DISCLOSURES: Supported by National Institutes of Health grant T32 CA009614-23.
New developments in the diagnosis and treatment of thyroid cancer
Version of Record online: 24 JUN 2013
© 2013 American Cancer Society, Inc.
CA: A Cancer Journal for Clinicians
Volume 63, Issue 6, pages 373–394, November/December 2013
How to Cite
Schneider, D. F. and Chen, H. (2013), New developments in the diagnosis and treatment of thyroid cancer. CA: A Cancer Journal for Clinicians, 63: 373–394. doi: 10.3322/caac.21195
- Issue online: 11 NOV 2013
- Version of Record online: 24 JUN 2013
- Manuscript Accepted: 26 APR 2013
- Manuscript Revised: 24 APR 2013
- thyroid cancer;
- papillary thyroid cancer;
- follicular thyroid cancer;
- medullary thyroid cancer;
Thyroid cancer exists in several forms. Differentiated thyroid cancers include those with papillary and follicular histologies. These tumors exist along a spectrum of differentiation, and their incidence continues to climb. A number of advances in the diagnosis and treatment of differentiated thyroid cancers now exist. These include molecular diagnostics and more advanced strategies for risk stratification. Medullary cancer arises from the parafollicular cells and not the follicular cells. Therefore, diagnosis and treatment differs from those of differentiated thyroid tumors. Genetic testing and newer adjuvant therapies have changed the diagnosis and treatment of medullary thyroid cancer. This review will focus on the epidemiology, diagnosis, workup, and treatment of both differentiated and medullary thyroid cancers, focusing specifically on newer developments in the field. CA Cancer J Clin 2013;63:373-394. ©2013 American Cancer Society, Inc.
Thyroid cancers exist in several forms. Providers caring for patients with thyroid cancer must tailor the evaluation, treatment, and surveillance to the specific type of tumor and each individual patient's risk factors for recurrence and mortality. Newer molecular diagnostics and targeted therapies offer patients the potential for tailored, or personalized, thyroid cancer therapy. However, the risk of complications versus any potential benefit must be weighed carefully since most thyroid cancers behave indolently, and complications could be lifelong.[1, 2]
The most common type of thyroid cancer is papillary thyroid cancer (PTC), comprising 80% of all cases. The second most common type is follicular thyroid cancer (FTC), which accounts for 10% to 20% of all cases. Together, PTC and FTC are termed differentiated thyroid cancer (DTC), and both arise from the thyroid follicular cells. Medullary thyroid cancer (MTC), however, arises from the parafollicular C cells. This neuroendocrine thyroid tumor represents 6% to 8% of all thyroid cancer cases and occurs in both familial and sporadic forms. Finally, anaplastic thyroid cancer (ATC) is one of the most aggressive and rapidly fatal cancers. It can develop from DTC that dedifferentiates over time or it also arises de novo.[3-6] The first part of this review will consider the spectrum of DTC, and the second section will cover MTC.
Differentiated Thyroid Cancer
Thyroid cancer is the most rapidly increasing malignancy in the United States for both men and women. Although the incidence of DTC has increased worldwide, there was a 2.4-fold increase in its incidence in the United States between 1973 and 2002, and the incidence has continued to rise over the last decade.[7, 8] This increasing incidence is attributed to the improved detection of smaller (<2 cm) tumors via more frequent and better ultrasound detection and fine-needle aspiration (FNA) biopsies. Another theory with which to explain the increasing incidence of DTC is the increased pathologic reporting of incidental microcarcinomas (tumors measuring < 1 cm) in thyroids removed for benign disease. Autopsy studies support this notion, since incidental microcarcinomas are discovered in 10% to 30% of the population.[10-12] Further analysis of the increasing incidence of thyroid cancers revealed that although the incidence of microcarcinomas increased by 19.3% per year between 1983 and 2006, the incidence of tumors measuring 1 cm to 2 cm, 2 cm to 5 cm, and greater than 5 cm in size increased by 12.3%, 10.3%, and 12.0% per year, respectively, over that same period. This suggests that the better detection of smaller tumors does not fully account for the overall increasing incidence of DTC. Possible explanations for the rising incidence include increased iatrogenic, or “diagnostic,” radiation exposure; changes in the population's body mass index; fertility drugs; or changes in menstrual cycles.[14-17] These potential causative factors need further exploration in the US population. Regardless of the reason behind the rising incidence of DTC, the mortality rate remains largely unchanged at 0.5 per 100,000 population.[8, 18]
External radiation exposure to the head and neck region is one of the most well-known causes of thyroid cancer. Historically, patients received radiation treatments for enlarged tonsils or acne. Today, patients with cancer such as Hodgkin disease might still receive mantle radiation. In addition, children exposed to radioactive fallout from the Chernobyl nuclear accident have demonstrated an increased incidence of thyroid cancer.[19, 20] Children, especially females, are particularly sensitive to external radiation, with the greatest risk for exposures before adolescence. This occurs with exposure to either radioactive isotopes, as in nuclear accidents, or external-beam radiation used for medical diagnostics or treatment. Originally, radiation doses of 1 to 10 gray (Gy) were considered causative, but further evaluation of patients exposed to the Chernobyl fallout demonstrated a linear dose-response relationship. Several studies have demonstrated an exposure odds ratio of 5.2 per Gy, even with lower doses.[21-23] Epidemiologic studies report that 7% to 9% of patients who received 5 Gy to 10 Gy of external-beam radiation develop thyroid cancer. A lag time of 10 to 20 years usually exists between exposure and the diagnosis of thyroid cancer, although much shorter periods have been reported.
Another environmental etiology for thyroid cancer is dietary iodine content. PTC occurs with a higher frequency in regions with a high dietary iodine content such as Iceland and the Pacific Rim. Iodine-deficient countries, in contrast, have a higher incidence of FTC. Many factors confound these studies linking changes in DTC frequencies to iodine intake. Other dietary factors such as selenium, goitrogen, and carcinogen intake likely play causative roles. However, it is difficult to isolate these factors from genetic and environmental factors that also likely contribute to thyroid carcinogenesis. Finally, the thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH) level has also been identified as a cancer risk. A higher TSH level in patients with thyroid nodular disease is associated with both a greater risk of DTC and advanced tumor stage.
In the last 10 to 15 years, the information on genetic etiologies of DTC has seen an exponential growth. Both inherited and acquired genetic lesions have been studied. DTC occurs in inherited syndromes such as Gardner, Cowden, and Werner syndromes.[28, 29] Familial nonmedullary thyroid cancer (FNMTC) is defined when 2 or more first-degree relatives are diagnosed with DTC in the absence of another syndrome. It exhibits autosomal dominant behavior with incomplete penetrance and variable expressivity.[29-31] Several candidate genes for FNMTC have been studied, including thyroid tumors with cell oxyphilia 1 (TCO1), multinodular goiter 1 (MNG1), familial papillary thyroid cancer/papillary renal neoplasia (fPTC)/PRN), and nonmedullary thyroid carcinoma 1 (NMTC1), but a single responsible gene has yet to be definitively identified.[32-35] Compared with sporadic DTC, FNMTC is more aggressive, with increased recurrence, local invasion, multicentricity, and lymph node metastases. FNMTC should be suspected in the setting of 2 or more family members with DTC and/or younger family members (those in their 20s to 30s) with more advanced cancers (ie, lymph node metastases). More recently, Mazeh et al demonstrated that even patients with just one family member affected by DTC were similar to patients with FNMTC in terms of age, tumor size, tumor multicentricity, lymph node metastases, local invasiveness, and disease recurrence. Hence, inherited forms of DTC may prove more common than previously thought, and current definitions may change with further study. Currently, FNMTC remains difficult to distinguish from sporadic DTC in the absence of a validated genetic test and therefore no screening recommendations exist.
Increasing investigation into acquired genetic lesions that can distinguish carcinoma from benign nodules has greatly expanded our knowledge of the molecular pathogenesis of DTC. A number of different molecular markers have been identified in DTC. Here, 4 molecular markers with the most literature in human studies will be discussed. Some centers are beginning to use these markers in clinical practice, as we will discuss in the section regarding diagnosis. One such marker is the RET and PTC (RET/PTC) rearrangement. For example, 70% of cancers found in Chernobyl survivors carried a RET/PTC rearrangement. The fusion of the tyrosine kinase-encoding domain of the RET protein with a heterologous group of genes occurs in 20% to 40% cases. RET/PTC rearrangements are common in small, multifocal PTCs accompanied by an inflammatory infiltrate, and often are seen in individuals exposed to ionizing radiation.
BRAF is a member of the RAF-MEK-ERK (extracellular signal-related kinase) serine/threonine kinase signaling cascade, and a BRAF mutation is found in 40% of PTC cases. The BRAF point mutation, or mutations in another member of this signaling pathway, RAS, are frequent in cases of poorly differentiated PTC or ATC. Most BRAF mutations keep the protein in its active form, resulting in constitutive activation of the RAF-MEK-ERK signaling cascade and continued mitogenic activity. The Ras proteins are plasma membrane GTPases activated by growth factor receptors. Mutations that result in constitutive activation of RAS lead to oncogenesis. RAS mutations occur in 20% to 50% of follicular cancers.
Similar to the RET/PTC rearrangement, another chromosomal translocation occurs in FTC. The promoter region of the gene encoding paired box 8 (PAX8) fuses with the coding sequence of the peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor-γ (PPARγ) gene in 35% of FTC cases.[40-42] The intracellular signaling consequences of the PAX8-PPARγ rearrangement remain unclear. RAS mutations are also highly prevalent in FTC, but Nikiforova et al found that RAS and PAX8-PPARγ rearrangements are mutually exclusive, suggesting that these are 2 distinct molecular pathways for FTC development.
Classification and Prognosis
DTCs are broadly categorized as papillary or follicular. In general, well-differentiated PTC has an excellent prognosis, with a 5-year survival rate of greater than 97%. Smaller tumors carry a better prognosis than larger tumors. PTCs measuring less than 1 cm in size are called papillary microcarcinomas, and have been reported in 10% to 30% of autopsy studies.[10, 43, 44] In the past, these tumors were incidentally detected in thyroidectomy specimens, but they are now detected with increasing frequency by high-resolution ultrasound. They are believed to have an excellent prognosis, but some may behave more aggressively than previously appreciated, and management remains controversial.[45, 46] In general, however, microcarcinomas hold an excellent prognosis with 10-year and even 15-year disease-specific survival rates exceeding 99%. Risk factors of mortality from a microcarcinoma include age older than 45 years, male sex, minority racial group, lymph node metastases, extrathyroidal extension or superficial location, intraglandular spread or multifocality, peritumoral fibrosis, and BRAF positivity. Several scoring systems that incorporate these factors have been developed to risk-stratify patients with microcarcinomas.[45, 47]
In addition to tumor size, age is another important determinant of prognosis in patients with DTC. Older patients tend to have more poorly differentiated, aggressive variants. In these cases, death results from local invasion and extensive metastases. Therefore, age, the completeness of resection, and extrathyroidal extension also are prognostic indicators that are used in many staging systems for DTC.[48, 49]
One of the greatest risk factors for disease-specific mortality is the presence of distant metastases.[50-52] While the significance of distant metastases is rarely disputed, the importance of lymph node metastases in determining DTC-specific survival remains controversial. Lymph node involvement is common in patients with PTC, but the precise incidence of lymph node metastases depends on how it is defined. Palpable disease in the lymph nodes is present in 5% to 10% of patients with PTC, but ultrasound detects pathologic lymph nodes in 30% of patients. Only 2% of patients with FTC have lymph node metastases because the route of spread is hematogenous rather than lymphatic, but treatment guidelines and retrospective studies frequently consider PTC and FTC together. Routine histologic examination of lymph nodes detects DTC in 20% to 50% of patients, but when polymerase chain reaction is performed, up to 90% of patients with DTC will be found to have lymph nodes with microscopic disease. Historically, lymph node involvement was believed to increase the rate of local recurrence without affecting survival, and therefore surgeons took a conservative approach to lymph node dissection for DTC. Wada et al demonstrated that patients with pathologically positive lymph nodes had a recurrence rate of 16.3% compared with 0% in patients without pathologic lymph nodes. Whether metastatic lymph nodes are clinically evident preoperatively appears to be an important factor in determining recurrence. For example, Ito et al found that if metastatic lymph nodes were not seen preoperatively, then the risk of lymph node recurrence was only 1.5%. Of note, in this study of 590 patients with microcarcinomas, 40% of patients had lateral neck lymph node metastases identified histologically after prophylactic neck dissection. Hence, lymph node metastases do affect recurrence, and clinically apparent lymph nodes are more important than pathologically positive ones. The impact of lymph node involvement on survival is less clear. Large series and population-based studies suggest that there is a small but significant affect on survival.[55-57]
Most current staging systems consider lymph node metastases as a binary factor, classifying patients by the presence or absence of diseased lymph nodes, or the anatomic location of these lymph nodes (Tables 1 and 2). The lymph node ratio (number of metastatic lymph nodes divided by the total number of lymph nodes harvested) is a method with which to further risk-stratify patients with lymph node disease.[57, 59-61] The lymph node ratio is helpful for clinicians caring for patients with PTC because it indicates the adequacy of lymph node dissection and the extent of disease. Although the lymph node ratio does independently impact disease-specific survival, it is probably most helpful in assessing recurrence risk and tailoring postoperative treatment and follow-up accordingly.
|PROGNOSTIC VARIABLE||EORTC, 1979||AGES, 1987||AMES, 1988||MACIS, 1993||OSU, (1994)||MSKCC, 1995||NTCTCS, 1998||Clinical Class, 1990|
|Positive lymph nodes||–||–||–||–||X||X||X||X|
|Primary Tumor (T)|
|TX||Primary tumor cannot be assessed|
|T0||No evidence of primary tumor|
|T1||Tumor ≤2 cm, limited to the thyroid|
|T1a||Tumor ≤1 cm, limited to the thyroid|
|T1b||Tumor >1 cm but <2 cm, limited to the thyroid|
|T2||Tumor >2 cm but <4 cm, limited to the thyroid|
|T3||Tumor >4 cm, limited to the thyroid or minimal extrathyroid extension (sternothyroid or perithyroidal soft tissues)|
|T4ab||Tumor of any size extending beyond the thyroid capsule to invade subcutaneous soft tissues, larynx, trachea, esophagus, or recurrent laryngeal nerve|
|T4b||Tumor invades prevertebral fascia or encases carotid artery or mediastinal vessels|
|Regional Lymph Nodes (N)|
|NX||Regional lymph nodes cannot be assessed|
|N0||No regional lymph node metastasis|
|N1||Regional lymph node metastasis|
|N1a||Metastasis to level VI lymph nodes|
|N1b||Metastasis to unilateral, bilateral, or contralateral cervical (levels I, II, III, IV, or V) or superior mediastinal (level VII) lymph nodes|
|Distant Metastasis (M)|
|M0||No distant metastasis|
|Differentiated Cancerc in Those Aged <45 y|
|Stage I||Any T any N M0|
|Stage II||Any T any N M1|
|Differentiated Cancer in Those Aged ≥45 y|
|Stage I||T1 N0 M0|
|Stage II||T2 N0 M0|
|Stage III||T3 N0 M0|
|T1 N1a M0|
|T2 N1a M0|
|T3 N1a M0|
|Stage IVA||T4a N0 M0|
|T4a N1a M0|
|T1 N1b M0|
|T2 N1b M0|
|T3 N1b M0|
|T4a N1b M0|
|Stage IVB||T4b any N M0|
|Stage IVC||Any T any N M1|
|Stage I||T1 N0 M0|
|Stage II||T2 N0 M0|
|T3 N0 M0|
|Stage III||T1 N1a M0|
|T2 N1a M0|
|T3 N1a M0|
|Stage IVA||T4a N0 M0|
|T4a N1a M0|
|T1 N1b M0|
|T2 N1b M0|
|T3 N1b M0|
|T4a N1b M0|
|Stage IVB||T4b any N M0|
|Stage IVC||Any T any N M1|
|Stage IVA||T4a any N M0|
|Stage IVB||T4b any N M0|
|Stage IVC||Any T any N M1|
PTC has several subtypes spanning the spectrum of well-differentiated, classical papillary cancers to the most aggressive, anaplastic tumors. Well-differentiated tumors can be subdivided by their aggressiveness. Less aggressive variants include follicular, oxyphilic, and cribriform-morular. The most common subtype is follicular variant PTC (FVPTC), which has features of both PTC and FTC but is classified as a PTC subtype. This subtype exhibits the overall follicular structure but with the nuclear features of PTC. Often FVPTC is mistaken for follicular neoplasms or carcinomas.[62, 63] Overall, the prognosis is intermediate between classical PTC and FTC. The prognosis also hinges on whether the tumors are completely encapsulated or invasive. Since FVPTC histologically resembles follicular adenomas or carcinomas, immunohistochemical stains such as HBME-1 have proven particularly useful in making the pathologic diagnosis.[65, 66]
It is important to recognize more aggressive variants of well-differentiated tumors. These include tall-cell, columnar-cell, solid, and diffuse-sclerosing variants. The tall-cell variant of PTC, commonly encountered in older patients, is larger and more invasive with extrathyroidal extension and metastatic disease. While tall-cell variant PTC is less iodine-avid than classical PTC, these tumors are typically positive on positron emission tomography (PET). Histologically, these tumors have cells whose height is at least 2 to 3 times as tall as they are wide. Traditional criteria require at least 50% of the cells to exhibit these tall features. Necrosis, a high mitotic index, and nuclear pseudoinclusions are also prominent in these tumors. Recently, several different centers have noted that tall-cell variant PTCs often harbor BRAF mutations, and molecular markers can be used to identify this subtype preoperatively.[67-69] Such molecular diagnostics may become helpful since this subtype is believed to be underdiagnosed.
In addition to tall-cell variant, columnar-cell, solid, and diffuse-sclerosing types also exhibit more aggressive behavior than classical PTC.
As follicular or papillary cancers progress or dedifferentiate, their prognosis becomes much worse. Anaplastic cancers are at the least-differentiated side of the spectrum, and represent one of the most aggressive cancers, with a 5-year disease-free survival rate and cause-specific survival rate approaching 0%. ATC can arise from well-differentiated tumors that dedifferentiate or it can also develop de novo. A group of tumors falls in between well-differentiated thyroid cancers and ATCs. These cancers, called poorly differentiated thyroid cancers, have a histologic appearance and behavior that is intermediate between well-differentiated PTC and ATC. Although the literature remains inconsistent regarding what constitutes poorly differentiated cancer, the best definition comes from Burman et al that “poorly differentiated thyroid carcinoma is a concept proposed to include carcinomas of follicular thyroid epithelium that retain sufficient differentiation to produce scattered small follicular structures and some thyroglobulin, but generally lack the usual morphologic characteristics of papillary and follicular carcinoma.” These tumors include insular and large-cell variants.[3, 71] Patients with these types of tumors tend toward locally advanced disease with recurrence and metastases. Furthermore, dedifferentiation of thyroid cancers leads to underexpression or disordered assembly of the sodium-iodide symporter, thereby decreasing the usefulness of radioactive iodine for treating or detecting metastatic disease. For these reasons, poorly differentiated thyroid cancers have a 51% disease-free survival rate and a 70% cause-specific survival rate at 5 years.[3, 70]
Figure 1 provides an organizational scheme for classifying tumors of follicular cell origin by differentiation status.
FTC and Variants
It is worth noting some important ways in which FTC differs from PTC. Pure FTC carries a worse prognosis compared with PTC. Even when the disease is confined to the thyroid, mortality rates range from 5% to 15%, although survival time still extends decades as in PTC. In addition to the prognostic factors common to DTC staging systems (discussed below), the prognosis in patients with FTC especially depends on the degree of capsular and vascular invasion. Minimally invasive tumors are macroscopically contained within the thyroid, but have microscopic foci of invasion into the capsule. Invasive tumors carry a worse prognosis and invade the capsule and vasculature.[74-76] For these reasons, FNA biopsy cannot distinguish a follicular adenoma from a carcinoma, and this has led to the investigation of molecular markers that can make this diagnosis, as will be discussed below. Until molecular diagnostics are perfected, the current standard of care is to perform a diagnostic lobectomy to distinguish follicular adenoma from carcinoma.[74, 77]
Hurthle cell or oncocytic tumors of the thyroid are often classified with follicular cancer as they are derived from the follicular cell. Hurthle cells arise from the follicular epithelium. Histologically, these cells feature large size, distinct cellular borders, plentiful granular cytoplasm, a large nucleus, and a prominent nucleolus. Hurthle cells are found in a variety of conditions including nodular goiter, chronic lymphocytic (Hashimoto) thyroiditis, and long-standing hyperthyroidism.[78, 79] Both adenomas and carcinomas of the Hurthle cell can occur, and differentiating them by cytology is as difficult as it is with follicular lesions.[76, 80] As with follicular tumors, capsular and vascular invasion distinguish carcinoma from adenomas. Large Hurthle cell cancers (those measuring > 2 cm) have a higher recurrence rate, ranging from 21% to 59%.[80, 81] Furthermore, Hurthle cell cancers do not always concentrate iodine. For these reasons, Hurthle cell carcinoma carries a worse prognosis compared with other DTCs. Adenomas carry an excellent prognosis after resection and less than 2.5% demonstrate malignant behavior, but resection is recommended for larger adenomas since size is a major predictor of malignancy.[81, 82] In one series, 65% of Hurthle cell neoplasms measuring 4 cm or greater were determined to be cancer on final pathology.
Primary lymphoma of the thyroid is not as common as DTC. Older females or patients with Hashimoto thyroiditis are at highest risk for developing thyroid lymphoma.[83, 84] These tumors typically present as a rapidly expanding mass causing pain and compressive symptoms. Flow cytometry of cytologic specimens can sometimes make the diagnosis, but it might also be difficult to distinguish from advanced Hashimoto thyroiditis. A core needle biopsy may therefore become necessary when this diagnosis is suspected to obtain enough tissue for flow cytometric analysis and/or analysis of antigen receptor gene rearrangements. Most are B-cell lymphomas treated with chemotherapy and radiation. Surgery is occasionally necessary for palliation. Prognosis depends on the histologic subtype. Of note, up to 20% of patients diagnosed with generalized lymphoma can also have secondary involvement of the thyroid.
Because of its unique extended survival period and the spectrum of disease behavior, a number of different staging or prognostic scoring systems have been developed for DTC.[48, 86, 87] Table 1 summarizes these various staging systems.
Classical prognostic indicators for DTC include age and sex. Age is such an important factor in determining a patient's survival from DTC that it is included in many of the staging systems for thyroid cancer. As with most other solid tumors, the tumor size also has prognostic significance, and most of the prognostic schemes also include this measure (Table 1).
Because of its questionable effect on mortality, lymph node status is not included in all of the staging systems available for DTC. For example, the AGES system (patient age, histologic grade of the tumor, tumor extent [extrathyroidal extension], and size of primary tumor) considers age, grade, extrathyroidal extension, and size. The AMES system (patient age, presence of distant metastases, extent and size of primary tumor) uses age, distant (non-lymph node) metastases, extent of primary tumor, and size. Some, like the MACIS system (metastasis, patient age, completeness of resection, local invasion, and tumor size) also account for the adequacy of surgical treatment. Alternatively, staging systems developed by the Ohio State University, the European Organization for Research and Treatment of Cancer, the National Thyroid Cancer Treatment Cooperative Study, Clinical Class, and the American Joint Committee on Cancer all do consider lymph node status.
The American Joint Committee on Cancer is the most widely used staging system (Table 2). It also is known as the TNM system since it considers tumor size and local extent (T), lymph node metastases (N), and distant metastases (M). Similar to many of the other thyroid cancer staging systems, it also considers age, with 2 different classifications for those individuals aged younger and those aged older than 45 years. In those aged younger than 45 years, patients with lymph node metastases are classified as having stage I disease unless they have distant metastases (stage II).
Like any newly discovered mass elsewhere in the body, the workup of a thyroid nodule begins with a thorough history and physical examination. A strong family history of thyroid cancer or prior radiation exposure to the head and neck should raise the suspicion of thyroid cancer. Rapid growth with compressive symptoms may indicate that the thyroid nodule is thyroid lymphoma or a poorly differentiated thyroid cancer.[3, 4, 24]
On physical examination, malignant nodules are harder and fixed while a nodule that is rubbery or soft and moves easily with deglutition suggests a benign nodule. Physical examination features alone do not ensure a benign diagnosis. Cervical lymphadenopathy also increases the likelihood that a thyroid nodule is malignant.[4, 94]
Since the management of patients with hyperthyroidism differs from those with nonfunctional nodules, obtaining a TSH measurement early in the workup of a thyroid nodule can efficiently identify patients with a nodule and hyperthyroidism. In the subset of patients with a suppressed TSH (hyperthyroid), a radioactive iodine-123 (I) scan can distinguish a solitary toxic nodule from a toxic multinodular goiter and Graves disease. A solitary hyperfunctioning nodule is rarely malignant, and FNA biopsy or further cancer workup is rarely necessary. Hyperfunctioning nodules are usually hypercellular, and may confuse the provider since cytology may suggest neoplasia, when the cellularity only reflects benign hyperplasia associated with excessive stimulation. The one exception is that functioning nodules in children do carry a higher risk of malignancy. If thyroid radionuclide scanning is undertaken, “cold” nodules should undergo FNA biopsy because 10% to 20% are malignant.[96, 97] Nevertheless, thyroid radionuclide scanning is not recommended as part of the initial workup of adult patients with thyroid nodules as it generally does not alter the management.
Other laboratory tests can be helpful once the diagnosis of a certain type of thyroid cancer is made. For example, measuring serum thyroglobulin (Tg) in patients with DTC can assist with the long-term follow-up of patients treated for DTC.[98-100] Although Tg can be elevated in patients with DTC, the test is not specific for diagnosing cancer. Elevations in Tg can occur in patients with benign thyroid disorders, and the American Thyroid Association guidelines do not recommend routine preoperative Tg measurement for patients with DTC. After a total thyroidectomy, however, elevations in Tg can reliably indicate recurrent or metastatic disease. Different threshold Tg levels can indicate recurrence depending on the concomitant TSH level.
FNA biopsy remains the gold standard for evaluating thyroid nodules. Most clinical practice guidelines recommend FNA biopsy for nodules measuring greater than 1 cm in largest dimension.[96, 99, 101] When the FNA result is clearly benign or malignant, the decision for further treatment including thyroidectomy then becomes evident. The false-negative rate for FNA biopsy is 1% to 3% (Table 3). The false-negative rate increases to 10% to 15% when the nodule is large (>4 cm).[101-103] Other clinical scenarios where the clinician should not always trust a benign FNA result include patients with a family history of thyroid cancer, patients with a history of radiation exposure, and those with cystic nodules. Ultrasound guidance can improve the accuracy of FNA biopsy because ultrasound can confirm that the nodule is actually being sampled and target the most suspicious portions of the nodule (ie, the wall of a cyst). This is especially true for nonpalpable or posteriorly located nodules.
|CATEGORY||RISK OF MALIGNANCY, %||RECOMMENDED MANAGEMENT|
|Nondiagnostic or unsatisfactory||1-4||Repeat FNA with US guidance|
|Atypia of undetermined significance or follicular lesion of undetermined significance||5-15||Repeat FNAa|
|Follicular neoplasm or suspicious for follicular neoplasm||15-30||Lobectomy|
|Suspicious for malignancy||60-75||Lobectomy ± frozen section or total thyroidectomy|
FNA results are classified according to the Bethesda criteria that indicate the risk of malignancy (Table 3). One of the limitations of cytology in evaluating thyroid nodules is that it cannot distinguish between adenoma and carcinoma for follicular lesions.[96, 102, 103] Therefore, lobectomy with permanent histology may be the best way to make a definitive diagnosis in patients with follicular or indeterminate lesions. Many centers have turned to the molecular analysis of FNA specimens to help distinguish follicular lesions. Cytology specimens are analyzed for a panel of mutations including BRAF, RAS, RET/PTC, and PAX8-PPARγ rearrangements.[39-41, 70, 106] This will be discussed further in subsequent sections.
Not only can ultrasound improve the accuracy of FNA biopsy, but it is also an important tool for evaluating thyroid nodules as it is used to measure the size and features of the nodule such as its borders, echogenicity, and vascularity. It can also identify additional nonpalpable nodules. Ultrasound alone can increase the clinician's suspicion for malignancy if the nodule has fine microcalcifications, irregular borders, or chaotic vascular patterns. In addition, ultrasound evaluates the lymph nodes in both the central and lateral neck compartments, which may prompt additional FNA biopsy of suspicious lymph nodes or alter the surgical plan (Fig. 2). Small metastatic central compartment lymph nodes may not be seen on ultrasound because they are obscured by the overlying thyroid. Although ultrasound is highly operator-dependent, it is noninvasive and does not involve any radiation or contrast risk to the patient. High-resolution ultrasound can also demonstrate extracapsular invasion and subtle lymph node involvement.[2, 105, 107-111] Therefore, ultrasound is the preferred method with which to evaluate the thyroid and cervical lymph nodes.
Very aggressive cancers that may invade local structures, extend into the chest, or demonstrate poorly differentiated cytology require careful preoperative planning. In this situation, computed tomography (CT) becomes a helpful preoperative imaging study for helping to plan en bloc resection of other organs aside from the thyroid, understand the extent of vascular involvement, determine if a thoracic incision is necessary, and plan for reconstruction.[2, 3, 112, 113] When using CT, it is best to avoid the administration of iodinated contrast as this will reduce the ability of residual thyroid tissue or thyroid cancer to take up subsequent radioactive iodine for many months.
Imaging studies often identify thyroid nodules incidentally. PET scans detect thyroid masses during the workup and staging of other cancers. This subset of incidentally discovered thyroid nodules deserves special attention because up to 50% of [F]fluorodeoxyglucose ([18F]FDG)-avid thyroid nodules will contain thyroid cancer. Therefore, PET-positive thyroid nodules should be biopsied by FNA. PET and/or CT scans are helpful for identifying lung or bone tumors in patients at risk for metastases, and this is especially true for patients with tumors that are not iodine-avid.[2, 112]
Role of Molecular Markers
As discussed above, the identification of molecular markers associated with either PTC or FTC has led to the development of several assays to improve upon FNA biopsy results. Specifically, these assays or gene panels target nodules with indeterminate cytology (follicular neoplasm, atypia, etc) to determine whether they are benign or malignant without the need for diagnostic surgery. For example, Nikiforov et al recently developed a panel of mutations including BRAF, NRAS, HRAS, KRAS, and 2 different RET/PTC rearrangements. The detection of any one of these mutations was associated with a final histopathologic diagnosis of cancer in 88% of cases with a cytologic diagnosis of atypia and 87% of cases with cytologic diagnoses of follicular neoplasm/suspicious for a follicular neoplasm. The risk of cancer in nodules without any mutation was as high as 28% in patients with a cytologic diagnosis suspicious for malignancy, 14% of patients with follicular cytology, and 6% of patients with atypia. While these results are quite encouraging, the sensitivity of the molecular panel still leaves room for uncertainty and has not negated the need for diagnostic surgery to make a definitive diagnosis.
Rather than identifying the molecular signature of malignancy, another group has developed a different molecular test designed to identify the gene expression profile of a benign nodule. In a multicenter study, this test had a sensitivity of 92% and a specificity of 52%. The negative predictive value (predicts truly benign lesions) was 95%, 94%, and 85%, respectively, for the cytologic diagnoses of atypia, follicular neoplasm/suspicious for follicular neoplasm, and suspicious. This testing may be helpful for patients who wish to avoid surgery because of excessive surgical risk, but still leaves at least a 7% chance that a benign result truly is a cancer. At this point, it remains unclear how patients who avoid surgery because of a molecular profile should be followed. Furthermore, the natural history of follicular lesions is unknown. Until these questions are clarified, these molecular tests will play a limited role in clinical decision-making for most patients.
The treatment of DTC is multidisciplinary and involves a surgeon, endocrinologist, nuclear medicine specialist, and, occasionally, a radiation oncologist. This approach best serves patients with DTC and will be highlighted in the sections that follow.
The extent of surgery for DTC remains controversial. This is especially true for small, encapsulated, well-differentiated tumors, and tumors measuring less than 1 cm in size (microcarcinomas). The approach to microcarcinomas will be discussed further below, but for the majority of DTCs measuring 1 cm or more and diagnosed preoperatively, most clinicians recommend a total thyroidectomy. The rationale for total thyroidectomy is based on tumor biology and current treatment modalities. DTC, especially PTC, tends to be multicentric, with up to 80% of patients having multiple tumor foci and bilateral disease detected in 60% when a thorough pathologic examination of the contralateral lobe is performed.[2, 6, 45] A total thyroidectomy as the initial procedure negates the need for reoperative surgery to remove the contralateral lobe should a recurrence become detected. Second, experienced thyroid surgeons can safely perform a total thyroidectomy, with permanent complications such as recurrent laryngeal nerve injury and hypoparathyroidism occurring at a rate of less than 2%.[46, 113] Radioactive iodine therapy for ablating microscopic disease becomes most effective when the thyroid remnant is small or absent. Tg measurement and radioiodine whole-body scanning are highly sensitive modalities for detecting recurrent or metastatic disease, but these 2 methods are most effective when all thyroid tissue has been removed.[2, 4]
Most low-risk cancers carry an excellent prognosis regardless of the extent of thyroidectomy, and there are no randomized prospective trials comparing total thyroidectomy with thyroid lobectomy in this group of patients. In addition, radioiodine may have limited usefulness in low-risk patients.[6, 45] For these reasons, some favor thyroid lobectomy in low-risk risk patients. For example, Shaha et al have reported a 20-year follow-up of 465 patients with low-risk DTC. Although the lobectomy group had more local recurrence compared with the group undergoing total thyroidectomy (4% vs 1%), this was not statistically significant. Similarly, other groups have also failed to demonstrate any significant effect on survival.[117-119] In contrast, large retrospective series have demonstrated improvement in recurrence for total thyroidectomy compared with less extensive resections.[91, 120-122] In a frequently cited study, Mazzaferri et al reported on 1355 patients with a mean follow-up of 15.7 years. Patients treated with total thyroidectomy experienced significant improvements in the recurrence rate (26% vs 40%; P < .02) and mortality rate (6% vs 9%; P = .02) compared with those undergoing lesser resections. While some have questioned the accuracy of risk stratification and accounting for complications in these retrospective studies, current guidelines still recommend a total or near-total thyroidectomy for small (those measuring <4 cm), unifocal, well-differentiated tumors with no lymph node metastases or extrathyroidal extension.
Another hotly debated topic related to the extent of initial surgery for DTC is the role of prophylactic central neck dissection. Although the 2006 American Thyroid Association guidelines stated that routine prophylactic central neck dissection should be considered for patients with DTC, the most recent guidelines have been revised to recommend that “prophylactic central neck dissection may be performed, especially in patients with advanced primary tumors” and “total thyroidectomy without prophylactic central neck dissection may be appropriate for small (T1 or T2), non-invasive, clinically node negative patients.”
The central neck lymph nodes are also classified as level VI lymph nodes and include the paratracheal, perithyroidal, and precricoid lymph nodes. These lymph nodes are found along and behind the recurrent laryngeal nerve and frequently surround the lower parathyroid gland (Fig. 2). Although the level VI lymph nodes contain macroscopic disease in 10% of cases, when they are removed prophylactically, 32% to 69% of patients will have microscopic metastases.[52, 124, 125]
Proponents of prophylactic central neck dissection argue that the initial operation is the safest time to remove central neck lymph nodes to prevent local recurrences and the complications associated with reoperative surgery in the central neck. Furthermore, the central neck lymph nodes are difficult to evaluate with preoperative ultrasound when the thyroid remains in place. Wada et al found the recurrence rate in patients treated with therapeutic lymph node dissection to be 21%, while patients who underwent prophylactic neck dissection experienced a recurrence rate of only 0.43%. Importantly, those patients without clinically overt lymph node disease who did not undergo prophylactic central neck dissection also experienced a very low recurrence rate of 0.65%. Hence, the absolute differences in recurrence are miniscule. Several other studies also support the concept that microscopically positive lymph nodes rarely progress to recurrence, especially after postoperative radioactive iodine ablation.[126-128] Therefore, the debate regarding prophylactic central neck dissection is closely tied to the usefulness of radioactive iodine.
Clinically evident lymph node metastases place patients at higher risk of recurrence, and these patients benefit from therapeutic lymph node dissection. Prophylactic central neck dissection modestly reduces an already low recurrence rate and potentially eliminates or reduces the need for radioactive iodine, but is also associated with its own risks such as hypoparathyroidism. The risk-benefit ratio may favor prophylactic central neck dissection in a subset of patients, but the putative risk factors that define such a subset remains unknown.[2, 61, 129, 130] Some groups are currently using molecular markers to preoperatively risk-stratify patients, and decide who might benefit from more aggressive surgery up front.[131, 132]
Thyroidectomy still involves the same basic steps historically described, but newer technology and attention to cosmesis account for some more recent modifications of the basic technique. Traditionally, a Kocher collar incision was used, but this requires a very large dissection superiorly to reach the upper pole of the thyroid, thereby placing the patient at risk for postoperative seroma. Intraoperative ultrasound can help assess the upper extent of the gland and place the incision appropriately. Often, the incision can be placed higher in the neck but hidden in a neck crease to allow a smaller but still cosmetically pleasing incision. Superior and inferior subplatysmal flaps are raised to create a working space around the thyroid. Instead of traditional clamps and ties, most of the vasculature feeding the thyroid can now be managed using energy devices such as the Harmonic scalpel or LigaSure device,[133, 134] but larger vessels still may require clips and/or ties. Before dividing any structures along the medial border of the gland, the recurrent laryngeal nerve must be identified and its course dissected. The nerve is found medial to the upper parathyroid gland and lateral to the lower parathyroid. The parathyroid glands must also be identified and dissected free from the thyroid on an intact vascular pedicle. Once the recurrent laryngeal nerve is identified, the branches of the inferior thyroid artery can be divided along the thyroid capsule.
In recent years, nerve monitoring devices have enabled surgeons to test the functionality of the recurrent laryngeal nerve intraoperatively. Reported rates of permanent recurrent laryngeal nerve injury when the surgeon visually identifies the nerve is less than 2%.[135, 136] Even the largest trials have failed to show any significant prevention of nerve injury.[137, 138] A multiinstitutional, prospective, nonrandomized study of 16,448 patients (29,998 nerves at risk) found no statistical difference in nerve injury rates when comparing patients treated with visual identification of the nerve alone with those treated with a combination of visual identification and nerve monitoring. In one of the few prospective studies, Thomusch et al reported on 8534 patients (15,403 nerves at risk). They compared direct stimulation of the recurrent laryngeal nerve with indirect stimulation of the vagus nerve (the recurrent nerve is a distal branch of the vagus), and found that direct stimulation had a much lower sensitivity for predicting nerve palsy compared with indirect stimulation (45.9% vs 99.6%). Although nerve monitoring does not prevent nerve injury, many surgeons still use this technology to identify nerve palsies when they do occur. This last study suggests that when nerve monitoring is used in this fashion, it should not simply be used to stimulate the recurrent laryngeal nerve directly. The use of nerve monitoring remains quite controversial. Many experts believe that nerve stimulation is generally not necessary for the primary surgery on the thyroid, and may be more useful for reoperations.
Before passing the specimen off the field, the surgeon should examine it to make sure that there is no parathyroid tissue adherent to the gland. Any inadvertently removed parathyroid tissue can be finely minced and reimplanted into either the sternocleidomastoid or the strap muscles. Frozen section of a biopsy of this tissue can distinguish between fat, parathyroid, or lymph node; this will also avoid autotransplanting cancer-bearing lymph nodes back into the patient. Two to 3 pockets are created within the muscle, and the minced parathyroid tissue is divided between these pockets. Each pocket should be marked with a permanent suture so that it can easily be found in a reoperative setting.
Preoperative FNA or intraoperative frozen section can confirm that enlarged lymph nodes seen on ultrasound harbor metastatic disease. Cytologic or pathologic confirmation of lymph node metastases should prompt the surgeon to perform a compartment-oriented lymph node dissection. Lymph node sampling or “berry picking” should be avoided as this leaves behind lymph nodes that likely contain microscopic disease that then become more difficult to excise in a reoperative setting.
Although “skip” metastases directly to the lateral compartment can occur in patients with PTC, the central neck lymph nodes (level VI) are usually the first to receive drainage from the thyroid (Fig. 2). The boundaries of the central neck are the carotid sheathes laterally, the hyoid bone superiorly, and the innominate artery inferiorly. Lymphadenectomy in this area requires skeletonizing the recurrent laryngeal nerve along its entire cervical course, and removing all the fibrofatty tissue along the trachea. Frequently, the lower parathyroid is invested in this tissue and becomes devascularized with this dissection.
A lateral neck dissection usually involves dissection of levels II, III, and IV (Fig. 2). This dissection puts the spinal accessory, phrenic, vagus, cervical sensory, sympathetic trunk, hypoglossal, greater auricular, and the marginal mandibular branch of the facial nerves at risk. The extent of lymph node dissection should be guided by preoperative and intraoperative ultrasound findings. Usually, the great vessels can be preserved, but more aggressive tumors can invade the internal jugular vein, and it should be sacrificed in this scenario. In addition to nerve injury, chyle leak is another complication of performing a lateral neck dissection.[2, 113]
In recent years, transaxillary approaches to thyroidectomy have been developed. There are several variations of these techniques including transaxillary endoscopic, robotic, and axillo-breast techniques.[142-147] All of these techniques avoid a neck incision, and instead hide the incision in the crease between the axilla and the breast. Long-term data on the adequacy of resection using these approaches are lacking, and these techniques come with added complication risks such as brachial plexus injury.
Remnant ablation with radioactive iodine is the standard adjuvant treatment in selected patients with DTC. It can only be administered after a total or near-total thyroidectomy, or otherwise the radioactive isotope will be absorbed by the remnant thyroid and will not destroy any micrometastatic disease as intended. Radioactive iodine is administered 1 to 3 months postoperatively as iodine-131 (131I) in an oral form whose half-life is 7 to 8 days. Consensus guidelines recommend a dose of 30 to 100 milliCuries (mCi) for patients with low-risk tumors and higher doses (100-200 mCi) for patients with residual disease, suspected microscopic disease, or more aggressive histologic subtypes (ie, tall-cell, columnar-cell, or insular variants).[99, 148-150] To stimulate intracellular uptake of the isotope, the TSH concentration should be at least as high as 30 mU/L.
There are 2 methods for achieving such an elevation in TSH. The traditional method requires the patient to withdraw from thyroid hormone replacement over 4 to 6 weeks.[4, 151] A newer method is to administer recombinant human TSH (rhTSH). rhTSH is administered in the form of intramuscular injections on 2 consecutive days followed by radioactive iodine on the third day. The advantage of this method is that the patient does not experience an extended period of hypothyroidism as with hormone withdrawal. However, long-term data on the effectiveness of rhTSH compared with traditional withdrawal are not established, although it appears effective for patients considered to be at low risk. The US Food and Drug Administration approved rhTSH for thyroid remnant ablation in patients who do not have evidence of metastatic disease.[152, 153] In addition to making the TSH rise, clinicians should also prepare patients by instructing them to follow a low-iodine diet for 1 to 2 weeks prior to radioactive iodine treatment. This diet requires patients to avoid foods that contain iodized salt, dairy products, eggs, seafood, soybeans or soy-containing products, and foods colored with red dye #3.[149, 150] Its important to note that rhTSH is not approved for use in children.
While some studies show no benefit to radioactive iodine therapy,[154, 155] other studies have demonstrated a reduction in locoregional recurrences and distant metastases.[91, 120] As with the controversy over the extent of thyroidectomy, the benefit of radioactive iodine for low-risk patients remains unclear. The most recent American Thyroid Association guidelines recommend remnant ablation for patients with T3 tumors or lymph node disease. Selective use is recommended for intrathyroidal tumors measuring 1 cm to 2 cm in size or T2 tumors. It is not recommended for intrathyroidal tumors less than or equal to 1 cm in size. The National Comprehensive Cancer Network guidelines require a more thorough evaluation for the extent of remaining disease after thyroidectomy with a radioiodine scan 1 to 12 weeks postoperatively. Radioactive iodine ablation is not recommended if the stimulated Tg is less than 1 ng/mL and the radioiodine scan is negative.
Recently, some studies have shown an increase in the risk of developing secondary malignancies after radioactive iodine therapy. This has been examined using the National Cancer Institute's Surveillance, Epidemiology, and End Results (SEER) database. Brown et al found that patients treated for DTC had significantly higher rates of nonthyroid second primary malignancies than expected in the general population. Although the excess risk was relatively small, it was greater in the subset of patients who were treated with radioactive iodine. Iyer et al specifically examined low-risk patients (T1N0 disease) treated with radioactive iodine and found that their excess absolute risk was 4.6 excess cases per 10,000 person-years at risk. As discussed above, radioactive iodine clearly benefits patients with larger tumors and metastatic disease, but the increased risk of secondary malignancies in low-risk patients, in whom the long-term benefit of radioactive iodine is questionable, means that careful patient selection is necessary.
Hematologic malignancies are the most common secondary malignancies after radioactive iodine, but there is also an association with kidney, breast, bladder, skin, and salivary gland cancers.[158-160] The more commonly noted side effects after radioiodine treatment include dry mouth, mouth pain, salivary gland swelling (sialadenitis), altered smell and taste, conjunctivitis, and fatigue. Women should not be pregnant at the time of treatment nor should they become pregnant for at least 6 months following treatment. Similarly, men should avoid conception for at least 6 months following treatment.[150, 159, 161, 162]
Since all cells of follicular origin depend on TSH for growth, TSH suppression through the administration of supraphysiologic doses of levothyroxine (T4) remains an important strategy for maintaining disease-free survival and overall survival.[163, 164] For high-risk patients with incomplete resection, tumor invasion into adjacent structures, or distant metastases, their physician should initially titrate levothyroxine dosing to a TSH of less than 0.1 mU/L. Patients at lower risk should be dosed to a TSH at or slightly below the lower limit of normal (0.1 mU/L-0.5 mU/L).[99, 148] Once patients remain disease free for at least 2 years, their TSH suppression can be liberalized to within the reference range. Patients with persistent disease should be kept at a TSH of less than 0.1 mU/L indefinitely. TSH suppression carries risks of arrhythmias, anxiety, and osteoporosis. The risks and benefits should be carefully considered, particularly in older patients. Due to the risk of bone loss, the National Comprehensive Cancer Network guidelines recommend daily calcium and vitamin D supplementation for patients receiving treatment with TSH suppression.
Although 131I is the preferred adjuvant therapy for thyroid carcinoma, external-beam radiation sometimes plays a role in treating this disease. Persistent, recurrent, anaplastic, or poorly differentiated tumors may fail to take up 131I. Treatment of ATCs almost always includes external-beam radiation since these tumors often cannot be completely resected and do not concentrate iodine. Although no improvement in overall survival has ever been documented, external-beam radiation is often administered after resection of poorly differentiated tumors to reduce the risk of local recurrence. The group at Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center has found that up to 85% of poorly differentiated tumors display some iodine avidity, and therefore treatment with radioactive iodine may remain worthwhile.3 Patients with incompletely resected tumors, unresectable disease, and locoregional recurrence in a previously operated field may benefit from external-beam radiation.[3, 165, 166] External-beam radiation is typically reserved as a last resort, after surgery and radioactive iodine have been exhausted.
Since radioactive iodine often can be effective for the treatment of well-differentiated tumors that have metastasized, cytotoxic chemotherapy has not been extensively evaluated for metastatic thyroid cancers. For patients with a large burden of disease, anaplastic cancers, or poorly differentiated tumors that are not iodine-avid, chemotherapy becomes an important treatment component after surgery or if the tumor is not resectable. In these rare situations, chemotherapy confers minimal effects as these tumors hold a very poor prognosis. Historically, doxorubicin was the most effective single agent. Combination therapy with doxorubicin and cisplatin resulted in modest objective response rates.[167, 168]
Newer, targeted therapies have shown some promise. Small molecule tyrosine kinase inhibitors (such as sorafenib or sunitinib) and antibodies (anti-vascular endothelial growth factor [VEGF]) should be considered in the context of ongoing clinical trials.[148, 169-171]
Mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAPK) inhibitors target specific oncogenic pathways in DTC progression. These small molecules are generally well tolerated with low toxicity profiles. As discussed above, the BRAF gene is commonly mutated in thyroid cancer, and therefore many of the targeted MAPK drugs block the Raf kinases in patients with RET or BRAF mutations.[172, 173] Sorafenib is an orally administered multikinase inhibitor targeting BRAF, VEGF, RET, and c-Kit. Two different phase 2 clinical trials enrolled patients with radioiodine-resistant metastatic DTC and reported that sorafenib stabilized disease progression and lowered serum Tg with minimal toxicity.[174, 175]
Emerging therapies specifically target angiogenesis because DTC tumors express high levels of VEGF receptors.[176, 177] Multikinase inhibitors such as motesanib, vandetanib, sunitinib, and axitinib have shown early promise in patients with DTC.[170, 178, 179] These drugs often target multiple VEGF receptors in addition to other signaling pathways such as c-Kit, RET, and platelet-derived growth factor.
Another mechanism targeted in anticancer therapy is the acetylation of N-terminal lysine residues on histones. Histone acetylation results in a more open chromatin configuration and gene transcription. Many different types of cancer cells have been found to have dysregulated histone acetyltransferase or histone deacetylase enzymes.[180-182] Several histone deacetylase inhibitors, including vorinostat, depsipeptide, and valproic acid, have been shown to have an effect on thyroid cancer cells.[183-185] For example, in thyroid carcinoma cell lines, valproic acid increased expression of the sodium-iodide symporter and radioiodine uptake.[186-188] Although many of these results come from in vitro studies or early-phase clinical trials, they do represent promising novel therapies with much lower toxicity than traditional chemotherapeutic agents.
Medullary Thyroid Cancer
MTC accounts for 6% to 8% of all thyroid cancers. Unlike DTC, MTC arises from the parafollicular C cells instead of the follicular epithelial cells. Hence, MTC is a neuroendocrine tumor and shares some properties common among neuroendocrine cancers, including secretion of peptide hormones such as calcitonin, serotonin, or vasoactive intestinal peptide. Approximately 25% of cases are due to germline genetic mutations, but most cases of MTC are sporadic. Hereditary cases occur either in isolation (familial MTC [FMTC]) or as part of the multiple endocrine neoplasia syndrome type 2 (MEN 2A or MEN 2B).[189-191]
Although any thyroid nodule could potentially harbor MTC, historical features that may alert the physician to the potential for MTC include a family history of MTC, pheochromocytoma, hyperparathyroidism, or other manifestations of MEN 2 syndromes. Similar to the evaluation of all thyroid nodules, neck ultrasound and FNA play a major role in diagnosing MTC. Hereditary cases are often detected through genetic screening to identify germline mutations in the RET gene. Almost all patients with sporadic disease present with a palpable neck mass and this could be either in the thyroid or a metastatic lymph node. Lymph node metastases occur in 35% to 50% of patients at the time of initial diagnosis. Therefore, ultrasound evaluation of the central and lateral neck compartments for suspicious lymph nodes becomes a crucial component of the initial diagnosis.
Since the parafollicular C cells are concentrated in the upper posterior portion of each thyroid lobe, many MTCs arise in a posterior location, causing symptoms such as hoarseness or dysphagia due to compression of local structures. If there is any concern for vocal cord function, then direct laryngoscopy should be performed preoperatively. MTCs secrete cytokines and other peptides that can cause symptoms such as flushing, diarrhea, and weight loss.
FNA characteristics of MTC include the presence of stromal amyloid without thyroid follicles. Spindle-shaped cells may be seen, and therefore MTC can be mistaken for parathyroid carcinoma or ATC unless the specimen is stained for calcitonin, chromogranin A, or carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA), substances produced by MTC that confirm the diagnosis. A more sensitive technique than immunohistochemistry on cytology specimens is to measure the calcitonin level in the washout fluid from an FNA. In addition, the presence of calcitonin messenger RNA has been performed when the cytologic or histologic diagnosis remains unclear. Histologically, MTCs form nests of cells with deposition of stromal amyloid that stains positively with Congo red stain. Staining for chromogranin A can also help to confirm the diagnosis.
Several serum markers can aid in the diagnosis of MTC, and are useful in following patients for recurrence and metastases. Calcitonin is commonly elevated in patients with MTC. Although a small percentage of healthy patients will have some elevation in calcitonin, patients with a diagnosis of MTC usually exhibit levels greater than 100 pg/mL. In borderline cases, the diagnosis can be clarified by stimulating the calcitonin with either intravenous calcium gluconate or pentagastrin. Before the advent of genetic testing, these stimulated measurements were used to screen patients at high risk for MTC. The degree of calcitonin elevation correlates with tumor burden, with lymph node metastases found at basal calcitonin levels of 10 pg/mL to 40 pg/mL, and distant metastases found with calcitonin levels greater than 150 pg/mL. Patients with calcitonin levels over 3000 pg/mL are likely to have widely metastatic disease, and are unlikely to be cured despite aggressive surgery.
Preoperative measurement of serum (CEA can also help risk-stratify patients. Overall, CEA elevations occur in more than 50% of patients with MTC, but a preoperative serum CEA level of greater than 30 ng/mL highly predicts the inability to cure the patient with surgery. CEA levels above 100 ng/mL may signify extensive lymph node and distant metastases. Following CEA levels postoperatively can also monitor disease progression. An increasing CEA level in the presence of a stable calcitonin level is associated with a worse prognosis as it may indicate tumor dedifferentiation and distant metastases. Other markers such as chromogranin A or serotonin can be elevated in patients with MTC as with many other neuroendocrine tumors, but calcitonin, chromogranin A, and CEA are the most useful for following MTC patients in the long term.[192, 200, 201]
Genetic testing plays an important role in the initial management because it identifies familial disease and risk-stratifies patients with hereditary forms. Familial disease is characterized by germline mutations in the RET gene. A small percentage of patients with apparently “sporadic” disease will also carry germline RET mutations, but truly sporadic cases frequently harbor somatic RET mutations. Commercial testing is performed through polymerase chain reaction amplification of the patient's germline DNA obtained from the white blood cells.
A spectrum of tumor aggressiveness exists among the various RET mutations, and the timing of prophylactic thyroidectomy is based on the specific mutation. Table 4 lists each mutation by codon and phenotype. Once a patient tests positive for a germline RET mutation, they should be carefully counseled regarding the risk to other family members and their children. At-risk family members should be identified and also tested so that prophylactic thyroidectomy can be offered at the appropriate time (Table 5). While some overlap exists for genetic mutations associated with MEN 2A and familial MTC, distinct mutations are usually associated with MEN 2B.[204, 205]
|EXON||CODON||AMINO ACID (WILD-TYPEMUTANT)||PHENOTYPE||FREQUENCY OF MEN 2 CASES, %|
|8||532, 533, 534||Ins-Glu-Glu-Cys||FMTC||Rare|
|RISK LEVEL FOR MTC||ATA RISK LEVELa||CODON MUTATION||AGE AT PROPHYLACTIC SURGERY|
|Level 3 (highest)||D||883||Within the first 6 mo of life (preferably within the first y)|
|Level 2 (higher)||B||611||By age 5 y|
|Level 1 (high)||B||609||By age 5 y to 10 y|
Complete surgical excision is the treatment of choice for patients with MTC. The minimum extent of surgery for patients with clinically apparent disease is a total thyroidectomy with bilateral central neck dissection. Approximately 81% of patients with palpable disease have central neck lymph node metastases, and the addition of central neck dissection improves cure rates over total thyroidectomy alone in patients with clinically evident disease at the time of presentation.[206, 207] The initial approach to lateral neck lymph nodes continues to evolve. Historically, the initial surgical treatment included an ipsilateral lateral compartment neck dissection because up to 80% of patients will have ipsilateral lymph node metastases. However, current guidelines recommend performing an ipsilateral lateral neck dissection if ultrasound or physical examination detects lymphadenopathy in the lateral neck, if central compartment lymph nodes are involved, or when the primary tumor measures greater than 1 cm. Contralateral lateral neck dissection is added when patients have bilateral tumors or there is extensive lymph node disease on the ipsilateral side. Because some patients often require extensive neck dissection, these procedures are often staged.[192, 193] Unlike DTC, where micrometastatic disease can be effectively treated with radioactive iodine ablation, the only effective treatment in patients with MTC is complete surgical resection. Therefore, all evident disease must be resected for the best long-term cure.
Prophylactic thyroidectomy is recommended for at-risk family members in hereditary MTC. Current recommendations for the timing of prophylactic thyroidectomy balance the need to remove the at-risk organ prior to it developing clinically apparent disease with the risks of surgery. In patients with hereditary MTC, an age-related progression exists from C-cell hyperplasia to carcinoma, and ultimately lymph node metastases. The optimal timing of prophylactic thyroidectomy depends on the risk level of the RET mutation (Table 5). In general, current guidelines recommend operating on children with MEN 2A and FMTC by age 5 years, while those with MEN 2B should undergo surgery before 6 months of age.[209, 210] Prophylactic surgery should consist of at least a total thyroidectomy. The role of prophylactic lymph node dissection in familial disease remains controversial. Lymph node metastases are present in 6% of screened patients, and therefore some argue that prophylactic central lymph node dissection should be performed. Opponents of this approach state that with a normal preoperative ultrasound, a normal calcitonin (basal and/or stimulated) level, and a normal CEA level, the risk of occult lymph node disease is very low and does not outweigh the risks of a central neck dissection such as permanent hypoparathyroidism.[5, 206, 211] Because any complications resulting from a prophylactic surgery become lifelong problems for the patient, experienced surgeons should perform prophylactic surgery for patients with MTC.
In general, prophylactic thyroidectomy does not need to include a central neck dissection for patients with MEN 2A and FMTC as long as surgery is performed prophylactically, before disease is clinically apparent. Because of the more aggressive nature of MTCs associated with MEN 2B, the performance of a central neck dissection with prophylactic thyroidectomy is optional, depending on the timing and the specific codon mutated.[192, 193]
Prior to proceeding with surgery, the surgeon should screen patients with hereditary disease for associated conditions such as pheochromocytoma (MEN 2A and MEN 2B) and hyperparathyroidism (MEN 2A).[205, 210, 211]
All patients will require thyroid hormone replacement once the thyroid is removed, but TSH suppression is not required because the parafollicular C cells are not under TSH growth control. After surgery, the next phase of treatment is surveillance. This begins 2 to 3 months postoperatively with new baseline calcitonin and CEA levels. If the calcitonin level is undetectable, these patients can then be followed with yearly calcitonin measurements. Imaging is undertaken when the calcitonin level rises.
A spectrum of disease severity exists for patients with both hereditary and sporadic MTC, and therefore the natural history of MTC varies widely. Distant metastases in the lung, liver, or bone can arise and quickly lead to death. Conversely, many patients live with a large tumor burden and very high calcitonin levels with few symptoms. Others develop intractable diarrhea. In this case, cytoreductive surgery or somatostatin analogs such as octreotide can palliate severe symptoms.
Conventional chemotherapy regimens with doxorubicin, dacarbazine, capecitabine, and fluorouracil have demonstrated only limited efficacy in patients with MTC. Newer, targeted therapies block the RET receptor tyrosine kinase or its multiple downstream pathways such as the ERK, phosphoinositide 3-kinase(PI3K)/Akt, p38 mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAPK), and c-Jun N-terminal kinase pathways.[106, 192, 213] Some of these tyrosine kinase inhibitors inhibit multiple signaling pathways simultaneously.[106, 214] These targeted therapies are currently being evaluated in multicenter trials.[214, 215]
Recently, the US Food and Drug Administration approved one of these targeted therapies, vandetanib, for the treatment of metastatic MTC. Vandetanib is a small molecule inhibitor of the VEGF receptor, epidermal growth factor receptor, and the RET tyrosine kinase. In a randomized controlled clinical trial, patients treated with vandetanib experienced a median progression-free survival of 22.6 months compared with 16.4 months in patients treated with placebo.
- 3Poorly differentiated and anaplastic thyroid cancer. Cancer Control. 2006;13:119-128., .
- 7National Cancer Institute. Thyroid Cancer Home Page. cancer.gov/cancertopics/types/thyroid. Accessed March 15, 2013.
- 8Howlader N, Noone AM, Krapcho M, et al, eds. SEER Cancer Statistics Review, 1975-2009 (Vintage 2009 Populations). Bethesda, MD: National Cancer Institute; 2012. seer.cancer.gov/statfacts/html/thyro.html. Accessed March 15, 2013.
- 29Familial nonmedullary thyroid carcinoma: a meta-review of case series. Thyroid. 1997;7:107-113..
- 30Familial nonmedullary thyroid carcinoma. Cancer Control. 2006;13:106-110., .
- 32Genetic predisposition to familial nonmedullary thyroid cancer: an update of molecular findings and state-of-the-art studies. J Oncol. 2010;2010:385206., , .
- 55Clinically significant prognostic factors for differentiated thyroid carcinoma: a population-based, nested case-control study. Cancer. 2006;106:524-531., , , .
- 57Impact of lymph node ratio on survival in papillary thyroid cancer [published online ahead of print December 23, 2012]. Ann Surg Oncol., , .
- 58Edge SB, Byrd DR, Compton CC, Fritz AG, Greene FL, Trotti A, eds. American Joint Committee on Cancer Staging Manual. 7th ed. New York, NY: Springer; 2010.
- 60An evaluation of lymph node yield and lymph node ratio in well-differentiated thyroid carcinoma. Am Surg. 2010;76:28-32., , , .
- 62Papillary thyroid carcinoma variants. Head Neck Pathol. 2011;5:51-56., , .
- 74Follicular thyroid cancer treated at the Mayo Clinic, 1946 through 1970: initial manifestations, pathologic findings, therapy, and outcome. Mayo Clin Proc. 1991;66:11-22., , , .
- 79Hurthle cell and mitochondrion-rich cell tumors. A clinicopathologic study. Cancer. 1986;57:1154-1163., , , , .
- 87Prognostic indicators in differentiated thyroid carcinoma. Cancer Control. 2000;7:229-239., .
- 99American Thyroid Association (ATA) Guidelines Taskforce on Thyroid Nodules and Differentiated Thyroid Cancer, , , et al. Revised American Thyroid Association management guidelines for patients with thyroid nodules and differentiated thyroid cancer. Thyroid. 2009;19:1167-1214.
- 101AACE/AME Task Force on Thyroid Nodules. American Association of Clinical Endocrinologists and Associazione Medici Endocrinologi medical guidelines for clinical practice for the diagnosis and management of thyroid nodules. Endocr Pract. 2006;12:63-102., , , et al;
- 112Role of [(18)F]-fluorodeoxy-D-glucose positron emission tomography and computed tomography in the early detection of persistent/recurrent thyroid carcinoma in intermediate-to-high risk patients following initial radioactive iodine ablation therapy. Thyroid. 2012;22:157-164., , , et al.
- 119Predictive value of AMES scoring system in selection of extent of surgery in well differentiated carcinoma of thyroid. Am Surg. 1995;61:151-155., .
- 129Central neck dissection for papillary thyroid cancer. Cancer Control. 2011;18:83-88., .
- 141American Thyroid Association Surgery Working Group; American Association of Endocrine Surgeons; American Academy of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery; American Head and Neck Society; , , , et al. Consensus statement on the terminology and classification of central neck dissection for thyroid cancer. Thyroid. 2009;19:1153-1158.
- 143Technological innovations in surgical approach for thyroid cancer. J Oncol. 2010;2010., .
- 147Feasibility and safety of a new robotic thyroidectomy through a gasless, transaxillary single-incision approach. J Am Coll Surg. 2010;211:e13-e19., , , et al.
- 148National Comprehensive Cancer Network. Thyroid carcinoma. J Natl Compr Canc Netw. 2010;8:1228-1274., , , et al;
- 152Recombinant human thyrotropin (rhTSH) aided radioiodine treatment for residual or metastatic differentiated thyroid cancer. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2010;(11):CD008302., , , et al.
- 169New directions in the systemic treatment of metastatic thyroid cancer. Oncology (Williston Park). 2009;23:768-775., , .
- 189Medullary thyroid carcinoma: targeted therapies and future directions. J Oncol. 2009;2009:183031., , , .
- 193North American Neuroendocrine Tumor Society (NANETS). The North American Neuroendocrine Tumor Society consensus guideline for the diagnosis and management of neuroendocrine tumors: pheochromocytoma, paraganglioma, and medullary thyroid cancer. Pancreas. 2010;39:775-783., , , , , ;
- 199Pretargeted anti-carcinoembryonic-antigen radioimmunotherapy for medullary thyroid carcinoma. J Clin Oncol. 2006;24:e37; author reply e38., .
- 203Management of medullary thyroid cancer. In: Sippel RS, Chen H, eds. The Handbook of Endocrine Surgery. Hackensack, NJ: World Scientific Publishing Company; 2011:63-78., .
- 205Indication and timing of thyroid surgery for patients with hereditary medullary thyroid cancer syndromes. J Natl Compr Canc Netw. 2006;4:139-147., .