A Theory of Noise Trading in Securities Markets

Authors

  • BRETT TRUEMAN

    Search for more papers by this author
    • Anderson Graduate School of Management, University of California, Los Angeles. I would like to thank Michael Brennan, Mark Grinblatt, David Hirshleifer, Bruce Miller, Mark Miller, Eduardo Schwartz, and Sheridan Titman, as well as an anonymous referee, for their helpful comments. All remaining errors are, of course, my own.


ABSTRACT

In a recent article, Black [1] introduces a type of trading that he terms noise trading. He asserts that noise trading, which he defines as trading on noise as if it were information, must be a significant factor in securities markets. However, he does not provide an explanation of why any investors would rationally want to engage in noise trading. The goal of this paper is to provide such an explanation for one type of investor, managers of investment funds. As shown here, the incentive for a manager to engage in noise trading arises because of the positive signal that the level of the manager's trading provides about his or her ability to collect private information concerning current and potential investments. If the manager's compensation is directly related to investors' perceptions of his or her ability, the manager will then trade more frequently than is justified on the basis of his or her private information. In addition to providing this explanation for noise trading, the results of this analysis may also be useful for further empirical exploration of the relation between investment fund portfolio turnover and subsequent performance.

Ancillary