Get access

Does the easy–difficult item measure attitude or perceived behavioural control?

Authors

  • Camille Gagné,

    Corresponding author
    1. Research Group on Behaviours in the Field of Health, Faculty of Nursing, Laval University, Quebec, Canada
    Search for more papers by this author
  • Gaston Godin

    1. Research Group on Behaviours in the Field of Health, Faculty of Nursing, Laval University, Quebec, Canada
    2. Canadian Research Chair on Behaviour and Health, Canada
    Search for more papers by this author

Correspondence should be addressed to Camille Gagné, Research Group on Behaviours in the Field of Health, Faculty of Nursing, Paul-Comtois Building, 4106, Laval University, Quebec (Quebec), Canada G1K 7P4 (e-mail: camille.gagne@fsi.ulaval.ca).

Abstract

Objective In order to determine if easy–difficult item measures attitude or perceived behavioural control (PBC), we used structural equation modelling of 10 cross-sectional data sets.

Design Cross-sectional design was used.

Method. Ten studies that examined health-related behaviours and used the theory of planned behaviour as a theoretical framework were analysed. Samples totalling N = 4,552 participants were employed. All studies involved multi-item measures of attitude (Aact) and PBC items derived from pilot testing.

Results Confirmatory factor analysis confirmed the discriminant validity of Aact and PBC. Structural equation modelling of relevant path indicated that in three studies, easy–difficult item is an indicator of both Aact and PBC. In the other seven studies, easy–difficult item belongs to PBC. The indexes of meta-analysis suggest that overall, easy–difficult item is an indicator of PBC.

Conclusion. Findings from 10 studies converged toward the conclusion that the easy–difficult item is an indicator of perceived PBC. However, since the easy–difficult item is sometimes classified as both Aact and PBC, and only the perceived difficulty dimension of PBC captures a significant increment in the variance of intention, it appears important to develop and validate a set of items devoted to measure the perceived difficulty dimension adequately.

Ancillary