The Evaluative Use of Citation Analysis for Communication Journals

Authors

  • EDWARD TRUMAN HOUSER

    1. Edward Truman Funkhouser (Ph.D., Ohio University, 1979) is an associate professor and associate head of the Department of Communication at North Carolina State University, Raleigh.
    Search for more papers by this author

  • The author may be contacted at funkhouser@social.chass.ncsu.edu. The author wishes to thank James W. Chesebro, John A. Daly, William J. Jordan, and Virginia P. Richmond for their advice and encouragement, and Ellen L. Teague and Harry M. Nicholos for their help with computer applications.

Abstract

This study investigated the impact of the omission of scholarly communication journals from Social Sciences Citation Index (SSCI) and Arts and Humanities Citation Index (AHCI) on citation-based appraisals of communication literature. Citation data were collected from reference lists in articles appearing in 27 communication journals published during 1990, including 14 not indexed by SSCI or AHCI. The 14 journals not included in SSCI or AHCI contributed 1,953, or 26%, of the 7,640 citations to authors during 1990, and 1,156, or 25%, of the 4,587 citations to journals in 1990. Twenty-seven of the 50 most frequently cited authors received 25% or more of their citations from journals omitted by SSCI and AHCI. This study found that an accurate evaluation of a scholar's articles based on citations received will not be possible until SSCI and/or AHCI choose to include the omitted journals, and that computer applications could be used to provide a convenient and inexpensive on-line citation index for communication literature. The Journal Impact Rating, a measure for use in comparing journals’impact on the basis of citations received, was introduced.

Ancillary