Referee's name:
Essential: fill in your name!

Referee's e-mail:

Do you wish to remain anonymous:

Yes No

Manuscript no.:

Abbreviated title:

Correspondence author(s):

1) How important do you consider the results reported?

nothing selected very important important less important unimportant

2) Does the article contribute to the advancement of efficient and practical synthesis or could it serve as the basis for future developements toward this goal?

nothing selected Yes Possibly *) No *)

3) Do the data obtained by experiment or calculation verify the hypotheses and conclusions?

nothing selected Yes No *)

4) Is the length of the manuscript appropriate to its contents?

nothing selected Yes No, the manuscript is too long *) No, the manuscript is too short *)

5) Do you recommend acceptance of the article?

nothing selected Yes, without alterations Yes, after minor alterations *) Yes, but only after major alterations *) No *)

6) If you are of the opinion that the contribution is not suitable for publication in Advanced Synthesis and Catalysis, please indicate which other journal you consider more appropriate.

*) Please give comments here:

For your archives, print or save the confirmation of this report (which comes immediately on submission) with your browser print or save function. You will also receive a copy of your report to your e-mail account. - Thanks -