In vitro antibacterial action of Tetraclean, MTAD and five experimental irrigation solutions
Article first published online: 4 MAY 2010
© 2010 International Endodontic Journal
International Endodontic Journal
Volume 43, Issue 6, pages 528–535, June 2010
How to Cite
Pappen, F. G., Shen, Y., Qian, W., Leonardo, M. R., Giardino, L. and Haapasalo, M. (2010), In vitro antibacterial action of Tetraclean, MTAD and five experimental irrigation solutions. International Endodontic Journal, 43: 528–535. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2591.2010.01712.x
- Issue published online: 4 MAY 2010
- Article first published online: 4 MAY 2010
- Received 6 July 2009; accepted 10 February 2010
- Enterococcus faecalis;
Pappen FG, Shen Y, Qian W, Leonardo MR, Giardino L, Haapasalo M.In vitro antibacterial action of Tetraclean, MTAD and five experimental irrigation solutions. International Endodontic Journal, 43, 528–535, 2010.
Aim To investigate the antibacterial effect of Tetraclean, MTAD and five experimental irrigants using both direct exposure test with planktonic cultures and mixed-species in vitro biofilm model.
Methodology Tetraclean, MTAD and five experimental solutions that were modifications of existing formulae including MTAD + 0.01% cetrimide (CTR), MTAD + 0.1% CTR, MTAC-1 (Tween 80 replaced by 0.01% CTR in MTAD), MTAC-2 (Tween 80 replaced by 0.1% CTR) and MTAD-D (MTAD without the Tween 80 and no CTR added) were used as disinfectants in the experiments. In the direct exposure test, a suspension of Enterococcus faecalis was mixed with each of the solutions. After 0.5, 1, 3 and 10 min, an inactivator was added and the number of surviving bacteria was calculated. A mixed-species biofilm from subgingival plaque bacteria was grown in brain heart infusion broth in anaerobic conditions on synthetic hydroxyapatite discs. Two-week-old biofilms were exposed to the solutions for 0.5, 1 and 3 min. The samples were observed by confocal laser scanning microscopy after bacterial viability staining. The scans were quantitatively analysed, and the volume of killed cells of all cells was calculated for each medicament.
Results Tetraclean and MTAC-2 (0.1% CTR) killed planktonic E. faecalis in <30 s. Complete killing of bacteria required 1 min by MTAC-1, 3 min by MTAD + 0.1% CTR and 10 min by MTAD, MTAD-D and MTAD + 0.01% CTR. In the biofilm test, there were significant differences in microbial killing between the different solutions and times of exposure (P < 0.005). MTAC-2 showed the best performance, killing 71% of the biofilm bacteria in 3 min, followed by MTAC-1 and Tetraclean. MTAD and the three MTAD modifications demonstrated the lowest antibacterial activity.
Conclusion Tetraclean was more effective than MTAD against E. faecalis in planktonic culture and in mixed-species in vitro biofilm. CTR improved the antimicrobial properties of the solutions, whereas Tween 80 seemed to have a neutral or negative impact on their antimicrobial effectiveness.