From Experience to Metaphysics: On Experience-based Intuitions and their Role in Metaphysics
Article first published online: 9 MAY 2013
© 2013 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.
How to Cite
Benovsky, J. (2013), From Experience to Metaphysics: On Experience-based Intuitions and their Role in Metaphysics. Noûs. doi: 10.1111/nous.12024
- Article first published online: 9 MAY 2013
Metaphysical theories are often counter-intuitive. But they also often are strongly supported and motivated by intuitions. One way or another, the link between intuitions and metaphysics is a strong and important one, and there is hardly any metaphysical discussion where intuitions do not play a crucial role. In this article, I will be interested in a particular kind of such intuitions, namely those that come, at least partly, from experience. There seems to be a route from experience to metaphysics, and this is the core of my interest here. In order to better understand such ‘arguments from experience’ and the kind of relationship there is between this type of intuitions and metaphysical theories, I shall examine four particular cases where a kind of experience-based intuition seems to motivate or support a metaphysical theory. At the end of the day, I shall argue that this route is a treacherous one, and that in all of the four cases I shall concentrate on, phenomenological considerations are in fact orthogonal to the allegedly ‘corresponding’ metaphysical claims. An anti-realist view of metaphysics will emerge.