Review of recommendations for the management of dental trauma presented in first-aid textbooks and manuals

Authors


Katarzyna Emerich, Department of Paediatric Dentistry, Medical University of Gdansk, ul. Orzeszkowej 18, 80-208 Gdansk, Poland
Tel.: +48 604 499 977
Fax: +48 58 551 58 39
e-mail: emerich@gumed.edu.pl

Abstract

Abstract –  Background:  To be able to help at the site of the oro-facial injury, the majority of persons would turn to medical books and first-aid books to extend their knowledge. Proper information in first-aid textbooks and manuals should be the best way to present necessary procedures on how to act at the site of injury. The objective of this review is to report the quality of the knowledge presented in first-aid books and manuals.

Methods:  We carried out a review of first-aid international textbooks and manuals available in Medical University Libraries in Poland. The inclusion criteria were all manuals on first-aid that were written for medical staff and lay persons, and were published between 1969 and 2007. All texts were screened for dental trauma treatment recommendations.

Results:  Our literature review has shown that among 45 first-aid textbooks and manuals only 19 mention procedures for use in case of dental trauma. Of those texts, only 13 detail the storage media for an avulsed tooth until replantation.

Conclusions:  Current, evidence-based, recommendations concerning first-aid procedures after dental trauma should be incorporated in forthcoming editions of first-aid textbooks and manuals. The guidance on procedures contained in reviewed texts is misleading.

The last decades have observed a dramatic increase in the number of research articles related to dental trauma among children and adolescents. This may indicate that traumatic dental injury has evolved into a major public health problem. Studies indicate that in industrialized countries, about one in five children have had a traumatic dental injury to permanent teeth before leaving school. Prevalence of injured teeth presented in the literature varies from 10% to 51% (1, 2).

Most of the available literature emphasizes that awareness of the correct procedure following dental trauma is unsatisfactory (3–7). It is recognized that the prognosis of traumatic dental injuries is dependent on the time between the injury and the initiation of treatment (8, 9). Emergency dental treatment by a physician is sometimes required when a dentist is unavailable. Holan and Shmueli’s survey findings suggest, however, that only 4% of physicians would provide an appropriate initial treatment that could help to save an avulsed tooth (10). Even in medical courses and first-aid training, management of dental trauma is seldom covered (11, 12).

In view of the widespread lack of knowledge with regard to first-aid procedures in cases of dental trauma, we report a review of dental trauma recommendations of first-aid textbooks and manuals.

It is of the utmost importance that this knowledge is widely available to all interested parties and that it is presented correctly in the first-aid books in accordance with the newest findings and recommendations of the relevant bodies.

Methods

The review was carried out on first-aid textbooks and manuals available in Medical University Libraries in Poland. The great majority of the books is available internationally as 34 of them were written in English, 1 of them in German, and only 10 originated in Polish language. The inclusion criteria were textbooks and manuals on first aid that were written for medical staff and lay persons and were published between 1969 and 2007. The texts were read carefully and screened for dental trauma treatment recommendations. The topics checked were:

  •  management of tooth avulsion (immediate replantation, storage media, time management factor, splinting procedures),
  •  tooth luxations,
  •  tooth fracture,
  •  recommendations for dental visit.

Results

Forty-five texts met the inclusion criteria. Of those, 34 texts were in English, 10 in Polish and 1 in German. Nine of the 34 English texts had also Polish edition. Eight first-aid texts published between 1969 and 1983 had no information about dental trauma management at all. In the years 1984 to 1998, we found 16 books and 7 of them had some information concerning dental trauma management. In the last 10 years, the situation has changed favourably, because among 21 books, we found 12 texts dealing with dental trauma (Fig. 1). Out of all 45 first-aid textbooks available, we could only find information about dental trauma management in 19 texts (13–31). The other 26 books had no information concerning first-aid procedures after dental injury (32–57). Treatment of an avulsed tooth appears in 15 texts, whereas the other books do not mention dental avulsion at all (Table 1). Of the 15 textbooks, 13 detail the storage media of an avulsed tooth until replantation and all of them point out the importance of the time factor in the management of avulsion: only nine of those, however, mentioned that the most important time is the first 30 to 60 min after injury. Only nine texts mentioned splinting procedure: three of those elaborate on temporary splinting procedure, but only three texts give the proper recommendation of splinting duration. Only nine books recommend immediate self-replantation as the treatment of choice. The management of traumatic tooth fracture is described in 12 books and tooth subluxation in 10. Recommendation of immediate referral to dental surgery is mentioned in seven first-aid texts, another four suggest that it should take place as soon as possible, and one text published in 2000 still recommends seeing the dentist after 7 days. The latter advice is inadmissible nowadays.

Figure 1.

 Number of texts published between 1969 and 2007 with and without information about dental trauma.

Table 1.   First-aid textbooks and manuals – dental trauma management presented in the texts
AuthorsYear of publicationLanguageTooth avulsionLuxationDental fractureTime to see the dentist
Immediate replantationStorage mediaTime factorSplinting
Beers MH. The Merck manual of medical information (13).2003ENRecommendedMilk30 min7–10 days++Immediately
Buntain WL. Management of pediatric trauma (14).1995ENRecommendedMilk, water, saliva60 min7–10 days-Immediately
Caroline NL. Study guide for emergency care in the streets (15).1995EN-Gauze soaked in salineSoon enough--
Cline DM, et al. Emergency Medicine (16).1999ENRecommendedHank’s solution, saliva, milk, wet gauze180 min-++As soon as possible
Dziak A, Rusin Z. Traumatologia sportowa (17).2000PL--Couple of hours-+Couple of hours
Finley JM, McConnell RY. Emergency wound repair (18).1984ENRecommended-60 min-+Immediately
Kaminski B, Dziak A. Dorazna pomoc lekarska (19).1984PL---4 weeks++-
Keim SM. Emergency Medicine on Call (20).2004ENAs soon as possibleMilk60 min-++-
King Ch, Henretig FM. Pocket Atlas of Pediatric Emergency Procedures (21).2000ENRecommended---+Immediately
Markovchick VJ, et al. Emergency Medicine Secrets (22).1993EN-Saliva, milk, saline, wet gauze120 min-+-
Marx JA, et al. Rosen’s emergency medicine: concepts and clinical practice (23).2006ENRecommendedHank’s solution, milk, saliva, saline30 minAcrylic splint or wiring 2 weeks++-
May HL, et al. Emergency medicine (24).1992EN---4 weeks++As soon as possible
Murtagh J. Pracice tips (25).1999ENRecommendedSaliva, milk30 minTemporary Alu-foilAs soon as possible
National Safety Council. Basic First Aid (26).2005ENRecommendedMilk, saliva, waterVery soon--
Plantz SH, Wipfler EJ. NMS: Emergency Medicine (27).2007ENAs soon as possibleSaliva, milk, wet gauzeAs soon as possible+++Immediately
Schimelpfenig T. Wilderness Medicine (28).2000EN-Wet gauze, saliva30 min-7 days
Sheridan RL. The trauma handbook of the Massachusetts General Hospital (29).2004EN±---As soon as possible
Strange GR, et al. Pediatric Emergency Medicine (30).1998ENRecommendedSaliva, milk, saline30 minTemporary dental wax++Immediately
Wyatt JP, et al. Oxford Handbook of Accident and Emergency Medicine (31).1999EN±MilkCouple of hoursTemporary Alu-foil++Immediately

Discussion

Tooth avulsion, a complex injury affecting multiple tissues with complete displacement of a tooth from its alveolar support, requires prompt and appropriate management to improve prognosis significantly (58). The other dental injuries like luxation or dental fracture does not require such prompt action, but should be seen by a dentist within the first 24 h. Tooth avulsion, which should be considered the real emergency in dentistry, represents up to 21% of all dental injuries (59). Although everyone should know that avulsed teeth can be replanted with relative ease, the literature shows that this is not common knowledge (3–7). It would seem obvious that an oro-facial injury requires the immediate attention of a dentist, but some studies show that many individuals do not seek treatment or advice after an injury at all (59–61). Avulsed tooth should be replanted within first 30 min and if not it should be placed in a transport media to avoid damage of root periodontal ligament cells. The longer the time lapse between tooth avulsion and replantation, the greater the risk of replacement resorption and inflammatory root resorption (62, 63).

It goes without saying that the best way to preserve the vitality of periodontal ligament cells is immediate replantation. In a hospital scenario where the first aid is given by medical staff, fixation of an avulsed tooth can be made by a suture by an easily performed temporary fixation method (64). A temporary splint made from aluminium foil, available in every kitchen or from any chocolate bar, can also be applied prior to emergency dental surgery (25, 31). Alternatively, if there is no one around brave enough to replant and stabilize the tooth, an avulsed tooth can be placed in milk, which is the preferred transport media, or in saliva (between the cheek and the lower molars). Other possible transport media – if available at the site of the injury – are Viaspan, Hank’s Balanced Salt Solution and physiologic saline (63).

All health professionals or other people managing dental trauma should be aware of first-aid procedure in order to avoid extra-oral dry time of a tooth. For the future outcome of tooth avulsion treatment, the tooth extra-oral dry time is much more important than when the patient was able to reach a dentist. In view of the above, the literature that recommends a dental visit up to 7 days after tooth avulsion should be corrected or removed from circulation.

The general public and non-dental professionals have very limited opportunity to gain knowledge of oral trauma management. The most popular sources are first-aid textbooks but, as we can see in this study, only some books have this kind of information. The other problem is that just 10 of the 45 books screened in this study contain all the information necessary for non-dental professionals about first care of tooth avulsion.

First-aid textbooks are used in medical courses and first-aid training and also as a self-help guide or manual in a real-time event. That is why the dental trauma management procedure should be described as simply as possible, but including all important factors.

Our study clearly shows that explanation of first-aid procedures after dental injury is insufficient and compounds lack of knowledge among doctors, teachers and other lay persons, for whom first-aid textbooks were written (3–5, 7). Our results are also in agreement with previous report presented by Zadik (65).

There is also a positive element to report from our study. Some improvement of the dental trauma management recommendations can be observed in the content of lately published textbooks: that is encouraging and we hope for further improvement.

Conclusion

Rarely can extensive consequences of injury be prevented by such simple knowledge and action. An effort should be made to train general medical practitioners and other emergency room staff to perform appropriate first-aid procedures for dental trauma. Worldwide, this would result in an improved outcome for everyone who injures his/her teeth. That is why current first-aid procedures after dental trauma should be incorporated in forthcoming editions of first-aid textbooks and manuals as the best way to promote simple knowledge of the subject. This, however, cannot be realized until outdated texts are revised and the appropriate procedures are included in all new first-aid books and manuals. Only in this way will those looking for this specific knowledge be able to apply the correct action at the site of the injury.

There is no relationship that can lead to any conflict of interests. No external funding was requested or used.

Ancillary