These authors contributed equally to this work.
IL-12 immunotherapy of murine leukaemia: comparison of systemic versus gene modified cell therapy
Article first published online: 9 JUL 2008
© 2008 The Authors Journal compilation © 2009 Foundation for Cellular and Molecular Medicine/Blackwell Publishing Ltd
Journal of Cellular and Molecular Medicine
Volume 13, Issue 8b, pages 1962–1976, August 2009
How to Cite
Labbe, A., Nelles, M., Walia, J., Jia, L., Furlonger, C., Nonaka, T., Medin, J. A. and Paige, C. J. (2009), IL-12 immunotherapy of murine leukaemia: comparison of systemic versus gene modified cell therapy. Journal of Cellular and Molecular Medicine, 13: 1962–1976. doi: 10.1111/j.1582-4934.2008.00412.x
- Issue published online: 26 NOV 2009
- Article first published online: 9 JUL 2008
- Received: April 4, 2008; Accepted: June 20, 2008
- B cell;
- T cell;
- gene therapy
The ability of IL-12 to initiate anti-leukaemia immune responses has been well established; however clinical outcomes fail to recapitulate the therapeutic benefits observed in the laboratory. To address this, we compared two systems of IL-12 therapy that elicit protective immune responses against the murine acute lymphoblastic leukaemia (ALL) cell line, 70Z/3. These systems differ in the method of IL-12 administration and ultimately result in leukaemia clearance by distinct mechanisms, emphasizing the importance of treatment vehicle. Injecting low-dose IL-12 was sufficient to elicit long-term protective immunity against an established leukaemia burden, mediated by both CD4+ and CD8+ T cells. These findings agree with the standard model of IL-12 activity. We compared this protocol to a cell-based approach in which a novel lentiviral vector (LV) expressing murine IL-12 was created, 70Z/3 cells transduced, and clones selected that stably secrete different amounts of IL-12. We found that only a small proportion (1%) of IL-12 secreting cells were required for rejection but that the amount of IL-12 produced per cell was critical for successful therapy. Importantly, the levels of IL-12 required were found to be higher than the levels reported to date in the human clinical trial literature. We found that the cell-based approach led to protective immunity that was both long-term and specific but dependent primarily on a CD4+ cellular subset alone. Our results highlight that the mode of IL-12 delivery has a distinct impact on the immune response initiated, leading to leukaemia clearance by disparate mechanisms. We also establish a new and critical parameter, IL-12 production/cell, which may have significant implications for future therapeutic design.
Immunotherapy is based on the premise that cancer cells express antigens that can be targeted by immune mechanisms and recognized by the immune system. However, despite the presence of such antigens, leukaemias are generally not readily recognized and eliminated by the host, as evidenced by the development of disease. The inability of the immune system to protect against leukaemias may be due to mechanisms of evasion, active suppression or sub-optimal activation of a response.
Cytokines are integral to both the innate and acquired immune systems. They can alter the balance of cellular and humoural responses, alter class switching of B lymphocytes and modify innate responses. These traits have made a number of cytokines interesting candidates for cancer immunotherapies [1–3]. Among these, IL-12 has been tested for its ability to promote immune recognition and a response against leukaemias.
Interleukin-12 is a heterodimeric cytokine with multiple biological effects on the immune system. It is composed of two subunits, p35 and p40, both of which are required for the secretion of the active form of IL-12, p70. Interleukin-12 acts on dendritic cells (DC) leading to increased maturation and antigen presentation, which can allow for the initiation of a T-cell response to leukaemia-specific antigens. It also drives the secretion of IL-12 by DCs, creating a positive feedback mechanism to amplify the response. Once a response is initiated, IL-12 plays a fundamental role in directing the immune system towards a Th1 cytokine profile, inducing CD4+ T cells to secrete IFN-γ and leading to a CD8+ cytotoxic T-cell response . However, IL-12 is also a strong pro-inflammatory cytokine that leads to the secretion of other cytokines including TNF-α which, combined with IFN-γ, is a prerequisite for the development of CD4+ CTLs . Furthermore, IL-12 can promote the activation of innate immune cells such as macrophages and eosinophils through its induction of IFN-γ and other cytokines. This activation then leads to IL-12 secretion by these cells and further amplification of both the innate and acquired responses . However, high levels of IL-12, and consequently IFN-γ, have also been associated with induction of antagonistic molecules such as IL-10 and the depletion of signalling molecules downstream of IL-12 such as STAT4 [6–8].
Direct injection of IL-12 has shown effectiveness in some mouse models of leukaemia [9–13]. While initial Phase I human trials employing this approach demonstrated adequate tolerance to treatment to warrant Phase II trials, these were less promising ([14–16] and discussed in ). It is well recognized in the literature that IL-12-induced anti-leukaemia activity is largely mediated by the secondary secretion of IFN-γ. Gollob et al., in particular, have suggested that the induction and maintenance of IL-12-induced IFN-γ expression is a key component of effective therapy in patients with metastatic renal cell cancer . However, the concomitant induction of antagonistic effects with elevated IFN-γ levels continues to pose a challenge and is the impetus for a number of groups to continue testing the efficacy of IL-12 following different dose and time protocols [7, 8, 18–20] and to evaluate the therapeutic potential of cell-based IL-12 gene therapy ([21–30] and discussed in [4, 13]) in order to overcome this.
More recent clinical trials have included approaches such as intratumoural injection of IL-12 secreting fibroblasts and dendritic cells, methods that have proven effective in mouse models. To date, although some degree of immune response has been demonstrated, these approaches have not had a significant impact on patient survival [16, 25, 27, 31]. Finding the reason for this disconnect is of paramount importance.
We recently published a model of ALL in which one variant of the 70Z/3 murine pre-B cell leukaemia line, 70Z/3-L, is lethal in syngeneic mice while another variant, 70Z/3-NL, elicits a protective immune response . The 70Z/3-L cells, although unable to initiate immunity, were readily rejected when an immune response was first initiated against 70Z/3-NL cells. Therefore, our model is amenable to testing whether IL-12 can initiate a specific immune response, recognition of 70Z/3-L and survival of challenged animals. 70Z/3 leukaemia is reminiscent of human ALL with neoplastic lesions arising in the liver, spleen, lymph nodes, bone marrow and rarely the central nervous system. Among the most common physical manifestations of the disease are ascites and splenomegaly.
We show here that intraperitoneal (IP) administration of low-dose recombinant IL-12 (rIL-12) elicits a protective response against an established leukaemia burden and that rejection is mediated by a CD4+ and CD8+ T-cell-dependent immune response which leads to long-term immune memory without the induction of antagonistic cytokines. We compared this protocol to a cell therapy approach in which 70Z/3-L cells have been transduced with an LV engineered to express murine IL-12 (both subunits) cDNA. Clones of 70Z/3-L cells producing a wide range of IL-12 were established. Injection of IL-12 producing 70Z/3-L cells provoked long-term and specific immunity without the induction of antagonistic mechanisms. Leukaemia clearance in this instance, however, was mediated by a CD4+ cellular subset alone, suggesting a qualitatively different route to immunity than that seen with systemic therapy. Of critical importance, we found that injection of as few as 1% IL-12 producing 70Z/3-L cells along with 99% untransduced 70Z/3-L cells was sufficient to elicit protective immunity as long as each of these cells produced IL-12 above a necessary threshold. This finding may explain the failure of many human cell therapy-based protocols. In these cases, IL-12 production is measured on bulk populations, making it impossible to know if sufficient IL-12 is being produced in the local environment influenced by the IL-12 producing cell, and normally the average production reported is below our established threshold [24, 25, 27, 31].
Materials and methods
Female (C57Bl/6xDBA/2)F1 mice (referred to as BDF1), 8–12 weeks old, were purchased from the Jackson Laboratories (Bar Harbor, ME, USA). Mice were kept under sterile conditions in the specific pathogen-free (SPF) animal facility at the Ontario Cancer Institute, Princess Margaret Hospital, Toronto, Ontario, Canada. Mice were fed an irradiated diet and autoclaved tap water. Animals were terminated by CO2 asphyxiation and cervical dislocation. The Animal Care Committee of the Ontario Cancer Institute approved all experimental protocols employed.
70Z/3-L leukaemia cells (described in ), derived from BDF1 mice, were maintained in IMDM with 5% heat inactivated foetal bovine serum (HYCLONE, South Logan, UT, USA), 100 μg/ml penicillin-streptomycin or 100 μg/ml kanamycin (GIBCO-Invitrogen, Burlington, Canada) and 5.5 × 10−5 M β-mercaptoethanol (referred to as complete IMDM) in a humidified atmosphere at 37°C and 5% CO2. Cell concentrations were kept at 5 – 10 × 105 cells/ml.
Lentiviral vector construction
Lentiviral vectors expressing IL-12 cDNA were constructed by a method similar to that described by Yoshimitsu et al.  with modification. Plasmid pORF-mIL12 (IL-12elasti(p35::p40) Mouse (p35::p40)) (InvivoGen, San Diego, CA, USA) was modified by creating EcoRI and BamHI restriction enzyme sites, upstream and downstream of the IL-12 gene respectively using a QuickChange Site-Directed Mutagenesis Kit (Stratagene, La Jolla, CA, USA). This resulting construct was then digested with EcoRI/BamHI (New England Biolabs, Ipswich, MA, USA). Murine IL-12 cDNA was purified after electrophoresis on a 1% agarose gel, and then subcloned into the pHR’ LV backbone downstream of the elongation factor 1 alpha (EF1α) promoter. Positive plasmid clones for pHR-cPPT-EF1α-muIL-12-WPRE (i.e. LV-muIL-12) were identified by diagnostic restriction enzyme digestion analyses and subsequent DNA sequencing (Innobiotech, Toronto, ON, Canada).
Viral production and transduction of the cells
Concentrated LVs were produced by a transient triple-transfection method using pHR-cPPT-EF1α-muIL-12-WPRE and accessory plasmids onto 293T monolayers by calcium phosphate [35, 36]. An approximate vector titre was estimated based on LV/enGFP  production and testing on naïve 293T cells that occurred in parallel. The murine pre-B leukaemia cell line, 70Z3-L, was then transduced with an approximate multiplicity of infection (MOI) of 20. Single cell clones, obtained by limiting dilution in 96 well plates at population densities of less than 0.3 cells/well, were then quantitated for IL-12 production/106cells/ml/2 hrs using a commercially available IL-12 ELISA kit (BD Biosciences, San Jose, CA, USA).
In vivo challenge experiments
Leukaemia cells and transduced cells were grown in complete IMDM and were washed 3 times with 30 ml of phosphate buffered saline (PBS) with Ca2+ and Mg2+. The cells were resuspended at 5 – 10 × 106 cells/ml in PBS and injected into the animals in a volume of 100–200 μl. Mice received IP injections that were performed on the right side of the abdomen using a 1 ml syringe with a 26-gauge needle.
Intraperitoneal administration of rIL-12
Recombinant mouse IL-12 was purchased from R&D Systems, Minneapolis, MN, USA. Mice were injected IP with 106 70Z/3-L cells in 100–200 μl PBS on day 0 followed by daily injections of 0.1–20 ng/mouse/day rIL-12 in PBS for a period of 14 days, starting on day 1. A secondary challenge consisted of IP injection of 106 70Z/3-L cells 70 days after primary challenge, which was carried out in the manner just described. For the delayed rIL-12 treatments mice received an IP injection of 104 70Z/3-L cells in 100–200 μl PBS on day 0. Thereafter, groups of 4 or 5 mice received 14 successive rIL-12 IP injections of 20 ng/mouse/day but the initiation of these injections was delayed by between 0 and 5 days. The animals were monitored daily for the appearance of symptoms both during the injection period and following the end of injections.
Intraperitoneal administration of leukaemia cell-produced IL-12
Interleukin-12 secreting cells were produced as described above. Mice were injected IP with 106 transduced cells or a mixture of transduced and naïve cells in various proportions in 100–200 μl PBS. A secondary challenge consisted of IP injection of 106 70Z/3-L cells or 106 L1210 cells more than 110 days after primary challenge, carried out in the manner just described. The animals were monitored daily for the appearance of symptoms following injection.
Challenge in depleted animals
Mice were depleted of CD4+, CD8+ or both T-cell subsets, as well as NK cells and IFN-γ using specific antibodies. The hybridoma GK1.5 is directed against CD4+ T cells, YTS169 against CD8+ T cells, HB170 (R4–6A2) against IFN-γ and the hybridoma HB9419 was used to produce an isotype control antibody. All hybridomas were obtained from the American Type Culture Collection (ATCC) (Manassas, VA, USA). The lines were grown in 2.5 litres of complete IMDM or OptiMEM in Lifecell culture bags (Lifecell Tissue Culture, Baxter Corporation, Concord, Canada) in a humidified atmosphere at 37°C and 5% CO2 until a live cell count (using trypan blue exclusion) revealed 30% dead cells in the culture. The media was then centrifuged and filtered to remove cells and cellular debris. Antibodies were purified from the media using an affinity column of packed sepharose beads (Gammabind G, Amersham Biosciences Corp, Piscataway, NJ, USA) and concentrated with Centriprep YM-30 columns (Millipore, Billerica, MA, USA) before dialysis in PBS. NK cells were depleted using an anti-asialoGM1 antibody produced by Wako Bioproducts (Richmond, VA, USA). Rabbit IgG (Sigma-Aldrich, Oakville, Canada) was used as a control for the anti-asialoGM1 antibody. The T-cell subset and IFN-γ antibodies were injected on days –1, 3, 7, 10 and 14. The doses used were 1mg of antibody on day –1 and 500 μg for the remaining injections. The NK cell-depleting antibody was injected on days –1, 4, 9 and 14 using the recommended dilution . Control isotype antibodies were injected following the same dose and schedule as their corresponding depleting antibodies. The depletion potential of the antibodies was demonstrated in vivo prior to their use in our experiments by injecting mice with a range of concentrations and subsequently examining tissues by flow cytometry to quantify cellular subsets, or examining serum for the presence of cytokines by ELISA. This experiment was conducted twice to test both model systems. In each case, cells were injected on day 0: either 106 70Z/3-L cells followed by 14 daily injections of rIL-12 (10 or 20ng/mouse/day) or 106 70Z/3-L vector-transduced cells of the LV12.2 clonal line. Controls included mice injected with 70Z/3-L alone and mice injected with PBS alone according to the appropriate injection schedule.
Serum collection in live mice was achieved by puncturing the saphenous vein with a sterile needle and collecting the blood in a serum separator tube (BD, Franklin Lakes, NJ, USA). These tubes were centrifuged at 10,000 RPM for 5 min. and serum was then transferred to a micro centrifuge tube and frozen at –20°C until use.
Bead assay for cytokine levels in the serum
Mice were injected IP on day 0 with 106 70Z/3-L cells in 100 μl PBS and treated daily with 100 μl preparations of PBS alone or containing low doses of rIL-12 (10 or 20 ng/mouse/day) for 14 days. Control groups included mice injected daily for 14 days with PBS in the absence of 70Z/3-L cells and rIL-12, and a group that was left entirely untreated. Alternatively, for the leukaemia cell-mediated IL-12 therapy experiment, mice were injected on day 0 with 106 70Z/3-L cells in 100 μl PBS containing various proportions of the 70Z/3-L vector-transduced cell line LV12.2 (0.5%, 1% and 10%). Control groups included mice injected with 70Z/3-L cells alone or PBS alone. Serum was non-terminally collected from all groups on days 7, 10 and 20 before their daily injection by puncture of the saphenous vein as described above. Serum samples were diluted 1/5 and stained according to the protocol provided with the Mouse Inflammation Cytometric Bead Array Kit (BD, San Diego, CA, USA). Standards were prepared in triplicate from independent dilutions and flow cytometry was done using a FACScan (Becton Dickinson, Oakville, Canada). Acquisition was performed using CellQuest software version 3.1. Note: due to insufficient blood collection, two mice treated with cell-mediated therapy in the 0.5% and one in the 1% group on day 7 and two mice in the PBS group on day 10 could not be tested. All mice from the group receiving 70Z/3-L cells alone in the leukaemia cell-produced IL-12 therapy model had perished by day 20 such that serum was not collected from this group.
Intraperitoneal administration of rIL-12 protects mice challenged with 70Z/3-L
Interleukin-12 is known to be a potent modulator of the immune response attributed with a number of anti-leukaemia effects including, but not limited to, T-cell-mediated antigen-specific leukaemia clearance. This molecule has been approved for clinical use but optimum delivery programs have yet to be defined. In an attempt to alter the course of 70Z/3-L leukaemia, we began by testing the effect of IP rIL-12 administration on the appearance of morbidity after IP injection of 106 70Z/3-L cells. We tested doses of 0.1–20 ng/mouse/day for 14 days, which are at least 20-fold below the maximum tolerated dose in mice. In Figure 1A, we show that doses above 10 ng were sufficient to significantly improve the survival of animals (P= 0.002).
Intraperitoneal administration of rIL-12 leads to long-term protective immunity against the 70Z/3-L leukaemia
We next addressed whether the results observed above were due solely to the acute effects of IP-administered rIL-12 on innate responses or to the induction of a long-term adaptive immune response in the mice. To accomplish this, mice received IP injections of 106 70Z/3-L cells, were treated for 14 days with 20 ng/mouse/day rIL-12, subsequently challenged 70 days later by IP injection of 106 70Z/3-L cells and monitored for the appearance of symptoms. A group of naïve mice was included to control for the efficiency of the cells to cause disease. Figure 1 Bii shows that all animals first treated with IP administration of rIL-12 (Fig. 1Bi) survived a secondary challenge with 70Z/3-L cells in the absence of further IL-12 therapy. Thus, IP administration of rIL-12 not only protected against the primary 70Z/3-L challenge but also established long-term protective immune memory.
Intraperitoneal administration of rIL-12 protects animals with pre-established 70Z/3-L leukaemia
To determine if IP administration of rIL-12 can lead to leukaemia clearance as well as protection from a developing neoplasm, treatment initiation was delayed to allow for dissemination of the disease. We undertook these experiments starting with 104 70Z/3-L cells injected IP because of their rapid growth. This dose is still lethal to 100% of mice in approximately 20 days . Initiation of rIL-12 administration was delayed by 0 to 5 days and continued for 14 days following the first injection. We found that we could delay the initiation of rIL-12 therapy by 5 days and still achieve significant protection against the leukaemia (Fig. 1C). The differences between the survival curves of the six treatment groups are not statistically significant and longer delays were not tested.
CD4+ and CD8+ T cells are required for the rIL-12-mediated rejection of 70Z/3-L cells after IP administration
Depleting antibodies were used to determine which cell types mediate the rIL-12-induced rejection of 70Z/3-L leukaemia after IP administration. We show in Figure 1D that both CD4+ and CD8+ T cells are important as depletion of either population eliminates immune protection in all animals. The mean survival was 14 days for mice depleted of CD8+ T cells, 23 days for mice depleted of CD4+ T cells and 13 days for mice depleted of both T cell subsets. The three curves are not statistically different from each other. We also included neutralizing antibodies against IFN-γ to examine its role in the rejection response. We found that this abrogated the protective effects of IP administered rIL-12 demonstrating that IFN-γ plays an essential role in leukaemia rejection. Although the importance of NK cells has been shown in other models of IL-12 therapy [38, 39] we did not observe changes in rejection of the 70Z/3-L leukaemia when NK cells were depleted in this treatment modality (Fig. 1D).
Generation of IL-12 secreting leukaemia cells by implementation of lentiviral transduction
Having established the basic parameters of IL-12 systemic therapy, we next compared this protocol to a cell-mediated approach. Figure 2A shows the lentiviral construct with an IL-12 fusion transgene under control of the EF-1α promoter that we generated. After transducing 70Z3-L cells with an approximate MOI of 20, single cell clones were derived as described in Materials and Methods. Supernatants from these clonal cell lines were tested for the production of IL-12. The range of secretion from selected clones varied from approximately 250–40,000 pg/ml/106cells/2 hrs and these levels remained stable over time as shown in Figure 2B. Furthermore, the different levels of IL-12 measured did not seem dependent on cell growth kinetics, nor on survival, as the in vitro growth properties of the vector-transduced clones were similar as measured by thymidine incorporation and visual inspection. Southern Blot analysis demonstrated that no clone had more than 7 proviral integration events (data not shown).
Only a small proportion of vector-transduced 70Z/3-L cells producing IL-12 are required to confer immunity
We proceeded to determine if the production of IL-12 by vector-transduced 70Z/3-L cells would elicit a protective immune response by injecting 106 cells of each of 12 clones, spanning a range of secretion levels, into the abdominal cavity of BDF1 mice. The three lowest producing clones (range: 200–1000 pg/ml/106 cells/2 hrs) failed to elicit an immune response and mice injected with these cells progressed towards death. In contrast, all mice injected with 106 cells of the 10 highest producing clones (range: 1500–40,000 pg/ml/106 cells/2 hrs) survived (Fig. 3).
One 70Z/3-L transduced clone, LV12.1 that produces approximately 21,500 pg/ml/106cells/2 hrs, was mixed with naïve 70Z/3-L cells to determine if the inclusion of IL-12 producing vector-transduced cells would result in the elimination of non-producing cells also. We initially found that as little as 2% of the vector- transduced cells were sufficient to confer complete protection (Fig. 4A). To further examine the efficacy of producer/non-producer proportions, two other 70Z/3-L-transduced clones were selected that differed in IL-12 production by 10-fold (clone LV12.3: 2000 pg/ml/106 cells/2 hrs versus clone LV12.2: 20,000 pg/ml/106 cells/2 hrs). In this case, as few as 0.5% (i.e. 5000 LV12.2 cells in 106 total cells) of the higher producing clone was sufficient to confer protection to 80% of the mice but 0.1% failed to protect any mice. However, even 10% (i.e. 100,000 LV12.3 cells in 106 total cells) of the lower producing clone was insufficient to protect, indicating that a threshold of IL-12 production per vector-transduced cell is required to elicit an effective immune response (Fig. 4B).
Leukaemia cell-mediated IL-12 therapy leads to specific long-term protective immunity against the 70Z/3-L leukaemia
More than 110 days after IP injection with 106 LV12.2 cells, mice were challenged with either 106 cells of the parental leukaemia line, 70Z/3-L, or another well-characterized B-cell leukaemia, L1210, and monitored for the appearance of symptoms. Groups of naïve mice were included to control for the efficiency of both the 70Z/3-L and L1210 cells to cause disease. Figure 5 shows that all animals to survive the initial insult with LV12.2 were immune to subsequent challenge with 70Z/3-L but not L1210. Thus, cell-mediated IL-12 therapy leads to specific long-term protective immunity.
CD4+ T cells are primarily required for leukaemia cell-mediated rejection of 70Z/3-L cells
Depleting antibodies were used to determine which cell types mediate the IL-12-induced rejection of 70Z/3-L leukaemia. We show in Figure 6 that the CD4+ T-cell subset is of primary importance unlike in the IP administered rIL-12 therapy model above. The mean survival of leukaemia challenged mice was 37 days for animals depleted of CD4+ T cells and 18 days for those depleted of both T-cell subsets. The curves are statistically different (P= 0.003), suggesting an important role for CD8+ T cells but only in the absence of CD4+ T cells. The CD8+ T-cell subset alone is not sufficient to confer protection. Furthermore, the neutralization of IFN-γ did not diminish the protective effect as was seen with IP administered rIL-12 therapy (Fig. 6). This was a surprising result and prompted us to further investigate the regulation of IFN-γ and various other inflammatory cytokines in each model.
In vivo cytokine regulation
Interleukin-12 induces the secretion of other cytokines that can have agonistic, antagonistic or synergistic effects and can influence the specific immune response that is initiated [6–8, 17, 40–43]. It was therefore important to measure the regulation of some of these cytokines in vivo to better understand how leukaemia rejection is accomplished and shed some light on the results of our neutralization experiments. For this purpose, we employed a flow cytometry technique that detects a panel of inflammatory cytokines, including IL-12 p70, TNF-α, IFN-γ, MCP-1, IL-10 and IL-6 in serum. Mice received IP injections of 106 70Z3-L cells on day 0 and daily IP injections of either 10 or 20ng rIL-12/mouse/day for 14 days. Alternatively, mice were challenged with an IP injection of 106 70Z3-L cells on day 0 spiked with various proportions (0.5%, 1% and 10%) of vector-transduced cells and serum samples were collected on days 7, 10 and 20. The results of these two assays are shown in Figure 7.
The levels of IL-10 induced on day 20 are significantly higher after leukaemia cell-mediated therapy as compared to IP administered rIL-12 therapy (P < 0.0017) but are not significantly different between IL-12 treated and control groups for either mode of delivery at any time point. Likewise, the levels of IFN-γ and TNF-α are significantly higher in response to IL-12 secreted from vector-transduced cells (P < 0.0015 and 0.0110 respectively). Of note, however, is that leukaemia cell-mediated treatment groups show significantly higher levels of IFN-γ than the control groups on day 7 (P= 0.0007) but resolve to near basal level by day 20. Interestingly, the systemic levels of IL-12 measured did not correspond to doses administered.
In this manuscript, we demonstrate that IP-administered low-dose rIL-12 therapy can elicit a protective immune response in leukaemia-bearing mice and that an effective approach to deliver IL-12 is via the leukaemia cells themselves. We found that remarkably few transduced leukaemia cells are needed to achieve protection provided a sufficient amount of IL-12 is produced per cell, and that protection is achieved in a manner distinct from that with IP administered rIL-12 therapy.
Given the key role that IL-12 plays in the initiation of effective immune responses in various leukaemia models, we re-examined the potential for cytokine therapy using a murine model of ALL. We have previously reported that 70Z/3-L cells lead to the rapid death of mice injected with as few as 102 cells. In contrast, we established variants of this line that are recognized by the immune system and subsequently rejected. Mixing as few as 105 of these non-leukaemic variants with 106 70Z/3-L cells resulted in complete rejection of all 70Z/3 cells . While we have not yet determined why these variants are recognized by the immune system, these experiments revealed that 70Z/3-L cells can be rejected if the immune system is appropriately modulated, making this experimental system amenable to the study of IL-12-induced anti-leukaemia activity.
Interleukin-12-based therapies have not become front line cancer treatments in part because studies often report low response rates among patients . The poor outcomes associated with IL-12 treatment in these clinical studies might be explained by the physiological response to IL-12-induced IFN-γ. For example, high levels of IL-12, and consequently IFN-γ, have been shown to induce IL-10 and lead to down-modulation of IL-12 responsiveness in the host . However, it has also been shown that leukaemia regression occurs only in patients who sustain elevated levels of IFN-γ throughout the course of their treatment .
Previous groups have demonstrated that administration of IL-12 at doses significantly below the maximum tolerated dose can avoid the induction of antagonistic mechanisms . Therefore, we first determined that daily IP administration of a dose as low as 10–20 ng of rIL-12 for 14 days, equivalent to 500–1,000 ng/kg, is sufficient to significantly increase the survival of mice injected with 70Z/3-L. Our chosen dose is effective against an established leukaemia burden and rejection leads to long-term immune memory in a T-cell-dependent manner. Similar results have been demonstrated in previous literature. The true value of these experiments lies in the comparisons we were able to draw between our two model systems.
We next investigated a cell-mediated strategy for delivery of IL-12 and found that 70Z/3-L cells could be readily transduced with our novel lentiviral construct. This approach may circumvent the dose-limiting toxicity experienced in human clinical trials of systemically delivered IL-12 that was not foreshadowed by pre-clinical murine studies. We found that different vector- transduced clones produce varied amounts of IL-12. This appears to be a stable trait as we have measured similar levels of secreted IL-12 for each clone on 2–5 independent occasions. The vector copy number in these clones was determined but we found that this alone does not explain the variable secretion levels, nor does their rate of proliferation.
The establishment of clones that produce different levels of IL-12 has allowed us to examine the relationship between IL-12 production and the proportion of IL-12+ vector-transduced versus IL-12− naïve 70Z/3-L cells necessary for immune activation. To date, this potentially critical aspect of cell-mediated cytokine therapy has not been thoroughly examined. We found that a very small proportion of IL-12 producing vector-transduced 70Z/3-L cells are sufficient to trigger a protective immune response. For one clone, LV12.2, 5000 such vector-transduced cells (but not 1000) were sufficient to save 80% of the mice injected with 106 70Z/3-L cells. This result could indicate either that a critical number of ‘hits’ or a sufficient amount of IL-12 is required to trigger an immune response. A reasonable interpretation of ‘hit’ might be an encounter between an IL-12 producing vector-transduced 70Z/3-L cell and an appropriate APC, such as a DC. The alternative explanation is that these 5000 vector-transduced cells simply deliver a sufficient quantity of IL-12 into the system to trigger an immune response. To determine which of these explanations is correct we employed a different clone, LV12.3, which produces 10-fold less IL-12 per cell and injected titrated numbers of these vector-transduced cells along with 106 70Z/3-L naïve cells. We found that even 100,000 LV12.3 cells failed to confer protection. This represents 20-fold more cells and twice the potential IL-12 released into the system. Together, these two experiments suggest that it is the number of ‘hits’ that matter rather than the absolute amount of IL-12 but that to qualify as a ‘hit’, the vector-transduced 70Z/3-L cell must produce IL-12 above a certain threshold.
Our findings have important implications for clinical trial design and may partly explain the differences observed between murine studies, in which IL-12 can initiate a curative immune response, and human studies, in which the immune response is modest and patient survival is normally unaffected. The protocols used in mouse studies usually involve selection of clones that secrete relatively high levels of IL-12 and frequently the preparation administered consists of 100% IL-12 secreting cancer cells. In contrast, human studies generally rely on freshly obtained populations of cells that are difficult to clone. Therefore bulk populations are transduced and average amounts of IL-12 produced by these populations are measured. In cases reported to date, these average amounts fall short of what we believe to be necessary to elicit protective immunity and there is no information on the distribution of production levels within these populations. Beyond being insufficient to induce antitumour immunity, lower IL-12 secreting cells may act to inhibit the desired response. The cytokine micromilieu in which a DC matures will define the cytokines that it later releases into the immunological synapse it forms with a T cell. These cytokines form an integral part of the instructive signal that polarizes the T-cells fate and determines the effector function that will be executed . Tumour cells are known to produce cytokines such as IL-10, IL-6 and TGF-β that suppress cellular responses. Because the particular combinations and ratios of cytokines present during DC maturation define their polarizing capacity, we suggest that the amount of IL-12 locally produced by each transduced tumour cell is additionally important as the ratio of IL-12 over such antagonistic cytokines must be sufficiently high to ensure the production of Th1 polarizing DCs and not tolerogenic DCs . A cell-mediated approach may facilitate achieving the necessarily high levels of local expression, without resulting in the toxicity observed in human trials, by confining production to the tumour microenvironment.
The IL-12-induced anti-leukaemia activity in our two models is T-cell-dependent but the subsets that are critical differ depending on the mode of IL-12 delivery. The role of IFN-γ also appeared to differ, prompting us to look at its in vivo regulation along with a number of other inflammatory cytokines. This was done using a flow cytometry-based cytokine bead assay. The regulation of IL-10, IFN-γ and TNF-α are of particular interest in our model systems because IL-10 is known to be the most biologically relevant antagonist of IL-12 , IFN-γ is thought to mediate the effects of IL-12 [4, 13] and a combination of IFN-γ and TNF-α is required for the development of CD4+ CTLs .
The fact that IL-10 production was not elevated above background in any of our treatment groups suggests that while local IL-12 production was high, the systemic amount was sufficiently low as to avoid the induction of antagonistic molecules and dampening of the biologic effect. Measured levels of IFN-γ were significantly higher in the treated groups receiving cell-produced IL-12 as compared to controls on day 7 but were not significant by day 10 and returned to near baseline by day 20. Furthermore, IFN-γ production was significantly greater in the cell-mediated model in general. There is ample literature describing how IL-12 leads to the increased maturation of DCs, the production of IFN-γ and more efficient antigen presentation by the IFN-γ-dependent up-regulation of MHC-II and co-stimulatory molecule expression. T-helper lymphocytes are driven by IFN-γ to differentiate with a type-1 functional profile and subsequently promote the strong CD8+ CTL response that we saw with IP administered rIL-12 therapy. This agrees with the classical model of cytotoxicity mediated by the traditional CD8+ CTL. However, there is also literature describing a role for CD4+ CTLs in models of infection [5, 46–48] and more recently in tumour immunology [49–54]. It is possible that the IFN-γ and TNF-α rich environment resulting from cell-mediated therapy led to the development of an effector CD4+ T-Cell population. This could account for the differential importance of T-cell subsets in our two models and explain the distinct results of the neutralization experiments. The major thrust of tumour vaccination research has traditionally focused on targeting CD8+ CTLs, which require stimulation by a CD4+ helper T-cell population, to affect tumour clearance but the clinical response has been limited. An emerging hypothesis in the field is that directly targeting CD4+ effector cells may be important in achieving a more robust anti-tumour response. Although the mechanism of action of the CD4+ population observed in our system has yet to be delineated, the incitement of a potent CD4+ effector response is of clear interest.
Despite the beneficial effects of IFN-γ highlighted above, a dampening of the response with repeated administration is still of concern in models of IL-12 therapy. An important attribute of our cell-mediated model is that a sufficient immune response is stimulated for a period of time corresponding to that required to eliminate the cancer but the signal is self-limiting. The source of IL-12 into the system is the cancer cells that are, themselves, the target of therapy. As the leukaemia cells are rejected, the source of IL-12 is reduced and IFN-γ levels return to baseline without a significant increase in the antagonistic molecule IL-10. Our approach differs from others in the field of immunotherapy in a number of informative ways. In protocols that engineer DCs and fibroblasts to stably secrete IL-12, for example, production would continue even after tumour clearance. In addition, the secretion levels reported to date have not reached what we propose to be therapeutic, possibly explaining the mixed responses observed. Alternatively, methods for stimulating the maturation of autologous tumour antigen-loaded DCs, leading to IL-12 production, have also been described . These DCs are only capable of producing IL-12 for approximately 18 hrs after administration and treatment efficiency may be highly dependent upon the amount of time required for these semi-mature DCs to travel to the LNs where they can stimulate a T-cell response. Another apparent limitation of this approach is the effect the maturation stimulus has on the migratory capacity of these DCs. Our IL-12 transduction protocol does not appear to interfere with the migration of the cell line used in our studies as evidenced by the successful eradication of a widely disseminated leukaemia. Each of these approaches possess merit and may prove to be very valuable and effective therapeutic regimens. We assert that tumour cell-mediated approaches warrant further investigation to round out this growing body of knowledge.
We have demonstrated in this manuscript that IL-12, given at doses below which the resulting systemic levels of IFN-γ lead to the induction of antagonistic mechanisms, is sufficient to launch a protective immune response against 70Z/3-L ALL cells and complete clearance of the leukaemia if individual tumour cells produce IL-12 above a critical threshold. We highlight that the mode of IL-12 delivery can have a profound impact on the nature of the immune response that is mounted and demonstrate a critical role for CD4+ cells in our cell-mediated model that apparently does not exist in our IP administration model. Moreover, a potentially problematic dampening of the immune response was not observed. This is possibly due to the localization of IL-12 secretion by, and self-limiting nature of the cell-mediated therapy approach we employed.
We thank Drs. Pam Ohashi, Brian Barber, Mark Minden, Keith Stewart, Craig Milne and Danijela Konforte for reviewing the manuscript and for helpful suggestions, and a special thanks to Paul Boutros for aiding with statistical analysis. We would also like to thank members of the Paige lab for helpful discussions and Dr. Yu Zhang for technical assistance. This work was supported by the National Cancer Institute of Canada/Terry Fox Foundation.
Disclosure: The authors declare no potential conflict of interest.
- 19Differential effect of high doses versus low doses of interleukin-12 on the adoptive transfer of human specific cytotoxic T lymphocyte in autologous lung tumors engrafted into severe combined immunodeficiency disease-nonobese diabetic mice: relation with interleukin-10 induction. Cancer. 2001; 91: 113–22., , , et al.
- 20Two phase I studies of low dose recombinant human IL-12 with Melan-A and influenza peptides in subjects with advanced malignant melanoma. Cancer Immunol. 2003; 3: 7–24., , , et al.
- 49Possible involvement of allogeneic antigens recognised by donor-derived CD4 cytotoxic T cells in selective GVL effects after stem cell transplantation of patients with haematological malignancy. Br J Haematol. 2006; 132: 56–65., , , et al.