Re-use of this article is permitted in accordance with the Terms and Conditions set out at http://wileyonlinelibrary.com/onlineopen#OnlineOpen_Terms
Primary Research Article
Increased freshwater discharge shifts the trophic balance in the coastal zone of the northern Baltic Sea
Article first published online: 16 MAY 2012
© 2012 Blackwell Publishing Ltd
Global Change Biology
Volume 18, Issue 8, pages 2509–2519, August 2012
How to Cite
Wikner, J. and Andersson, A. (2012), Increased freshwater discharge shifts the trophic balance in the coastal zone of the northern Baltic Sea. Global Change Biology, 18: 2509–2519. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2486.2012.02718.x
- Issue published online: 10 JUL 2012
- Article first published online: 16 MAY 2012
- Accepted manuscript online: 16 APR 2012 10:00PM EST
- Manuscript Revised: 1 MAR 2012
- Manuscript Accepted: 1 MAR 2012
- Manuscript Received: 15 DEC 2011
- Kempe Foundation
- Swedish Research Council for Environment, Agricultural Sciences and Spatial Planning
- DOC ;
- food web;
- Top of page
- Materials and methods
- Supporting Information
Increased precipitation is one projected outcome of climate change that may enhance the discharge of freshwater to the coastal zone. The resulting lower salinity, and associated discharge of both nutrients and dissolved organic carbon, may influence food web functioning. The scope of this study was to determine the net outcome of increased freshwater discharge on the balance between auto- and heterotrophic processes in the coastal zone. By using long-term ecological time series data covering 13 years, we show that increased river discharge suppresses phytoplankton biomass production and shifts the carbon flow towards microbial heterotrophy. A 76% increase in freshwater discharge resulted in a 2.2 times higher ratio of bacterio- to phytoplankton production (Pb:Pp). The level of Pb:Pp is a function of riverine total organic carbon supply to the coastal zone. This is mainly due to the negative effect of freshwater and total organic carbon discharge on phytoplankton growth, despite a concomitant increase in discharge of nitrogen and phosphorus. With a time lag of 2 years the bacterial production recovered after an initial decline, further synergistically elevating the microbial heterotrophy. Current climate change projections suggesting increased precipitation may therefore lead to increased microbial heterotrophy, thereby decreasing the transfer efficiency of biomass to higher trophic levels. This prognosis would suggest reduced fish production and lower sedimentation rates of phytoplankton, a factor of detriment to benthic fauna. Our findings show that discharge of freshwater and total organic carbon significantly contributes to the balance of coastal processes at large spatial and temporal scales, and that model's would be greatly augmented by the inclusion of these environmental drivers as regulators of coastal productivity.
- Top of page
- Materials and methods
- Supporting Information
Climate scenarios suggest that the increased CO2 levels in the atmosphere and associated warming will increase precipitation in the northern hemisphere (Dore, 2005). For northern Scandinavia, precipitation is predicted to increase by a maximum of 21% compared to the current average (Meier, 2006). As a result the discharge of freshwater, and thereby nutrient load to the coastal zone, will increase.
The current view is that increased discharge of nitrogen and phosphorus promotes phytoplankton productivity and therefore eutrophication in the coastal zone (Larsson et al., 1985; Smith, 2006; Finkel et al., 2010). This is based on the fact that most studies implicate phosphorus and nitrogen as the major limiting nutrients of phytoplankton biomass production (Rabalais et al., 2002). Consequently, increased fresh water discharge should result in elevated primary production and high food web efficiency, and so in greater fish and shellfish production (Nixon, 1988).
However, Howarth et al. (2000), contrastingly reported higher primary production during dry than wet years in the Hudson estuary, suggesting weaker stratification and light penetration to be the main cause. Also, organic carbon is typically discharged at higher levels simultaneously with nitrogen and phosphorus, potentially exerting several negative effects on phytoplankton productivity (Hessen et al., 2010). In accordance with this, estuaries worldwide are often reported as net-heterotrophic, suggesting that externally supplied organic carbon is an important driver of coastal metabolism (Kemp et al., 1997; Sandberg et al., 2004). Dissolved organic carbon may support bacterioplankton biomass production, resulting in increased competition for mineral nutrients with phytoplankton (Pengerud et al., 1987; Thingstad et al., 2008; Barrera-Alba et al., 2009). Increased freshwater discharge may further influence stratification of the water column, affecting the vertical distribution of phytoplankton and their effective light climate (Cole et al., 1992; Howarth et al., 2000; Jager et al., 2008). Furthermore, an increase in humic and suspended substances may reduce light climate and, in conjunction with reduced salinity, may change the taxonomic composition of resident communities (Gasiunaite et al., 2005; Hessen et al., 2010).
Marine productivity and transfer efficiency in the coastal food web are important to understand in view of changing freshwater discharge, as they may influence the functionality of the coastal ecosystem. Whether larger phytoplankton or small bacterioplankton dominate the biomass at the food web base will influence the food web efficiency, defined as fish production per unit of primary production (Nixon, 1988; Rand & Stewart, 1998; Berglund et al., 2007). If the net effect of increased freshwater discharge is higher primary production of larger phytoplankton in the coastal zone, this may lead to increased production of fish and shellfish (Finkel et al., 2010). In contrast, the large influence of riverine dissolved and suspended organic matter in the coastal zone can both reduce primary production and promote a microbial food web structure with poor transfer efficiency of organic carbon to fish and shellfish (Sandberg et al., 2004; Berglund et al., 2007). To properly manage coastal resources and mitigate future effects of climate change, a better understanding of the net effect of increased freshwater discharge on an ecosystem scale is therefore required.
Taken together, it is difficult to predict the net outcome of increased river discharge for coastal productivity and the balance between auto- and heterotrophic processes, or to simulate it in controlled laboratory experiments. In this study, we therefore investigated the influence of a relatively moderate, but climatologically relevant, change in freshwater discharge on the ratio of bacterial to phytoplankton biomass production in full-scale coastal ecosystems over several years. This was used as a proxy for the relative importance of microbial production, and thereby losses from fish production and sedimentation.
Three different coastal sea areas were included, providing varying riverine load, morphology, productivity level and hydrography. In addition, long-term effects were examined by using a 13 year data set. The advantage of this strategy was that it addressed many of the composite effects of increased freshwater discharge on hydrography, chemistry, and biology in the coastal zone. Long-term field data sets also encompass effects on larger and more relevant time scales than can be achieved in controlled experimental systems, an important aspect in assessing climate-driven environmental change.
Materials and methods
- Top of page
- Materials and methods
- Supporting Information
The study was performed between 1994 and 2006 in three different basins within the northern Baltic Sea that have varying freshwater load, size, and maximum depth (Table 1; Fig. 1). Bothnian Bay is divided from the Bothnian Sea by the 20 m deep northern Quark (Wulff et al., 1990). The Öre estuary is relatively open towards the off-shore Bothnian Sea and lacks a marked sill. The catchment area consists mainly of coniferous forests and mires, and a smaller proportion of mountainous areas with tundra vegetation (Sweden) and arable land (Finland).
|Basin||Area (km2)||Volume (km3)||Maximum depth (m)||Mean depth (m)||Water exchange (yr)||Load of TOC (106 kg yr−1)|
|Bothnian Bay (Ignatius et al., 1981)||36, 800||1490||147||43||5||329|
|Öre estuary (Brydsten, 1992)||50||1||–||16||0.03||12|
|Bothnian Sea (Ignatius et al., 1981)||66, 000||4340||294||68||3||483|
Between 13 and 26 samplings per year and basin were performed from a research vessel, allowing production rate measurements and sample preparation typically to start within 1 h from sampling. From 1994 to 1999, one station per basin was visited, while sampling was extended to include two replicate stations in each basin (about 70 km apart) after the year 2000. Samples were taken with 7 dm3 Niskin® bottles (General Oceanics Inc., Miami, FL, USA) mounted on a rosette sampler. Sampling stations in the Bothnian Bay were A5 (65°10.00N; 23°14.00E) and A13 (64°42.50N; 22°4.00E); in the Bothnian Sea, C1 (62°35.20N; 19°58.41E), C3 (62°39.17N; 18°57.14E), and C14 (62°5.99N; 18°32.91E); and in the Öre Estuary station, B3 (63°29.98N; 19°49.14E) and B7 (63°31.50N; 19°48.49E). Station C3 replaced station C1 from the year 2000 an onwards: both represented the north-western Bothnian Sea. Samplings were reduced to 6 yr−1 at station C1 1998, due to a temporary reallocation of funding.
Phytoplankton biomass production (Pp)
Until the year 2000, water samples were taken at distinct depths and incubated at the sampling depth, attached to a drifting buoy (Andersson et al., 1996). CO2 fixation was measured at five depths by uptake of H14CO3− (2.1 mCi mmol−1; Danish Hydrological Institute®) by phytoplankton during 3 h incubation periods, as described in Steeman-Nielsen (1952). Depths used were 1, 2, 5, 10, and 20 m. Daily CO2 fixation was calculated by multiplying with the quotient of integrated diel light irradiance and irradiance during the incubation. Light irradiance in water was measured with a Li-Cor LI-193SA spherical sensor (Li-Cor Corporate Offices, Lincoln, NE, USA) and surface irradiance with a Li-Cor LI-190SA planar sensor (400–700 nm). Trapezoidal integration was used to calculate integrated values. From 2001, samples were collected with a 10 m hose and incubation was undertaken onboard the research ship in an ICES incubator with differently shaded incubation bottles (Riegman et al., 1990). Photosynthetic maximum (Pmax) and maximum light utilization coefficient (αP:I) was calculated by fitting data to a tangential equation according to Jassby & Platt (1976). Daily CO2 fixation was calculated from the parameters Pmax, αP:I, surface reflection of light (empirically derived 0.82) and hourly mean irradiance at given depths from light attenuation and irradiance below the sea surface. Values down to 20 m were modelled using calculated light irradiance at each depth and assuming estimated coefficients above 10 m to be applicable. Light attenuation was determined by fitting ln transformed data to Beer's law, taking deviating surface values, ship shadowing, and nonlinear data into account. Trapezoidal integration was used to calculate integrated values. Phytoplankton specific growth rate, rphyto, was calculated as the ratio of Pp and biomass of phytoplankton. This was measured by the Uthermöl technique in Lugol preserved samples, using a sedimentation chamber according to Andersson et al. (1996).
A calibration of the different incubation strategies showed no significant differences, according to a Model II regression of ln transformed data (correction factor = 1.08, 95% CI ± 0.27, n = 61); neither was a level shift in the time series observed at the time of method shift (Fig. S1).
Bacterioplankton biomass production (Pb)
Bacterioplankton biomass production rate was measured by uptake of 3H-Thymidine (85 Ci mmol−1; Amersham®; GE Healthcare, Buckinghamshire, UK) in 1.5 mL Eppendorf tubes (Smith & Azam, 1992). Thymidine uptake in natural samples during short incubations (1 h) in small volumes (1 mL) is specific for active heterotrophic bacteria, as shown by microautoradiography (Fuhrman & Azam, 1982). Thymidine uptake was converted to cells produced by an empirically derived factor of 1.4 × 1018 cells [mol 3H-Thymidine]−1 (±SE 0.1 × 1018, n = 73), calibrating the thymidine uptake to growth of the natural bacterial community (Wikner & Hagström, 1999). The carbon density per cell was determined by image analysis of acridine orange-stained cells and the published volume-to-carbon density functions (Norland, 1993; Blackburn et al., 1998). The ratio of bacterio- to phytoplankton biomass production rate was defined as the Pb:Pp ratio.
Data on precipitation was provided from the Swedish Meteorological and Hydrological Institute's regular monitoring program (SMHI, 2009). The station in Haparanda (lat. 65.84, long. 24.11) was representing the Bothnian Bay and Sundsvall airport (lat. 62.52, long. 17.44) represented the Bothnian Sea.
Riverine flow rate
Data on river flow was provided from the Swedish Meteorological and Hydrological Institute's regular monitoring program (SMHI, 2009). The hydrological database is generally based on daily (24 h) data of water flow (m3 s−1). In the studied sea area 157 stations, covering 30 major rivers in the drainage area, contributed to the drainage basin aggregated flow values. Water flow was measured by water-level gauges calibrated by current measurements in river cross-sections (Anonymous, 1979; Bergstrom & Carlsson, 1994). For smaller watercourses, artificial measuring weirs were used, and discharge calculated by hydraulic formulas. Monthly means have a reported error of ±5%.
Discharged total organic carbon, total nitrogen, and total phosphorus
Total organic carbon (TOCr), nitrogen (TNr), and phosphorus (TPr) in river water were measured by the Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, using standardized protocols within the Swedish monitoring program for river run-off (Demandt, 2009). Within this monitoring program, 25 major rivers in the drainage basins were measured at a single sampling station per river, per month. TOCr was analysed in HCL-acidified samples by high-temperature catalytic oxidation with a Shimadzu TOCr 5050® instrument (Peltzer et al., 1996). Total nitrogen and phosphorus were determined by oxidative digestion with peroxodisulfate and spectrophotometric analysis in a Technicon Autoanalyzer (Bran & Luebbe, Solna, Sweden), according to the International Organization for Standardization (ISO) 11905-1 and ISO 6878, respectively.
Load of riverine organic carbon to the sea
The discharge of total organic carbon (TOCr) was normalized to the sea basin area to harmonize with biomass production variables in units per area (Table 1). The TOCr was assumed to be uniformly distributed in each basin over the course of a year. For the Öre estuary, 10% of the TOCr was assumed to be metabolized in the estuary, as 90% has been shown to be exported to the off-shore areas of the Bothnian Sea (Forsgren & Jansson, 1992). Other sources of TOCr to the marine environment were assumed to be negligible (Sandberg et al., 2004).
Values from distinct depths were integrated by the trapezoidal method over the average water column in each basin (Table 1). Carbon dioxide fixation values were integrated to 20 m. Where measurements were not available to maximum depths, this value was extrapolated from closest relevant depths and stations to minimize integration differences. Yearly productivity values were calculated from daily values by using trapezoidal integrations.
Data was tested for normal distribution by the Shapiro–Wilks test, and for homogeneity of variances according to the Levene statistic, using SPSS® statistical software (v. 18; IBM Corporation, Armonk, NY, USA). Values were transformed when data differed from normal distribution. No significant autocorrelation was found for discharge of nutrients and freshwater values, according to analysis of the autocorrelation function (ACF) or partial autocorrelation function (PACF). An α value for Type I errors of 0.05 was applied. Tests were two-tailed in all cases, where appropriate. Exponential model coefficients (cf. Eqn (2)) and degree of determination was estimated by the curve estimation regression module in SPSS (v. 18). Model II linear regression was performed with a reduced major axis loss function and bootstrap estimate of coefficient standard error. Pearson or Spearman correlations were used, depending on the distribution of data. Choice of linear or nonlinear models was based on maximizing R2 and lack of dependence of residuals on the predicted values.
A cubic curve fit was applied using the SPSS® Curve estimation module to verify that the interannual dynamics with time (t) were significant, according to the model
Data sets which lagged 1 and 2 years were analyzed. The residuals were tested for autocorrelation in the SPSS® Forecasting module and random distribution by graphic plots. Where significant autocorrelation was observed, data were also applied to an autoregressive integrated model (ARI) with appropriate lag and difference of two. Degree of explanation, (R2), root mean squared error (RMSE) and other model quality measures in the SPSS® Fit syntax were used to assess the best model. Cubic curve models showed the best fit to observed data, except for Pb:Pp vs. time in the Bothnian Sea, where an ARI (4,2) model was used.
A combined standard uncertainty equation was applied to estimate the relative contribution of bacterial and phytoplankton community biomass production, respectively, to the change in Pb:Pp ratio, as outlined in the published guide to the expression of uncertainty in measurement (GUM, 2008, Eq. 10).
All marine data are archived in the regional database dBotnia at Umeå Marine Sciences Centre (http://www.umf.umu.se) and the Swedish national marine database at the Swedish Meteorological and Hydrological Institute (SMHI).
- Top of page
- Materials and methods
- Supporting Information
The annual precipitation showed an elevated level between 1998 and 2001 over the drainage and sea area for both the Bothnian Bay and Bothnian Sea (Fig. S2). The value for year 2000 in the latter area (846.6 mm) was the highest precipitation recorded since 1930 (SMHI, 2009). A natural pulse of freshwater discharge consequently occurred during the years 1998–2001 in northern Scandinavia, when the discharge was higher than in adjacent years (Fig. 2; Table 2). The freshwater input was 1.3–1.8 times higher during this high-flow period than during 1994–1997 (ANOVA Bonferroni post hoc test, P < 0.033 in all cases, n = 4). For the Bothnian Sea in the northern Baltic, the flow rates for three out of these 4 years were close to the highest recorded in a 40 year time series, with a peak value 21% higher than the long-term average (91 km3 yr−1) (Bergstrom & Carlsson, 1994).
|1994–1997 (a)||1998–2001 (b)||2002–2006 (c)||a vs. b||b vs. c||a vs. c|
|River flow (km3 yr−1)||52||70||53||0.033||0.032||1|
|Total C (106 kg yr−1)||258||440||283||0.019||0.033||1|
|Total N (106 kg yr−1)||15||24||17||0.009||0.24||1|
|Total P (106 kg yr−1)||1.0||1.1||0.74||1||0.156||0.334|
|River flow (km3 yr−1)||0.85||1.5||0.98||0.011||0.03||1|
|Total C (106 kg yr−1)||8.8||18||11||0.022||0.081||1.000|
|Total N (106 kg yr−1)||0.35||0.61||0.44||0.018||0.114||0.688|
|Total P (106 kg yr−1)||0.028||0.034||0.022||1||0.661||1|
|River flow (km3 yr−1)||68||99||53||0.033||0.032||1.00|
|Total C (106 kg yr−1)||375||663||424||0.008||0.017||1.00|
|Total N (106 kg yr−1)||22||35||24||0.007||0.014||1.00|
|Total P (106 kg yr−1)||0.92||1.3||0.70||0.097||0.006||0.45|
Total organic carbon (TOCr) and total nitrogen (TNr) load showed a strong correlation with flow rate, explaining the major part of their interannual variation (linear regression, R2 > 0.92, P < 0.001 for all basins, n = 13) (On-line data base Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences). The flow rate also explained a large but somewhat smaller part of the variation in total phosphorus (TP, R2 > 0.40, P < 0.021). The variation in flow rate in Fig. 2 therefore also indicates the major variation in load of TOCr, TNr, and to some extent TPr to the marine environment.
The load of TNr and TOCr was significantly higher in all basins during 1998–2001 than in the preceding period (P > 0.018, ANOVA with Bonferroni's post hoc test, Table 2). For TPr, only the P-value for the Bothnian Sea (0.097) approached the applied significance level. Nonetheless, the mean value of P load during 1998–2001 was 7.7%, 21%, and 41% greater than the preceding period, in the Bothnian Bay, Öre estuary, and Bothnian Sea, respectively. The result showed that interannual variability in P load was too great to be able to detect statistically this magnitude of difference. No significant change in the C:N ratio between the periods could be shown. However, the C:P ratio of discharged material increased during the studied period by about 50% in the Bothnian Bay and Bothnian Sea (Bonferroni test, P = 0.005, n = 4), while the 26% increase in the Öre estuary could not be shown to be significant (n = 4).
We demonstrated a significant shift in the ratio between bacterioplankton biomass production and phytoplankton biomass production (Pb:Pp, i.e., ‘trophic balance’) associated with the freshwater pulse (Fig. 2; Table S1). A cubic curve fit verified a statistically significant peak after year 2000 in the Bothnian Bay (R2 = 0.60, P = 0.034) and the Öre estuary (R2 = 0.67, P = 0.014), while an autoregressive ARI (1, 1) model was significant in the Bothnian Sea (R2 = 0.40, P = 0.037). The first derivative at value zero suggested the maximum was at year 2002 at all sites (graphic determination for the ARI model). A lag of 2 years between river discharge and response in Pb:Pp ratio was indicated in the time series (Fig. 2). Comparing 1994–1997 to 1998–2001, the relative importance of microbial heterotrophic productivity increased in all studied sites by a factor of 1.3–2.6. Five years after the end of the high flow period (2004–2006), the Pb:Pp ratio was still skewed towards heterotrophy in the Bothnian Sea (Table S1, t-test, t = −2.82, df = 4, P = 0.048). In the Bothnian Bay and Öre estuary basins, the Pb:Pp ratio was not significantly different during 2004–2006 compared to the level before the flow peak.
Maximum and minimum values of Pb:Pp had a ratio of between five and seven depending on the site, showing that variation in trophic balance in the coastal ecosystem may be substantial (Table S1). However, the interannual variability in the Pb:Pp ratio appeared steadier before the peak flow, independent of site (±CV = 25%, 1994–1997). Consequently, even a relatively modest increase in river flow, amounting to 32–76% of the 1994–1997 rate (albeit +21% of the long term average), had a major effect on the coastal Pb:Pp ratio in our case study.
The importance of microbial heterotrophic processes (Pb:Pp) increased exponentially with increased discharge of riverine TOC to the coastal zone (TOCr), when lagged +2 years according to the model
This was valid for all sites, based on statistically significant coefficients from an exponential regression (Fig. S3, Table 3). TOCr explained a significant part of the variation (i.e., R2) in Pb:Pp at all sites, with the highest value at the coastal site. The y-intercepts were significant in the Bothnian Bay and Öre estuary. Only the b coefficient in the Öre estuary was different from the off-shore basins, based on 2 × SE, a consequence of the higher TOCr to this coastal site. A model II linear regression also showed significantly positive slope coefficients (data not shown).
|(−)||([g C]−1 m2 yr)|
|Basin||a||SE (a)||P (a)||b||SE (b)||P (b)||n|
Most of the change in Pb:Pp was due to a decrease in phytoplankton biomass production, rather than an increase in bacterioplankton biomass production (Fig. S1). A variance component analysis (standard uncertainty calculation) suggested that, on average, 71% of the variation in the Pb:Pp ratio was due to the decrease in phytoplankton biomass production and 29% was due to increase in bacterioplankton biomass production (Table S2). The difference between minimum and maximum phytoplankton annual production was also unexpectedly large, threefold to sixfold depending on sea basin (Fig. S1). However, where more freshwater discharge promoted increased input of TNr and TPr, and thus potentially increased phytoplankton production, our data showed that it instead decreased (Fig. S1; Table 2).
To test for a potential effect on phytoplankton due the change in growth conditions, rphyto was analyzed with specific TOCr discharge by a model II regression and Pearson correlation (Fig. 3). This showed a significant negative relationship for both the Öre estuary (P < 0.05, R2 = 0.46) and the Bothnian Sea (P < 0.05, R2 = 0.32). The Bothnian Bay did, however, not show a significant correlation, while a negative slope coefficient was demonstrated (P < 0.05).
- Top of page
- Materials and methods
- Supporting Information
Increased precipitation around the millennium shift caused a marked increase in freshwater discharge during a few years, and also direct input of freshwater and nutrients to the sea surface by rain (Figs 3 and 4). By using this extreme peak flow of river water in a 40 year time series, in conjunction with long-term ecological marine time series data, we demonstrated a marked shift from autotrophy (Pb:Pp < 1) to heterotrophy (Pb:Pp > 1) in three coastal sites (Fig. 2; Table S1). At all sites, the Pb:Pp ratio was positively correlated with the load of TOCr (Fig. S3; Table 3). This result showed that the net effect of increased freshwater flow to the marine environment hampered phytoplankton biomass production, while bacterial biomass production was maintained. This observation was unexpected considering that increased river flow was accompanied by an increase in TNr and TPr, implying increased phytoplankton biomass production on mineralized nutrients. However, the observed effect may be explained by including influence of freshwater, TOCr, and bacterioplankton growth in production models for the coastal ecosystem, as outlined below.
The discharge of riverine TOC was a major driver of the Pb:Pp ratio at all sites, assuming some contribution to the remaining variation from random measurement variance (R2-values, Fig. S3). The slope coefficients were not significantly different between the off-shore basins, suggesting a similar response on trophic balance from increased TOCr discharge. The markedly lower slope coefficient for the coastal Öre estuary reflects the markedly higher specific load of riverine TOC at this coastal site. However, due to the correlation between TOCr and freshwater discharge (R2 > 0.92), either factor may still contribute to explain the observed change in trophic balance. The degree of explanation was slightly lower in the off-shore basins when using freshwater discharge as the independent variable, and the slope coefficient for the Bothnian Sea was not significantly different from zero. This indicates a specific importance of discharged TOCr for the observed effects. Other variables investigated to explain the variability in the Pb:Pp ratio, such as the C:P ratio in river discharge, marine nutrient concentrations or global photosynthetically active irradiation, did not show significant correlation in any basin (data not shown). The only exception was marine inorganic nitrogen, which showed a positive relationship with Pb:Pp in the Bothnian Sea (r = 0.80, P = 0.02).
Our results suggest that the suppression of phytoplankton biomass production explained a greater proportion (71%) of the change in Pb:Pp ratio than an increase in bacterial biomass production (Table S2). Therefore, an explanation of the change in Pb:Pp ratio should be primarily sought in the control of phytoplankton biomass production. One contributing reason for the lack of a positive response in phytoplankton biomass production was that increased freshwater flow mainly increased the TOCr and TNr load, while an increase in TPr was moderate and not statistically significant (Fig. S1; Table 2). Thus, the increase in the major limiting nutrient, phosphorus, was lower relative to other nutrients, at elevated flows of freshwater. Phosphorus is considered the limiting nutrient in most of this study area, while a shift to nitrogen limitation occurs in the southern Bothnian Sea (Zweifel et al., 1993; Andersson et al., 1996). Total nutrient and carbon pools were used, as these also encompass organic and particulate fractions, assumed to be largely available also to osmotrophs by phagotrophy, mineralization, and photolysis in the food web during the long time scales investigated (Kieber et al., 1990; Sandberg et al., 2004).
The lag applied in Table 3 means that the TOCr discharge at a given year resulted in a full effect showing in the trophic balance 2 years later (Fig. 2). Based on the primary data, this is caused by the reduced bacterial biomass production in the first year of high freshwater discharge (year 1998, Fig. S1). The Pb then successively increased to preflow level or above, also elevating the Pb:Pp ratio. A hypothesis to explain the observed lag period may be that initially recalcitrant carbon and nutrient substrates (organic and particle bound), are gradually made available by exudates released during phagotrophy of particles, mineralization, and photolytic cleavage of dissolved organically bound nitrogen and phosphorus, when exposed to the marine environment (Pengerud et al., 1987; Kieber et al., 1990; Thingstad et al., 1993). In addition a change in bacterioplankton diversity, as an adaptation to the newly available substrate resources, may gradually promote a more efficient metabolism of the terrigenous substrates, based on observations in culture studies (Kisand et al., 2002). The response of the phytoplankton specific growth rate (i.e., rphyto), in contrast, was immediate, as shown by a significant relationship with TOCr discharge, without lag, discussed below (Fig. 3).
Field data supported the hypothesis that growth limitation of phytoplankton was present because of a significant negative relationship between rphyto and specific TOCr discharge (Fig. 3). The realized rphyto is expected to decrease with enhanced competition, and thus, in this case, with increased Pb:Pp. The strongest influence of TOCr (i.e., highest slope coefficient) occurred in the Bothnian Sea, suggesting this basin to be most sensitive to elevated freshwater discharge. The negative effect on rphyto could, however, also result from other factors, e.g., reduced effective light climate as a consequence of discharged coloured and suspended matter, or changed stratification (Howarth et al., 2000; Hessen et al., 2010). This was based on that the results were almost identical when using freshwater discharge as the independent variable (data not shown). We can only speculate that the lack of a significant correlation in the Bothnian Bay was due to the smaller contribution of phytoplankton community growth to the observed change in trophic balance in this basin (Table S2).
The effect of freshwater discharge on phytoplankton growth without lag suggested an influence of factors in the discharge which exerted an immediate action (Figs 3 and S1). Discharge of coloured humic substance, suspended material and a deeper mixed layer, reducing the effective light climate for phytoplankton, are all in synergy and expected to act without a time lag on the annual scale (Cole et al., 1992; Howarth et al., 2000; Hessen et al., 2010). This explanation is also in accordance with model analyses, suggesting light limitation to override nutrient limitation in deeper and better mixed water columns (Jager et al., 2010). The simultaneously increased load of carbon to the coastal zone provided another, synergistic, explanation for the shift in carbon balance, and reduction in phytoplankton biomass production. Riverine dissolved organic carbon is an alternate carbon source of phytoplankton released carbon for the heterotrophic bacteria (Zweifel et al., 1993; Wikner et al., 1999). This may have promoted a competition between bacterio- and phytoplankton for inorganic nutrients, where the former has superior affinity for these substrates (Pengerud et al., 1987; Mindl et al., 2005). As bacterioplankton community growth showed a lag of 2 years, competition for limiting nutrients is, however, not likely to explain the initial reduction in phytoplankton growth (Fig. S1). When the bacterioplankton community with time became better able to exploit the more riverine-influenced carbon source the competition scenario may have contributed by adding a synergistic hampering effect on phytoplankton production. Simultaneous discharge of elements such as Fe associated with TOCr discharge may in addition, by chemical binding, have reduced the available pool of PO43− for phytoplankton (Blomqvist et al., 2004). Consequently, reduced access to mineral nutrients may also explain the hampered phytoplankton biomass production. The relative importance of changed light conditions for phytoplankton and competition of limiting nutrient was however not investigated in this study.
Similar studies of the composite effects of discharged carbon, nitrogen, and phosphorus on trophic balance in the coastal zone are scarce in the literature, especially given the datasets cover large temporal and spatial scales. In a long-term study of the Hudson estuary, Howarth et al. (2000) stressed the importance of climate drivers, such as freshwater discharge, on primary production. Similar to our findings, primary production was suppressed at higher levels of freshwater discharge in their study, primarily explained by weaker stratification and light penetration. Caraco & Cole (2003) also reported a tenfold lower ratio of de novo gross primary production to allochthonous organic load during a wet year than a dry one in the Hudson River, in agreement with our conclusions. In an estuary-lagoon system in eastern Brazil, increased freshwater flow was found to stimulate bacterial production while hampering primary production, with a resulting Pb:Pp ratio of up to 20 during the rainy season (Barrera-Alba et al., 2009). Our findings were also in line with the ‘Thingstad-paradox’ observed in an Arctic mesocosm experiment, in which addition of carbon substrate led to a lower accumulation of carbon in the system, due to hampered phytoplankton biomass production (Thingstad et al., 2008). Similar results are reported from the Hunter Estuary, Australia, where addition of glucose reduced chlorophyll-a concentration, while increasing bacterial abundance and respiration (Hitchcock et al., 2010). In shallow unproductive lakes increased load of terrigenous dissolved organic carbon (DOC) is also responsible for hampering total lake productivity (Karlsson et al., 2009). Thus, our results add support to an emerging picture of TOC availability as an important, but counterintuitive, controller of aquatic productivity. This study contributes by showing the importance of riverine TOC for the coastal zone at large temporal and spatial scales. It also provides evidence for a general relationship between the riverine TOC supply and Pb:Pp ratio of the coastal sea.
The explanatory model outlined above seems mainly associated with estuaries at temporal scales from seasonal to annual. In short-term studies of freshwater plumes entering directly into oceanic waters (i.e., Strait of Georgia, Bay of Bengal), a stimulating effect on primary production has been reported (Harrison et al., 1991; Gomes et al., 2000). Effects were, however, reported to alternate between negative and positive, depending on the temporal scale in one particular environment. Thus, in oceanic environments positive effects of freshwater plumes on plankton productivity are possible, suggesting a lower negative influence of the freshwater and TOC supply on phytoplankton growth in these environments.
We consider the bacterial and phytoplankton biomass production ratio to have sufficient accuracy when estimating the distribution of major pelagic carbon flows (i.e., microbial hetero- vs. autotrophic processes). Phyto- and bacterioplankton biomass production clearly dominates the marine food web carbon flow, and are therefore pivotal factors in coastal ecosystem function (Kemp et al., 1997; Sandberg et al., 2004). Pb:Pp values have further been shown to give similar results to alternative methods using mass balances or oxygen models in estimating net ecosystem metabolism, net CO2 emission and net heterotrophy (Stigebrandt, 1991; Kemp et al., 1997; Sandberg et al., 2004). It is also well documented that increase in bacterial biomass production will promote carbon flow through the multi-trophic level protozoan dominated food chain, with associated respiration losses (Pengerud et al., 1987; Wikner & Hagström, 1988; Sandberg et al., 2004; Berglund et al., 2007). Lower fish production and sedimentation is thereby expected, compared to the shorter food chain associated with the flow of phytoplankton biomass directly through the mesozooplankton community. Bacterio- and phytoplankton biomass production are therefore key processes for the trophic balance and food web efficiency of the coastal sea.
The found relationship between riverine discharge of TOC and coastal trophic balance suggests that increased precipitation, and the resulting higher load of freshwater and terrigenous TOC, will lead to a food web dominated by heterotrophic microorganisms (Sandberg et al., 2004; Berglund et al., 2007; Fig. 4). As production of organic matter by phytoplankton is simultaneously suppressed, a lowered supply of food to fish and benthic organisms is expected (Nixon, 1988; Berglund et al., 2007; Finkel et al., 2010). Our view of the effect of precipitation on coastal productivity is thus opposite to recent assessments of climate-change effects for the Baltic Sea (Neumann, 2010). Neumanns's model study suggested an increase in phytoplankton biomass of 5% and extended growth season at elevated precipitation based on the classical view of phytoplankton growth limited only by phosphorus or nitrogen. Influence of freshwater discharge on pelagic stratification, light climate, and concentration of riverine TOC should therefore be included in current models for coastal management and resource utilization (e.g., mitigation of eutrophication and allowable fish catch), as well as in forecasting the consequences of climate change (Fig. 4). Supply of nitrogen and phosphorus alone are insufficient to accurately predict coastal productivity.
- Top of page
- Materials and methods
- Supporting Information
We give credit to the technical staff at Umeå Marine Sciences Centre and the Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences who have collected and analyzed the field data over the years. The field sampling at sea was made possible by Umeå Marine Sciences Centre and the Swedish Coastguard in the northern region, providing both ship time and support at sea. We are grateful to Peter Anton, Department of Mathematics and Mathematical Statistics, Umeå University, for use of the combined standard uncertainty calculation. Owen Rowe is acknowledged for carefully checking the language, and Kristina Viklund for the map and explanatory model diagram. Sverker Evans at the Swedish Environmental Protection Agency is acknowledged for continuous support by funding long-term time series through Swedish national environmental monitoring. We are grateful for the constructive remarks by the editor and reviewers contributing to the final quality of this manuscript. J.W. was provided financial support from the Kempe Foundation. A.A. was given scientific support by a grant from the Swedish Research Council for Environment, Agricultural Sciences and Spatial Planning.
- Top of page
- Materials and methods
- Supporting Information
- 1996) Succession and growth limitation of phytoplankton in the Gulf of Bothnia (Baltic Sea). Marine Biology, 126, 791–801. , , , , (
- Anonymous (1979) Streamflow Records of Sweden. Swedish Meteorological and Hydrological Institute, Stockholm, Sweden.
- 2009) Influence of allochthonous organic matter on bacterioplankton biomass and activity in a eutrophic, sub-tropical estuary. Estuarine Coastal and Shelf Science, 82, 84–94. , , , (
- 2007) Efficiency of a phytoplankton-based and a bacteria-based food web in a pelagic marine system. Limnology and Oceanography, 52, 121–131. , , , (
- 1994) River runoff to the Baltic sea – 1950–1990. Ambio, 23, 280–287. , (
- 1998) Rapid determination of bacterial abundance, biovolume, morphology and growth by neural network-based image analysis. Applied and Environmental Microbiology, 64, 3246–3255. , , , , (
- 2004) Why the limiting nutrient differs between temperate coastal seas and freshwater lakes: a matter of salt. Limnology and Oceanography, 49, 2236–2241. , , (
- 1992) Wave-induced sediment resuspension in the Öre estuary, northern Sweden. Hydrobiologia, 235, 71–83. (
- 2003) Hydrologic control of external carbon loads and primary production in the tidal freshwater Hudson. In: Conference on Hudson River Fishes and their Environment (ed Waldman JR, Limburg KE, Strayer DL), pp. 63–74. American Fisheries Society, Poughkeepsie, NY. , (
- 1992) Can phytoplankton maintain a positive carbon balance in a turbid, freshwater, tidal estuary. Limnology and Oceanography, 37, 1608–1617. , , (
- 2009) Vattenkemiska och -fysikaliska analysmetoder. Geokemiska laboratoriet, SLU, Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, Uppsala, Sweden. Available at: http://www.ma.slu.se/ShowPage.cfm?OrgenhetSida_ID=11081 [Waterchemical and -physical analytical methods.] (accessed 15 February 2010). (
- 2005) Climate change and changes in global precipitation patterns: what do we know? Environment International, 31, 1167–1181. (
- 2010) Phytoplankton in a changing world: cell size and elemental stoichiometry. Journal of Plankton Research, 32, 119–137. , , , , , (
- 1992) The turnover of river-transported iron, phosphorus and organic carbon in the Öre estuary, northern Sweden. Hydrobiologia, 235/236, 585–596. , (
- 1982) Thymidine incorporation as a measure of heterotrophic bacterioplankton production in marine surface waters: evaluation and field results. Marine Biology, 66, 109–120. , (
- 2005) Seasonality of coastal phytoplankton in the Baltic Sea: influence of salinity and eutrophication. Estuarine Coastal and Shelf Science, 65, 239–252. , , et al. (
- 2000) Influence of physical processes and freshwater discharge on the seasonality of phytoplankton regime in the Bay of Bengal. Continental Shelf Research, 20, 313–330. , , (
- GUM (2008) Guide to the Expression of Uncertainty in Measurement. International organisation for standardization, Joint committee for Guides in Metrology, Geneva, Switzerland.
- 1991) Nutrient and plankton dynamics in the Fraser-river plume, Strait of Georgia, British-Columbia. Marine Ecology-Progress Series, 70, 291–304. , , et al. (
- 2010) Input of organic carbon as determinant of nutrient fluxes, light climate and productivity in the Ob and Yenisey estuaries. Estuarine Coastal and Shelf Science, 88, 53–62. , , , , , , (
- 2010) Responses of estuarine bacterioplankton, phytoplankton and zooplankton to dissolved organic carbon (DOC) and inorganic nutrient additions. Estuaries and Coasts, 33, 78–91. , , , (
- 2000) Climatic control on eutrophication of the Hudson River estuary. Ecosystems, 3, 210–215. , , , (
- 1981) Quaternary geology of the Baltic Sea. In: The Baltic Sea (ed. Voipio A), pp. 54–104. Elsevier, Amsterdam, the Netherlands. , , , (
- 2008) Influence of water-column depth and mixing on phytoplankton biomass, community composition, and nutrients. Limnology and Oceanography, 53, 2361–2373. , , (
- 2010) Physical determinants of phytoplankton production, algal stoichiometry, and vertical nutrient fluxes. American Naturalist, 175, E51–E104. , , (
- 1976) Mathematical formulation of relationship between photosynthesis and light for phytoplankton. Limnology and Oceanography, 21, 540–547. , (
- 2009) Light limitation of nutrient-poor lake ecosystems. Nature, 460, 506–580. , , , , , (
- 1997) Organic carbon balance and net ecosystem metabolism in Chesapeake Bay. Marine Ecology-Progress Series, 150, 229–248. , , , (
- 1990) Formation of carbonyl compounds from UV-induced photodegradation of humic substances in natural waters: fate of riverine organic carbon in the sea. Limnology and Oceanography, 35, 1503–1515. , , (
- 2002) Phylogeny of culturable estuarine bacteria catabolizing riverine organic matter in the northern Baltic Sea. Applied Environmental Microbiology, 68, 379–388. , , (
- 1985) Eutrophication and the Baltic Sea: causes and consequences. Ambio, 14, 9–14. , , (
- 2006) Baltic Sea climate in the late twenty-first century: a dynamical downscaling approach using two global models and two emission scenarios. Climate Dynamics, 27, 39–68. (
- 2005) Effects of phosphorus loading on interactions of algae and bacteria: reinvestigation of the ‘phytoplankton-bacteria paradox’ in a continuous cultivation system. Aquatic Microbial Ecology, 38, 203–213. , , , , , (
- 2010) Climate-change effects on the Baltic Sea ecosystem: a model study. Journal of Marine Systems, 81, 213–224. (
- 1988) Physical energy inputs and the comparative ecology of lake and marine ecosystems. Limnology and Oceanography, 33, 1005–1025. (
- 1993) The relationship between biomass and volume of bacteria. In: Handbook of Methods in Aquatic Microbial Ecology (eds Kemp PF, Sherr BF, Sherr EB, Cole JJ), pp. 303–307. Lewis Publishers, Boca Raton, FL. (
- 1996) A comparison of methods for the measurement of dissolved organic carbon in natural waters. Marine Chemistry, 54, 85–96. , , , , , (
- 1987) The reciprocal interaction between degradation of glucose and ecosystem structure. Studies in mixed chemostat cultures of marine bacteria, and bacterivorous nanoflagellates. Marine Ecology-Progress Series, 35, 111–117. , , (
- 2002) Nutrient-enhanced productivity in the northern Gulf of Mexico: past, present and future. Hydrobiologia, 475, 39–63. , , , , , (
- 1998) Prey fish exploitation, salmonine production, and pelagic food web efficiency in Lake Ontario. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences, 55, 318–327. , (
- 1990) Primary production of phytoplankton at a frontal zone located at the northern slope of the Dogger-bank (North-sea). Marine Biology, 105, 329–336. , , (
- 2004) Pelagic food web and carbon budget in the northern Baltic Sea: potential importance of terrigenous carbon. Marine Ecology-Progress Series, 268, 13–29. , , , (
- SMHI (2009) Sveriges Oceanografiska Datacenter (SwedODC). SMHI, Norrköping, Sweden. Available at: http://www.smhi.se/cmp/jsp/polopoly.jsp?d=5431&l=sv [Swedish Oceanographic Datacenter] (accessed 1 May 2009).
- 2006) Responses of estuarine and coastal marine phytoplankton to nitrogen and phosphorus enrichment. Limnology and Oceanography, 51, 377–384. (
- 1992) A simple, economical method for measuring bacterial protein synthesis rates in seawater using 3H-leucine. Marine Microbial Foodwebs, 6, 107–114. , (
- 1952) The use of radioactive (14C) for measuring organic production in the sea. Journal du Conseil International pour l'Exploration de la Mer, 18, 117–140. (
- 1991) Computations of oxygen fluxes through the sea surface and the net production of organic matter with application to the Baltic sea and adjacent areas. Limnology and Oceanography, 36, 444–454. (
- Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences. Data Host for Inland Waters (2009) Uppsala, Sweden. Available at: http://www.slu.se/en/faculties/nl/about-the-faculty/departments/department-of-aquatic-sciences-and-assessment/ (accessed 10 May 2009).
- 1993) Phosphorus cycling and algal-bacterial competition in Sandsfjord, western Norway. Marine Ecology-Progress Series, 9, 9. , , (
- 2008) Counterintuitive carbon-to-nutrient coupling in an Arctic pelagic ecosystem. Nature, 455, 387–390. , , et al. (
- 1988) Evidence for a tightly coupled nanoplanktonic predator-prey link regulating the bacterivores in the marine enviroment. Marine Ecology-Progress Series, 50, 137–145. , (
- 1999) Bacterioplankton intra-annual variability at various allochthonous loading: importance of hydrography and competition. Aquatic Microbial Ecology, 20, 245–260. , (
- 1999) Differences in consumption of allochtonous DOC at limnic and estuarine conditions in a watershed. Aquatic Microbial Ecology, 17, 289–299. , , (
- 1990) Nutrient dynamics of the Baltic Sea. Ambio, 19, 126–133. , , (
- 1993) Consumption of dissolved organic carbon by marine bacteria and demand for inorganic nutrients. Marine Ecology-Progress Series, 101, 23–32. , , (
- Top of page
- Materials and methods
- Supporting Information
|gcb2718-sup-0001-FigureS1.docx||Word document||180K||Figure S1. Annual phytoplankton- and bacterioplankton biomass production rate during the investigation period.|
|gcb2718-sup-0002-FigureS2.docx||Word document||180K||Figure S2. Annual precipitation at representative stations in the Bothnian Bay and Bothnian Sea drainage areas, respectively.|
|gcb2718-sup-0003-FigureS3.docx||Word document||180K||Figure S3. Trophic balance (Pb:Pp-ratio) as a function of specific TOC discharge with a 2 year lag.|
|gcb2718-sup-0004-TableS1.docx||Word document||180K||Table S1. Statistics and comparison of the Pb:Pp ratio between time periods (a–c).|
|gcb2718-sup-0005-TableS2.docx||Word document||180K||Table S2. Variance contribution from phytoplankton (Vp) and bacterioplankton biomass production (1-Vp), respectively, to the variation in the Pb:Pp ratio (VB:P).|
Please note: Wiley Blackwell is not responsible for the content or functionality of any supporting information supplied by the authors. Any queries (other than missing content) should be directed to the corresponding author for the article.