Counterfactual thinking and functional differences in depression†
This research was partially supported by the European Program POCTI/PSI/42215—FEDER–FCT. Preliminary results were presented at the Fifth National Symposium of Research in Psychology, Lisbon 2003, and at the 9th International Conference on Motivation (EARLI) in 2004.
Abstract
The purpose of the studies reported in this paper was to evaluate the function of counterfactual thinking (CT) in depression. In Experiment 1, depressed and non‐depressed participants were asked to imagine themselves as the protagonist of a hypothetical situation, and to think counterfactually about three different scenarios. The results showed that there was a similar CT style (in terms of direction, structure and focus of mutation) for the depressed and the non‐depressed groups. It was also found that the perceived preparation for a future similar situation increased after CT and, contrary to our hypotheses, this effect was observed in both groups. In Experiment 2, a real‐life situation was used (a course examination) in which participants experienced a negative outcome (a poor score on the test). Again, it was observed that depressed and non‐depressed participants showed the same CT style, but non‐depressed participants were more likely to use CT spontaneously. In addition, the second study showed further differences between the two groups: depressed participants not only showed a lack of cognitive benefits from thinking counterfactually (i.e., after CT they do not feel more prepared for future similar events, nor able to avoid a similar bad outcome, in contrast to the non‐depressed participants), but also show a lack of behavioural changes (both intentions to change and actual changes over the subsequent week). In conclusion, these results provide evidence about the function of CT both in depressed and in non‐depressed thinking, and highlight both the similarities and differences for these two groups. Copyright © 2008 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
Number of times cited according to CrossRef: 12
- Anne Gene Broomhall, Wendy J. Phillips, Donald W. Hine and Natasha M. Loi, Upward counterfactual thinking and depression: A meta-analysis, Clinical Psychology Review, 10.1016/j.cpr.2017.04.010, 55, (56-73), (2017).
- Neal J. Roese and Kai Epstude, The Functional Theory of Counterfactual Thinking: New Evidence, New Challenges, New Insights, , 10.1016/bs.aesp.2017.02.001, (1-79), (2017).
- Eugenia Kulakova and Mante S. Nieuwland, Understanding Counterfactuality: A Review of Experimental Evidence for the Dual Meaning of Counterfactuals, Language and Linguistics Compass, 10, 2, (49-65), (2016).
- Xue Feng, Ruolei Gu, Fucheng Liang, Lucas S. Broster, Yunzhe Liu, Dandan Zhang and Yue-jia Luo, Depressive states amplify both upward and downward counterfactual thinking, International Journal of Psychophysiology, 97, 2, (93), (2015).
- Flora Kokkinaki and Nick Sevdalis, Effect of Motivational Goals on the Causal Realism of Counterfactual Thoughts, The Journal of Psychology, 149, 7, (643), (2015).
- Chong Chen, Taiki Takahashi, Shin Nakagawa, Takeshi Inoue and Ichiro Kusumi, Reinforcement learning in depression: A review of computational research, Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews, 55, (247), (2015).
- Juliana Sarantopoulos Faccioli and Patricia Waltz Schelini, Styles of Counterfactual Thoughts in People with and without Signs of Depression, The Spanish Journal of Psychology, 18, (2015).
- Claire M. Gillan, Sharon Morein-Zamir, Muzaffer Kaser, Naomi A. Fineberg, Akeem Sule, Barbara J. Sahakian, Rudolf N. Cardinal and Trevor W. Robbins, Counterfactual Processing of Economic Action-Outcome Alternatives in Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder: Further Evidence of Impaired Goal-Directed Behavior, Biological Psychiatry, 75, 8, (639), (2014).
- Jenny Reichert, Monica K. Miller, Brian H. Bornstein and Hon. Donald E. Shelton, How reason for surgery and patient weight affect verdicts and perceptions in medical malpractice trials: A comparison of students and jurors, Behavioral Sciences & the Law, 29, 3, (395-418), (2011).
- Fuschia M. Sirois, Jennifer Monforton and Melissa Simpson, “If Only I Had Done Better”: Perfectionism and the Functionality of Counterfactual Thinking, Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 36, 12, (1675), (2010).
- Florença Lucia Coelho Justino and Patrícia Waltz Schelini, Cognições sobre Eventos Passados: uma Revisão da Literatura, Revista Colombiana de Psicología, 10.15446/rcp.v27n2.65585, 27, 2, (103-116), (2018).
- Anne Gene Broomhall and Wendy J. Phillips, Self-referent upward counterfactuals and depression: Examining regret as a mediator, Cogent Psychology, 10.1080/23311908.2017.1416884, 5, 1, (2018).
