Unions and Police Productivity: An Econometric Investigation

Authors

  • DENNIS BYRNE,

  • HASHEM DEZHBAKHSH,

  • RANDALL KING

    Search for more papers by this author
    • *The authors are affiliated, respectively, with the University of Akron, Emory University, and the University of Akron. Send inquiries to Hashem Dezhbakhsh, Department of Economics, Emory University, Atlanta, GA 30322–2240. We thank Daniel Levy for helpful comments, Ray Atkins for research assistance, the Federal Bureau of Investigation for providing us with city-specific crime and arrest data, major municipal police departments for responding to our survey, and the editor and three anonymous referees for valuable comments. The usual disclaimer applies.


Abstract

We examine the effect of unionization on police productivity in large U.S. metropolitan areas. We define police output in the context of a production function model that draws also on the crime literature. We estimate the resulting model using a data set that includes published and unpublished government statistics as well as our own survey of police departments. Results suggest that the effect of unions on police productivity varies according to categories of police performance. In particular, if performance is stratified according to the severity of crimes, unions seem to have an insignificant effect on police productivity with respect to serious crimes. For minor crimes, unionization alters the parameters of police production function, leading to diminished productivity.

Ancillary