The effects of a new mouthrinse containing chlorhexidine, cetylpyridinium chloride and zinc lactate on the microflora of oral halitosis patients: a dual‐centre, double‐blind placebo‐controlled study
Abstract
enAim: This study evaluated the microbial effects of a newly formulated mouthwash (Halita®) on oral halitosis patients.
Methods: Forty subjects were included in this dual‐centre, double‐blind, placebo‐controlled parallel study. Inclusion and exclusion criteria were used to select patients. At baseline and at 2 weeks post‐treatment, full‐mouth organoleptic odor scores, level of volatile sulphur compounds (VSC) and the Winkel Tongue Coating Index were recorded. Standardized samples of tongue coating, saliva and subgingival plaque were microbiologically investigated. Participants were randomly assigned to the test or placebo groups.
Results: High prevalences were observed for Fusobacterium nucleatum, Prevotella intermedia and Porphyromonas gingivalis in tongue coating, saliva and subgingival plaque samples. A significant positive correlation between baseline total counts of P. gingivalis in saliva samples and organoleptic and VSC scores was found. Two weeks post‐treatment there was a reduction in total anaerobic counts in all samples in the test group. A significant positive correlation was observed between the reduction in total counts in saliva samples and the reduction in organoleptic scores in the test group. Significant reductions in total counts and proportions of F. nucleatum and total counts of P. intermedia in tongue coating samples were observed in the test group.
Conclusions: The test mouthwash demonstrated efficacy in reducing the microbiological parameters in three oral niches in moderate to severe halitosis patients without periodontitis, and this was correlated with the improvements in organoleptic and VSC scores but not with the tongue coating scores.
Zusammenfassung
deDie Effekte einer neuen Chlorhexidin, Cetylpyridinchlorid und Zinklaktat enthaltenden Mundspülung auf die Mikroflora von Patienten mit oraler Halitosis: eine Zweizentren doppelt blinde und mit Placebo kontrollierte Studie
Ziel: Diese Studie überprüfte die mikrobiologischen Effekte eines neu zusammengesetzten Mundwassers (Halita®) bei Patienten mit oraler Halitosis.
Methoden: 40 Personen wurden in diese Zweizentrenstudie, die doppelt blind und mit Placebo parallel kontrolliert war, einbezogen. Einschluss‐ und Ausschlusskriterien wurden bei der Auswahl der Patienten genutzt. Zur Basis und 2 Wochen nach der Behandlung wurden ein Mundodor Score, der Level von volatilen Schwefelbestandteilen (VSC) und der Winkel Zungenbelagindex aufgezeichnet. Standardisierte Proben des Zungenbelags, des Speichels und der subgingivalen Plaque wurden mikrobiologisch untersucht. Die Teilnehmer wurden zufällig zu der Test‐oder der Placebogruppe zugeordnet.
Ergebnisse: Eine hohe Prävalenz von Fusobacterium nucleatum, Prevotella intermedia und Porphyromonas gingivalis wurde im Zungenbelag, im Speichel und in den subgingivalen Plaqueproben beobachtet. Eine signifikante positive Korrelation zwischen dem totalen Gehalt von P. gingivalis zur Basis im Speichel, den organoleptischen und VSC Werten wurde gefunden. Zwei Wochen nach der Behandlung war eine Reduktion im totalen anaeroben Bakteriengehalt in allen Proben der Testgruppe zu beobachten. Eine signifikante positive Korrelation wurde zwischen der Reduktion im totalen Gehalt in den Speichelproben und der Reduktion in den organoleptischen Werten in der Testgruppe beobachtet. Eine signifikante Reduktion im totalen Gehalt und den Proportionen von F. nucleatum und dem totalen Gehalt von P. intermedia im Zungenbelag wurde in der Testgruppe beobachtet.
Schlussfolgerungen: Das getestete Mundwasser demonstrierte die Effizienz in der Reduktion der mikrobiologischen Parameter in drei oralen Nischen bei Patienten mit moderater bis schwerer Halitosis ohne Parodontitis. Diese Ergebnisse waren korreliert mit der Verbesserung der organoleptischen und VSC Werte, aber nicht mit den Werten des Zungenbelags.
Resumé
frEffets d'un nouveau bain de bouche contenant de la chlorhexidine, du chlorure de cétylpyridinium et du lactacte de zinc sur la microflore de patients présentant une halitose : une étude contrôlée en double aveugle
Cette étude a évalué les effets microbiens d'une nouvelle solution (Halita®) chez des patients présentant une halitose. Quarante patients ont été inclus dans cette étude parallèle, contrôlée, en double aveugle, effectuée dans deux centres. Des critères d'inclusion et d'exclusion ont été utilisés pour sélectionner les patients. Lors de l'examen initial et deux semaines après le traitement, les scores d'odeur organoleptique de toute la bouche, le niveau des composés sulfure volatiles (VSC) et l'indice de langue chargée de Winkel ont été enregistrés. Des échantillons standardisés du recouvrement de la langue, de la salive et de la plaque sous‐gingivale ont été analysés microbiologiquement. Les patients ont été répartis de manière randomisée dans les groupes test et placebo. Des fréquences globales élevées ont été observées pour le Fusobacterium nucleatum, le Prevotella intermedia et le Porphyromonas gingivalis sur la langue, dans la salive et dans les échantillons de plaque sous‐gingivale. Une relation positive significative existait entre les comptages totaux lors de l'examen initial de P. gingivalis dans les échantillons de salive et les scores VSC et organoleptiques. Deux semaines après le traitement, une réduction dans les comptages anaéorobies totaux dans tous les échantillons du groupe test a été constatée. Une relation positive significative a été observée entre la réduction des comptages totaux dans les échantillons salivaires et la réduction des scores organoleptiques dans le groupe test. Des réductions significatives dans les comptages totaux et les proportions de F. nucleatum et les comptages totaux de P. intermedia dans les échantillons provenant de la langue ont été observés dans le groupe test. Le bain de bouche test a démontré son efficacitéà réduire les paramètres microbiologiques dans trois niches buccales chez des patients avec halitose modérée à sévère sans parodontite, d'où la corrélation avec les améliorations des scores organoleptiques et VSC et non avec les scores de l'indice de langue chargée.
Number of times cited: 57
- E Van der Sluijs, GA Van der Weijden, NL Hennequin‐Hoenderdos and DE Slot, The effect of a tooth/tongue gel and mouthwash regimen on morning oral malodour, International Journal of Dental Hygiene, 16, 1, (92-102), (2017).
- Jeong Hyun Kang, Dae Jeong Kim, Bong Kyu Choi and Ji Woon Park, Inhibition of malodorous gas formation by oral bacteria with cetylpyridinium and zinc chloride, Archives of Oral Biology, 84, (133), (2017).
- M García‐Gargallo, M Zurlohe, E Montero, B Alonso, J Serrano, M Sanz and D Herrera, Evaluation of new chlorhexidine‐ and cetylpyridinium chloride‐based mouthrinse formulations adjunctive to scaling and root planing: pilot study, International Journal of Dental Hygiene, 15, 4, (269-279), (2016).
- Yufeng Zheng, Xiaoxue Xu, Zhigang Xu, Junqiang Wang and Hong Cai, Introduction of the Biofunctions into Traditional Metallic Biomaterials, Metallic Biomaterials, (31-57), (2017).
- N Fujiwara, K Murakami, M Nakao, M Toguchi, H Yumoto, T Amoh, K Hirota, T Matsuo, S Sano, K Ozaki and Y Miyake, Novel reuterin‐related compounds suppress odour by periodontopathic bacteria, Oral Diseases, 23, 4, (492-497), (2017).
- S Saad, P Gomez-Pereira, K Hewett, P Horstman, J Patel and J Greenman, Daily reduction of oral malodor with the use of a sonic tongue brush combined with an antibacterial tongue spray in a randomized cross-over clinical investigation, Journal of Breath Research, 10, 1, (016013), (2016).
- S Erovic Ademovski, P Lingström and S Renvert, The effect of different mouth rinse products on intra‐oral halitosis, International Journal of Dental Hygiene, 14, 2, (117-123), (2015).
- L Mendes, J Coimbra, AL Pereira, M Resende and MG Pinto, Comparative effect of a new mouthrinse containing chlorhexidine, triclosan and zinc on volatile sulphur compounds: a randomized, crossover, double‐blind study, International Journal of Dental Hygiene, 14, 3, (202-208), (2015).
- Mohamed Sultan and James H. Lewis, Miscellaneous Upper Gastrointestinal Symptoms, Practical Gastroenterology and Hepatology Board Review Toolkit, (56-69), (2016).
- Hee Jung Son and Hae Sook Hong, The Effects of S-solution and A-solution on Oral Health in Preschool Children, Journal of Korean Biological Nursing Science, 17, 2, (150), (2015).
- Magda Feres, Luciene Cristina Figueiredo, Marcelo Faveri, Marcelo C. Guerra, Luis R. Mateo, Bernal Stewart, Malcolm Williams and Foti Panagakos, The efficacy of two oral hygiene regimens in reducing oral malodour: a randomised clinical trial, International Dental Journal, 65, 6, (292-302), (2015).
- Dagmar E. Slot, Sophie De Geest, Fridus A. Weijden and Marc Quirynen, Treatment of oral malodour. Medium‐term efficacy of mechanical and/or chemical agents: a systematic review, Journal of Clinical Periodontology, 42, S16, (S303-S316), (2015).
- Sung-Hoon Lee and Dong-Heon Baek, Effects of Streptococcus thermophilus on volatile sulfur compounds produced by Porphyromonas gingivalis, Archives of Oral Biology, 59, 11, (1205), (2014).
- Ju-Sik Kim, Ji-Woon Park, Dae-Jung Kim, Young-Ku Kim and Jeong-Yun Lee, Direct effect of chlorine dioxide, zinc chloride and chlorhexidine solution on the gaseous volatile sulfur compounds, Acta Odontologica Scandinavica, 72, 8, (645), (2014).
- Taruna Singh, Sheikh Shreaz and Athar Adil Hashmi, Synthesis of Sunflower Oil Based Bimetallic Polymer and Its Antifungal Studies, International Journal of Polymeric Materials, 10.1080/00914037.2013.769168, 62, 12, (653-662), (2013).
- S. Saad, K. Hewett and J. Greenman, Use of an in vitro flat-bed biofilm model to measure biologically active anti-odour compounds, Applied Microbiology and Biotechnology, 97, 17, (7865), (2013).
- A. D. Apatzidou, E. Bakirtzoglou, I. Vouros, V. Karagiannis, A. Papa and A. Konstantinidis, Association between oral malodour and periodontal disease-related parameters in the general population, Acta Odontologica Scandinavica, 71, 1, (189), (2013).
- F Siena, M Del Fabbro, S Corbella, S Taschieri and R Weinstein, Evaluation of chlorhexidine 0.05% with the adjunct of fluoride 0.05% in the inhibition of plaque formation: a double blind, crossover, plaque regrowth study, International Journal of Dental Hygiene, 11, 3, (186-190), (2012).
- GC Raangs, EG Winkel and AJ Winkelhoff, In vitro antimicrobial effects of two antihalitosis mouth rinses on oral pathogens and human tongue microbiota, International Journal of Dental Hygiene, 11, 3, (203-207), (2013).
- Jesica Dadamio, Marie Van Tournout, Wim Teughels, Christel Dekeyser, Wim Coucke and Marc Quirynen, Efficacy of different mouthrinse formulations in reducing oral malodour: a randomized clinical trial, Journal of Clinical Periodontology, 40, 5, (505), (2013).
- Yuka Makino, Takayuki Yamaga, Akihiro Yoshihara, Kaname Nohno and Hideo Miyazaki, Association Between Volatile Sulfur Compounds and Periodontal Disease Progression in Elderly Non‐Smokers, Journal of Periodontology, 83, 5, (635-643), (2012).
- K Nohno, T Yamaga, N Kaneko and H Miyazaki, Tablets containing a cysteine protease, actinidine, reduce oral malodor: a crossover study, Journal of Breath Research, 6, 1, (017107), (2012).
- C Scully and J Greenman, Halitology (breath odour: aetiopathogenesis and management), Oral Diseases, 18, 4, (333-345), (2012).
- T Blom, DE Slot, M Quirynen and GA Van der Weijden, The effect of mouthrinses on oral malodor: a systematic review, International Journal of Dental Hygiene, 10, 3, (209-222), (2012).
- S Saad, K Hewett and J Greenman, Effect of mouth-rinse formulations on oral malodour processes in tongue-derived perfusion biofilm model, Journal of Breath Research, 6, 1, (016001), (2012).
- S Saad, J Greenman and H Shaw, Comparative effects of various commercially available mouthrinse formulations on oral malodour, Oral Diseases, 17, 2, (180-186), (2010).
- Neil Poulter, Matthew Donaldson, Geraldine Mulley, Luis Duque, Nicholas Waterfield, Alex G. Shard, Steve Spencer, A. Tobias A. Jenkins and Andrew L. Johnson, Plasma deposited metal Schiff-base compounds as antimicrobials, New Journal of Chemistry, 35, 7, (1477), (2011).
- Walter A. Bretz, Aaron Biesbrock, Patricia M. Corby, Andrea L. Corby, Walter G. Bretz, Jennifer Wessel and Nicholas J. Schork, Environmental and Genetic Contributions to Indicators of Oral Malodor in Twins, Twin Research and Human Genetics, 14, 06, (568), (2011).
- Kouichirou Shin, Ken Yaegaki, Takatoshi Murata, Hisataka Ii, Tomoko Tanaka, Izumi Aoyama, Koji Yamauchi, Tomohiro Toida and Keiji Iwatsuki, Effects of a composition containing lactoferrin and lactoperoxidase on oral malodor and salivary bacteria: a randomized, double-blind, crossover, placebo-controlled clinical trial, Clinical Oral Investigations, 15, 4, (485), (2011).
- Marta Escribano, David Herrera, Sergio Morante, Wim Teughels, Marc Quirynen and Mariano Sanz, Efficacy of a low‐concentration chlorhexidine mouth rinse in non‐compliant periodontitis patients attending a supportive periodontal care programme: a randomized clinical trial, Journal of Clinical Periodontology, 37, 3, (266-275), (2010).
- W Wigger-Alberti, K Gysen, E-M Axmann and K-P Wilhelm, Efficacy of a new mouthrinse formulation on the reduction of oral malodourin vivo.A randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled, 3 week clinical study, Journal of Breath Research, 4, 1, (017102), (2010).
- D Wilhelm, K Gysen, A Himmelmann, C Krause and K-P Wilhelm, Short-term effect of a new mouthrinse formulation on oral malodour after single usein vivo: a comparative, randomized, single-blind, parallel-group clinical study, Journal of Breath Research, 4, 3, (036002), (2010).
- N. Lourith and M. Kanlayavattanakul, Review Article: Oral malodour and active ingredients for treatment, International Journal of Cosmetic Science, 32, 5, (321-329), (2010).
- Satish K.S. Kumar and Gerald Byrne, Some Evidence Shows that Certain Mouthrinses Can Reduce Halitosis, The Journal of the American Dental Association, 141, 8, (1008), (2010).
- Ganesh R. Veerappan and James H. Lewis, Halitosis, Practical Gastroenterology and Hepatology: Esophagus and Stomach, (188-192), (2010).
- Isabelle Schaefer and Bert Braumann, Halitosis, Oral Health and Quality of Life during Treatment with Invisalign® and the Effect of a Low-dose Chlorhexidine Solution, Journal of Orofacial Orthopedics / Fortschritte der Kieferorthopädie, 71, 6, (430), (2010).
- Muneo Tanaka, Masahiro Toe, Hideki Nagata, Miki Ojima, Masae Kuboniwa, Katsumasa Shimizu, Kenji Osawa and Satoshi Shizukuishi, Effect of Eucalyptus‐Extract Chewing Gum on Oral Malodor: A Double‐Masked, Randomized Trial, Journal of Periodontology, 81, 11, (1564-1571), (2010).
- Eun-Kyoung Choi, Hye-Hyang Lee, Mi-Sun Kang, Byung-Gook Kim, Hoi-Soon Lim, Seon-Mi Kim and In-Chol Kang, Potentiation of bacterial killing activity of zinc chloride by pyrrolidine dithiocarbamate, The Journal of Microbiology, 48, 1, (40), (2010).
- Kayoko Shinada, Masayuki Ueno, Chisato Konishi, Sachiko Takehara, Sayaka Yokoyama, Takashi Zaitsu, Mari Ohnuki, Fredrick Allan Clive Wright and Yoko Kawaguchi, Effects of a mouthwash with chlorine dioxide on oral malodor and salivary bacteria: a randomized placebo-controlled 7-day trial, Trials, 11, 1, (2010).
- AMWT Van Den Broek, L Feenstra and C De Baat, A review of the current literature on management of halitosis, Oral Diseases, 14, 1, (30-39), (2007).
- Kayoko Shinada, Masayuki Ueno, Chisato Konishi, Sachiko Takehara, Sayaka Yokoyama and Yoko Kawaguchi, A randomized double blind crossover placebo-controlled clinical trial to assess the effects of a mouthwash containing chlorine dioxide on oral malodor, Trials, 9, 1, (2008).
- N. Silva, M. Gajardo and A. Quintero, Bacilos Gram Negativos No Fastidiosos en la Microbiota Subgingival y Lingual en un Grupo de Pacientes Chilenos con Periodontitis, Revista Clínica de Periodoncia, Implantología y Rehabilitación Oral, 1, 1, (5), (2008).
- Hidayet Burak Polat, Hakan Özdemir and Sinan Ay, Effect of different mouth rinses on third molar surgery–related oral malodor, Oral Surgery, Oral Medicine, Oral Pathology, Oral Radiology, and Endodontology, 105, 3, (e1), (2008).
- Crispian Scully and John Greenman, Halitosis (breath odor), Periodontology 2000, 48, 1, (66-75), (2008).
- Kouichirou Shin, Ayako Horigome, Hiroyuki Wakabayashi, Koji Yamauchi, Tomoko Yaeshima and Keiji Iwatsuki, In vitroandin vivoeffects of a composition containing lactoperoxidase on oral bacteria and breath odor, Journal of Breath Research, 2, 1, (017014), (2008).
- José Roberto Cortelli, Mônica Dourado Silva Barbosa and Miriam Ardigó Westphal, Halitosis: a review of associated factors and therapeutic approach, Brazilian Oral Research, 22, suppl 1, (44), (2008).
- G. Rutger Persson, Justin Yeates, Rigmor E. Persson, Regula Hirschi‐Imfeld, Marianne Weibel and H. Asuman Kiyak, The Impact of a Low‐Frequency Chlorhexidine Rinsing Schedule on the Subgingival Microbiota (the TEETH clinical trial), Journal of Periodontology, 78, 9, (1751-1758), (2007).
- Eun-Kyung Jung, Antimicrobial Activity of Extract and Fractions from Drynaria fortunei Against Oral Bacteria, Journal of Bacteriology and Virology, 37, 2, (61), (2007).
- AC Donaldson, MP Riggio, HJ Rolph, J Bagg and PJ Hodge, Clinical examination of subjects with halitosis, Oral Diseases, 13, 1, (63-70), (2006).
- Marcelo Faveri, Mitsue F. Hayacibara, Giselle Cancine Pupio, Jaime A. Cury, Claudia Ota Tsuzuki and Roberto M. Hayacibara, A cross‐over study on the effect of various therapeutic approaches to morning breath odour, Journal of Clinical Periodontology, 33, 8, (555-560), (2006).
- Marcelo Faveri, Magda Feres, Jamil Awad Shibli, Roberto F. Hayacibara, Mitsue M. Hayacibara and Luciene Cristina de Figueiredo, Microbiota of the Dorsum of the Tongue After Plaque Accumulation: An Experimental Study in Humans, Journal of Periodontology, 77, 9, (1539-1546), (2006).
- F. Yesim Bozkurt, Mine Öztürk and Zuhal Yetkin, The Effects of Three Oral Sprays on Plaque and Gingival Inflammation, Journal of Periodontology, 76, 10, (1654-1660), (2005).
- David Herrera, Sagrario Santos, Jorge Ferrús, Germán Barbieri, Leonardo Trombelli and Mariano Sanz, Efficacy of a 0.15% benzydamine hydrochloride and 0.05% cetylpyridinium chloride mouth rinse on 4‐day de novo plaque formation, Journal of Clinical Periodontology, 32, 6, (595-603), (2005).
- Silvia Roldán, David Herrera, Ana O'Connor, Itziar González and Mariano Sanz, A Combined Therapeutic Approach to Manage Oral Halitosis: A 3‐Month Prospective Case Series, Journal of Periodontology, 76, 6, (1025-1033), (2005).
- Silvia Roldán, David Herrera, Isabel Santa‐Cruz, Ana O'Connor, Itziar González and Mariano Sanz, Comparative effects of different chlorhexidine mouth‐rinse formulations on volatile sulphur compounds and salivary bacterial counts, Journal of Clinical Periodontology, 31, 12, (1128-1134), (2004).
- P.K. Sreenivasan and E. Gittins, The effects of a chlorhexidine mouthrinse on culturable microorganisms of the tongue and saliva, Microbiological Research, 159, 4, (365), (2004).
- Sagrario Santos, David Herrera, Elsa Lopez, Ana O'Connor, Itziar Gonzalez and Mariano Sanz, A randomized clinical trial on the short-term clinical and microbiological effects of the adjunctive use of a 0.05% chlorhexidine mouth rinse for patients in supportive periodontal care, Journal of Clinical Periodontology, 31, 1, (45), (2004).




