Get access

A Review of Forensic Implications of Opioid Prescribing with Examples from Malpractice Cases Involving Opioid-Related Overdose

Authors

  • Ben A. Rich JD, PhD,

    Corresponding author
    1. UC Davis School of Medicine, Sacramento, California
      Ben A. Rich, JD, PhD, UC Davis School of Medicine, Patient Support Services Building, 4150 V Street, Suite 2500, Sacramento, CA 95817, USA. Tel: 916-734-6010; Fax: 916-734-1531; E-mail: barich@ucdavis.edu.
    Search for more papers by this author
  • Lynn R. Webster MD, FACPM, FASAM

    1. Lifetree Clinical Research, Salt Lake City, Utah, USA
    Search for more papers by this author

Ben A. Rich, JD, PhD, UC Davis School of Medicine, Patient Support Services Building, 4150 V Street, Suite 2500, Sacramento, CA 95817, USA. Tel: 916-734-6010; Fax: 916-734-1531; E-mail: barich@ucdavis.edu.

Abstract

Objective.  To provide a forensic overview and trace common threads among malpractice lawsuits involving patients who overdosed while consuming therapeutic opioids.

Methods.  One of us (LRW) reviewed 35 medical records of patients with chronic pain who overdosed, 20 of them fatally, while consuming therapeutic opioids, leading to lawsuits against physicians for malpractice. The reviews were requested by plaintiff and defense attorneys from across the United States from 2005 to 2009 to ascertain which drug(s) were primarily responsible for each death and whether the death was due to physician error, patient nonadherence, or some other reason. Complaints against pharmaceutical companies were excluded. Cases were examined for common trends, and comment is offered.

Results.  Methadone was responsible for the most deaths at 10 (50%), and hydrocodone was second at four deaths (20%) The most common risk factors found in the medical records of decedents included prescriber error in initiating, converting or titrating doses, patient nonadherence to medical instruction, presence of comorbid mental disorders, toxicological presence of benzodiazepines, middle age, and unrelieved pain. This article focuses on examples of physician errors and how they can be prevented.

Conclusions.  Common trends emerge from medical records of opioid decedents. Patient actions con-tribute, but physician error, particularly regarding prescribing methadone for pain, is apparent as well. A focused effort to determine the types and causes of common physician errors and how they might be avoided may lead to safer, more effective clinical interventions in the management of pain.

Get access to the full text of this article

Ancillary