Quality of life of children with spina bifida in Kenya is not related to the degree of the spinal defects
Corresponding Author Dan Poenaru, BethanyKids at Kijabe Hospital, Box 20, 00220 Kijabe, Kenya. Tel.: +254 20 3246500; Fax: +254 20 3246355; E-mail: email@example.com
Objectives To assess the relationship between the degree of symptoms and defects caused by spina bifida and the quality of life (QoL) of children with spina bifida in Kenya.
Methods Children with spina bifida at BethanyKids at Kijabe Hospital, at mobile clinics throughout Kenya and a control group of healthy children were interviewed regarding their QoL. The SEIQoL-DW was used as an instrument to measure the QoL. This instrument can transfer well across cultures by using open questions clustered in six domains chosen based on the study group responses. Symptoms and impairment caused by spina bifida were obtained from the medical files.
Results Sixty-nine per cent of 102 patients with spina bifida had a myelomeningocele, 59% had hydrocephalus, and of 49 incontinent children older than 2.5 years, 67% used clean intermittent catheterization. Quality of life of children was 65.1 on a scale from 0 to 100, compared to 78.0 in the healthy control group. Not one single determinant made a significant difference in the overall QoL. The most important domains were ‘development’ and ‘self-actualization’. The lowest scores were found in the domain ‘health and disease’.
Conclusion This study showed no significant influence of the degree of defects of spina bifida on the QoL, but identified domains that can be targeted for improvement in children with spina bifida.
Objectifs: Evaluer l’association entre le degré des symptômes et des déficiences causées par le spina-bifida et la qualité de vie des enfants qui en sont atteints au Kenya.
Méthodes: Les enfants atteints de spina-bifida à BethanyKids, à l’hôpital de Kijabe, dans des cliniques mobiles à travers le Kenya et un groupe témoin d’enfants sains, ont été interrogés sur leur qualité de vie. Le SEIQoL-DW a été utilisé comme instrument pour mesurer la qualité de vie. Cet instrument peut facilement être transposé dans diverses cultures à l’aide de questions ouvertes regroupées dans 6 domaines choisis sur base des réponses du groupe d’étude. Les symptômes et les altérations causés par le spina-bifida ont été obtenus à partir des dossiers médicaux.
Résultats: 68% des 102 patients avaient un spina-bifida myéloméningocèle, 59% avaient une hydrocéphalie et sur 49 enfants incontinents âgés de plus de 2,5 ans, 67% utilisaient la Cathéterisation Intermittente. La qualité de vie des enfants était de 65,1 sur une échelle de 0 à 100, comparée à 78,0 dans le groupe témoin. Pas un seul déterminant n’a montré une différence significative dans la qualité de vie en général. Les domaines les plus importants étaient le «développement» et «l’épanouissement personnel». Les scores les plus faibles ont été trouvés dans le domaine de «la santé et la maladie».
Conclusion: Cette étude n’a montré aucune influence significative du degré de déficience due au spina-bifida sur la qualité de vie, mais a identifié des domaines qui pourraient être ciblés pour amélioration chez les enfants atteints de spina-bifida.
Objetivos: Evaluar la relación entre el grado de los síntomas y los defectos causados por la espina bífida, y la calidad de vida de los niños con espina bífida en Kenia.
Métodos: Se entrevistó acerca de su calidad de vida a niños con espina bífida en BethanyKids del Hospital de Kijabe, en clínicas móviles a lo largo de Kenia y a un grupo de niños sanos (controles). Se utilizó el método SEIQoL-DW como instrumento para medir la calidad de vida. Este instrumento puede transferirse bien entre culturas utilizando preguntas abiertas agrupadas en 6 dominios escogidos basándose en las respuestas del grupo de estudio. Los síntomas y la discapacidad causados por la espina bífida se obtuvieron de archivos médicos.
Resultados: Un 68% de 102 pacientes con espina bífida tenía un mielomeningocele, 59% tenían hidrocefalia, y de 49 niños mayores de 2.5 años con incontinencia, un 67% utilizaban cateterismo intermitente limpio. La calidad de vida de los niños era de 65.1 en una escala de 0 a 100, comparado con un 78.0 en el grupo control sano. Ningún determinante marcaba una diferencia significativa en la calidad de vida en general. Los dominios más importantes eran el ‘desarrollo’ y ‘auto-actualización’. Los puntajes más bajos estaban en el dominio ‘salud & enfermedad’.
Conclusión: Este estudio demostró que no había una influencia significativa en el grado de defectuosidad de la espina bífida y la calidad de vida, pero identificó dominios que pueden ser objeto de mejoras en niños con espina bífida.
Provide feedback or get help You are viewing our new enhanced HTML article.
If you can't find a tool you're looking for, please click the link at the top of the page to "Go to old article view". Alternatively, view our Knowledge Base articles for additional help. Your feedback is important to us, so please let us know if you have comments or ideas for improvement.
Spina bifida (SB) is a congenital spinal dysraphism (disorder of fusion of the neural tube). Neural tube defects have an incidence around the world of 0.79–6.39 per 1000 live births (Bowman et al. 2009). SB can be divided into spina bifida occulta and spina bifida aperta. In SB occulta, the defect is covered by a layer of skin and the defect is not visible immediately, which may cause it not to be discovered until it becomes symptomatic, while in SB aperta, the defect is immediately visible. Spina bifida aperta can be further subdivided into myelomeningocele, meningocele and lipomeningocele. The most common form of SB aperta is myelomeningocele, consisting of a sac containing meninges, cerebrospinal fluid, nerves and/or dysplastic spinal cord. Both the brain and spinal cord are often dysplastic, causing additional pathology such as hydrocephalus and Chiari II malformation (McLone & Dias 2003; Kaufman 2004). The spectrum of malformations results in various neurological symptoms, including para-lysis and/or spasticity of extremities, urinary incontinence, faecal incontinence and neurocognitive retardation (Shurtleff 2000; Bowman et al. 2001; Davis et al. 2005). Surgical closure of the spinal defect soon after birth is the standard of management of SB (Charney et al. 1991). Complications of SB include renal failure, kyphosis, latex allergy and pressure sores. The medical care of patients with SB therefore is complex and multi-faceted, focused on preventing complications. Clean intermittent catheterization (CIC) is commonly used to prevent renal failure and to control urinary incontinence.
Spina bifida is a chronic disease, and its multiple symptoms and complications are likely to influence the children’s quality of life (QoL). In recent years, several studies have investigated the QoL of children with SB in the western world (Kirpalani et al. 2000; Cate et al. 2002; Padua et al. 2002; Lemelle et al. 2006). These studies have highlighted the negative impact of mobility limitation, urinary incontinence and level of the lesion on QoL. A study by Bier et al. (2005) concludes that ‘maximizing functional independence should be a priority in improving HRQOL in individuals with myelomeningocele’. Interestingly, however, children with SB rate their own QoL less negatively than the persons treating them (Rasmussen et al. 1993; Parkin et al. 1997). More surprisingly, a study by Padua et al. (2002) concluded that there was ‘no linear inverse correlation between disability and QOL in patients with spina bifida’, and another study by Muller-Godeffroy et al. (2008) confirmed this by showing that medical factors and disability were not significantly related to the health-related QoL. A Dutch study by Barf et al. (2007) concluded that SB did not seem to be an important determinant of life satisfaction.
To the authors’ knowledge, there are no validated QoL studies of children with SB from African settings. This is important, as social and economic factors would be expected to play a significant role in QoL, thus leading to different results than in Western studies. Consequently, the aim of this study is to assess the relationship between degree of symptoms and defects caused by SB and the QoL of children with SB in Africa.
Patients and methods
Study design and patients
This cross-sectional study was undertaken at BethanyKids at Kijabe Hospital (BKKH) and its several mobile clinics throughout Kenya. BKKH is a faith-based non-governmental referral unit for children with surgical disabilities, primarily spina bifida and hydrocephalus. The management of SB at BKKH is non-selective, i.e. all children are considered surgical candidates regardless of the motor level or presence of hydrocephalus. Children were included in the study if they had a diagnosis of SB and were not older than 18 years when interviewed. During the interviews, it became clear that parents who spend a maximum of 6 months with the SB child were not able to reflect about QoL with SB; therefore, the exclusion criterion was age <6 months.
All children with SB at BKKH or in the mobile clinics were invited to participate in the study. A control group of healthy children in the same age category was recruited from the local community of Kijabe. Parents of the children were given consent forms in English and Kiswahili, and interviews followed the standard consenting process. Preferably, the child was interviewed, though in some cases this was impossible because of the age of the child or because of his/her cognitive retardation. In such cases, the parent of the child was interviewed regarding the child’s QoL. Analysis of paired parent–child interviews, taken at the same time, in 23 patients with SB in our study group showed no significant differences in total QoL score nor in the scores of QoL domains. The only significant difference was found in weight, ‘health and disease’ was significantly more important to parents than children. This finding supports the decision to use both child and parent interviews in the analysis, where the difference in weight is considered in the interpretation of the results. After the interview, further medical data were obtained from the patient’s medical file. The study was approved by the Ethics Committee of Kijabe Hospital.
Interview and medical data
For QoL assessment, the Schedule for the Evaluation of Individual Quality of Life-Direct Weight (SEIQoL-DW) tool was used. This is an open method tool, validated and reliable to detect the aspects of the individual QoL (Moons et al. 2004), consisting of three phases. In phase 1, the patient or his/her parent was asked to name the five most important areas in the patient’s life. This was an open question, not a multiple choice one, and they could name anything they found important. In phase 2, subjects were asked to score these five areas, using a visual analogue scale from 0 to 100 – 0 being ‘it could not be worse’ and 100 being ‘it could not be better’. In phase 3, the named areas were ranked and weighted using a coloured rotating sliced disc. The areas were attached to one colour on that disc and were enlarged or reduced based on their importance to the patient. All five areas added up to 100%.
Additional data were extracted from the patients’ medical files, including motor level of the SB, presence of hydrocephalus, history of VP shunting and incontinence. A formal classification system was used to score functional urinary incontinence (Lemelle et al. 2006), with or without catheter (Table 1).
Table 1. Classification systems for urine incontinence
|Incontinent||Permanent||Leakage from continuous to several times a day|
|Frequent||Leakage from several times a day to several times a week|
|Continent||Occasional||Leakage from several times a week to several times a month|
|Rare||Leakage less than once a month|
|Never||No leakage at all|
The SEIQoL-DW can transfer well across cultures by using open questions (Joyce et al. 2003). For analysis purposes, these were clustered into six domains chosen based on the study group responses: (i) health and disease; (ii) development; (iii) resources; (iv) basic needs; (v) self-actualization; and (vi) social environment. ‘Health and disease’ included answers such as complications of SB, health, SB symptoms, pain and urinary problems. ‘Development’ consisted both of physical development (such as being able to walk and grow) as well as psychological and communicative development. ‘Resources’ consisted of answers such as financial situation and toys. ‘Basic needs’ included references to food, clothes, shelter, sleep, education and health care. ‘Self-actualization’ consisted of topics like playing, hobbies, trips, independence and religion. ‘Social environment’ was defined by topics such as friends, family and environment.
Individual scores (0–100) and weights (0–100% = 0.00–1.00) were multiplied, and all five areas received in six clusters as follows: (i) health and disease, (ii) development, (iii) resources, (iv) basic needs, (v) self-actualization and (vi) social environment. Naturally, with this as with any other artificial clustering, two or more named topics may have ended up being placed into the same cluster. These combined topics were then used to calculate a weighted mean score per domain.
Statistical analysis included the Mann–Whitney U test, with significance level set at 0.05. For testing within-group differences with more than two categories, the Kruskal–Wallis test was used, with significance level set at 0.05. All statistical analyses were performed using spss® v15.
During the period December 2007–February 2008, a total of 125 children with SB and 64 healthy children, or their parents, were interviewed and their medical charts reviewed. Twenty-three children with SB were excluded because of being younger than 6 months of age (n = 20) or missing key information from the chart (n = 3). The healthy group comprised 24 parent interviews and 40 child interviews. The group of 102 patients with SB consisted of 63 parent interviews and 39 child interviews. The demographic and other baseline data of the SB study group are listed in Table 2. Myelomeningocele was the most frequent lesion. The percentage of SB children with hydrocephalus was 59%. Of 49 children with documented incontinence, 33 (67%) used CIC.
Table 2. Baseline characteristics of 102 children with spina bifida
|0–2 years||35 (34)|
|2–6 years||25 (24)|
|6–12 years||21 (21)|
|12+ years||21 (21)|
|Movement lower extremity|
|No catheter||16 (32.7)|
Quality of life
Mean SEIQoL-DW of children with SB was 65.1 ± 16.6, on a scale of 0–100. In healthy Kenyan children, this score is 78.0 ± 14.2, predictably significantly higher (P < 0.001). Table 3 shows the different important domains of QoL in children with SB and healthy children. In the SB group, ‘development’ was the most important domain, and it received a fair score (63), although the SB group scored significantly lower than the healthy control group (81) on this domain. Next, in order of importance in the SB group came ‘self-actualization’, which scored very well (73). ‘Health and disease’ received predictably the lowest score (51), but it was not given much weight. Next to the significant difference of ‘development’ scores between SB and control group, the SB group differed also significantly in scores of ‘health and disease’, ‘basic needs’ and ‘resources’. ‘Self-actualization’ was significantly more important in the healthy control group.
Table 3. The six SEIQoL-DW domains with their weight and score in patients with spina bifida
|Development||24.2% (20.2)||62.9 (26.2)||20.8% (14.9)||80.8 (19.3)||0.386||<0.001|
|Self-actualization||21.4% (21.0)||72.8 (19.3)||31.0% (25.5)||78.2 (14.6)||0.017||0.202|
|Social environment||19.2% (20.5)||65.8 (27.4)||17.1% (18.0)||69.7 (31.6)||0.663||0.304|
|Basic needs||15.8% (19.2)||62.1 (23.6)||17.7% (21.2)||74.6 (22.2)||0.648||0.009|
|Health and disease||10.8% (16.0)||51.0 (25.2)||6.0% (10.6)||83.8 (15.2)||0.059||<0.001|
|Resources||8.6% (13.2)||58.0 (26.7)||7.4% (16.9)||74.1 (32.8)||0.141||0.041|
QoL and SB determinants
Several SB variables were tested for their influence on QoL, both through the overall SEIQoL-DW score and the subscore for each domain. Table 4 shows that none of the variables made a significant difference to the overall QoL, nor to the subscores of the QoL domains ‘development’, ‘self-actualization’, ‘health and disease’ and ‘resources’. The only significant differences were found within the scores of ‘social environment’ and ‘basic needs’, where incontinent children scored higher than continent children.
Table 4. Impact of patient variables on overall QoL and QoL domains
|Male||67.9 (15.3)||0.090 (102)||66.8 (25.2)||0.169 (79)||76.3 (15.8)||0.154 (70)|
|Female||61.7 (17.5)||58.7 (27.0)||68.2 (22.7)|
|Meningo||64.8 (17.7)||0.706 (72)||60.1 (28.4)||0.912 (57)||73.0 (16.8)||0.878 (47)|
|Myelomeningo||62.8 (17.8)||60.2 (28.2)||69.5 (23.5)|
|Lipomeningo||58.7 (62.7)||57.9 (23.6)||68.4 (19.7)|
|Yes||66.6 (16.8)||0.410 (100)||64.8 (26.7)||0.392 (77)||74.2 (19.9)||0.477 (69)|
|No||63.7 (16.4)||62.7 (23.8)||72.0 (18.8)|
|Movement lower extremity|
|Yes||64.6 (16.9)||0.870 (101)||65.1 (24.9)||0.539 (78)||71.1 (19.6)||0.328 (69)|
|No||65.5 (16.2)||58.9 (28.5)||75.2 (18.7)|
|Continence||63.1 (19.3)||0.494 (51)||69.1 (27.1)||0.367 (43)||68.8 (21.3)||0.489 (39)|
|Incontinence||67.2 (15.2)||62.1 (27.5)||74.9 (14.9)|
|Male||67.6 (27.0)||0.600 (70)||64.4 (22.5)||0.339 (56)||53.9 (21.2)||0.454 (41)||60.8 (29.1)||0.613 (38)|
|Female||64.1 (28.0)||59.0 (25.2)||45.6 (31.8)||55.5 (24.8)|
|Meningo||75.2 (16.5)||0.829 (46)||65.5 (15.4)||0.283 (43)||59.3 (25.0)||0.119 (29)||67.3 (30.2)||0.470 (26)|
|Myelomeningo||67.4 (24.7)||64.3 (23.0)||49.7 (20.3)||51.3 (27.6)|
|Lipomeningo||57.2 (37.2)||35.3 (34.5)||22.5 (3.5)||57.5 (24.7)|
|Yes||66.5 (26.7)||0.975 (69)||63.2 (23.9)||0.629 (56)||56.7 (19.9)||0.066 (40)||51.3 (24.6)||0.130 (37)|
|No||65.0 (29.6)||59.4 (23.5)||42.5 (30.1)||65.7 (28.4)|
|Movement lower extremity|
|Yes||63.5 (28.8)||0.457 (70)||62.6 (23.5)||0.793 (55)||49.4 (29.7)||0.500 (41)||58.5 (26.3)||0.889 (38)|
|No||68.4 (25.9)||61.0 (24.5)||53.6 (16.5)||56.9 (28.7)|
|Continence||46.7 (32.6)||0.036 (36)||48.6 (26.1)||0.019 (20)||51.9 (32.0)||0.500 (21)||55.1 (28.0)||0.573 (14)|
|Incontinence||68.3 (25.3)||75.0 (13.6)||42.2 (26.6)||64.8 (19.5)|
Study design, methods and clustering
The strength of the SEIQoL-DW as an instrument for assessing QoL in our study group is the fact that it translates easily across cultures, as the questionnaire consists of open questions (Joyce et al. 2003); it is validated and reliable (Moons et al. 2004); and it is a quantitative measurement making it possible to compare different study groups (Joyce et al. 2003). A weakness of the SEIQoL-DW is the variety of answers that can be given. In the administration manual of the SEIQoL-DW, the authors caution in interpreting total QoL scores as it is the sum of the products of individual cue scores by cue weights, each of which may vary independently (O’Boyle et al. 1993). The large variety of answers needs to be clustered. The difficulty lies in correctly assigning answers that can fit into more than one cluster, or answers that are hard to place into any cluster. For instance, the domain ‘health and disease’ includes replies related to SB, its consequences and complications. Mobility problems, however, although often a consequence of SB, were clustered in the domain ‘development’ rather than ‘health and disease’. Such ambiguities and inconsistencies are inherent to any clustering of real-life replies and must be borne to mind in interpreting the results of the current study. In addition, by using the SEIQoL-DW, there is the pitfall that the interviewer will use suggestive questions in an attempt to understand the interviewee (Joyce et al. 2003).
In our analysis, there were no significant differences in total SEIQoL-DW scores between patients and proxies. In another research, there was also no significant difference between the total SEIQoL-DW scores obtained from patients and proxies (Pearcy et al. 2008). These findings underline the ability of using a third party in assessing the SEIQoL-DW. However, data published on this subject are scarce.
The percentage of hydrocephalus in our SB group was 59%, well below the usual range of 78–86% in developed countries (Stein & Schut 1979; Olsson et al. 2007; Talamonti et al. 2007), but well within the more conservative range of 54–59% reported in African and Asian studies (Alatise et al. 2006; Kumar & Singhal 2007). One likely explanation for this geographical difference is a sampling distortion – the Western studies appear to include only myelomeningoceles, while the African and Asian reports include all spinal dysraphisms. Indeed, the percentage of hydrocephalus in our study among the SB subtype myelomeningocele group was 81%. As one can read in the above-named studies, our study population is very similar to other studies.
Several SB determinants were purposefully omitted in the baseline Table 2, because there were too few data for reliable statistical analysis. Examples of such omitted variables include shunt infections, shunt malfunction, shunt revision and use of continence drugs. Some of these factors may well play a role, but a larger sample size would be required for their analysis. Some determinants were purposefully omitted in the baseline Table 2, because there was a high co-linearity between the determinants, for example between motor level of lesion and movement lower extremity. The most practical and functional determinants were selected for analysis.
For the determinant ‘lesion type’, there were 30 missing values. This is a large number and mainly caused by incomplete documentation in the medical files. Another determinant with missing values was ‘urine continence’, some children were not able to differentiate between continent and incontinent or it was not translated very well, and sometimes, there was no parent available to add information.
Quality of life and SB determinants
A key finding of our study is the significant difference in QoL between children with SB and healthy children. Concerning overall QoL and QoL within the domain of ‘health and disease’ (comparable to the health-related QoL used in many other studies), not one analysed SB-related variable made a significant difference. As previously mentioned, previous literature supports this finding (Parkin et al. 1997; Padua et al. 2002; Muller-Godeffroy et al. 2008). The ‘health and disease’ domain had the lowest scores, but this domain was not given much weight. Even so, this domain is more important to the parent than to the child, and therefore appears falsely more prominent in the dominated parent-interviewed SB study group. ‘Health and disease’, with SB as a part of it, is of little importance for children. This may be a reason why their level of SB has no significant influence on the overall QoL. Medical determinants may not make a significant difference, perhaps because of the fact that the children are born with the disease and its complications and become used to it. Or a sample-size problem may still be at play here. To test this, a power calculation was performed for the variable ‘continence’, yielding the impractical required sample size of 1741 children.
For every domain, the mean scores were calculated. It is important to keep in mind with interpreting these results that not every interviewee gave answers in every single domain, for example some named three answers in one domain. The number of scores per domain is therefore lower than the total number of interviewed patients with SB and has less power to find significant differences. The only significant differences were found within the scores of ‘social environment’ and ‘basic needs’, where incontinent children scored better than continent children. Lemelle et al. (2006) concluded that they ‘did not find a strong relationship between incontinence and health-related QoL’. However, continent children scoring lower than incontinent children were completely unexpected and are impossible or at least difficult to explain. The numbers of scores per domain were low (36 and 20), thus it is likely that the outcomes are not very reliable. ‘Basic needs’ is a domain, which has not much interference with continence, but social environment could have.
Assuming although that none of the analysed SB determinants have a significant impact on overall QoL, this study begs the question: What does make a significant difference on the QoL of children with SB? ‘Self-actualization’ as a domain scored best in QoL and second in importance. This in fact could be one reason why children with SB appear to have a good life. This domain includes playing, hobbies, trips, independence and religion. Often children with SB can play very well, have hobbies and do many things, which give them joy in life. It is very important for them to have peers and family who recognize their ability in this area, as this may improve their score in other domains such as ‘social environment’. As children with SB are able to share with others the very activities that improve their QoL, their overall QoL also increases.
The ‘development’ domain, which received average scores, was the most important domain for SB children. This domain consists of items such as physical development, ability to walk and grow, and psychological and communicative development. The SB group scored significantly lower on this domain than the healthy control group. Acceptance and stimulation of the child by the people around him/her can play a significant role in the psychological and communicative development. Such acceptance comes from community and caregiver education regarding SB and its consequences. Indeed, a widespread education process – as initiated by our institution – can make a long-lasting impact on the QoL and future of children with spina bifida.
Spina bifida is a disease with many symptoms and potential complications. The QoL of children with SB is 65 compared to 78 in the healthy control group. As found in Western studies, no SB-related clinical factor, including the level and type of spinal lesion, made a significant difference on the QoL of children with SB in our study.
The most important domains of QoL were ‘self-actualization’ and ‘development’. The lowest scores were found in the domain ‘health and disease’. ‘Self-actualization’ was the key domain, which gave the children a better QoL. The most important domain for children with SB was ‘development’, with significantly lower scores than for healthy children. This domain could be improved by family, caregiver and community education regarding the condition of SB and its consequences.
This work was supported by the International Federation for Spina Bifida and Hydrocephalus (IFSBH) and the Julius Center for Health Sciences and Primary Care, University Medical Center Utrecht, The Netherlands.