Local text cohesion, reading ability and individual science aspirations: key factors influencing comprehension in science classes
Abstract
In response to the concern of the need to improve the scientific skills of school children, this study investigated the influence of text design (in terms of text cohesion) and individual differences, with the aim of identifying pathways to improving science education in early secondary school (Key Stage 3). One hundred and four secondary school children (56 females, 48 males), aged 12–13 years took part in the study. To assess the influence of local cohesion (lexical and grammatical links between adjacent sentences) in science texts, we measured students' comprehension (through multiple choice questions) of science text that was high and low in local cohesion. To explore the role of individual differences, students completed tests to measure general reading ability, general intelligence, facets of conscientiousness, science self‐concept and individual, friends and family aspirations in science. Students were more accurate in answering comprehension questions after reading text that was high in cohesion than low in cohesion, suggesting that high local text cohesion improved students' comprehension of science text. Reading ability predicted increased comprehension for both text designs. Individual aspirations in science accounted for unique variance for comprehension for high cohesion text. Implications for the teaching of secondary school science are discussed.
Number of times cited: 5
- Andreas Lachner, Iris Backfisch and Matthias Nückles, Does the accuracy matter? Accurate concept map feedback helps students improve the cohesion of their explanations, Educational Technology Research and Development, (2018).
- Louise Nell, Leo Lentz and Henk Pander Maat, How Text Presentation and Financial Literacy Affect Pension Communication Success, International Journal of Business Communication, (232948841774829), (2017).
- Courtney Karasinski, Comprehension of narratives, non-fiction, and complex syntax as predictors of science achievement, Speech, Language and Hearing, 19, 4, (203), (2016).
- Sophie Susannah Hall, John Maltby, Ruth Filik and Kevin B. Paterson, Key skills for science learning: the importance of text cohesion and reading ability, Educational Psychology, 36, 2, (191), (2016).
- Hendrik Härtig, Patricia Heitmann and Jan Retelsdorf, Analyse der Aufgaben zur Evaluation der Bildungsstandards in Physik - Differenzierung von schriftsprachlichen Fähigkeiten und Fachlichkeit, Zeitschrift für Erziehungswissenschaft, 18, 4, (763), (2015).
