IS THERE A CONSERVATIVE SOLUTION TO THE MANY THINKERS PROBLEM?
Version of Record online: 21 JUL 2010
© 2010 Blackwell Publishing Ltd
Volume 23, Issue 3, pages 275–290, September 2010
How to Cite
Kovacs, D. M. (2010), IS THERE A CONSERVATIVE SOLUTION TO THE MANY THINKERS PROBLEM?. Ratio, 23: 275–290. doi: 10.1111/j.1467-9329.2010.00467.x
- Issue online: 21 JUL 2010
- Version of Record online: 21 JUL 2010
On a widely shared assumption, our mental states supervene on our microphysical properties – that is, microphysical supervenience is true. When this thesis is combined with the apparent truism that human persons have proper parts, a grave difficulty arises: what prevents some of these proper parts from being themselves thinkers as well? How can I know that I am a human person and not a smaller thinker enclosed in a human person? Most solutions to this puzzle make radical, if not absurd, claims. Recently, however, Michael Burke and Howard Robinson proposed conservative solutions that, according to them, do not have such undesired consequences. This paper argues that the conservative solutions tacitly assume at least one of the radical ones, and therefore they provide no alternative to the extreme solutions.