Re-use of this article is permitted in accordance with the Terms and Conditions set out at http://wileyonlinelibrary.com/onlineopen#OnlineOpen_Terms
ENDOSYMBIOTIC CALCIFYING BACTERIA: A NEW CUE TO THE ORIGIN OF CALCIFICATION IN METAZOA?
Article first published online: 14 MAY 2012
No Claim to original U.S. government works. Evolution© 2012 The Society for the Study of Evolution.
Volume 66, Issue 10, pages 2993–2999, October 2012
How to Cite
Uriz, M. J., Agell, G., Blanquer, A., Turon, X. and Casamayor, E. O. (2012), ENDOSYMBIOTIC CALCIFYING BACTERIA: A NEW CUE TO THE ORIGIN OF CALCIFICATION IN METAZOA?. Evolution, 66: 2993–2999. doi: 10.1111/j.1558-5646.2012.01676.x
- Issue published online: 1 OCT 2012
- Article first published online: 14 MAY 2012
- Accepted manuscript online: 21 APR 2012 12:31PM EST
- Received August 9, 2011 , Accepted April 6, 2012 , Data Archived: Dryad doi:10.5061/dryad.ff586c8k
- marine sponges;
Sponges show the highest diversity of associated bacteria among marine invertebrates. Immunological evidence traces the origin of the sponge bacterial symbioses to the Precambrian era. Hence, sponges appear to be ideally suited for studying the evolutionary origins of prokaryote–metazoan associations. Sponges produce either calcareous or siliceous skeletons, which only coexist in a relict group of demosponges, the sclerosponges. We report here, for the first time, intensive calcification in nonsclerosponge siliceous demosponges. Calcification is mediated by endosymbiotic bacteria (calcibacteria) located in archeocyte-like sponge cells. These calcibacteria are devoid of bacterial walls and divide within sponge cells until they became surrounded by a calcitic sheet, being subsequently extruded to the sponge subectosomal (subepithelial) zone. Thousands of bacteria-produced calcitic spherules cover the surface of the host sponges, forming a cortex-like structure that mimics a rudimentary peripheral skeleton. Calcibacteria are vertically transferred to the sponge larvae during embryogenesis. Calcium detoxification may have generated this symbiotic association, with some additional benefits for the sponges, such as skeletal formation and deterrence from predation. This unique symbiosis holds implications for sponge biology and may advance discussions on the role of bacteria in early biocalcification processes in metazoans.
Sponges (Porifera) are the earliest branching metazoans (Li et al. 1998; Philippe et al. 2009), and they show the highest diversity of associated bacteria among marine invertebrates (Schmitt et al. 2011). Immunological evidence has tracked the origin of sponge bacterial symbioses to before the Cambrian period (Wilkinson 1984). Therefore, sponges appear to be appropriate organisms for studying the evolutionary origins of prokaryote–metazoan symbioses.
Extant sponges have either siliceous or calcareous skeletons (Uriz 2006), which rarely coexist in the same species. So far, the only exception to this clear-cut dichotomy in the mineral nature of sponge skeletons is the so-called coralline demosponges or sclerosponges that produce a massive calcium carbonate skeleton and free siliceous spicules simultaneously (Vacelet 1985). Extant sclerosponges are considered relict, but representatives of this group proliferated and built reefs in the late Permian (Paleozoic) and late Triassic (Mesozoic) periods (Reitner 1989). The adaptive potential of a double mineralization is illustrated by examples of extant sclerosponges (e.g., genus Merlia). This genus usually shows both types of mineral skeletons, but produces mainly a calcareous skeleton in silica-depleted habitats (i.e., M. lipoclavidiscaVacelet and Uriz 1991) or mainly a siliceous skeleton in silica-rich habitats (i.e., M. deficiensVacelet 1980). The calcareous skeletons of sclerosponges are made of intracellular spherical structures (spherulites) that are excreted to the sponge mesohyl, where they grow epitaxially, by successive superposition of aragonite-made layers, to build walls and chambers (Willenz and Hartman 1989; Wood 1991; Wörheide 1998). The possible role of symbiotic bacteria in the formation of the sclerosponge spherulites has been considered. A bacterial signature was found in the spherulites of the sclerosponge Astrosclera willeyana (Jackson et al. 2010). Later, Jackson et al. (2011) reported the presence of a protein (spheruline) in the spherulites of this species, which, according to several lines of evidence (Jackson et al. 2011), seems likely to be encoded by a sponge gene horizontally acquired from a bacterium. Thus, there is growing indication of the participation of prokaryote genes in sponge biocalcification, but the direct involvement of symbiotic bacteria has never been proved.
Here, we present the first evidence of endosymbiotic calcifying bacteria (hereafter calcibacteria) within nonsclerosponge sponges of the genus Hemimycale (Demospongiae: Poecilosclerida, Van Soest 2002). These calcifying bacteria may have implications for sponge biology and may support the hypothesis of an early endosymbiotic origin of calcification in metazoans.
SAMPLING AND EXPERIMENTAL PROCEDURES
Fresh sponges of the genus Hemimycale were collected from several seas (H. columella: NE Spain, Mediterranean Sea; H. arabica: Red Sea, Hemimycale sp.: E Africa, Indian Ocean) and immediately processed for light, epifluorescence Transmission Electron (TEM) and Scanning Electron (SEM) microscopy studies, and Transmission Electron Microscope (TEM) and Scanning Electron Microscope (SEM). The presence of calcibacteria was microscopically verified less than 1 h after collection.
To determine the amount of calcium carbonate (as a proxy for calcibacteria abundance), specimens (N= 5 per species) were dried at 80 °C for 48 h in a stove and then weighed (A) using an analytical balance. The dried samples were placed in an oven at 600 °C to remove the organic matter. The remaining minerals, mainly consisting of siliceous spicules and calcibacterial coats, were weighed (B) and put in a Pyrex fingerbowl, where the calcareous material was removed through boiling in nitric acid. This process left a residue mostly consisting of siliceous spicules that were rinsed with distilled water and dehydrated with absolute ethanol before being dried and weighed (C). The weight of the calcibacteria coats was calculated as B–C and was referred to as the sponge dry weight in percentage by the formula (B–C) × 100/A.
MORPHOLOGICAL AND ULTRASTRUCTURE OBSERVATION (TEM AND SEM)
Small pieces, approximately 3 mm in diameter, were obtained from living sponges (H. columella, H. arabica), fixed for TEM (Uriz et al. 2008), and embedded in Spurr. Ultrathin sections were lead citrate stained and observed through a JEOL JEM-1010 TEM (Scientific-Technical Services of the University of Barcelona). Isolated calcibacteria were dehydrated, gold palladium metalized, and observed through a Hitachi S-3520N SEM (Microscopy Service ICM-CSIC, Barcelona). Calcibacteria cryofracture was performed in liquid nitrogen to observe the inner part of the calcibacterial coat. For light microscope observation, fresh samples were dissociated in seawater by stirring them with a pipette and a drop of cell suspension was observed.
ENERGY-DISPERSIVE X-RAY (EDX) ANALYSIS
EDX analysis was performed to determine the chemical nature of the calcibacterial coat (RÖNTEC Microanalyzer ICM-CSIC, Barcelona) according to standard practice (Turon et al. 2000).
DAPI AND FISH
DNA staining and in situ hybridization with bacterial and archaeal probes was performed on sponge sections. A fragment of a living individual of H. columella was fixed in 4% buffered paraformaldehyde (PANREAC, Spain). This fragment was dehydrated and embedded in paraffin, cut into 5-μm-thick sections, mounted on slides and stored at −20 °C. Sponge sections were DAPI stained and used for catalyzed-reported deposition whole cell fluorescence in situ hybridization (CARD-FISH) with bacteria-specific (EUB338) and archaea-specific (ARC915) probes (Pernthaler and Amann 2004; Auguet and Casamayor 2008). Other bacterial probes were also assayed for Betaproteobacteria (BET42a), Bacteroidetes (CF319a), and Actinobacteria (HGC69a), but they gave negative results. All probes were synthetized by Molecular Probes (Invitrogen, USA). The hybridized DNA was observed with a Zeiss epifluorescence microscope using the appropriate filter sets for DAPI (Zeiss filter set 01, BP365/12 FT396 LP397) and Alexa-Fluor 488 (Zeiss filter set 09, BP450–490 FT510 LP515).
Sponge calcibacteria were extraordinarily abundant (their calcareous coats represented 30–60% of the sponge dry weight) in all three currently known species of the genus Hemimycale (Demospongiae: Poecilosclerida) inhabiting different seas, that is, H. columella (Bowerbank 1874), Atlanto-Mediterranean; H. arabica (Ilan et al. 2004), Red Sea; and Hemimycale sp. (taxonomic status currently being determined by the authors), Indian Ocean, E. Africa (Fig. 1 A–C).
The calcibacteria were coccoid in shape and 200–800 nm in diameter (about 500 nm on average) and were found within vacuoles of amoeboid, archeocyte-like sponge cells (hereafter calcibacteriocytes) of about 15 μm in diameter (Fig. 2A, B). Degenerated calcibacteria were also observed in the sponge mesohyl as a result of calcibacteriocyte lysis. The bacterial nature of the calcibacteria was confirmed by electron (TEM) and epifluorescence microscope observations (DAPI staining and CARD-FISH techniques with specific prokaryote probes). Calcibacteria showed positive hybridization with the universal eubacterial probe (Fig. 2C, F) and only rare signals with the universal archaeal probe (Fig. 2D).
Viewed through electron microscopy, the calcibacteria showed loose inner material and appeared to be devoid of a typical cell wall; they were instead surrounded by a 100-nm-thick calcareous coat. Their organic content was arranged in a peripheral ring bounded by the bacterial membrane and an inner nucleoid (Fig. 3A, B). The electron microscopy observations indicated that recently replicated calcibacteria were not calcified and were able to replicate within the calcibacteriocyte vacuoles (Fig. 3C); subsequently, they secreted a calcareous coat consisting of 20–30 nm nanospherules (Fig. 3D, E). Finally, the cytoplasmic content was progressively reduced, and only the empty spherules remained (Fig. 3E). EDX microanalysis showed that the coat did not contain P, but Mg and Ca in a ratio corresponding to low-Mg calcite crystallization (Fig. 4A). Interestingly, the calcification process can be initiated even before bacterial division is complete (Fig. 4B). Calcibacteriocytes completely filled with calcibacteria were concentrated at the sponge periphery, conferring a whitish tinge to the sponge surface (Fig. 1D), where they lysed and released the calcibacteria to the mesohyl near the sponge surface.
We observed the vertical transmission of calcibacteria during the reproductive cycle of H. columella. The maturation of sponge embryos involves the incorporation of maternal cells (nurse cells). Maternal calcibacteriocytes were observed surrounding an embryo (Fig. 1E) and were phagocytized by the growing embryo, as it is reported for typical nurse cells. Once engulfed, the calcibacteriocytes disintegrated and released the calcibacteria into the embryo's mesohyl (Fig. 3F). The noncalcified calcibacteria replicated and were phagocytized by ameboid (archeocyte-like) embryonic cells, after which calcification proceeded. Thus, the sponge larvae contained abundant calcibacteria upon release, and recently settled sponges (rhagons) already exhibited an accumulation of calcibacteriocytes in their surface tissues (Fig. 1F).
To the best of our knowledge, this is the first report of intracellular calcifying bacteria living in symbiosis with marine invertebrates. Vacelet et al. (1987) first reported the presence of irregular calcareous bodies in the sponge Hemimycale columella but did not ascertain their nature. Irregular calcareous bodies similar to those reported in H. columella have also been described from the tropical Spirophorida Cinachyrella alloclada (Rützler and Smith 1992), which suggests the presence of calcibacteria in the later species as well.
The genus Hemimycale belongs in the order Poecilosclerida that mainly harbors “low bacterial abundance” sponges (Hentschel et al. 2003). However, our findings show that a sole morphotype of calcibacteria contributed up to 60% of the consortium weight in Hemimycale spp., whereas the diverse bacterial assemblages that characterize “high microbial abundance” sponges only accounted for up to 38% of the sponge volume (Vacelet 1975). This result supports the recently manifested need to reevaluate earlier sponge categorizations according to the abundance of their associated bacteria (Thacker and Freeman 2012).
Ankyrins, adhesion-related proteins (ARP) and tetratricopeptide repeat domain-encoding proteins (TPR), which may allow sponge cells to discriminate between food and bacterial symbionts, have been detected in the genome of several sponges harboring bacterial symbionts (Thomas et al. 2010; Liu et al. 2011), which denotes the capacity of sponge cells to identify potential symbionts. Whether these proteins are expressed in all sponge cells or are specific to archeocytes remains unknown. Hemimycale calcibacteria were contained in archeocyte-like cells, but they were absent from the more specialized sponge cells: choanocytes (water pumping), collencytes (collagen secretion), sclerocytes (spicule formation), and pinacocytes (pseudoepithelia formation). Archeocytes are pluripotent ameboid cells that move across the sponge mesohyl, phagocytizing cell debris and bacteria (Boury-Esnault and Rützler 1997) and are involved in immunologic processes (Sabella et al. 2007). Due to these abilities, archeocytes may detect “foreign” material in the sponge tissues, including microbes, and are thus particularly suitable cells for developing bacterial symbiosis. Once phagocytized, the microbes are recognized as a food and undergo digestion in archeocyte lysosomes or are identified as “potential partners” and kept alive and allowed to divide within the vacuole.
The phylogenetic identification of the Hemimycale calcibacterium is underway. A 16S rRNA gene tag-pyrosequencing of H. columella tissue has revealed that the most frequently recovered sequence (65%) was a representative of the Alphaproteobacteria class (authors’ current research), within which mitochondria and many parasitic and symbiotic bacteria of invertebrates fit. These abundant bacteria may correspond to the Hemimycale calcibacteria, which is in agreement with the fact that the Bacteroidetes, Betaproteobacteria, and Actinobacteria probes did not gave positive signal in the CARD FISH assays on the sponge tissue. However, most in-depth studies, including in situ hybridization with other specific molecular probes, need to be conducted to confirm their taxonomic identity.
In contrast to other endosymbiotic bacteria previously reported in sponges, the calcibacteria of Hemimycale lack bacterial walls, show scant cytoplasmic material, and are contained in cytoplasmic vacuoles, as has been reported for some obligate endosymbionts of other invertebrates (e.g., Baumann et al. 2000; Shigenobu et al. 2000; Pérez-Brocal et al. 2006). These characteristics suggest evolutionary adaptations for living within eukaryotic cells. Overall, the evidence presented in this work suggests a consistent symbiotic sponge–calcibacteria relationship for the following reasons: (i) calcibacteria are present and abundant in all representatives of the host taxon (genus Hemimycale) reported from several oceans under distinct ecological conditions, (ii) there is a lack of obvious adverse effects in either symbiont or host, and (iii) calcibacteria are vertically transmitted to sponge progeny. This symbiosis likely has profound implications for the sponge biology, with positive, predictable effects. The improvement of sponge fitness through a series of beneficial functions, such as Ca2+ detoxification and supplementary skeletal formation, is the most obvious purported benefits.
Additional advantageous functions derived from calcibacteria can be proposed. Hemimycale are not edible by fish, sea urchins, or other benthic predators (Becerro et al. 1997), although the siliceous skeleton, which has been reported to deter fishes from consuming some sponges (Burns and Illan 2003), is poorly developed. Hemimycale columella also seems to be weakly defended chemically, as its secondary metabolites only display antimitotic activity (Becerro et al. 1997). The enormous density of calcibacteria at the sponge surface is likely to contribute to the reported deterrence against potential predators. However, the putative antipredatory role of calcibacteria and the environmental conditions preventing or enhancing their proliferation deserve future ecological investigations.
On the other hand, the swift proliferation of the bacteria and their consequent accumulation in the host tissues suggest potential interference with the sponge's biological functions. Curiously, calcibacteria accumulation does not seem to harm the sponge in any appreciable way. In fact, Hemimycale sponges grow faster (according to the authors’ current research) than other demosponges in the same habitat (e.g., Turon et al. 1998; Blanquer et al. 2008; De Caralt et al. 2008), perhaps assisted by the supplementary biomass of replicating calcibacteria. Calcification within the calcibacteriocyte vacuoles could be a mechanism that maintains bacterial replication below a threshold that could damage the sponge. Furthermore, calcibacteriocytes accumulate at the sponge periphery and release calcibacteria to the sponge periphery in a similar way to that reported for spherulous or excretory sponge cells (Uriz et al. 1996). Together, these mechanisms may prevent calcibacteria from harming the sponge and, as a by-product, allow for the formation of a rudimentary skeletal cortex on the sponge surface.
The extent of the sponge–calcibacteria association remains unknown, but this symbiosis may be more common than presently thought. The customary use of nitric acid to remove the organic matter for spicule cleaning dissolves calcium carbonate and may have prevented their detection in typical taxonomic studies. Calcibacteria have also recently been found in the poecilosclerid Crella cyatophora from the Red Sea (authors’ current research) and, as stated above, may be present in the Spirophorida Cinachyrella alloclada (Rützler and Smith 1992). If calcibacteria occur in at least two distant Orders of demosponges (Poecilosclerida and Spirophorida), and might have been overlooked in others, then a phylogenetic study of these bacteria may give insights on the evolutionary origin of this association and possibly trace it back to a common sponge ancestor. This scenario might support the potential role of endosymbiotic bacteria on the origin of calcification processes in basal metazoans, backing implications of previous studies suggesting horizontal transfer of bacterial calcification genes to sclerosponges (Jackson et al. 2011). As in sclerosponges, the siliceous skeleton of Hemimycale has been reduced considerably compared with taxonomically close species, perhaps to accommodate the extensive calcareous sclerites. However, we have shown here that unlike in sclerosponges, in which calcification is ultimately produced by the sponge (Jackson et al. 2007, 2011), the calcium carbonate skeleton in Hemimycale is a direct result of the associated bacteria.
The elimination of excess cellular Ca2+, which is incompatible with life, has been proposed as one of the evolutionary forces triggering a variety of mineral exoskeletons in marine invertebrates (Simkiss 1977; Brennan et al. 2004). Relatively early in animal life, the Ca2+ ion became a messenger of basic cell functions, which forced cells to maintain intracellular calcium ions at concentrations several orders of magnitude lower than those in the ambient seawater (William 2000). Thus, once cells were threatened due to calcium overshoot, natural selection would have acted to fix mechanisms for either actively reducing intracellular Ca2+ concentrations or tolerating the intracellular precipitation of calcium salts (Lowenstam and Margulis 1980). It has been hypothesized that calcium extrusion first evolved in prokaryotes to protect magnesium enzymes and to prevent phosphates from precipitating (Hoehler et al. 2001). According to the widely accepted “seriated endosymbiosis theory” (Margulis 1981), it is conceivable that bacteria also played a role in calcium regulation in early cell consortia. However, calcifying endosymbiotic bacteria have not been reported in metazoans until now.
The Hemimycale species certainly have the potential to serve as exceptional living models for the experimental study of bacteria-mediated calcification in metazoans and the biological interactions between calcibacteria and eukaryotic cells.
Associate Editor: J. Wernegreen
The authors thank the Scientific-Technical Services of the University of Barcelona, in particular N. Cortadellas and A. García for processing the TEM samples; J. M. Fortuño from the Instituto de Ciencias del Mar (ICM), Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Cientficas (CSIC) for processing the SEM samples; C. Gutiérrez and J. C. Auguet for laboratory help with the FISH techniques; P. Galand for help with the pyrosequencing blasts; A. R. Pérez-Porro for providing one sample of a ripe sponge for the TEM study; E. Macpherson for helpful discussions; and P. Erwin for improving the English style. We especially want to pay homage to the late Prof. Lynn Margulis, who provided insightful advice and useful discussions on our results. The study has been funded by projects CTM2010–22218, MICINN and SGR2009–655, Generalitat de Catalunya to MJU, and CGL2009–13318, MICINN to EOC.
- 2008. A hotspot for cold Crenarchaeota in the neuston of high mountain lakes. Environ. Microbiol. 10:1080–1086. , and .
- 2000. Bacteriocyte-associated endosymbionts of insects. Pp. 1–67 in M. Dworkin, ed. The prokaryotes. Springer, New York . , , and
- 1997. Multiple functions for secondary metabolites in encrusting marine invertebrates. J. Chem. Ecol. 23:1527–1547. , , and .
- 2008. Hidden diversity in sympatric sponges: adjusting life-history dynamics to share substrate. Mar. Ecol. Prog. Ser. 371:109–115. , , and .
- 1997. Thesaurus of Sponge Morphology. Pp. 1–55 in Smithsonian Contributions to Zoology 596. Smithsonian Institution Press, Washington , DC . , and , eds.
- 2004. Seawater chemistry and the advent of biocalcification geology 32:473–476. , , and .
- 2003. Comparison of anti-predatory defenses of Red Sea and Caribbean sponges II. Physical defense. Mar. Ecol. Prog. Ser. 252:115–123. , and .
- 2008. Grazing, differential size-class dynamics and survival of the Mediterranean sponge Corticium candelabrum. Mar. Ecol. Prog. Ser. 360:97–106. , , and .
- 2003. Microbial diversity of marine sponges. Pp. 60–88 in W.E.G. Müller, ed. Molecular marine biology of sponges. Springer Verlag, Heidelberg . , , , , , , and .
- 2001. The role of microbial mats in the production of reduced gases on the early Earth. Nature 412:324–327. , , .
- 2007. Sponge paleogenomics reveals and ancient role for carbonic anhydrase in skeletogenesis. Science 316:1893–1895. , , , , and .
- 2010. An evolutionary fast-track to biocalcification. Geobiology 8:191–196. doi: 10.1111/j.1472-4669.2010.00236.x. , , and .
- 2011. A horizontal gene transfer supported the evolution of an early metazoan biomineralization strategy. BCM Evol. Biol. 11:238–244. , , , and
- 1998. Precambrian sponges with cellular structures. Science. 279:879–882. , , and .
- 2011. Functional genomic analysis of an uncultured delta-proteobacterium in the sponge Cymbastela concentrica. ISME J. 5:427–435. , , and .
- 1980. Evolutionary prerequisists for early phanerozoic calcareous skeletons. BioSystems 12:27–41. , and .
- 1981. Symbiosis in cell evolution. WH Freeman Co., New York. 452 p.
- 2006. A small microbial genome: the end of a long symbiotic relationship? Science 314:312–313. , , , , , , , , and .
- 2004. Sensitive multi-color fluorescence in situ hybridation for the identification of environmental microorganisms. Mol. Microbiol. Ecol. Manual 2:711–726. , and .
- 2009. Phylogenomics revives traditional views on deep animal relationships. Curr. Biol. 19:706–712. , , , K. Pick, C. Borchiellini, N. Boury-Esnault, J. Vacelet, E. Renard, E. Houliston, E. Quéinnec., et al. (20 co-authors).
- 1989. Lower and mid-Creaceous coralline sponge communities of the Boreal and Tethyan realms in comparison with the moderns ones. Paleoecological and paleogeographical implications. Pp. 851–878 in J. Wiedmann ed. Cretaceous of the western Tethys, Proceedings of the 3rd Internacional Cretaceous Symposium, Tübingem 1987. E. Schweizerbart, Stuttgart .
- 1992. Guide to western Atlantic species of Cinachyrella (Porifera: Tetillidae). Proc. Biol. Soc. Wash. 105:148–164. , and .
- 2007. Cyclosporin a suspends transplantation reactions in the marine sponge Microciona prolifera. J. Immunol. 179:5927–5935. , , , , , , and .
- 2011. Assessing the complex sponge microbiota: core, variable and species-specific bacterial communities in marine sponges. ISME J. 6:564–576. , , , , , , , , , and .
- 2000. Genome sequence of the endocellular bacterial symbiont of aphids Buchnera sp. APS Nat. 407:81–86. , , , , and .
- 1977. Biomineralization and detoxification. Calc. Tiss. Res. 24:199–200.
- 2012. Sponge-microbe symbioses: recent advances and new directions. Adv. Mar. Biol. 62:57–111. , and .
- 2010. Functional genomic signatures of sponge bacteria reveal unique and shared features of symbiosis. ISME J. 4:1557–1567. , , , , , , , , , .
- 1998. Growth dynamics and mortality of the encrusting sponge Crambe crambe (Poecilosclerida) in contrasting habitats: correlation with population structure and investment in defence. Funct. Ecol. 12:631–639. , , and .
- 2000. Distribution of brominated compounds within the sponge Aplysina aerophoba: coupling of X-ray microanalysis with cryofixation techiques. Cell Tiss. Res. 301:311–322. , , and .
- 2006. Mineral skeletogenesis in sponges. Can. J. Zool. 84:322–356.
- 1996. Location of toxicity within the Mediterranean sponge Crambe crambe (Demospongiae: Poecilosclerida). Mar. Biol. 124:583–590. , , , and .
- 2008, Ultrastructure and dispersal potential of sponge larvae: tufted versus evenly ciliated parenchymellae. Mar. Ecol. 29:280–297. , , and .
- 1975. Electron microscope study of the association between bacteria and sponges of the genus Verongia (Dictyoceratida). J. Microsc. Biol. Cell. 23:271–288.
- 1980. Squelette calcaire facultatif et corps de regeneration dans le genre Merliaéponges apparentées aux Chaetétidés fossiles. Compte rendu hebdomadaire des séances de l’Académie des sciences 2:227–230. .
- 1985. Coraline sponges and the evolution of Porifera. Pp. 1–13 in S. C. Morris, J. D. George, R. Gibson, H. M. Platt, H. M. , eds.. The origins and relationships of lower invertebrates. The Systematics Association, 28. Clarendon Press, Oxford , U.K. .
- 1991. Deficient spiculation in a new species of Merlia (Merliidae, Demospongiae) from the Balearic Islands. Pp. 170–178 in J. Reitner and Keupp , eds. Fossil and recent sponges. Springer-Verlag, Berlin , Heidelberg . , and .
- 1987. The calcium carbonate spherules of Hemimycale columella (Demosponges, Poecilosclerida) and their taxonomic value. Pp. 257–274 in J. Vacelet, and N. Boury-Esnault, eds. Taxonomy of Porifera from the NE Atlantic and Mediterranean Sea. NATO ASI Series G: Ecological Sciences 13 Springer-Verlag , Berlin . , , and .
- 2002. Family Hymedesmiidae Topsent, 1928. Pp. 575–601 in J. N. H. Hooper, and R. W. M. Van Soest, eds. Systema porifera: a guide to the classification of sponges. Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers, New York .
- 1984. Inmunological evidences for the Precambrian origin of bacterial symbioses in marine sponges. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. B 220:509–517.
- 1989. Micromorphology and ultrastructure of Caribbean demosponges. I Ceratoporella nicholsoni and Stromatospongia norae (Ceraotoporellidae: Porifera). Mar. Biol. 103:387–401. , and .
- 2000. Calcium homeostasis and its evolution. Pp. 1–28 in E. Carafoli, and J. Krebs, eds. Calcium homeostasis. 3 topics in biological inorganic chemistry. Springer-Verlag, New York .
- 1991. Non-spicular biomineralization in calcified demosponges. Pp. 322–340 in J. Reitner, and H. Keupp H., eds. Fossil and recent sponges. Springer-Verlag, Berlin .
- 1998. The reef cave dwelling ultraconservative coralline demosponge Astrosclera willeyana Lister, 1900 from the Indo-Pacific. Micromorphology, ultrastructure, biocalcification, isotope record, taxonomy, biogeography, phylogeny. Facies 38:1–88.