Luck, Mystery and Supremacy: D. Z. Phillips Reads Nagel and Williams on Morality
Version of Record online: 5 JUN 2007
Volume 30, Issue 3, pages 266–284, July 2007
How to Cite
Mulhall, S. (2007), Luck, Mystery and Supremacy: D. Z. Phillips Reads Nagel and Williams on Morality. Philosophical Investigations, 30: 266–284. doi: 10.1111/j.1467-9205.2007.00323.x
- Issue online: 5 JUN 2007
- Version of Record online: 5 JUN 2007
This paper critically examines D. Z. Phillips’ critical examination of Nagel's and Williams's famous exchange about moral luck. It argues that Phillips fails properly to identify the fundamental issues at stake in the exchange – particularly with respect to the role of scepticism, of the picture of the will as an extensionless point, and of the putative supremacy of morality – and so fails to recognise a certain commonality of interest between himself and those he criticises.