Are solar cycles predictable?
Abstract
Various methods (or recipes) have been proposed to predict future solar activity levels – with mixed success. Among these, some precursor methods based upon quantities determined around or a few years before solar minimum have provided rather high correlations with the strength of the following cycles. Recently, data assimilation with an advection‐dominated (flux‐transport) dynamo model has been proposed as a predictive tool, yielding remarkably high correlation coefficients. After discussing the potential implications of these results and the criticism that has been raised, we study the possible physical origin(s) of the predictive skill provided by precursor and other methods. It is found that the combination of the overlap of solar cycles and their amplitude‐dependent rise time (Waldmeier's rule) introduces correlations in the sunspot number (or area) record, which account for the predictive skill of many precursor methods. This explanation requires no direct physical relation between the precursor quantity and the dynamo mechanism (in the sense of the Babcock‐Leighton scheme or otherwise). (© 2007 WILEY‐VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim)
Number of times cited: 10
- David Stenning, David van Dyk, Yaming Yu and Vinay Kashyap, A Bayesian Analysis of the Solar Cycle Using Multiple Proxy Variables, Current Trends in Bayesian Methodology with Applications, 10.1201/b18502-29, (585-607), (2015).
- Guiping Zhou, Jingxiu Wang and Chunlan Jin, Solar Intranetwork Magnetic Elements: Flux Distributions, Solar Physics, 283, 2, (273), (2013).
- Yu. A. Nagovitsyn and A. I. Kuleshova, The Waldmeier rule and early diagnostics of the maximum of the current solar cycle, Astronomy Reports, 56, 10, (800), (2012).
- Y. Yu, D. A. van Dyk, V. L. Kashyap and C. A. Young, A Bayesian Analysis of the Correlations Among Sunspot Cycles, Solar Physics, 281, 2, (847), (2012).
- ZhanLe Du and HuaNing Wang, Predicting the solar maximum with the rising rate, Science China Physics, Mechanics and Astronomy, 55, 2, (365), (2012).
- R. H. Cameron and M. Schüssler, Are the strengths of solar cycles determined by converging flows towards the activity belts?, Astronomy & Astrophysics, 548, (A57), (2012).
- Zhanle Du, The Relationship between Prediction Accuracy and Correlation Coefficient, Solar Physics, 270, 1, (407), (2011).
- ShaoWu Wang, XinYu Wen and JianBin Huang, Global cooling in the immediate future?, Chinese Science Bulletin, 55, 33, (3847), (2010).
- R. Brajša, H. Wöhl, A. Hanslmeier, G. Verbanac, D. Ruždjak, E. Cliver, L. Svalgaard and M. Roth, On solar cycle predictions and reconstructions, Astronomy & Astrophysics, 496, 3, (855), (2009).
- J. A. Abreu, J. Beer, F. Steinhilber, S. M. Tobias and N. O. Weiss, For how long will the current grand maximum of solar activity persist?, Geophysical Research Letters, 35, 20, (2008).
