ON TAYLOR'S JUSTIFICATION OF MEDICAL INFORMED CONSENT

Authors


Dr Jukka Varelius, Department of Behavioural Sciences and Philosophy, FIN-20014 University of Turku, Finland. Tel: +358 2 333 5206/Fax + 358 2 333 6390. Email: jukka.varelius@utu.fi

ABSTRACT

In contemporary Western biomedical ethics, informed consent practices are commonly justified in terms of the intrinsic value of patient autonomy. James Stacey Taylor maintains that this conception of the moral grounding of medical informed consent is mistaken. On the basis of his reasoning to that effect, Taylor argues that medical informed consent is justified by the instrumental value of personal autonomy. In this article, I examine whether Taylor's justification of medical informed consent is plausible.

Ancillary