Get access

Against Arguments from Reference*

Authors


  • *

    We would like to thank Elizabeth Harman, Jonathan Weinberg, and Wayne Wu for helpful comments on previous drafts.

Abstract

It is common in various quarters of philosophy to derive philosophically significant conclusions from theories of reference. In this paper, we argue that philosophers should give up on such ‘arguments from reference.’ Intuitions play a central role in establishing theories of reference, and recent cross-cultural work suggests that intuitions about reference vary across cultures and between individuals within a culture (Machery et al. 2004). We argue that accommodating this variation within a theory of reference undermines arguments from reference.

Ancillary