Review
Virtual reality exposure therapy in anxiety disorders: a systematic review of process‐and‐outcome studies*
*
The authors report they have no financial relationships within the past 3 year to disclose.
Abstract
In recent years, virtual reality exposure therapy (VRET) has become an interesting alternative for the treatment of anxiety disorders. Research has focused on the efficacy of VRET in treating anxiety disorders: phobias, panic disorder, and posttraumatic stress disorder. In this systematic review, strict methodological criteria are used to give an overview of the controlled trials regarding the efficacy of VRET in patients with anxiety disorders. Furthermore, research into process variables such as the therapeutic alliance and cognitions and enhancement of therapy effects through cognitive enhancers is discussed. The implications for implementation into clinical practice are considered. Depression and Anxiety, 2010. © 2010 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.
Citing Literature
Number of times cited: 84
- Roos Pot-Kolder, Wim Veling, Jacqueline Counotte and Mark van der Gaag, Anxiety Partially Mediates Cybersickness Symptoms in Immersive Virtual Reality Environments, Cyberpsychology, Behavior, and Social Networking, (2018).
- Bob-Antoine J. Menelas, Corentin Haidon, Adrien Ecrepont and Benoit Girard, Use of virtual reality technologies as an Action-Cue Exposure Therapy for truck drivers suffering from Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder, Entertainment Computing, 24, (1), (2018).
- Alexandra Ghiţă and José Gutiérrez-Maldonado, Applications of virtual reality in individuals with alcohol misuse: A systematic review, Addictive Behaviors, 81, (1), (2018).
- Federica Pallavicini, Luca Morganti, Barbara Diana, Olivia Realdon, Valentino Zurloni and Fabrizia Mantovani, Mobile Virtual Reality to Enhance Subjective Well-Being, Encyclopedia of Information Science and Technology, Fourth Edition, 10.4018/978-1-5225-2255-3.ch541, (6223-6233), (2018).
- Marianne Schmid Mast, Emmanuelle P. Kleinlogel, Benjamin Tur and Manuel Bachmann, The future of interpersonal skills development: Immersive virtual reality training with virtual humans, Human Resource Development Quarterly, 29, 2, (125-141), (2018).
- Amador Cernuda Lago, Innovations in Research and Development of Scientific Procedures to Reach the Success and the Excellence by Means of Psychology Applied to the High Performance, Key Issues for Management of Innovative Projects, 10.5772/intechopen.68490, (2017).
- Maher Ben-Moussa, Marius Rubo, Coralie Debracque and Wolf-Gero Lange, DJINNI: A Novel Technology Supported Exposure Therapy Paradigm for SAD Combining Virtual Reality and Augmented Reality, Frontiers in Psychiatry, 8, (2017).
- Mascha van ’t Wout, Christopher M. Spofford, William S. Unger, Elizabeth B. Sevin and M. Tracie Shea, Skin Conductance Reactivity to Standardized Virtual Reality Combat Scenes in Veterans with PTSD, Applied Psychophysiology and Biofeedback, 10.1007/s10484-017-9366-0, 42, 3, (209-221), (2017).
- David L. Neumann, Robyn L. Moffitt, Patrick R. Thomas, Kylie Loveday, David P. Watling, Chantal L. Lombard, Simona Antonova and Michael A. Tremeer, A systematic review of the application of interactive virtual reality to sport, Virtual Reality, (2017).
- Cristina Botella, Rosa M. Baños, Azucena García-Palacios and Soledad Quero, Virtual Reality and Other Realities, The Science of Cognitive Behavioral Therapy, 10.1016/B978-0-12-803457-6.00022-2, (551-590), (2017).
- Jessica L. Maples-Keller, Carly Yasinski, Nicole Manjin and Barbara Olasov Rothbaum, Virtual Reality-Enhanced Extinction of Phobias and Post-Traumatic Stress, Neurotherapeutics, 10.1007/s13311-017-0534-y, 14, 3, (554-563), (2017).
- Martin Dechant, Sabine Trimpl, Christian Wolff, Andreas Mühlberger and Youssef Shiban, Potential of virtual reality as a diagnostic tool for social anxiety: A pilot study, Computers in Human Behavior, 76, (128), (2017).
- Irene Alice Chicchi Giglioli, Gabriella Pravettoni, Dolores Lucia Sutil Martín, Elena Parra and Mariano A. Raya, A Novel Integrating Virtual Reality Approach for the Assessment of the Attachment Behavioral System, Frontiers in Psychology, 8, (2017).
- S. Bioulac, E. de Sevin, P. Sagaspe, A. Claret, P. Philip, J.A. Micoulaud-Franchi and M.P. Bouvard, Qu’apportent les outils de réalité virtuelle en psychiatrie de l’enfant et l’adolescent ?, L'Encéphale, (2017).
- Marijn C. W. Kroes, Joseph E. Dunsmoor, Wayne E. Mackey, Mason McClay and Elizabeth A. Phelps, Context conditioning in humans using commercially available immersive Virtual Reality, Scientific Reports, 10.1038/s41598-017-08184-7, 7, 1, (2017).
- Luca Chittaro, Riccardo Sioni, Cristiano Crescentini and Franco Fabbro, Mortality salience in virtual reality experiences and its effects on users’ attitudes towards risk, International Journal of Human-Computer Studies, 101, (10), (2017).
- Corentin Haidon, Adrien Ecrepont, Benoit Girard and Bob-Antoine J. Menelas, A Driving Simulator Designed for the Care of Trucker Suffering from Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder, Serious Games and Edutainment Applications, 10.1007/978-3-319-51645-5_19, (411-431), (2017).
- D. Freeman, S. Reeve, A. Robinson, A. Ehlers, D. Clark, B. Spanlang and M. Slater, Virtual reality in the assessment, understanding, and treatment of mental health disorders, Psychological Medicine, 47, 14, (2393), (2017).
- Jessica L. Maples-Keller, Brian E. Bunnell, Sae-Jin Kim and Barbara O. Rothbaum, The Use of Virtual Reality Technology in the Treatment of Anxiety and Other Psychiatric Disorders, Harvard Review of Psychiatry, 25, 3, (103), (2017).
- Myrthe L. Tielman, Mark A. Neerincx, Rafael Bidarra, Ben Kybartas and Willem-Paul Brinkman, A Therapy System for Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder Using a Virtual Agent and Virtual Storytelling to Reconstruct Traumatic Memories, Journal of Medical Systems, 41, 8, (2017).
- Martine J. van Bennekom, Pelle P. de Koning and Damiaan Denys, Virtual Reality Objectifies the Diagnosis of Psychiatric Disorders: A Literature Review, Frontiers in Psychiatry, 8, (2017).
- Pietro Cipresso, Alessandro Bessi, Desirée Colombo, Elisa Pedroli and Giuseppe Riva, Computational Psychometrics for Modeling System Dynamics during Stressful Disasters, Frontiers in Psychology, 8, (2017).
- Cristina Botella, Javier Fernández-Álvarez, Verónica Guillén, Azucena García-Palacios and Rosa Baños, Recent Progress in Virtual Reality Exposure Therapy for Phobias: A Systematic Review, Current Psychiatry Reports, 19, 7, (2017).
- Sofia Seinfeld, Ilias Bergstrom, Ausias Pomes, Jorge Arroyo-Palacios, Francisco Vico, Mel Slater and Maria V. Sanchez-Vives, Influence of Music on Anxiety Induced by Fear of Heights in Virtual Reality, Frontiers in Psychology, 6, (2016). 2016 IEEE International Conference on Serious Games and Applications for Health (SeGAH) Orlando, FL, USA 2016 IEEE International Conference on Serious Games and Applications for Health (SeGAH) IEEE , (2016). 978-1-5090-2210-6 Adrien Ecrepont, Corentin Haidon, Benoit Girard and Bob-Antoine J. Menelas A fully customizable truck-driving simulator for the care of people suffering from Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder , (2016). 1 8 7586271 , 10.1109/SeGAH.2016.7586271 http://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/7586271/
- Isabel L. Kampmann, Paul M.G. Emmelkamp, Dwi Hartanto, Willem-Paul Brinkman, Bonne J.H. Zijlstra and Nexhmedin Morina, Exposure to virtual social interactions in the treatment of social anxiety disorder: A randomized controlled trial, Behaviour Research and Therapy, 77, (147), (2016).
- Sushunova G. Martinez, Karla A. Badillo-Urquiola, Rebecca A. Leis, Jamie Chavez, Tiffany Green and Travis Clements, Investigation of Multimodal Mobile Applications for Improving Mental Health, Foundations of Augmented Cognition: Neuroergonomics and Operational Neuroscience, 10.1007/978-3-319-39952-2_32, (333-343), (2016).
- Wei-Peng Teo, Makii Muthalib, Sami Yamin, Ashlee M. Hendy, Kelly Bramstedt, Eleftheria Kotsopoulos, Stephane Perrey and Hasan Ayaz, Does a Combination of Virtual Reality, Neuromodulation and Neuroimaging Provide a Comprehensive Platform for Neurorehabilitation? – A Narrative Review of the Literature, Frontiers in Human Neuroscience, 10, (2016).
- Julia Diemer, Nora Lohkamp, Andreas Mühlberger and Peter Zwanzger, Fear and physiological arousal during a virtual height challenge—effects in patients with acrophobia and healthy controls, Journal of Anxiety Disorders, 37, (30), (2016).
- Corentin Haidon, Adrien Ecrepont, Benoit Girard and Bob-Antoine J. Menelas, Gamification of a Truck-Driving Simulator for the Care of People Suffering from Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder, Games and Learning Alliance, 10.1007/978-3-319-40216-1_33, (312-322), (2016).
- Giuseppe Riva, Rosa M. Baños, Cristina Botella, Fabrizia Mantovani and Andrea Gaggioli, Transforming Experience: The Potential of Augmented Reality and Virtual Reality for Enhancing Personal and Clinical Change, Frontiers in Psychiatry, 7, (2016).
- Wouter van Ballegooijen, Britt Klein and Nils Lindefors, ICBT for Panic Disorder and Agoraphobia: From the Computer at Home to Real-Life ‘In Vivo’ Exposure, Guided Internet-Based Treatments in Psychiatry, 10.1007/978-3-319-06083-5_3, (33-52), (2016).
- M. Morgiève, K. N’Diaye, A.-H. Clair, A. Pelissolo and L. Mallet, Peut-on augmenter l’efficacité de la thérapie cognitive et comportementale pour le trouble obsessionnel compulsif par un adjuvant informatique innovant ?, L'Encéphale, 42, 5, (402), (2016).
- S.A. Steinman, B.M. Wootton and D.F. Tolin, Exposure Therapy for Anxiety Disorders, Encyclopedia of Mental Health, 10.1016/B978-0-12-397045-9.00266-4, (186-191), (2016).
- Daniel Campos, Juana Bretón-López, Cristina Botella, Adriana Mira, Diana Castilla, Rosa Baños, Miquel Tortella-Feliu and Soledad Quero, An Internet-based treatment for flying phobia (NO-FEAR Airlines): study protocol for a randomized controlled trial, BMC Psychiatry, 10.1186/s12888-016-0996-1, 16, 1, (2016).
- Clare K. Purvis, Megan Jones, Jakki O. Bailey, Jeremy Bailenson, C. Barr Taylor and Amy Brown, Developing a Novel Measure of Body Satisfaction Using Virtual Reality, PLOS ONE, 10, 10, (e0140158), (2015).
- Mônica Macedo, António Marques and Cristina Queirós, Virtual reality in assessment and treatment of schizophrenia: a systematic review, Jornal Brasileiro de Psiquiatria, 64, 1, (70), (2015).
- Elias Aboujaoude, Wael Salame and Lama Naim, Telemental health: A status update, World Psychiatry, 14, 2, (223-230), (2015).
- Youssef Shiban, Iris Schelhorn, Paul Pauli and Andreas Mühlberger, Effect of combined multiple contexts and multiple stimuli exposure in spider phobia: A randomized clinical trial in virtual reality, Behaviour Research and Therapy, 71, (45), (2015).
- Julia Diemer, Paul Pauli and Andreas Mühlberger, Virtual Reality in Psychotherapy, International Encyclopedia of the Social & Behavioral Sciences, 10.1016/B978-0-08-097086-8.21070-2, (138-146), (2015).
- Alfons O. Hamm, Phobias Across the Lifespan, International Encyclopedia of the Social & Behavioral Sciences, 10.1016/B978-0-08-097086-8.21015-5, (37-44), (2015).
- Rosa M. Baños Rivera, Cristina Botella Arbona, Azucena García‐Palacios, Soledad Quero Castellano and Juana Bretón López, Treating Emotional Problems with Virtual and Augmented Reality, The Handbook of the Psychology of Communication Technology, (548-566), (2015).
- Sara A. Freedman, Ehud Dayan, Yael Bleich Kimelman, Heidi Weissman and Renana Eitan, Early intervention for preventing posttraumatic stress disorder: an Internet-based virtual reality treatment, European Journal of Psychotraumatology, 6, 1, (25608), (2015).
- 이수진 and Kyong-Mee Chung, Effect of an Exposure Program to Vegetables to Increase Young Children's Vegetable Consumption, Korean Journal of Health Psychology, 20, 2, (425), (2015).
- Luca Chittaro and Fabio Buttussi, Assessing Knowledge Retention of an Immersive Serious Game vs. a Traditional Education Method in Aviation Safety, IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics, 21, 4, (529), (2015).
- Marta Miragall, Rosa M. Baños, Ausiàs Cebolla and Cristina Botella, Working alliance inventory applied to virtual and augmented reality (WAI-VAR): psychometrics and therapeutic outcomes, Frontiers in Psychology, 6, (2015).
- Yun Ling, Harold T. Nefs, Nexhmedin Morina, Ingrid Heynderickx, Willem-Paul Brinkman and Mel Slater, A Meta-Analysis on the Relationship between Self-Reported Presence and Anxiety in Virtual Reality Exposure Therapy for Anxiety Disorders, PLoS ONE, 9, 5, (e96144), (2014).
- Julia Diemer, Andreas Mühlberger, Paul Pauli and Peter Zwanzger, Virtual reality exposure in anxiety disorders: Impact on psychophysiological reactivity, The World Journal of Biological Psychiatry, 15, 6, (427), (2014).
- Katharina Meyerbröker, Virtual Reality Exposure Therapy, The Wiley Handbook of Anxiety Disorders, (1310-1324), (2014).
- Alfons O. Hamm, Specific Phobias: Assessment and Treatment, The Wiley Handbook of Anxiety Disorders, (895-923), (2014).
- Paul M.G. Emmelkamp, Daniel David, Tom Beckers, Peter Muris, Pim Cuijpers, Wolfgang Lutz, Gerhard Andersson, Ricardo Araya, Rosa M. Banos Rivera, Michael Barkham, Matthias Berking, Thomas Berger, Christina Botella, Per Carlbring, Francesc Colom, Cecilia Essau, Dirk Hermans, Stefan G. Hofmann, Susanne Knappe, Thomas H. Ollendick, Filip Raes, Winfried Rief, Heleen Riper, Saskia Van Der Oord and Bram Vervliet, Advancing psychotherapy and evidence‐based psychological interventions, International Journal of Methods in Psychiatric Research, 23, S1, (58-91), (2013).
- Silvia Serino, Stefano Triberti, Daniela Villani, Pietro Cipresso, Andrea Gaggioli and Giuseppe Riva, Toward a validation of cyber-interventions for stress disorders based on stress inoculation training: a systematic review, Virtual Reality, 18, 1, (73), (2014).
- Russell A. McCann, Christina M. Armstrong, Nancy A. Skopp, Amanda Edwards-Stewart, Derek J. Smolenski, Jennifer D. June, Melinda Metzger-Abamukong and Greg M. Reger, Virtual reality exposure therapy for the treatment of anxiety disorders: An evaluation of research quality, Journal of Anxiety Disorders, 28, 6, (625), (2014).
- Nexhmedin Morina, Willem-Paul Brinkman, Dwi Hartanto and Paul M.G. Emmelkamp, Sense of presence and anxiety during virtual social interactions between a human and virtual humans, PeerJ, 2, (e337), (2014).
- Przemysław Bąbel and Anna M. Ziółkowska, Terapia behawioralna zaburzeń lękowych, Postępy Psychiatrii i Neurologii, 23, 1, (3), (2014).
- Soledad Quero, M. Ángeles Pérez-Ara, Juana Bretón-López, Azucena García-Palacios, Rosa M. Baños and Cristina Botella, Acceptability of virtual reality interoceptive exposure for the treatment of panic disorder with agoraphobia, British Journal of Guidance & Counselling, 42, 2, (123), (2014).
- Nina Wong Sarver, Deborah C. Beidel and Josh S. Spitalnick, The Feasibility and Acceptability of Virtual Environments in the Treatment of Childhood Social Anxiety Disorder, Journal of Clinical Child & Adolescent Psychology, 43, 1, (63), (2014).
- L. Chittaro, Anxiety Induction in Virtual Environments: An Experimental Comparison of Three General Techniques, Interacting with Computers, 26, 6, (528), (2014).
- Matilda E. Nowakowski, Jenny Rogojanski and Martin M. Antony, Specific Phobia, The Wiley Handbook of Cognitive Behavioral Therapy, (979-1000), (2013).
- K. Meyerbroeker, N. Morina, G.A. Kerkhof and P.M.G. Emmelkamp, Virtual Reality Exposure Therapy Does Not Provide Any Additional Value in Agoraphobic Patients: A Randomized Controlled Trial, Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics, 82, 3, (170), (2013).
- Lars‐Göran Öst and Lena Reuterskiöld, Specific Phobias, CBT for Anxiety Disorders, (107-133), (2013).
- Stephen J. Morley and Johan W. S. Vlaeyen, Chronic Pain, The Wiley Handbook of Cognitive Behavioral Therapy, (463-488), (2013).
- Vlasios Brakoulias, Virtual reality can help to develop a new reality, Australian & New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry, 47, 2, (186), (2013).
- M. Wrzesien, M. Alcaiz, C. Botella, J-M Burkhardt, J. Breton-Lopez, M. Ortega and D. B. Brotons, The Therapeutic Lamp: Treating Small-Animal Phobias, IEEE Computer Graphics and Applications, 33, 1, (80), (2013).
- Norman B. Schmidt, Kristina J. Korte, Aaron M. Norr and Meghan E. Keough, Panic Disorder, The Wiley Handbook of Cognitive Behavioral Therapy, (917-940), (2013).
- Patricia R. DeLucia, Stephanie A. Harold and Yi-Yuan Tang, Innovation in Technology-Aided Psychotherapy Through Human Factors/Ergonomics: Toward a Collaborative Approach, Journal of Contemporary Psychotherapy, 43, 4, (253), (2013).
- David C. Mohr, Michelle Nicole Burns, Stephen M. Schueller, Gregory Clarke and Michael Klinkman, Behavioral Intervention Technologies: Evidence review and recommendations for future research in mental health, General Hospital Psychiatry, 35, 4, (332), (2013).
- Daniel David, Silviu-Andrei Matu and Oana Alexandra David, New Directions in Virtual Reality-Based Therapy for Anxiety Disorders, International Journal of Cognitive Therapy, 6, 2, (114), (2013).
- Joung Huem Kwon, John Powell and Alan Chalmers, How level of realism influences anxiety in virtual reality environments for a job interview, International Journal of Human-Computer Studies, 71, 10, (978), (2013).
- Lars‐Göran Öst and Erik Skaret, Future Research and Applications, Cognitive Behaviour Therapy for Dental Phobia and Anxiety, (221-229), (2013).
- Antonia Koskina, Iain C. Campbell and Ulrike Schmidt, Exposure therapy in eating disorders revisited, Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews, 37, 2, (193), (2013).
- E. Glotzbach-Schoon, M. Andreatta, A. Mühlberger and P. Pauli, Context conditioning in virtual reality as a model for pathological anxiety, e-Neuroforum, 19, 3, (2013).
- David Opriş, Sebastian Pintea, Azucena García‐Palacios, Cristina Botella, Ştefan Szamosközi and Daniel David, Virtual reality exposure therapy in anxiety disorders: a quantitative meta‐analysis, Depression and Anxiety, 29, 2, (85-93), (2011).
- Katharina Meyerbroeker, Mark B. Powers, Anda van Stegeren and Paul M.G. Emmelkamp, Does Yohimbine Hydrochloride Facilitate Fear Extinction in Virtual Reality Treatment of Fear of Flying A Randomized Placebo-Controlled Trial, Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics, 81, 1, (29), (2012).
- Xueni Pan, Marco Gillies, Chris Barker, David M. Clark, Mel Slater and Susana Martinez-Conde, Socially Anxious and Confident Men Interact with a Forward Virtual Woman: An Experimental Study, PLoS ONE, 7, 4, (e32931), (2012). 2012 12th International Conference on Computational Science and Its Applications (ICCSA) Salvador, Bahia, Brazil 2012 12th International Conference on Computational Science and Its Applications IEEE , (2012). 978-1-4673-1691-0 978-0-7695-4710-7 Fernando M. de Oliveira, Regina S. Lanzillotti, Rosa M.E. Moreira da Costa, Raquel Goncalves, Paula Ventura and Luis A. Vidal de Carvalho ARVET AND SAPTEPT: A Virtual Environment and a System Supported by Fuzzy Logic in Virtual Reality Exposure Therapy for PTSD Patients , (2012). 103 107 6257617 , 10.1109/ICCSA.2012.26 http://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/6257617/
- Peter M. Yellowlees, Kevin M. Holloway and Michelle Burke Parish, Therapy in Virtual Environments—Clinical and Ethical Issues, Telemedicine and e-Health, 18, 7, (558), (2012).
- Benjamin Gregor Aas, What’s Real?, Virtual Worlds and Metaverse Platforms, 10.4018/978-1-60960-854-5.ch006, (88-99)
- Raquel Gonçalves, Ana Lúcia Pedrozo, Evandro Silva Freire Coutinho, Ivan Figueira, Paula Ventura and Mel Slater, Efficacy of Virtual Reality Exposure Therapy in the Treatment of PTSD: A Systematic Review, PLoS ONE, 7, 12, (e48469), (2012).
- Marta Ferrer-García and José Gutiérrez-Maldonado, The use of virtual reality in the study, assessment, and treatment of body image in eating disorders and nonclinical samples: A review of the literature, Body Image, 9, 1, (1), (2012).
- P.M.G. Emmelkamp and K. Meyerbröker, Virtual Reality Exposure Therapie, Psychopraktijk, 3, 1, (37), (2011).
- Peter G. Mezo, Jeanna Hall, Christopher M. Duggan and Valerie A. Noël, An Initial Comparison of Live Instruction and Immersive Video Modes of Progressive Muscle Relaxation, Journal of Technology in Human Services, 29, 3, (212), (2011).
- Antoine Hone-Blanchet, Tobias Wensing and Shirley Fecteau, The Use of Virtual Reality in Craving Assessment and Cue-Exposure Therapy in Substance Use Disorders, Frontiers in Human Neuroscience, 10.3389/fnhum.2014.00844, 8, (2014).
- Cristina Botella, M. Ángeles Pérez-Ara, Juana Bretón-López, Soledad Quero, Azucena García-Palacios, Rosa María Baños and Ingmar H.A. Franken, In Vivo versus Augmented Reality Exposure in the Treatment of Small Animal Phobia: A Randomized Controlled Trial, PLOS ONE, 10.1371/journal.pone.0148237, 11, 2, (e0148237), (2016).
