Problems and paradigms
Human genetic diversity: Lewontin's fallacy
Abstract
In popular articles that play down the genetical differences among human populations, it is often stated that about 85% of the total genetical variation is due to individual differences within populations and only 15% to differences between populations or ethnic groups. It has therefore been proposed that the division of Homo sapiens into these groups is not justified by the genetic data. This conclusion, due to R.C. Lewontin in 1972, is unwarranted because the argument ignores the fact that most of the information that distinguishes populations is hidden in the correlation structure of the data and not simply in the variation of the individual factors. The underlying logic, which was discussed in the early years of the last century, is here discussed using a simple genetical example. BioEssays 25:798–801, 2003. © 2003 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.
Citing Literature
Number of times cited: 96
- Stephen Ousley, Richard L. Jantz and Joseph T. Hefner, From Blumenbach to Howells, Forensic Anthropology, (65-97), (2017).
- Syed B. Nizami, Sayyada Z. Hassan Kazmi, Fatima Abid, Mustafeez M. Babar, Aneeqa Noor, Najam-us-Sahar S. Zaidi, Sami U. Khan, Humna Hasan, Mohsin Ali and Alvina Gul, Omics Approaches in Forensic Biotechnology, Omics Technologies and Bio-Engineering, 10.1016/B978-0-12-804659-3.00006-3, (111-129), (2018).
- Kenneth M. Weiss, The tales genes tell (or not): A century of exploration, American Journal of Physical Anthropology, 165, 4, (741-753), (2018).
- Klaus Desmet, Ignacio Ortuño-Ortín and Romain Wacziarg, Culture, Ethnicity, and Diversity, American Economic Review, 107, 9, (2479), (2017).
- M. Tibayrenc, The Race/Ethnic Debate, On Human Nature, 10.1016/B978-0-12-420190-3.00037-5, (633-649), (2017).
- Michael D. Edge, Bridget F. B. Algee-Hewitt, Trevor J. Pemberton, Jun Z. Li and Noah A. Rosenberg, Linkage disequilibrium matches forensic genetic records to disjoint genomic marker sets, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 114, 22, (5671), (2017).
- Jonathan Anomaly, Race Research and the Ethics of Belief, Journal of Bioethical Inquiry, 14, 2, (287), (2017).
- M. Tibayrenc, Human Population Variability and Its Adaptive Significance, On Human Nature, 10.1016/B978-0-12-420190-3.00006-5, (85-109), (2017).
- Laith A. Younus, Abdul Hussein A. Algenabi, Mohammed S. Abdul-Zhara and Majid K. Hussein, FTO gene polymorphisms (rs9939609 and rs17817449) as predictors of Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus in obese Iraqi population, Gene, 627, (79), (2017).
- Edouard Machery and Luc Faucher, Why Do We Think Racially? Culture, Evolution, and Cognition, Handbook of Categorization in Cognitive Science, 10.1016/B978-0-08-101107-2.00046-4, (1135-1175), (2017).
- Bo Winegard, Benjamin Winegard and Brian Boutwell, Human Biological and Psychological Diversity, Evolutionary Psychological Science, 3, 2, (159), (2017).
- Ferdinando Arzarello and Daniele Manzone, The Planimeter as a Real and Virtual Instrument that Mediates an Infinitesimal Approach to Area, Digital Technologies in Designing Mathematics Education Tasks, 10.1007/978-3-319-43423-0_7, (121-149), (2016).
- Lauren Alpert Sugden and Sohini Ramachandran, Integrating the signatures of demic expansion and archaic introgression in studies of human population genomics, Current Opinion in Genetics & Development, 41, (140), (2016).
- John Novembre and Benjamin M Peter, Recent advances in the study of fine-scale population structure in humans, Current Opinion in Genetics & Development, 41, (98), (2016).
- Adam Hochman, Race: Deflate or pop?, Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences, 57, (60), (2016).
- Yaron Granot, Omri Tal, Saharon Rosset, Karl Skorecki and Francesc Calafell, On the Apportionment of Population Structure, PLOS ONE, 11, 8, (e0160413), (2016).
- Olivier Lemeire, Beyond the realism debate: The metaphysics of ‘racial’ distinctions, Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences, 10.1016/j.shpsc.2016.08.001, 59, (47-56), (2016).
- Nathan Cofnas, Science Is Not Always “Self-Correcting”, Foundations of Science, 21, 3, (477), (2016).
- BRIAN M. DONOVAN, Reclaiming Race as a Topic of the U.S. Biology Textbook Curriculum, Science Education, 99, 6, (1092-1117), (2015).
- Yuichi Amitani, Natural Kinds, Species, and Races:, Kagaku tetsugaku, 48, 1, (35), (2015).
- Edward H. Hagen, Evolutionary Psychology and Its Critics, The Handbook of Evolutionary Psychology, (1-25), (2015).
- David Ludwig, Against the New Metaphysics of Race, Philosophy of Science, 82, 2, (244), (2015).
- Michael D. Edge and Noah A. Rosenberg, Implications of the apportionment of human genetic diversity for the apportionment of human phenotypic diversity, Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences, 52, (32), (2015).
- Andreas Wollstein and Oscar Lao, Detecting individual ancestry in the human genome, Investigative Genetics, 6, 1, (2015).
- David Ludwig, Conceptual Relativity in Science, A Pluralist Theory of the Mind, 10.1007/978-3-319-22738-2_4, (47-84), (2015).
- Brian M. Donovan, Putting humanity back into the teaching of human biology, Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences, 52, (65), (2015).
- Jonathan Michael Kaplan, Massimo Pigliucci and Joshua Alexander Banta, Gould on Morton, Redux: What can the debate reveal about the limits of data?, Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences, 52, (22), (2015).
- Marianne Sommer, Population-genetic trees, maps, and narratives of the great human diasporas, History of the Human Sciences, 10.1177/0952695115573032, 28, 5, (108-145), (2015).
- Rasmus Grønfeldt Winther, Roberta L. Millstein and Rasmus Nielsen, Introduction: Genomics and philosophy of race, Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences, 52, (1), (2015).
- Ernesto Schwartz‐Marin, Genetics, The Wiley Blackwell Encyclopedia of Race, Ethnicity, and Nationalism, (1-3), (2015).
- Edwin Francisco Herrera Paz, Chiara Scapoli, Elisabetta Mamolini, Massimo Sandri, Alberto Carrieri, Alvaro Rodriguez‐Larralde and Italo Barrai, Surnames in Honduras: A Study of the Population of Honduras through Isonymy, Annals of Human Genetics, 78, 3, (165-177), (2014).
- Brian M. Donovan, Playing with fire? The impact of the hidden curriculum in school genetics on essentialist conceptions of race, Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 51, 4, (462-496), (2013).
- David Ludwig, Hysteria, race, and phlogiston. A model of ontological elimination in the human sciences, Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences, 45, (68), (2014).
- Joan H. Fujimura, Deborah A. Bolnick, Ramya Rajagopalan, Jay S. Kaufman, Richard C. Lewontin, Troy Duster, Pilar Ossorio and Jonathan Marks, Clines Without Classes, Sociological Theory, 10.1177/0735275114551611, 32, 3, (208-227), (2014).
- Kaplan, Lorusso and Winther, Race, Genomics, and Philosophy of Science, Critical Philosophy of Race, 2, 2, (160), (2014).
- Savage and Brown, Mapping Music: Cluster Analysis Of Song-Type Frequencies Within And Between Cultures, Ethnomusicology, 58, 1, (133), (2014).
- Bo Winegard and Ben Winegard, Book Review: Darwin's Duel with DescartesA review of WadeNicholas, A Troublesome Inheritance: Genes, Race, and Human History.Penguin: New York, 2014, 288 pp., US$20.68, ISBN # 1594204462 (Hardcover)., Evolutionary Psychology, 12, 3, (147470491401200), (2014).
- Thomas J. Bouchard, Genes, Evolution and Intelligence, Behavior Genetics, 10.1007/s10519-014-9646-x, 44, 6, (549-577), (2014).
- J.-L. Bonniol, Que faire de la « race » ? Du diagnostic à la thérapie, Annales de Dermatologie et de Vénéréologie, 141, 8-9, (553), (2014).
- Yoshitaka Fukui, A downward bias in probability of misclassification of human polymorphic loci? (referring to DOI 10.1002/bies.10315), BioEssays, 35, 8, (755-755), (2013).
- G. Barbujani, S. Ghirotto and F. Tassi, Nine things to remember about human genome diversity, Tissue Antigens, 82, 3, (155), (2013).
- Frank Salter and Henry Harpending, J.P. Rushton’s theory of ethnic nepotism, Personality and Individual Differences, 55, 3, (256), (2013).
- Adam Hochman, Racial discrimination: How not to do it, Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences, 44, 3, (278), (2013).
- Omri Tal, Two complementary perspectives on inter-individual genetic distance, Biosystems, 111, 1, (18), (2013).
- Jonathan Marks, The Nature/Culture of Genetic Facts, Annual Review of Anthropology, 10.1146/annurev-anthro-092412-155558, 42, 1, (247-267), (2013).
- JAMES J. LEE and CARSON C. CHOW, The causal meaning of Fisher's average effect, Genetics Research, 95, 2-3, (89), (2013).
- Jonathan Michael Kaplan and Rasmus Grønfeldt Winther, Prisoners of Abstraction? The Theory and Measure of Genetic Variation, and the Very Concept of “Race”, Biological Theory, 7, 4, (401), (2013).
- Benjamin Lê Cook, Thomas G. McGuire and Alan M. Zaslavsky,, Measuring Racial/Ethnic Disparities in Health Care: Methods and Practical Issues, Health Services Research, 47, 3pt2, (1232-1254), (2012).
- Trevor Pearce, Philosophy of biology in the twenty-first century, Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences, 43, 1, (312), (2012).
- Juan Manuel Sánchez Arteaga and Charbel N. El-Hani, Othering Processes and STS Curricula: From Nineteenth Century Scientific Discourse on Interracial Competition and Racial Extinction to Othering in Biomedical Technosciences, Science & Education, 21, 5, (607), (2012).
- Jiannbin Lee Shiao, Thomas Bode, Amber Beyer and Daniel Selvig, The Genomic Challenge to the Social Construction of Race, Sociological Theory, 30, 2, (67), (2012).
- T. Rzeszutek, P. E. Savage and S. Brown, The structure of cross-cultural musical diversity, Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, 279, 1733, (1606), (2012).
- Omri Tal, The cumulative effect of genetic markers on classification performance: Insights from simple models, Journal of Theoretical Biology, 293, (206), (2012).
- Sushil Amirisetty, Gurjit K. Khurana Hershey and Tesfaye M. Baye, AncestrySNPminer: A bioinformatics tool to retrieve and develop ancestry informative SNP panels, Genomics, 100, 1, (57), (2012).
- R. A. Foley and M. Mirazon Lahr, The evolution of the diversity of cultures, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, 366, 1567, (1080), (2011).
- John Novembre and Sohini Ramachandran, Perspectives on Human Population Structure at the Cusp of the Sequencing Era, Annual Review of Genomics and Human Genetics, 12, 1, (245), (2011).
- Lili Ding, Howard Wiener, Tilahun Abebe, Mekbib Altaye, Rodney CP Go, Carolyn Kercsmar, Greg Grabowski, Lisa J Martin, Gurjit K Khurana Hershey, Ranajit Chakorborty and Tesfaye M Baye, Comparison of measures of marker informativeness for ancestry and admixture mapping, BMC Genomics, 12, 1, (2011).
- Noah A. Rosenberg, A Population-Genetic Perspective on the Similarities and Differences among Worldwide Human Populations, Human Biology, 83, 6, (659), (2011).
- Anthony Walsh and Ilhong Yun, Race and Criminology in the Age of Genomic Science, Social Science Quarterly, 92, 5, (1279-1296), (2011).
- Stephen M. Colarelli, Debra A. Poole, Kate Unterborn and Geeta C. D'Souza, Racial Prototypicality, Affirmative Action, and Hiring Decisions in a Multiracial World, International Journal of Selection and Assessment, 18, 2, (166-173), (2010).
- Michael A. Woodley, Is Homo sapiens polytypic? Human taxonomic diversity and its implications, Medical Hypotheses, 10.1016/j.mehy.2009.07.046, 74, 1, (195-201), (2010).
- Neven Sesardic, Race: a social destruction of a biological concept, Biology & Philosophy, 25, 2, (143), (2010).
- Robert A Foley, Evolution and Human Cognitive Diversity: What Should We Expect?, Interdisciplinary Science Reviews, 35, 3-4, (241), (2010).
- Tesfaye M Baye, Hemant K Tiwari, David B Allison and Rodney C Go, Database mining for selection of SNP markers useful in admixture mapping, BioData Mining, 2, 1, (2009).
- Jan Saarela and Fjalar Finnäs, Geographic Ancestry and Cause-specific Mortality in a National Population, Population Research and Policy Review, 28, 2, (169), (2009).
- Jeffrey C. Long, Jie Li and Meghan E. Healy, Human DNA sequences: More variation and less race, American Journal of Physical Anthropology, 139, 1, (23-34), (2009).
- Lyle W. Konigsberg, Bridget F.B. Algee‐Hewitt and Dawnie Wolfe Steadman, Estimation and evidence in forensic anthropology: Sex and race, American Journal of Physical Anthropology, 139, 1, (77-90), (2009).
- Stephen Ousley, Richard Jantz and Donna Freid, Understanding race and human variation: Why forensic anthropologists are good at identifying race, American Journal of Physical Anthropology, 139, 1, (68-76), (2009).
- T Jombart, D Pontier and A-B Dufour, Genetic markers in the playground of multivariate analysis, Heredity, 102, 4, (330), (2009).
- STEPHEN MORSE, The geography of tyranny and despair: development indicators and the hypothesis of genetic inevitability of national inequality, The Geographical Journal, 174, 3, (195-206), (2008).
- Snait B. Gissis, When is ‘race’ a race? 1946–2003, Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences, 10.1016/j.shpsc.2008.09.006, 39, 4, (437-450), (2008).
- J. Z. Li, D. M. Absher, H. Tang, A. M. Southwick, A. M. Casto, S. Ramachandran, H. M. Cann, G. S. Barsh, M. Feldman, L. L. Cavalli-Sforza and R. M. Myers, Worldwide Human Relationships Inferred from Genome-Wide Patterns of Variation, Science, 319, 5866, (1100), (2008).
- John Hartigan, Is Race Still Socially Constructed? The Recent Controversy over Race and Medical Genetics, Science as Culture, 10.1080/09505430802062943, 17, 2, (163-193), (2008).
- Andrea S. Camperio Ciani, Claudio Capiluppi, Antonio Veronese and Giuseppe Sartori, The adaptive value of personality differences revealed by small island population dynamics, European Journal of Personality, 21, 1, (3-22), (2006).
- Charles Crawford, Commentary on ‘the adaptive value of personality differences revealed by small island population dynamics’, European Journal of Personality, 21, 4, (383-387), (2007).
- Michael Bamshad and Stephen L Guthery, Race, genetics and medicine: does the color of a leopardʼs spots matter?, Current Opinion in Pediatrics, 19, 6, (613), (2007).
- Robin O. Andreasen, BIOLOGICAL CONCEPTIONS OF RACE, Philosophy of Biology, 10.1016/B978-044451543-8/50022-8, (455-481), (2007).
- Reinhard Siegmund-Schultze and Sandy Zabell, Richard von Mises and the “problem of two races”: A statistical satire in 1934, Historia Mathematica, 34, 2, (206), (2007).
- Oscar Lao, Kate van Duijn, Paula Kersbergen, Peter de Knijff and Manfred Kayser, Proportioning Whole-Genome Single-Nucleotide–Polymorphism Diversity for the Identification of Geographic Population Structure and Genetic Ancestry, The American Journal of Human Genetics, 78, 4, (680), (2006).
- Keith C. Cheng and Victor A. Canfield, The role of SLC24A5 in skin color, Experimental Dermatology, 15, 10, (836), (2006).
- Michael Steffens, Claudia Lamina, Thomas Illig, Thomas Bettecken, Rainer Vogler, Patricia Entz, Eun-Kyung Suk, Mohammad Reza Toliat, Norman Klopp, Amke Caliebe, Inke R. König, Karola Köhler, Jan Lüdemann, Amalia Diaz Lacava, Rolf Fimmers, Peter Lichtner, Andreas Ziegler, Andreas Wolf, Michael Krawczak, Peter Nürnberg, Jochen Hampe, Stefan Schreiber, Thomas Meitinger, H.-Erich Wichmann, Kathryn Roeder, Thomas F. Wienker and Max P. Baur, SNP-Based Analysis of Genetic Substructure in the German Population, Human Heredity, 62, 1, (20), (2006).
- David Serre and Thomas J. Hudson, Resources for Genetic Variation Studies, Annual Review of Genomics and Human Genetics, 7, 1, (443), (2006).
- J.-L. Bonniol, La peau « noire » : va-et-vient d’un anthropologue entre le biologique et le social, Annales de Dermatologie et de Vénéréologie, 133, 11, (853), (2006).
- Ian Hacking, Genetics, biosocial groups & the future of identity, Daedalus, 135, 4, (81), (2006).
- Henry Harpending and Gregory Cochran, Genetic diversity and genetic burden in humans, Infection, Genetics and Evolution, 6, 2, (154), (2006).
- Kenneth M. Weiss and Stephanie M. Fullerton, Racing around, getting nowhere, "Evolutionary Anthropology: Issues, News, and Reviews", 14, 5, (165-169), (2005).
- Noah A. Rosenberg, Algorithms for Selecting Informative Marker Panels for Population Assignment, Journal of Computational Biology, 12, 9, (1183), (2005).
- Stacy J�rgensen and Rodney Mauricio, Hybridization as a source of evolutionary novelty: leaf shape in a Hawaiian composite, Genetica, 123, 1-2, (171), (2005).
- Armand Marie Leroi, A family tree in every gene, Journal of Genetics, 84, 1, (3), (2005).
- Lynn B Jorde and Stephen P Wooding, Genetic variation, classification and 'race', Nature Genetics, 36, 11s, (S28), (2004).
- Michael Bamshad, Stephen Wooding, Benjamin A. Salisbury and J. Claiborne Stephens, Deconstructing the relationship between genetics and race, Nature Reviews Genetics, 10.1038/nrg1401, 5, 8, (598-609), (2004).
- Joanna L Mountain and Neil Risch, Assessing genetic contributions to phenotypic differences among 'racial' and 'ethnic' groups, Nature Genetics, 36, 11s, (S48), (2004).
- Jonathan Michael Kaplan, ‘Race’: What Biology Can Tell Us about a Social Construct, eLS, (2011).
- Oscar Lao and Manfred Kayser, Human Relationships Inferred from Genetic Variation, eLS, (2009).
- Koffi N. Maglo, Tesfaye B. Mersha and Lisa J. Martin, Population Genomics and the Statistical Values of Race: An Interdisciplinary Perspective on the Biological Classification of Human Populations and Implications for Clinical Genetic Epidemiological Research, Frontiers in Genetics, 10.3389/fgene.2016.00022, 7, (2016).
- Lia Betti, Noreen von Cramon-Taubadel, Andrea Manica, Stephen J. Lycett and John H. Relethford, Global Geometric Morphometric Analyses of the Human Pelvis Reveal Substantial Neutral Population History Effects, Even across Sexes, PLoS ONE, 10.1371/journal.pone.0055909, 8, 2, (e55909), (2013).
