Slum Wars of the 21st Century: Gangs, Mano Dura and the New Urban Geography of Conflict in Central America

Authors

  • Dennis Rodgers

    1. is Senior Research Fellow, Brooks World Poverty Institute, University of Manchester (e-mail: dennis.rodgers@manchester.ac.uk), and Visiting Senior Fellow, Crisis States Research Centre, London School of Economics. His research interests relate to issues of conflict, violence and urban development in Nicaragua and Argentina. He is co-editor (with Gareth Jones) of Youth Violence in Latin America (Palgrave Macmillan, 2009).
    Search for more papers by this author

  • A very preliminary draft of this paper was presented to the UK Development Studies Association (DSA) Urban Policy Study Group meeting held at the London School of Economics on 15 May 2006, and a more developed version at the Institute of Social Studies (ISS) ‘Cities of Extremes’ Lustrum conference held in The Hague, 15–16 October 2007. I am grateful to participants at both forums, as well as to Jo Beall, Sean Fox and Development and Change anonymous reviewers for their thoroughly constructive comments and critiques.

ABSTRACT

The political economy of violence in Central America is widely perceived as having undergone a critical shift during the past two decades, often pithily summarized as a movement from ‘political’ to ‘social’ violence. Although such an analysis is plausible, it also offers a depoliticized vision of the contemporary Central American panorama of violence. Basing itself principally on the example of Nicaragua, the country in the region that is historically perhaps most paradigmatically associated with violence, this article offers an alternative interpretation of the changes that the regional landscape of violence has undergone. It suggests that these are better understood as a movement from ‘peasant wars of the twentieth century’ (Wolf, 1969) to ‘urban wars of the twenty-first century’ (Beall, 2006), thereby highlighting how present-day urban violence can in many ways be seen as representing a structural continuation of past political conflicts, albeit in new spatial contexts. At the same time, however, there are certain key differences between past and present violence, as a result of which contemporary conflict has intensified. This is most visible in relation to the changing forms of urban spatial organization in Central American cities, the heavy-handed mano dura response to gangs by governments, and the dystopian evolutionary trajectory of gangs. Taken together, these processes point to a critical shift in the balance of power between rich and poor in the region, as the new ‘urban wars of the twenty-first century’ are increasingly giving way to more circumscribed ‘slum wars’ that effectively signal the defeat of the poor.

Ancillary