Referee's name:
Essential: fill in your name!

Referee's e-mail:

Do you wish to remain anonymous:

Yes No

Manuscript no.:

Abbreviated title:

Correspondence author(s):

1) How important do you consider the results reported?

nothing selected very important (top 10% of papers) important (top 30% of papers) less important unimportant

2) Do the data obtained by experiment or calculation verify the hypotheses and conclusions?

nothing selected Yes No *)

3) Is the length of the manuscript appropriate to its contents?

nothing selected Yes No, the manuscript is too long *) No, the manuscript is too short *)

4) Do you recommend acceptance of the article?

nothing selected Yes, without alterations Yes, after minor alterations *) No, the manuscript requires major alterations *) No *)

5) If you are of the opinion that the contribution is publishable, but not sufficiently novel for Advanced Materials, please indicate which other journal you consider more appropriate.

*) Please give comments here:

For your archives, print or save the confirmation of this report (which comes immediately on submission) with your browser print or save function. You will also receive a copy of your report to your e-mail account. - Thanks -