by cells of different histotypes only upon cell stress infection or tumour transformation . Thus, interaction with normal resting tissues does not lead to alloreactive NK cell activation.
The function and specificity of KIRs regulates the ability of NK cells to kill leukaemic blasts
Our early studies on the inhibitory KIR specific for HLA-C alleles revealed the existence of a clear-cut discrimination between the specificity of the HLA-class I allele of KIR2DL1 and that of KIR2DL2/3. Thus, as mentioned above, KIR2DL1 recognizes the C2 specificity while KIR2DL2/3 is specific for the C1 specificity . We reached this conclusion by functional analysis of selected NK cell clones characterized by given KIR2DL phenotypes. The C2 specificity of KIR2DL1 was confirmed in many studies, including those assessing the cytolytic activity of phenotypically selected NK cell clones against leukaemia blasts. On the other hand, two recent studies have shown that KIR2DL2/3 can also interact with HLA-C alleles belonging to the C2 specificity [54,67]. Although this interaction is weaker than that of KIR2DL2/3 with C1, it is sufficient to generate inhibitory signals that may prevent efficient NK-mediated killing. The inhibition may or may not be detected depending on the intensity of the activating signals generated during NK cell/target cell interaction. Thus, a strong NK cell stimulation via activating receptors may be sufficient to overcome the inhibition. Remarkably, in the case of NCR, their ligands are expressed in most leukaemic cells (anti-NCR antibodies strongly inhibit killing) [68,69].
Recent experimental evidence has revealed that some activating KIRs (e.g. KIR2DS1) may not allow a precise phenotypic identification and influence the function of alloreactive NK subsets. As shown by our early studies, upon recognition of HLA-Cw4 on Epstein–Barr virus (EBV)-transformed target cells, KIR2DS1 induced potent NK cell-mediated cytotoxicity . Additional reports confirmed further that KIR2DS1 recognizes different alleles belonging to the C2 specificity [70,71]. In a recent study we provided direct evidence that KIR2DS1 may play a crucial role in the lysis of C2/C2 leukaemia blasts (not only of EBV-transformed cell lines) . Thus, a series of donor-derived NK cell clones co-expressing KIR2DS1 together with either NKG2A or KIR2DL2/3 isolated from donor or recipient after HSCT killed patient leukaemia blasts efficiently. Moreover, cytolysis was inhibited by monoclonal antibody (mAb)-mediated blocking of KIR2DS1. In line with our findings that, in C1-mismatched HSCT, most KIR2DL2/3+ NK cells killed C2/C2 target cells poorly, Chewing et al. reported that a ‘missing self’ alloresponse to C2 could rarely be detected in NK cells from donors lacking KIR2DS1 . The molecular basis of this finding is that KIR2DL2/3 can recognize not only C1, but also C2 (see above). Remarkably, among the C1-mismatched pairs of our study (in which the alloreactive subset was KIR2DL2/3+) all patients receiving haplo-HSCT from KIR2DS1+ donors (four of eight) are alive and in complete remission, while fatal relapses occurred in three of four recipients transplanted from donors lacking KIR2DS1 . These data support strongly the evidence of a substantial clinical relevance of KIR2DS1-mediated recognition of leukaemia cells (Fig. 1). On the contrary, we could not document a specific role of KIR2DS2 in the mechanism of recognition and killing of leukaemia blasts.
The identification of HLA class I-specific NK receptors and the analysis of alloreactive NK cells represent the biological basis to devise a novel translational exploitation capable of bridging basic research with relevant clinical application. Thus, considerable evidence has indicated that alloreactive NK cells developing from haploidentical HSCT represent a most remarkable source of effector cells to fight successfully high-risk leukaemias and possibly other tumours [73,74]. The possibility to assess directly both the size and the cytolytic activity of the alloreactive NK cell populations allows not only identification of donors capable of generating alloreactive NK cells but also selection of the best possible donor . A recent study on high-risk paediatric ALL refractory to chemotherapy extended further the major clinical impact of NK alloreactivity in haploidentical HSC transplantation. This study provided the first clear evidence that the NK alloreactivity against leukaemia blasts is regulated by integrated signals delivered by both inhibitory and activating KIRs ( and Locatelli et al., in preparation). Remarkably, the expected alloreactivity against C2/C2 leukaemia blasts mediated by KIR2DL2/3+ NK cells were often impaired because this C1-reactive receptor was found to recognize C2 weakly as well. This affected substantially the ability to kill ‘KIR mismatched’ leukaemic targets unless C2 recognition was counterbalanced by KIR2DS1 functioning as a potent inducer of leukaemic blast-killing .
Taken together, these novel findings provide new information that may greatly improve our understanding of the molecular mechanisms at the basis of successful haplo-HSCT in patients with high-risk leukaemias.
A. Moretta is founder and shareholder of Innate-Pharma and hence declares a financial interest. The other authors declare no conflict of interest.