Reconsidering the Relationship Between Cultural Theory, Political Ideology, and Political Knowledge

Authors


  • The authors would like to thank Keith Gaddie, Kuhika Gupta, Carol Silva, and the anonymous referees for their helpful comments on this article. The data used in this article were collected by Michael D. Jones with the support of National Science Foundation grant number SBR 0962589. Author Jones will share all data for purposes of replication.

Abstract

Objective

Social scientists from a variety of disciplines have employed concepts drawn from cultural theory (CT) to explain preferences across an array of issues. Recent research has challenged key elements of CT in a number of ways, perhaps most importantly by arguing that cultural types are simply another formulation of political ideology, and that only politically knowledgeable respondents reliably utilize either cultural or ideological categories in formulating preferences. This study reconsiders and expands upon this contention.

Methods

Principal component analyses of responses to a U.S. national survey of 4,387 people.

Results

Our findings are threefold: (1) people with low levels of political knowledge are able to sort egalitarianism and individualism into coherent worldviews; (2) people with high levels of knowledge do not collapse egalitarianism and individualism onto a single scale of political ideology; and (3) regardless of levels of knowledge, survey respondents are able to recognize all four of the value orientations proposed by CT.

Conclusion

CT, which is related to but different than political ideology, offers a robust system of worldviews that both high- and low-knowledge individuals might draw upon to formulate opinions and make decisions.

Ancillary