These authors contributed equally to this study.
HopPtoN is a Pseudomonas syringae Hrp (type III secretion system) cysteine protease effector that suppresses pathogen-induced necrosis associated with both compatible and incompatible plant interactions
Article first published online: 31 AUG 2004
Volume 54, Issue 2, pages 353–365, October 2004
How to Cite
López-Solanilla, E., Bronstein, P. A., Schneider, A. R. and Collmer, A. (2004), HopPtoN is a Pseudomonas syringae Hrp (type III secretion system) cysteine protease effector that suppresses pathogen-induced necrosis associated with both compatible and incompatible plant interactions. Molecular Microbiology, 54: 353–365. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2958.2004.04285.x
- Issue published online: 6 SEP 2004
- Article first published online: 31 AUG 2004
- Received 22 June, 2004.
Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato DC3000 causes bacterial speck disease in tomato, and it elicits the hypersensitive response (HR) in non-host plants such as Nicotiana tabacum and Nicotiana benthamiana. The compatible and incompatible interactions of DC3000 with tomato and Nicotiana spp., respectively, result in plant cell death, but the HR cell death occurs more rapidly and is associated with effective plant defense. Both interactions require the Hrp (HR and pathogenicity) type III secretion system (TTSS), which injects Hop (Hrp outer protein) effectors into plant cells. Here, we demonstrate that HopPtoN is translocated into tomato cells via the Hrp TTSS. A hopPtoN mutant produced eightfold more necrotic ‘speck’ lesions on tomato leaves than did DC3000, but the mutant and the wild-type strain grew to the same level in infected leaves. In non-host N. tabacum leaves, the hopPtoN mutant produced more cell death, whereas a DC3000 strain overexpressing HopPtoN produced less cell death and associated electrolyte leakage in comparison with wild-type DC3000. Transient expression of HopPtoN via infection with a PVX viral vector enabled tomato and N. benthamiana plants to tolerate, with reduced disease lesions, challenge infections with DC3000 and P. syringae pv. tabaci 11528, respectively. HopPtoN showed cysteine protease activity in vitro, and hopPtoN mutants altered in the predicted cysteine protease catalytic triad (C172S, H283A and D299A) lost HR suppression activity. These observations reveal that HopPtoN is a TTSS effector that can suppress plant cell death events in both compatible and incompatible interactions.
Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato (Pst) DC3000 is the causal agent of bacterial speck of tomato and Arabidopsis, and it multiplies to high levels and causes necrotic lesions on the leaves, stems, and fruits of infected plants. Like many strains of P. syringae, DC3000 also elicits the hypersensitive response (HR) in non-host plants such as tobacco (Klement et al., 1964; Fouts et al., 2003). The HR is a rapid, localized, defense-associated, programmed cell death triggered by the recognition of a plant pathogen. The relationship between the plant cell death events associated with the HR (incompatible interactions) and with disease (compatible interactions) is unclear at this point, but both plant responses require Pst to have a functional type III secretion system (TTSS), which is encoded by hrp (HR and pathogenicity) and hrc (HR and conserved) genes. Type III secretion systems are found in a wide variety of plant and animal pathogens, where they function to inject bacterial effector proteins into the cytosol of eukaryotic cells. Once inside the host cell, the effectors alter cellular processes to the advantage of the pathogen.
Pst DC3000 appears to carry at least 40 TTSS effector genes (Collmer et al., 2002; Buell et al., 2003; Greenberg and Vinatzer, 2003; Schechter et al., 2004). Only a few P. syringae effector genes have been shown to have a loss-of-function virulence phenotype (Ritter and Dangl, 1995; Badel et al., 2003; Bretz et al., 2003; Espinosa et al., 2003), apparently because of functional redundancy among the effectors. However, many effector genes have strong gain-of-function avirulence (Avr) phenotypes associated with gene-for-gene interactions that control the cultivar-specific resistance of some crop species against specific races of the pathogen. In these pathosystems, incompatible pathogen races produce an Avr (effector) protein that is recognized by a cognate R gene product in the resistant cultivar, which results in elicitation of the HR and in avirulence (Keen, 1990).
P. syringae is divided into more than 50 groups known as pathovars, based on specificity for host species. For example, DC3000 is in pathovar tomato and is avirulent on soybean and many other crop species. This broader limitation in host range may result from the defensive recognition of multiple effectors by plant species that are non-hosts for a given pathovar, a hypothesis that is supported by the finding that various soybean cultivars can detect several Pst effectors, any one of which elicits the HR (Kobayashi et al., 1989). The role of TTSS effector proteins as Avr determinants in incompatible interactions has been particularly well studied, but we know much less about the function of these proteins in compatible interactions (Dangl and Jones, 2001; Martin et al., 2003; Chang et al., 2004).
Avirulence phenotypes provided the first means to identify TTSS effectors in P. syringae (Keen, 1990), but many recently identified P. syringae TTSS effectors have been found on the basis of their ability to travel the TTSS pathway (Badel et al., 2002; Collmer et al., 2002; Guttman et al., 2002; Petnicki-Ocwieja et al., 2002; Schechter et al., 2004). These effectors have accordingly been designated as Hops (Hrp outer proteins) (Alfano and Collmer, 1997). Many Hops have characteristic patterns in their N-terminal 50 amino acids. The patterns include an isoleucine, leucine, valine, alanine, or proline in the third or fourth amino acid position, a high percentage of serine in the first 50 amino acids, and the absence of acidic residues within the first 12 amino acids of the protein (Guttman et al., 2002; Petnicki-Ocwieja et al., 2002). These patterns are useful for identifying Hop candidates, but experimental verification is still required. The adenylate cyclase (Cya) assay, which is now routinely used to study translocation of phytopathogen effectors into plant cells, employs fusions of the test protein to the catalytic domain of Cya (Bordetella pertussis adenylate cyclase), which produces cAMP exclusively in the presence of eukaryotic calmodulin (Sory and Cornelis, 1994; Casper-Lindley et al., 2002; Schechter et al., 2004).
Effector genes are found throughout the Pst DC3000 genome, both individually and in clusters such as the Hrp pathogenicity island conserved effector locus (CEL) (Alfano et al., 2000; Buell et al., 2003). There are 10 genes in the CEL of DC3000: PSPTO1378, avrEPto, PSPTO1376, hopPtoM, shcM, hrpW, hopPtoA1, PSPTO1371, PSPTO1370 (designated CEL ORF7 previously and hopPtoN in this work), and PSPTO1369 (designated shcN in this work). Four of these genes encode known Avr/Hop proteins (avrE, hopPtoM, hrpW and hopPtoA1), another is predicted to encode a TTSS substrate (PSPTO1370), and three are known or predicted to encode TTSS chaperones (PSPTO1376, shcM and PSPTO1369). Because several effectors encoded in the CEL of the Hrp pathogenicity island appear conserved between P. syringae pathovars and have probably been horizontally acquired with the genes encoding the TTSS machinery (Alfano et al., 2000), they are thought to play a particularly important role in pathogenesis. In fact, there is good experimental evidence to support this hypothesis. For example, a deletion affecting avrE, hopPtoM and hopPtoA1 strongly reduced the virulence of DC3000 in tomato (Alfano et al., 2000). Additionally, HopPtoM is important for the formation of disease lesions in tomato (Badel et al., 2003), and HopPtoA1 and its paralogue HopPtoA2 contribute to the initial development of individual bacterial colonies in tomato leaves (Badel et al., 2002). Another predicted TTSS substrate in this region is encoded by PSPTO1370, which has several characteristics of an effector gene: it is expressed in planta, activated by the HrpL alternative sigma factor, and possesses patterns in its predicted N-terminal 50 amino acids that are associated with TTSS substrates (Boch et al., 2002; Fouts et al., 2002; Guttman et al., 2002; Petnicki-Ocwieja et al., 2002).
Biochemical activities have been associated with only a few P. syringae TTSS effectors (Innes, 2003; Chang et al., 2004). For example, AvrRpm1 induces the phosphorylation of RIN4, a protein implicated in both basal defenses and RPM1-mediated HR, and HopPtoD2 has protein tyrosine phosphatase activity (Mackey et al., 2002; Bretz et al., 2003; Espinosa et al., 2003). Furthermore, investigation of the Avr activities of AvrPphB and AvrRpt2 have revealed that AvrPphB has cysteine protease activity, and AvrRpt2 likely also has cysteine protease activity based on catalytic triad mutant phenotypes (Axtell et al., 2003; Shao et al., 2003). The Pst DC3000 PSPTO1370 also is predicted to be a cysteine protease because it possesses a potential catalytic triad (C172, H283, D299) that is characteristic of the YopT/AvrPphB family of TTSS effectors (Shao et al., 2002). Interestingly, members of this effector family are found in both plant and animal pathogens (Shao et al., 2002; Shao et al., 2003).
Here, we report that the PSPTO1370 protein, henceforth designated as HopPtoN, is translocated into plant cells in a TTSS-dependent manner, partially suppresses the cell death associated with both compatible and incompatible P. syringae–plant interactions, requires all three of the amino acids in the cysteine protease catalytic triad to suppress the HR, and displays cysteine protease activity in vitro.
HopPtoN is translocated into plant cells by the P. syringae Hrp TTSS
The N-terminal 50 amino acids of HopPtoN (PSPTO1370) has several characteristics of P. syringae TTSS substrates. It has a hydrophobic amino acid (isoleucine) in position three, no acidic amino acids in the first 12 positions, and a high serine content of 14%. Furthermore, hopPtoN is in a bicistronic operon, and the promoter-proximal ORF (PSPTO1369) is characteristic of a TTSS chaperone. Specifically, the predicted PSPTO1369 protein is small (18.2 kDa) and mostly α-helical (nnPredict). To determine whether or not HopPtoN is a type III substrate that can be translocated into plant cells and whether or not the putative PSPTO1369 chaperone has a role in the level of HopPtoN that is delivered to plant cells, we constructed two plasmids expressing a fusion of Cya to the C-terminus of full-length HopPtoN in vector pCPP3234 (Schechter et al., 2004). Plasmid pCPP3238 expressed HopPtoN-Cya alone, and plasmid pCPP3239 expressed both PSPTO1369 and HopPtoN-Cya. To demonstrate that HopPtoN translocation was dependent upon the Hrp TTSS, we used CUCPB5114, a derivative of DC3000 from which the hrp/hrc (hrp conserved) genes have been deleted. As shown in Fig. 1A, DC3000(pCPP3238) translocated HopPtoN-Cya into tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum cultivar Money Maker) leaf cells, as indicated by Cya-dependent cAMP production. Infiltration with DC3000(pCPP3239) produced even more cAMP, suggesting that PSPTO1369, henceforth referred to as ShcN (specific Hrp chaperone), promoted the delivery of HopPtoN by the TTSS.
Because some chaperones are required for the stabilization of their client effectors within the bacterial cytoplasm (Feldman and Cornelis, 2003), we examined the accumulation of HopPtoN in DC3000(pCPP3238) and DC3000(pCPP3239) grown in King's medium B (Fig. 1B). In this medium, the native shcN and other genes in the Hrp regulon are not expressed (Fouts et al., 2002). Nevertheless, constitutively expressed HopPtoN accumulated to the same level in DC3000(pCPP3238) as in DC3000(pCPP3239) regardless of the expression of ShcN. Thus, ShcN is not needed to stabilize HopPtoN within DC3000. Finally, neither pCPP3238 nor pCPP3239 promoted any cAMP production when expressed in CUCPB5114, which indicates that translocation of HopPtoN-Cya is TTSS-dependent.
Mutating the Pst DC3000 hopPtoN worsens disease symptoms in tomato
To test the role of HopPtoN in virulence in tomato, we used suicide plasmid pKnockout-Ω (Windgassen et al., 2000), carrying an internal fragment of hopPtoN, to construct a hopPtoN mutant derivative of DC3000, CUCPB5388. Tomato plants were inoculated with test bacteria and monitored for formation of the necrotic lesions that are characteristic of bacterial speck. Unexpectedly, CUCPB5388 produced more necrotic lesions than wild-type DC3000 (Fig. 2). The wild-type level of lesions was restored by expressing hopPtoN in trans following transformation with pCPP5071, which constitutively expresses shcN-hopPtoN from the vector nptII promoter, which has been shown to be a strong promoter in P. syringae (Gopalan et al., 1996).
This increased-lesion phenotype was detected when bacteria were inoculated with a blunt syringe, but it was observed most clearly when plants were inoculated by dipping, as shown in Fig. 2A. Close inspection of many inoculated plants revealed that the primary effect of mutating hopPtoN was to increase the number, rather than the size, of lesions. This can be seen in the representative panels shown in Fig. 2A, and it is further documented with the lesion counts on tomato leaflets presented in Fig. 2B, which show that CUCPB5388 produced c. eightfold more lesions than DC3000. Lesions appeared 4 days post inoculation, expanded to near full size by 8 days, and were surrounded by extensive chlorosis at 12 days (Fig. 2A). No new lesions were observed beyond 8 days post inoculation (data not shown). Assays of bacterial populations in leaves 8 days post inoculation revealed no significant differences in the populations achieved by the DC3000 or hopPtoN mutant CUCPB5388 (Fig. 2C). These data indicate that HopPtoN suppresses the ability of Pst to elicit necrotic disease lesions in host tomato leaves, but this change in lesion phenotype does not have an apparent effect on bacterial growth in planta.
Altered production of HopPtoN affects the ability of Pst DC3000 to elicit the HR in non-host tobacco leaves
Tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum) has been extensively used to study the HR. P. syringae pathovars that have hosts other than tobacco typically elicit the HR in tobacco leaves, which is a useful diagnostic feature (Palleroni, 1984). We inoculated tobacco leaves via a blunt syringe with DC3000 and the hopPtoN mutant strain CUCPB5388. We used a dilution series of inoculum, and 24 h after inoculation, we observed that CUCB5388, relative to DC3000, caused a slight but reproducible increase in confluent tissue collapse at the threshold level of inoculum needed for elicitation of the HR (Fig. 3A).
To determine if we could suppress the HR by overexpressing HopPtoN in Pst DC3000, we inoculated tobacco leaves with DC3000 and DC3000(pCPP5071). Tobacco leaves were inoculated by blunt syringe infiltration of both strains, at decreasing levels of inoculum, and the threshold level for eliciting the HR was observed 24 h later (Fig. 3B). Both DC3000 and DC3000(pCPP5071) elicited confluent tissue death, indicative of the HR in infiltrated areas when inoculated at 8 × 106 cfu ml−1 or higher, but at the threshold level of 4 × 106 only DC3000 elicited tissue death. Similar results were observed in multiple experiments.
Although death of the infiltrated tissue is the signature of the HR, the HR is also accompanied by loss of electrolytes from the infiltrated tissue, which provides a more quantitative measure of the response (Cook and Stall, 1968; Goodman, 1968; Torres et al., 2002). Accordingly, we sampled leaf sections that had been inoculated with DC3000 and DC3000(pCPP5071) at inoculum levels near the threshold needed for elicitation of confluent tissue collapse, and we measured the leakage of electrolytes, as indicated by the increased conductivity of water in which leaf samples were bathed (Fig. 4). Electrolyte leakage from inoculated leaf tissue was substantially lower with DC3000(pCPP5071) than with empty vector control DC3000(pCPP5040) (Fig. 4).
It is important to note that the threshold inoculum level needed by Pst DC3000 to elicit the visible HR and electrolyte leakage from tobacco varies with the age of the leaves, the season, and other factors affecting the hypersensitivity of the plants. However, we have repeatedly observed that at the empirically determined threshold for wild-type DC3000 with a given batch of plants, CUCPB5388 produces a stronger HR, and DC3000 (pCPP5071) produces a reduced HR and reduced electrolyte leakage. Thus, either mutation or overexpression of HopPtoN can affect the ability of Pst to elicit the HR in non-host tobacco, and HopPtoN appears to suppress the HR.
Transient expression of HopPtoN via a PVX viral vector in tomato and Nicotiana benthamiana reduces symptoms elicited by virulent P. syringae strains
The previous experiments suggested that HopPtoN can operate inside plant cells to reduce the cell death associated with P. syringae interactions in both host tomato and non-host tobacco, but they leave open the possibility that altered production of HopPtoN affects the deployment of other effectors. To address this concern, we used a viral vector to express HopPtoN in plant cells. We cloned hopPtoN into PVX expression vector pQuiet2, such that the bacterial gene would be expressed strongly in plant cells following systemic infection by the viral vector. We then introduced the PVX constructs into PVX-susceptible tomato and N. benthamiana plants by Agrobacterium tumefaciens-mediated infection. Four weeks later, typical leaf-crinkling symptoms of systemic PVX infection were evident in N. benthamiana(Fig. 5). At this time we inoculated the PVX-infected tomato and N. benthamiana plants with Pst DC3000 and the tobacco wildfire pathogen P. syringae pv. tabaci 11528, respectively. In both cases, we introduced the inoculum by syringe infiltration so that we could observe multiple, identical inoculations on a single leaf, and we used the low levels of inoculum that are typically employed to assay the compatible interactions of virulent strains with their susceptible hosts. The representative leaves in Fig. 5 reveal that the confluent disease necrosis observed 7 days after infiltration of the P. syringae strains was markedly reduced in the PVX::hopPtoN-infected leaves that were expressing hopPtoN. The PVX::hopPtoN-infected tomato leaves showed relatively more chlorosis than necrosis, and some inoculation zones in PVX::hopPtoN-infected N. benthamiana leaves produced no necrosis. However, we saw no effect of hopPtoN expression on bacterial population levels in planta 4 days after inoculation, when bacterial populations were at their maximum (data not shown). These observations provide further evidence that HopPtoN acts inside plant cells to reduce the necrosis associated with P. syringae infection of susceptible hosts.
Delivery of HopPtoN by a cloned P. syringae Hrp system expressed in non-pathogen Pseudomonas fluorescens can suppress the HR normally elicited in Nicotiana benthamiana by a Pst DC3000 challenge inoculation
Several Pst DC3000 TTSS effectors have been shown able to suppress the HR when delivered by Pseudomonas. fluorescens 55 carrying pHIR11, which expresses the hrp/hrc genes from P. syringae pv. syringae 61 (Jamir et al., 2004). In order to rapidly observe the effects of HopPtoN on plant cells in the absence of other type III effectors we expressed the protein in P. fluorescens containing pLN18, a derivative of pHIR11 that lacks the functional effector protein hopPsyA (Jamir et al., 2004). By using overlapping zones of infiltration in non-host N. benthamiana leaves, in which P. fluorescens(pLN18, pCPP5040) or P. fluorescens(pLN18, pCPP5071), which expresses shcN-hopPtoN, were delivered 2 h before challenge inoculation of Pst DC3000, we found that HopPtoN was capable of strongly suppressing the HR (Fig. 6). This test provided a clear gain-of-function phenotype for exploring the potential biochemical activity of HopPtoN in planta.
Mutagenesis of the predicted cysteine protease catalytic triad in HopPtoN abolishes its ability to suppress the HR
HopPtoN has a predicted cysteine protease catalytic triad (C172, H283 and D299), which it shares with other members of the YopT/AvrPphB family of TTSS effectors (Shao et al., 2002). To test the role of the catalytic triad in the ability of HopPtoN to suppress the HR, we constructed site-directed mutations affecting each of these residues in a plasmid encoding both shcN and hopPtoN, pCPP5060. These constructs were moved via Gateway cloning methods into pCPP5040 and then transformed into P. fluorescens(pLN18) and Pst DC3000 for biological testing. We first tested the ability of these HopPtoN mutants to suppress the HR that is normally elicited by DC3000 in N. benthamiana, using the method described above involving inoculation with P. fluorescens(pLN18) expressing HopPtoN variants followed by an overlapping DC3000 challenge inoculation. In contrast to native HopPtoN, the C172S, H283A, and D299A mutants showed no HR-suppressive activity (Fig. 6). Immunoblot analysis revealed no difference between the native protein and the three mutants in their levels in P. fluorescens(pLN18) (data not shown), and these mutations are beyond the N-terminal region in P. syringae effectors that carries TTSS targeting signals and are therefore unlikely to be affected in delivery to plant cells (Petnicki-Ocwieja et al., 2002; Schechter et al., 2004).
We then tested the ability of the HopPtoN catalytic triad mutants to suppress the HR elicitation activity of DC3000 in tobacco when overexpressed directly in DC3000 (Fig. 7). Whereas DC3000 overexpressing the native HopPtoN in trans suppressed HR elicitation and associated electrolyte leakage in tobacco leaves at the threshold level of inoculum for wild-type DC3000, DC3000 overexpressing the HopPtoM C172S, H283A, and D299A variants at the same inoculum level failed to do so (Fig. 7). These observations suggest that HopPtoN has cysteine protease activity which is essential for HR suppressor activity.
HopPtoN has cysteine protease activity in vitro
HopPtoN is a member of the CA clan of papain-like cysteine proteases (Barrett and Rawlings, 2001; Shao et al., 2002).To determine if HopPtoN has protease activity in vitro, we first constructed HopPtoN-His6 fusions involving the native protein and the three catalytic triad mutants and purified the proteins from Escherichia coli extracts by affinity chromatography using non-denaturing buffers. We then assayed protease activity of the proteins using resorufin-labeled casein as a substrate (Twining, 1984). The unaltered HopPtoN-His6 and papain were both able to cleave the resorufin-label from casein. However, we saw no significant cleavage with the three altered HopPtoN-His6 proteins or when we added E64, a specific inhibitor of the CA clan of papain-like cysteine proteases, to the native HopPtoN or papain (Fig. 8). From these data, we conclude that HopPtoN is a cysteine protease in the CA clan that requires all three of the catalytic residues, C172, H283 and D299.
TTSS effectors are now seen to be collectively required for the pathogenicity of P. syringae, and a better understanding of pathogenesis will require determination of the virulence phenotypes and biochemical activities of individual effectors. To that end, we have shown that the Pst DC3000 effector HopPtoN is delivered into plant cells via the Hrp TTSS, suppresses cell death in both compatible and incompatible interactions, and possesses cysteine protease activity that is essential for suppressor activity. A particularly striking finding is that a Pst hopPtoN mutant is increased in its ability to produce disease lesions on its host tomato.
The Pst hopPtoN gene is located downstream of shcN (Alfano et al., 2000), and a strain of DC3000 overexpressing SchN and HopPtoN delivered HopPtoN into plant cells twice as efficiently as when ShcN was not similarly expressed. The location of the shcN gene, the physical properties of the predicted ShcN protein, and the stimulation of HopPtoN translocation all suggest that ShcN is a chaperone for HopPtoN (Feldman and Cornelis, 2003). Several other effector genes in the Pst DC3000 genome are linked with apparent chaperone genes, and shcN joins a growing list of these chaperone candidates for which there is experimental evidence of a role in effector delivery (Alfano and Guo, 2003; Badel et al., 2003; Buell et al., 2003).
Chaperones can affect the secretion (into the medium) and translocation (into host cells) of TTSS effectors by multiple mechanisms, including stabilization, maintenance in a secretion/translocation-competent state, piloting to the TTSS pathway, and establishment of a hierarchy for secretion/translocation (Feldman and Cornelis, 2003). ShcN does not appear necessary to stabilize HopPtoN within Pst DC3000. However, our focus in this report is on the biological activity of HopPtoN, and future experiments are needed to determine the mechanism by which ShcN promotes delivery of HopPtoN into plant cells. A particular important question is whether chaperoned effectors are delivered preferentially over other effectors by DC3000 (Feldman and Cornelis, 2003).
There is growing evidence that some effectors are able to suppress the defense-associated HR. First, the P. syringae pv. phaseolicola VirPphA was observed to block the HR elicited by other effectors, whose Avr activity is apparently masked by VirPphA (Jackson et al., 1999). Then, AvrPtoB, a Pst DC3000 effector showing 52% amino acid identity to VirPphA, was demonstrated to operate inside plant cells to block R gene-dependent programmed cell death and also to block the Avr activity of a domain within AvrPtoB itself (Abramovitch et al., 2003). Most recently, a survey of multiple DC3000 effectors using a P. fluorescens(pHIR11) system revealed that a third of the effectors can act inside plant cells to block the HR elicited in tobacco by the pHIR11-encoded effector HopPsyA (Jamir et al., 2004). Furthermore, mutagenesis of several of these effectors enables Pst DC3000 to elicit an enhanced HR in tobacco, as was similarly observed here with hopPtoN mutant CUCPB5388.
All of these observations are focused on regulation of the programmed cell death associated with incompatible interactions, and they do not address the nature of the cell death associated with the necrotic lesions that develop in the later stages of a compatible interaction. What is the relationship between the cell death events accompanying incompatible and compatible interactions? A review of physiological observations of P. syringae–plant interactions made before 1982 led to the conclusion that ‘the development of hypersensitive and normosensitive necrosis must be considered as being similar processes; their induction however, requires different numbers of bacterial cells and their development proceeds at different rates (Klement, 1982). A subsequent review of pioneering studies on defense gene expression in compatible and incompatible interactions also highlighted the similarity of the responses despite the differences in timing (Lamb et al., 1992). A recent large-scale mRNA expression profile analysis of Arabidopsis responses during compatible and incompatible interactions with P. syringae comprehensively documented the overall similarity of the responses and further proposed that a common signal transduction pathway underlies both (Tao et al., 2003). This report also noted the higher variability (reduced system robustness) in the response of Arabidopsis to compatible P. syringae strains. Several observations with HopPtoN and other Pst DC3000 effectors support this model.
The concept that a common signal transduction pathway leads to cell death and other responses in both compatible and incompatible P. syringae–plant interactions is supported by our finding that a single TTSS effector, HopPtoN, suppresses cell death in both interactions. The further concept of lower system robustness (higher variability) of the compatible response is consistent with the variable effects on lesion formation of three recently studied Pst DC3000 effectors. Mutations in hopPtoN, hopPtoM, and hopPtoD2, enhance, reduce, or do not affect, respectively, the ability of Pst DC3000 to cause bacterial speck disease lesions in tomato (Badel et al., 2003; Bretz et al., 2003; Espinosa et al., 2003). It is noteworthy that hopPtoD2 nevertheless is able to suppress HR cell death (Espinosa et al., 2003). The ability of other effectors with HR suppressor activity to alter the necrosis associated with disease now demands close scrutiny.
The ability of HopPtoN and HopPtoD2 to suppress the HR warrants further discussion because it is dependent on different biochemical activities. HopPtoD2 is a protein tyrosine phosphatase that appears to act downstream of NtMEK2DD, a constitutively active mitogen-activated protein kinase that can activate an HR-like programmed cell death (Espinosa et al., 2003). In contrast, as shown here, HopPtoN is a cysteine protease. The target(s) of HopPtoD2 phosphatase activity and HopPtoN protease activity are unknown, but the plant response model described above would suggest that they are components of a single signal transduction pathway that controls programmed cell death. Indeed, the Arabidopsis RIN4 protein, which mediates HR responses involving the R genes RPM1 and RPS2, appears to be phosphorylated by AvrRpm1 and proteolytically degraded by AvrRpt2 (Mackey et al., 2002; 2003; Axtell and Staskawicz, 2003). This is an example of a single plant protein that is modified in different ways by two P. syringae effectors, although in this case, the documented consequence of these activities is R gene-dependent elicitation of the HR.
HopPtoM and HopPtoN appear to have opposite effects on lesion formation in host tomato leaves. Both of the encoding genes are located in the Hrp pathogenicity island CEL, and given the observation that bacterial genes with related function are commonly clustered (Lawrence and Roth, 1996), it is tempting to speculate that these proteins function in some coordinated way to modulate lesion formation during pathogenesis. It is also noteworthy that the altered lesion phenotypes of hopPtoM and hopPtoN mutants are not accompanied by a commensurate change in bacterial growth in planta (Badel et al., 2003). Early observations of P. syringae–plant interactions have highlighted the cessation of bacterial growth that attends cell death during both incompatible and compatible interactions (Klement et al., 1964). Whether plant cell death is causal or merely coincidental with the inhibition of bacterial growth is unclear. However, our observations argue against a causal role in compatible interactions and suggest that the characteristic speck, spot, and blight symptoms that are diagnostic of various P. syringae diseases are orchestrated by the TTSS effector system (in concert with diffusible, low molecular weight toxins in some cases (Bender et al., 1999)).
We have shown here that the loss of a single effector can produce an increase in tomato bacterial speck symptoms that appears, at least in laboratory assays, to have no parasitic benefit. Questions for the future include the proteolytic targets of HopPtoN action, the nature of any selection pressures encountered by P. syringae in the field that would calibrate the degree of death elicited in hosts, and the potential use of hopPtoN transgenes to produce crops that can tolerate P. syringae infections through reduced symptom expression.
Plasmids, strains and DNA
The strains and plasmids used in this study are described in Table 1. All Pseudomonas strains were grown in King's B broth (KB) at 30°C and all A. tumefacians and E. coli strains were grown in Luria broth (LB) at 37°C. All hopPtoN and shcN-hopPtoN expression plasmids were created using Gateway™ cloning technology (Invitrogen, Carlsbad, CA). In short, the gene or genes of interest were amplified by plolymerase chain reaction (PCR) from the DC3000 genome with ExTaq (TaKaRa) using primers that introduced an attB1 sequence and a Shine-Dalgarno sequence upstream and an attB2 sequence downstream. These PCR products were combined with pDONR201 along with BP clonase enzyme per manufacturer's protocol (Invitrogen). All pDONR clones were checked by sequencing, and expression clones were made by combining the pDONR plasmids with the desired expression vector along with LR clonase. The recombination reactions were carried out as suggested by the manufacturer (Invitrogen). All expression constructs were confirmed by sequence analysis. Four Gateway compatible expression vectors were used: (i) pCPP3234, a derivative of the broad-host-range vector pVLT35 that employs a tac promoter to express insert genes and generates hybrid proteins with a C-terminal Cya fusion for TTSS translocation studies (Schechter et al., 2004); (ii) pCPP5040, a derivative of the broad-host-range vector pML123 (Labes et al., 1990), which expresses insert genes from the nptII promoter, and generates protein products with a C-terminal HA tag for expression in Pseudomonas spp.; (iii) pQuiet2, a PVX amplicon with PVX in the min-binary vector pCB302-3 for transient expression of transgenes in plants (He et al., 2004); and (iv) pET-DEST42, which allows for T7-regulated expression of insert genes and production of proteins with a C-terminal His6-V5 epitope tag for purification from E. coli (Invitrogen).
|Strain or plasmid||Genotype or relevant phenotype||Source or reference|
|DH5α||F–φ80lacZΔM15 ΔlacZYA-argF)U169 deoR recA1 endA1 hsdR17 phoA supE44 thi-1 gyrA96 relA1 λ∠||Invitrogen|
|P. syringae pv. tomato|
|DC3000||Wild type, Rifr||Cuppels, 1986|
|CUCPB5114||DC3000 ΔhrpK-hrpR::ΩCm, Rifr Cmr||Fouts et al., 2003|
|CUCPB5388||DC3000 hopPtoN::pKnockout, Spr Strr||This study|
|P. fluorescens 55||Wild type, Nxr||Huang et al., 1988|
|P. syringae pv. tabaci 11528||Wild type, Nxr||American Type Culture Collection|
|Agrobacterium tumefaciens GV3101 (pMP90)||Carries Vir plasmid encoding T-DNA transfer machinery, Rifr, Gmr||American Type Culture Collection 33970|
|pDONR201||Entry vector of Gateway™ cloning, Kmr,Cmr||Invitrogen|
|pCPP5060||pDONR201 containing shcN-hopPtoN, Kmr||This study|
|pCPP5061||pDONR201 containing hopPtoN, Kmr||This study|
|pCPP3234||pVLT35::Gateway™ cassette-Cya fusion, broad-host-range vector containing tac promoter and lacI q, Spr, Strr, Cmr||Schechter et al., 2004|
|pCPP3238||pCPP3234 expressing HopPtoN-Cya, Spr,Strr||This study|
|pCPP3239||pCPP3234 expressing ShcN-HopPtoN-Cya, Spr,Strr||This study|
|pKnockout-Ω||Smr Spr mob in pBluescript IISK(–) with modified MCS||Windgassen et al., 2000|
|pCPP5040||pML123::Gateway™ cassette, broad-host-range vector allowing for constitutive expression from nptII promoter and C-terminal HA tag, Gmr, Cmr||This study|
|pCPP5071||pCPP5040 expressing ShcN-HopPtoN-HA tag, Gmr||This study|
|pQuiet2||PVX amplicon with Gateway™ cassette, Kmr||He et al., 2004|
|pCPP3216||pQuiet2 expressing HopPtoN||This study|
|pLN18||pLAFR3 derivative containing 25 kb P. syringae pv. syringae 61 hrc/hrp cluster with shcA and hopPsyA replaced by an nptII cassette, Tcr Kmr||Jamir et al., 2004|
|pCPP5142||pCPP5060 derivative with shcN-hopPtoN C172S, Kmr||This study|
|pCPP5143||pCPP5060 derivative with shcN-hopPtoN H283A, Kmr||This study|
|pCPP5144||pCPP5060 derivative with shcN-hopPtoN D299A, Kmr||This study|
|pCPP5171||pCPP5040 derivative with shcN-hopPtoN C172S and C-terminal HA tag, Gmr||This study|
|pCPP5172||pCPP5040 derivative with shcN-hopPtoN H283A and C-terminal HA tag, Gmr||This study|
|pCPP5173||pCPP5040 derivative with shcN-hopPtoN D299A and C-terminal HA tag, Gmr||This study|
|pET-DEST42||pET Gateway compatible vector allowing for T7-regulated expression of a protein with a C-terminal His6-V5 tag, Ampr||Invitrogen|
|pCPP3390||pET-DEST42 expressing ShcN-HopPtoN-His6-V5 tag. Ampr||This study|
|pCPP3391||pET-DEST42 expressing ShcN-HopPtoN C172S-His6-V5 tag. Ampr||This study|
|pCPP3392||pET-DEST42 expressing ShcN-HopPtoN H283A-His6-V5 tag. Ampr||This study|
|pCPP3393||pET-DEST42 expressing ShcN-HopPtoN D299A-His6-V5 tag. Ampr||This study|
Construction of the Pst DC3000 hopPtoN mutant was carried out by PCR amplifying an internal 660-bp sequence of hopPtoN, corresponding to nucleotides 100–760 of the coding sequence, from the DC3000 genome and cloning into pKnockout-Ω (Windgassen et al., 2000). The resultant plasmid was transferred into DC3000 via conjugation. As pKnockout cannot replicate in DC3000, single crossover integrants were selected by resistance to spectinomycin. Orientation of integration was determined by Southern blot analysis. The site-directed mutants of hopPtoN were made in pCPP5060 using the QuikChange™ Site-Directed Mutagenesis Kit (Stratagene, LaJolla, CA) and then transferred via Gateway cloning reactions into expression vectors pCPP5040 and pET-DEST42 to produced the plasmids listed in Table 1. All plasmids were confirmed by sequencing.
All tomato (L. esculentum cv. Money Maker) plants used in this study were between 3 and 4 weeks old, and all N. benthamiana and N. tabacum cultivar Xanthi were between 4 and 6 weeks old and were grown in greenhouse conditions Some disease assays with tomato plants were performed by dipping the plants for 30 s into a 10 mM MgCl2 solution containing 0.02% Silwet and the bacterial inoculum. All other plant assays were performed by infiltrating a bacterial suspension into plant leaves using a blunt syringe. The areas of infiltration were marked lightly on the back of leaves. Levels of bacterial inoculum differed between experiments and are noted in the figures or legends. Bacterial levels in planta were determined by cutting leaf disks with a boring tool (inner diameter 0.7 cm) and placing the plant material in 500 µl of 10 mM MgCl2. The disks were completely homogenized and the resulting suspension, containing the bacteria, was diluted and plated on KB plates with rifampicin (50 µg ml−1) and cycloheximide (2 µg ml−1).
A. tumefaciens strain GV3101 carrying pQuiet2, a PVX amplicon with the Gateway™ cassette (kindly provided by Gregory B. Martin) and pQuiet2::hopPtoN were grown overnight in 250 ml of LB with appropriate antibiotics. Cells were harvested by centrifugation at 7000 g for 10 min and re-suspended in 30 ml of 10 mM MgCl2, 150 µM acetosyringone to a final OD600 of 0.3. The bacterial suspension was infiltrated with a blunt syringe into two lower leaves of two-week-old tomato or four-week-old N. benthamiana plants. Challenge inoculations with P. syringae strains were carried out four weeks later, when typical leaf-crinkling symptoms of PVX infection were seen systemically in N. benthamiana.
Plant cAMP and electrolyte leakage assays
Cya assays were performed as previously described (Schechter et al., 2004). Briefly, tomato plants were inoculated via a blunt syringe with Pst strains containing plasmids expressing Cya-fusions. Plant tissue was sampled 8 h later using a boring tool with a 0.7 cm inner diameter, placed in 300 µl of 0.1 M HCl, and ground into a fine suspension. Samples were incubated at −20°C overnight, and cAMP levels were determined using the Correlate-EIA cAMP immunoassay kit according to the manufacturer's directions (Assay Designs). Electrolyte leakage assays were initiated by removing four leaf samples using a boring tool with an inner diameter of 0.7 cm. Samples were placed into a glass test tube with 10 ml of distilled water and a vacuum was pulled 5 times using a 30-ml syringe connected to the tube by means of a rubber stopper with a hole for the tip of the syringe. The tubes were then shaken for 1 h (200 r.p.m) at room temperature. Plant material was removed and conductivity was measured using a YSI Model 3100 Conductivity Instrument with a YSI 3252 probe (YSI Incorporated, Yellow Springs, OH).
Cysteine protease assays
E. coli cultures containing plasmids expressing HopPtoN-His6, wild type or mutant, were grown at 25°C to an OD600 of 0.6 and induced with 0.5 mM isopropyl β-D-thiogalactoside (IPTG) for 3 h. Cells were harvested by centrifugation at 4000 g for 20 min, and the pellets were frozen overnight at −80°C. Native HopPtoN was purified per protocols 9 and 10 in the QIAexpressionist handbook (Qiagen). Protease activity was assayed as described (Twining, 1984), with minor modifications using resorufin-labeled casein (Roche) as a substrate. Briefly, lyophilized samples of papain, HopPtoN, or the mutant versions of HopPtoN, were dissolved in assay buffer (0.1 M sodium phosphate pH 7.0, 10 mM EDTA, 10 mM cysteine, 0.01% Brij-35 detergent) with 5 µM E64 (Sigma, St Louis, MO, USA) to a final volume of 80 µl. (Preliminary tests in the pH range of 6.5–9.0 indicated that pH 7.0 was optimal.) The assay mixture was incubated for 1 h at 37°C, then the reaction was stopped by treatment with 150 µl of 10% trichloroacetic acid for 10 min at 37°C. Samples were centrifuged, and the A574 of 200 µl of supernatant plus 300 µl of 0.5 M Tris-HCl pH 8.8 was determined.
We thank G. Salcedo and M. Martínez for their technical advice with in vitro cysteine protease assays, G. B. Martin for providing pQuiet2, and K. Loeffler for the photography. This work was supported by NSF Plant Genome Research Program Cooperative Agreement DBI-0077622, NSF grant MCB-9982646, and a post-doctoral fellowship from the Ministerio de Educación Cultura y Deporte of Spain to E. López-Solanilla.
- 2003) Pseudomonas type III effector AvrPtoB induces plant disease susceptibility by inhibition of host programmed cell death. EMBO J 22: 60–69. , , , , and (
- 1997) The type III (Hrp) secretion pathway of plant pathogenic bacteria: trafficking harpins, Avr proteins, and death. J Bacteriol 179: 5655–5662. , and (
- 2003) The Pseudomonas syringae Hrp (type III) protein secretion system: Advances in the new millenium. In Plant–Microbe Interactions, Vol. 6. Stacey, G., and Keen, N.T. (eds). St. Paul, MN: APS Press, pp. 227–258. , and (
- 2000) The Pseudomonas syringae Hrp pathogenicity island has a tripartite mosaic structure composed of a cluster of type III secretion genes bounded by exchangeable effector and conserved effector loci that contribute to parasitic fitness and pathogenicity in plants. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 97: 4856–4861. , , , , , , and (
- 2003) Initiation of RPS2-specified disease resistance in Arabidopsis Is coupled to the AvrRpt2-directed elimination of RIN4. Cell 112: 369–377. , and (
- 2003) Genetic and molecular evidence that the Pseudomonas syringae type III effector protein AvrRpt2 is a cysteine protease. Mol Microbiol 49: 1537–1546. , , , and (
- 2002) A gene in the Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato Hrp pathogenicity island conserved effector locus, hopPtoA1, contributes to efficient formation of bacterial colonies in planta and is duplicated elsewhere in the genome. Mol Plant Microbe In 15: 1014–1024. , , , and (
- 2003) Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato DC3000 HopPtoM (CEL ORF3) is important for lesion formation but not growth in tomato and is secreted and translocated by the Hrp type III secretion system in a chaperone-dependent manner. Mol Microbiol 49: 1239–1251. , , , , , and (
- 2001) Evolutionary lines of cysteine peptidases. Biol Chem 382: 727–733. , and (
- 1999) Pseudomonas syringae phytotoxins: mode of action, regulation, and biosynthesis by peptide and polyketide synthetases. Microbiol Mol Biol Rev 63: 266–292. , , and (
- 2002) Identification of Pseudomonas syringae genes induced during infection of Arabidopsis thaliana. Mol Microbiol 44: 73–88. , , , , , and (
- 2003) A translocated protein tyrosine phosphatase of Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato DC3000 modulates plant defence response to infection. Mol Microbiol 49: 389–400. , , , , , and (
- 2003) The complete sequence of the Arabidopsis and tomato pathogen Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato DC3000. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 100: 10181–10186. , , , , , , et al. (
- 2002) Direct biochemical evidence for type III secretion-dependent translocation of the AvrBs2 effector protein into plant cells. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 99: 8336–8341. , , , and (
- 2004) Wake of the flood: ascribing functions to the wave of type III effector proteins of phytopathogenic bacteria. Curr Opin Microbiol 7: 11–18. , , , and (
- 2002) Genomic mining type III secretion system effectors in Pseudomonas syringae yields new picks for all TTSS prospectors. Trends Microbiol 10: 462–469. , , , , and (
- 1968) Effect of Xanthomonas vesicatoria on loss of electrolytes from leaves of Capsicum annum. Phytopathology 58: 617–619. , and (
- 1986) Generation and characterization of Tn5 insertion mutations in Pseudomonas syringae pv. Tomato Appl Environ Microbiol 51: 323–327. (
- 2001) Plant pathogens and integrated defence responses to infection. Nature 411: 826–833. , and (
- 2003) The Pseudomonas syringae type III-secreted protein HopPtoD2 possesses protein tyrosine phosphatase activity and suppresses programmed cell death in plants. Mol Microbiol 49: 377–387. , , , , and (
- 2003) The multitalented type III chaperones: all you can do with 15 kDa. FEMS Microbiol Lett 219: 151–158. , and (
- 2002) Genomewide identification of Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato DC3000 promoters controlled by the HrpL alternative sigma factor. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 99: 2275–2280. , , , , , , et al. (
- 2003) A Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato DC3000 Hrp (type III secretion) deletion mutant expressing the Hrp system of bean pathogen P. syringae pv. syringae 61 retains normal host specificity for tomato. Mol Plant Microbe In 16: 43–52. , , , , and (
- 1968) The hypersensitive reaction in tobacco a reflection of change in host permeability. Phytopathology 58: 872–873. (
- 1996) Expression of the Pseudomonas syringae avirulence protein AvrB in plant cells alleviates its dependence on the hypersensitive response and pathogenicity (Hrp) secretion system in eliciting genotype-specific hypersensitive cell death. Plant Cell 8: 1095–1105. , , , , , and (
- 2003) Identifying type III effectors of plant pathogens and analyzing their interaction with plant cells. Curr Opin Microbiol 6: 20–28. , and (
- 2002) A functional screen for the Type III (Hrp) secretome of the plant pathogen Pseudomonas syringae. Science 295: 1722–1726. , , , , , and (
- 2004) Silencing of subfamily I of protein phosphatase 2A catalytic subunits results in activation of plant defense responses and localized cell death. Plant J 38: 563–577. , , , , , and (
- 1988) Molecular cloning of a Pseudomonas syringae pv. syringae gene cluster that enables Pseudomonas fluorescens to elicit the hypersensitive response in tobacco plants. J Bacteriol 170: 4748–4756. , , , , , , et al. (
- 2003) New effects of type III effectors. Mol Microbiol 50: 363–365. (
- 1999) Identification of a pathogenicity island, which contains genes for virulence and avirulence, on a large native plasmid in the bean pathogen Pseudomonas syringae pathovar phaseolicola. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 96: 10875–10880. , , , , , , et al. (
- 2004) Identification of Pseudomonas syringae type III secreted effectors that suppress programmed cell death in plants and yeast. Plant J 37: 554–565. , , , , , , et al. (
- 1990) Gene-for-gene complementarity in plant–pathogen interactions. Annu Rev Genet 24: 447–463. (
- 1982) Hypersensitivity. In Phytopathogenic Prokaryotes, Vol. 2. Mount, M.S., and Lacy, G.H. (eds). New York: Academic Press, pp. 149–177. (
- 1964) Hypersensitive reaction induced by phytopathogenic bacteria in the tobacco leaf. Phytopathology 54: 474–477. , , and (
- 1989) Cloned avirulence genes from the tomato pathogen Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato confer cultivar specificity on soybean. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 86: 157–161. , , and (
- 1990) A new family of RSF1010-derived expression and lac -fusion broad-host-range vectors for gram-negative bacteria. Gene 89: 37–46. , , and (
- 1992) Emerging strategies for enhancing crop resistance to microbial pathogens. Biotechnology 10: 1436–1445. , , , and (
- 1996) Selfish operons: horizontal transfer may drive the evolution of gene clusters. Genetics 143: 1843–1860. , and (
- 2002) RIN4 interacts with Pseudomonas syringae type III effector molecules and is required for RPM1-mediated resistance in Arabidopsis. Cell 108: 743–754. , , , and (
- 2003) Arabidopsis RIN4 Is a target of the type III virulence effector AvrRpt2 and modulates RPS2-mediated resistance. Cell 112: 379–389. , , , , and (
- 2003) Understanding the functions of plant disease resistance proteins. Annu Rev Plant Biol 54: 23–61. , , and (
- 1984) Genus 1. Pseudomonas. In Bergey's Manual of Systematic Bacteriology. Krieg, N.R., and Holt, J.G. (eds). Baltimore, MD: Williams & Wilkins, pp. 141–199. (
- 2002) Genomewide identification of proteins secreted by the Hrp type III protein secretion system of Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato DC3000. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 99: 7652–7657. , , , , , , et al. (
- 1995) The avrRpm1 gene of Pseudomonas syringae pv. maculicola is required for virulence on Arabidopsis. Mol Plant Microbe In 8: 444–453. , and (
- 2004) Pseudomonas syringae type III secretion system targeting signals and novel effectors studied with a Cya translocation reporter. J Bacteriol 186: 543–555. , , , , and (
- 2002) A Yersinia effector and a Pseudomonas avirulence protein define a family of cysteine proteases functioning in bacterial pathogenesis. Cell 109: 575–588. , , , , and (
- 2003) Cleavage of Arabidopsis PBS1 by a bacterial type III effector. Science 301: 1230–1233. , , , , , and (
- 1994) Translocation of a hybrid YopE-adenylate cyclase from Yersinia enterocolitica into HeLa cells. Mol Microbiol 14: 583–594. , and (
- 2003) Quantitative nature of Arabidopsis responses during compatible and incompatible interactions with the bacterial pathogen Pseudomonas syringae. Plant Cell 15: 317–330. , , , , , , et al. (
- 2002) Arabidopsis gp91phox homologues AtrbohD and AtrbohF are required for accumulation of reactive oxygen intermediates in the plant defense response. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 99: 517–522. , , and (
- 1984) Fluorescein isothiocyanate-labeled casein assay for proteolytic enzymes. Anal Biochem 143: 30–34. (
- 2000) Rapid gene inactivation in Pseudomonas aeruginosa. FEMS Microbiol Lett 193: 201–205. , , and (