Letters to the Editor
Structure and mechanics of fibrin clots formed under mechanical perturbation
Version of Record online: 13 MAR 2013
© 2013 International Society on Thrombosis and Haemostasis
Journal of Thrombosis and Haemostasis
Volume 11, Issue 3, pages 557–560, March 2013
How to Cite
Structure and mechanics of fibrin clots formed under mechanical perturbation. J Thromb Haemost 2013; 11: 557–60., , , .
- Issue online: 13 MAR 2013
- Version of Record online: 13 MAR 2013
- Accepted manuscript online: 7 JAN 2013 12:34PM EST
- Manuscript Accepted: 23 DEC 2012
- Manuscript Received: 24 OCT 2012
- National Science Foundation
- University of Erlangen-Nuremberg
The mechanical properties of a blood clot are of crucial importance for its ability to stem the flow of blood at a site of vascular injury . These properties are largely determined by the mechanics of the underlying structural scaffold, a branched network of the biopolymer fibrin . This network forms during coagulation, when monomeric fibrin assembles into protofibrils that laterally aggregate into thicker fibers and occasionally branch to form a percolated, three-dimensional structure . Alterations in network structure, such as changes in fiber density, fiber thickness or branching probability, strongly affect the mechanics of the network [3-6].
Investigations of the relationship of the network architecture to bulk-level mechanics are commonly performed on in vitro fibrin networks polymerized under static conditions [3, 7, 8]. However, in the body, blood clots form in a mechanically dynamic environment: intravascular clots form in the presence of flowing blood, whereas clots forming in the extravascular tissue might also be exposed to mechanical perturbations other than flow, for instance due to the action of breathing and body movements, or the pulsatile dilation of the vessel wall. Indeed, the structure of fibrin clots polymerized under fluid flow is profoundly changed [9, 10]. However, the effects of mechanical perturbations during clot polymerization on clot structure and its resultant mechanical properties remain unknown.
Here, we report the effect of mechanical perturbation during polymerization on the structure and mechanics of fibrin clots. We polymerized fibrin clots (0.8 mg/mL human fibrinogen (Enzyme Research Labs, South Bend, IN, USA), 0.05 NIH units/mL human α-thrombin (Enzyme Research Labs), in a buffer containing 0.15 m NaCl, 20 mm Ca, 25 mm HEPES at pH 7.4) for at least 1 hour at 25 °C in situ in a strain-controlled rheometer (ARES-G2, TA Instruments, New Castle, DE, USA) fitted with a cone-plate geometry (Fig. 1A). During polymerization, we continuously applied sinusoidal shear perturbations with a frequency of 0.1 Hz at six different strain amplitudes (0%, 10%, 30%, 45%, 60% and 90%) (Fig. 1B). Subsequently, we measured the stress-strain response of the clots by applying a strain ramp at 1%/s (Fig. 1B). The local slope of the stress-strain curve characterizes the differential stiffness, K', of the material as a function of strain. All data are averages of two to four independent experiments per condition. We confirmed by denaturing gel electrophoresis that our fibrinogen stock had sufficient trace amounts of factor XIII for complete γ-γ cross-linking within 10 min, and that monomeric α-chains were nearly completely depleted after 1 hour of polymerization (data not shown).
Fibrin clots polymerized in the absence of mechanical perturbation exhibited a highly non-linear mechanical response with several characteristic regimes . At low strain, the differential stiffness was constant, corresponding to a linear elastic modulus. Beyond a characteristic strain, the differential stiffness steeply increased and the mechanics became highly non-linear. Eventually, the differential stiffness reached a plateau and the mechanics became approximately linear. Ultimately, the differential stiffness again increased, with the mechanics again becoming non-linear until the clot broke (Fig. 1C).
Fibrin clots polymerized under oscillatory perturbations also exhibited these regimes. However, the characteristic strain for the onset of non-linearity increased with increasing perturbation amplitude (Fig. 1C, horizontal arrow). Interestingly, the transition into the plateau regime occurred at the strain value corresponding to the perturbation amplitude (Fig. 1C, vertical bars). Consequently, all further transitions were shifted to larger strains, and the clots ruptured successively later (Fig. 1D, blue). Moreover, the differential stiffnesses and the rupture stresses were of comparable magnitude for clots polymerized at perturbation amplitudes up to 60% (Fig. 1D, red). However, the initial stiffnesses in the linear regime decreased dramatically for perturbation amplitudes larger than 10% (Fig. 1D, green). These results suggest that the linear modulus, commonly reported as the only measure of clot mechanics, is a poor indicator of the high-strain mechanics and rupture stress.
To determine the origin of these perturbation-induced mechanical alterations, we polymerized fluorescently labeled fibrin clots (0.8 mg/mL of a 1:6 mixture of fibrinogen labeled with TAMRA-SE (Sigma, St Louis, MO, USA) with unlabeled fibrinogen) in a home-built parallel-plate shear cell mounted on a confocal microscope (Leica SP5, equipped with a 63 ×/1.2NA water immersion lens; Wetzlar, Germany) (Fig. 1E). To replicate the perturbing oscillations of the rheometer, we continuously moved the upper plate back and forth at different amplitudes for at least 1 hour while the clots were forming. Subsequently, we imaged the full three-dimensional structure of each clot by acquiring a stack of evenly spaced optical sections. Projections of x–z slices along the y-axis show that fibrin clots formed without perturbations had a largely homogeneous distribution of isotropically orientated fibers (Fig. 1F). In contrast, the structure of clots polymerized under perturbation showed two distinct layers: a layer of homogeneous clot structure with a density comparable to that of the unperturbed sample, and a second layer with a highly inhomogeneous structure of bundled fibers and large pores (Fig. 1H–J). The thickness of the bundled layer increased with increasing perturbation amplitude, and the pore size was comparable to the layer thickness. Similar fiber bundling has also been reported for networks polymerized under steady fluid flow . Layer formation and bundling occurred only when the perturbations were applied during polymerization; to confirm this, we applied an oscillatory strain of 60% for 1 hour to a clot polymerized under static conditions. We found that the fiber density and degree of homogeneity of the clot remained unchanged (Fig. 1G). Moreover, the non-linear mechanics of fully polymerized and cross-linked clots did not change even under repeated large shear oscillations (data not shown) .
To explore how the change in clot structure led to changes in the mechanical response, we translated the top plate by 5% strain increments and acquired full three-dimensional images after each shear step. The sequence of x–z projections reveals the dynamic behavior of the clots as they were sheared (movie S1 in Supporting Material). A clot polymerized under static conditions deformed evenly throughout its entire thickness, with many fibers aligning in the direction of strain; in the strain-stiffening regime, these fibers stretched homogeneously, suggesting that the mechanical properties are homogenous throughout the clot. In contrast, for the clots polymerized under oscillatory perturbation, the two structurally different layers exhibited different behaviors when the clots were sheared (movie S1). Initially, at low strains, the fiber bundles accommodated the full applied deformation by tilting and straightening, whereas the fibers in the dense region remained virtually undeformed and only translated horizontally with the moving plate. However, once the fiber bundles became straight, the dense region of the clot also began to deform.
Clots polymerized under larger perturbation amplitudes had larger regions of thicker yet more undulated bundles, which could accommodate a proportionally larger deformation until they were straightened; hence, the strain where the denser region began to stretch was greater (Fig. 1K–M). Furthermore, the lowered linear modulus of these clots indicates that the initial straightening of the bundles required less force than the deformation of unperturbed clots. However, once the fiber bundles were straightened and the clots exhibited strain-stiffening, the typical stiffness range was comparable to that of unperturbed clots. Hence, the mechanics of the dense region of perturbed clots must be similar to those of unperturbed clots. Therefore, the occurrence of the structural heterogeneity explains the delayed onset of the non-linear stiffening of clots formed under perturbation, whereas the abundance of a dense clot layer explains the mechanical similarity to unperturbed clots when strained to large deformations.
In contrast to undulated bundles formed upon application of oscillatory perturbations during polymerization, application of a constant flow during polymerization of fibrin clots results in straight fibers aligned in the direction of flow [9, 10]. Undulated bundles led to a lower linear modulus and a delay in the non-linear response; in contrast, straight fibers should cause an immediate onset of the non-linear response, which would increase the apparent linear modulus of clots formed under flow .
In conclusion, we have shown that fibrin polymerized under continuous oscillatory shear perturbations forms rigid clots that exhibit a significantly later onset of strain-stiffening, a postponed rupture strain, and a lower linear modulus. Up to perturbation amplitudes of 45% strain, the typical non-linear stiffnesses of these clots, as well as their rupture stresses, are of similar magnitude to those formed without perturbation. These changes in the mechanical properties result from changes in clot architecture: one part of the clot shows a highly bundled structure, while the remaining part is virtually unaltered. This architectural adjustment to the specific loading conditions of the environment may enable blood clots to maintain their non-linear properties and prevent early rupture, hence, allowing them to serve their function over a wide range of mechanical challenges.
This work was supported by the ‘Emerging Fields Initiative’ of the University of Erlangen-Nuremberg (Project: TOPbiomat) (SM and BF) and by the National Science Foundation through the Harvard Materials Research Science and Engineering Center (DMR-0820484) (DAW).
Disclosure of Conflict of Interests
The authors state that they have no conflict of interest.
|jth12123-sup-0001-MovieS1.avi||video/avi||3861K||Movie S1. Dynamic behavior of fibrin clots polymerized under perturbation during shear up to 250% strain in 5% increments.|
Please note: Wiley Blackwell is not responsible for the content or functionality of any supporting information supplied by the authors. Any queries (other than missing content) should be directed to the corresponding author for the article.