physica status solidi (a)

Cover image for Vol. 212 Issue 5

Editor: Stefan Hildebrandt (Editor-in-Chief), Sabine Bahrs (Deputy Editor)

Online ISSN: 1862-6319

Associated Title(s): physica status solidi (b), physica status solidi (c), physica status solidi (RRL) - Rapid Research Letters

physica status solidi

Referee's Report

Referee: 
Your e-mail address (required): 
Paper Number (required):
Paper Title: 
Author(s): 

Please see our Checklist for Referees as a guideline for your assessment.

1. Suitability of subject
The paper may be published as a
regular journal paper in
 physica status solidi (a) - applications and materials science
physica status solidi (b) - basic solid state physics
invited or contributed article in physica status solidi (c) - current topics in solid state physics
The subject of the paper is better suited for a different journal.
 Please state journal(s):
 


2. Recommendation regarding publication
Publication in the present form (please give reasons).
Publication subject to minor amendments indicated in the report (further review not necessary).
The author should be advised to revise the paper for resubmission (second review necessary).
 I am willing to review the revised version.
I suggest as an alternative referee (please give communication details, if possible):
The paper should be rejected without qualification.


3. Evaluation of scientific content and clarity of presentation
Scientific content:Excellent Good Average Marginal Poor
Presentation:Excellent Good Average Marginal Poor
Language polishing required:major minor none    
Message to Editor (not to be forwarded to authors):


4. Comments
Please support your recommendation with comments, suitable for transmission to the author, typed in the following field (also in the case of acceptance!).


For your records, please print this page or print/save the confirmation of this report which comes immediately on submission.

SEARCH

SEARCH BY CITATION