Does population ecology have general laws?
Abstract
There is a widespread opinion among ecologists that ecology lacks general laws. In this paper I argue that this opinion is mistaken. Taking the case of population dynamics, I point out that there are several very general law‐like propositions that provide the theoretical basis for most population dynamics models that were developed to address specific issues. Some of these foundational principles, like the law of exponential growth, are logically very similar to certain laws of physics (Newton's law of inertia, for example, is almost a direct analogue of exponential growth). I discuss two other principles (population self‐limitation and resource‐consumer oscillations), as well as the more elementary postulates that underlie them. None of the “laws” that I propose for population ecology are new. Collectively ecologists have been using these general principles in guiding development of their models and experiments since the days of Lotka, Volterra, and Gause.
Number of times cited: 74
- David Hammer, Julia Gouvea and Jessica Watkins, Idiosyncratic cases and hopes for general validity: what education research might learn from ecology / Casos idiosincrásicos y expectativas de validez general: lo que la investigación en educación puede aprender de la ecología, Infancia y Aprendizaje, 10.1080/02103702.2018.1504887, 41, 4, (625-673), (2018).
- Antoni Margalida, Pilar Oliva-Vidal, Alfonso Llamas and Mª Àngels Colomer, Bioinspired models for assessing the importance of transhumance and transboundary management in the conservation of European avian scavengers, Biological Conservation, 10.1016/j.biocon.2018.11.004, 228, (321-330), (2018).
- Pitágoras A. Piana, Bárbara F. Cardoso, Joilson Dias, Luiz C. Gomes, Angelo A. Agostinho and Leandro E. Miranda, Using long-term data to predict fish abundance: the case of Prochilodus lineatus (Characiformes, Prochilodontidae) in the intensely regulated upper Paraná River, Neotropical Ichthyology, 15, 3, (2017).
- Pablo Antúnez, Christian Wehenkel, Carlos A. López-Sánchez and José C. Hernández-Díaz, The Role of Climatic Variables for Estimating Probability of Abundance of Tree Species, Polish Journal of Ecology, 65, 3, (324), (2017).
- Stefanie A. Hartmann, Steffen Oppel, Gernot Segelbacher, Mery E. Juiña and H. Martin Schaefer, Decline in territory size and fecundity as a response to carrying capacity in an endangered songbird, Oecologia, 183, 2, (597), (2017).
- Lixian Zhang, Ting Yang and Patrizio Colaneri, Stability and Stabilization of Semi-Markov Jump Linear Systems With Exponentially Modulated Periodic Distributions of Sojourn Time, IEEE Transactions on Automatic Control, 62, 6, (2870), (2017).
- Mark Sagoff, Theoretical ecology has never been etiological: A reply to Donhauser, Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences, 63, (64), (2017).
- Luke Fenton‐Glynn, Ceteris Paribus Laws and Minutis Rectis Laws, Philosophy and Phenomenological Research, 93, 2, (274-305), (2016).
- Burt P. Kotler, Joel S. Brown, Sonny S. Bleicher and Keren Embar, Intercontinental-wide consequences of compromise-breaking adaptations: the case of desert rodents, Israel Journal of Ecology & Evolution, 62, 3-4, (186), (2016).
- Joel S. Brown, Why Darwin would have loved evolutionary game theory, Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, 283, 1838, (20160847), (2016).
- Patrick Mimphis Tchepmo Djomegni and Kevin Jan Duffy, Multi-dynamics of travelling bands and pattern formation in a predator-prey model with cubic growth, Advances in Difference Equations, 2016, 1, (2016).
- Lixian Zhang, Songlin Zhuang and Richard D. Braatz, Switched model predictive control of switched linear systems: Feasibility, stability and robustness, Automatica, 67, (8), (2016).
- Hiroshi Takaichi and Tomonori Kawano, Expanded and Practical Use of Logistic Equations in Eco-Toxicity Evaluation: Cases of Lethal Metal Toxicity Curves in Green Paramecia with Minimal-Sized Experiments, Journal of Advanced Computational Intelligence and Intelligent Informatics, 20, 5, (681), (2016).
- Christian O. Marks and Charles D. Canham, A quantitative framework for demographic trends in size‐structured populations: analysis of threats to floodplain forests, Ecosphere, 6, 11, (1-55), (2015).
- Michael Deveau, Richard Karsten and Holger Teismann, The Modellers’ Halting Foray into Ecological Theory: Or, What is This Thing Called ‘Growth Rate’?, Acta Biotheoretica, 63, 2, (99), (2015).
- Iddo Eliazar, Growth and inequality, Physica A: Statistical Mechanics and its Applications, 437, (457), (2015).
- Edina Lengyel, Judit Padisák and Csilla Stenger-Kovács, Establishment of equilibrium states and effect of disturbances on benthic diatom assemblages of the Torna-stream, Hungary, Hydrobiologia, 750, 1, (43), (2015).
- Nicolas W.R. Lapointe, Steven J. Cooke, Jack G. Imhof, Daniel Boisclair, John M. Casselman, R. Allen Curry, Otto E. Langer, Robert L. McLaughlin, Charles K. Minns, John R. Post, Michael Power, Joseph B. Rasmussen, John D. Reynolds, John S. Richardson and William M. Tonn, Principles for ensuring healthy and productive freshwater ecosystems that support sustainable fisheries, Environmental Reviews, 10.1139/er-2013-0038, 22, 2, (110-134), (2014).
- Jorge Horvath, Towards a Mathematical Description of Biodiversity Evolution, Challenges, 5, 2, (324), (2014).
- Cedric Puleston, Shripad Tuljapurkar, Bruce Winterhalder and Kathleen A. O'Connor, The Invisible Cliff: Abrupt Imposition of Malthusian Equilibrium in a Natural-Fertility, Agrarian Society, PLoS ONE, 9, 1, (e87541), (2014).
- Gimme Walter and Rob Hengeveld, References, Autecology, 10.1201/b16805-14, (385-440), (2014).
- Viorel Pâslaru, The mechanistic approach of The Theory of Island Biogeography and its current relevance, Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences, 45, (22), (2014).
- Martha M. Ellis and Mark Rees, Evidence for transient dynamics in plant populations based on long‐term demographic data, Journal of Ecology, 101, 3, (734-742), (2013).
- Jean‐Dominique Lebreton and Olivier Gimenez, Detecting and estimating density dependence in wildlife populations, The Journal of Wildlife Management, 77, 1, (12-23), (2012).
- Christopher K. Williams, Accounting for wildlife life‐history strategies when modeling stochastic density‐dependent populations: A review, The Journal of Wildlife Management, 77, 1, (4-11), (2012).
- Máurea Nicoletti Flynn and William Roberto Luiz Silva Pereira, Ecological model of competitive interaction among three species of amphipods associated to Bryocladia thrysigera (J. Agardh) and extreme environmental stress effects, Nauplius, 21, 1, (01), (2013).
- C. Athena Aktipis, Amy M. Boddy, Robert A. Gatenby, Joel S. Brown and Carlo C. Maley, Life history trade-offs in cancer evolution, Nature Reviews Cancer, 13, 12, (883), (2013).
- David M. Choate, Chelse M. Prather, Matt J. Michel, Ashley K. Baldridge, Matthew A. Barnes, David Hoekman, Christopher J. Patrick, Janine Rüegg and Todd A. Crowl, Integrating Theoretical Components: A Graphical Model for Graduate Students and Researchers, BioScience, 62, 6, (594), (2012).
- Xanic J. Rondon, Graeme S. Cumming, Rosa E. Cossío and Jane Southworth, The Effects of Selective Logging Behaviors on Forest Fragmentation and Recovery, International Journal of Forestry Research, 2012, (1), (2012).
- Fuke Wu and G. Yin, Environmental noise impact on regularity and extinction of population systems with infinite delay, Journal of Mathematical Analysis and Applications, 396, 2, (772), (2012).
- Marvin Chester, A law of nature?, Open Journal of Ecology, 01, 03, (77), (2011).
- Jani Raerinne, Causal and Mechanistic Explanations in Ecology, Acta Biotheoretica, 59, 3-4, (251), (2011).
- Fuke Wu and Shigeng Hu, Stochastic suppression and stabilization of delay differential systems, International Journal of Robust and Nonlinear Control, 21, 5, (488-500), (2010).
- Miguel Á. Olalla‐Tárraga, “Nullius in Bergmann” or the pluralistic approach to ecogeographical rules: a reply to Watt et al. (2010), Oikos, 120, 10, (1441-1444), (2011).
- Aaron M Ellison and Brian Dennis, Paths to statistical fluency for ecologists, Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment, 8, 7, (362-370), (2009).
- Ranjit Kumar Upadhyay and V. Sree Hari Rao, Short-term recurrent chaos and role of Toxin Producing Phytoplankton (TPP) on chaotic dynamics in aquatic systems, Chaos, Solitons & Fractals, 39, 4, (1550), (2009).
- Robert D. Holt, IJEE Soapbox, Israel Journal of Ecology & Evolution, 55, 3, (189), (2009). 2008 Mexican International Conference on Computer Science (ENC) Mexicali, Mexico 2008 Mexican International Conference on Computer Science IEEE , (2008). 978-0-7695-3439-8 Cecilia Leal Ramirez, Antonio Rodriguez Diaz and Oscar Castillo Fuzzy Cellular Model Applied to the Dynamics of a Uni-Specific Population Induced by Environment Variations , (2008). 211 220 4653256 , 10.1109/ENC.2008.22 http://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/4653256/
- Daniel Fortin, Douglas W. Morris and Philip D. McLoughlin, Habitat Selection and the Evolution of Specialists in Heterogeneous Environments, Israel Journal of Ecology & Evolution, 54, 3-4, (311), (2008).
- P. Vadasz and A.S. Vadasz, Microbial Models, Encyclopedia of Ecology, 10.1016/B978-008045405-4.00212-3, (2369-2389), (2008).
- Vera Istvánovics, The Role of Biota in Shaping the Phosphorus Cycle in Lakes, Freshwater Reviews, 1, 2, (143), (2008).
- Raphaël Proulx and Lael Parrott, Measures of structural complexity in digital images for monitoring the ecological signature of an old-growth forest ecosystem, Ecological Indicators, 8, 3, (270), (2008).
- Alan Hastings, Editorial – an ecological theory journal at last, Theoretical Ecology, 1, 1, (1), (2008).
- R.W. Wright, The geometry of transient crashes and their dependence on demographic rates, Theoretical Population Biology, 73, 2, (300), (2008).
- Samuel M. Scheiner and Michael R. Willig, A general theory of ecology, Theoretical Ecology, 1, 1, (21), (2008).
- Norman Owen‐Smith, The refuge concept extends to plants as well: storage, buffers and regrowth in variable environments, Oikos, 117, 4, (481-483), (2008).
- Norman Owen-Smith, The refuge concept extends to plants as well: storage, buffers and regrowth in variable environments, Oikos, 0, 0, (080211051304426), (2008).
- Mark Colyvan, Population Ecology, A Companion to the Philosophy of Biology, (301-320), (2008).
- Eric M. Schauber, Brett J. Goodwin, Clive G. Jones and Richard S. Ostfeld, SPATIAL SELECTION AND INHERITANCE: APPLYING EVOLUTIONARY CONCEPTS TO POPULATION DYNAMICS IN HETEROGENEOUS SPACE, Ecology, 88, 5, (1112-1118), (2007).
- Robert J. Cabin, Science and Restoration Under a Big, Demon Haunted Tent: Reply to Giardina et al. (2007), Restoration Ecology, 15, 3, (377-381), (2007).
- Sébastien Barot, Manuel Blouin, Sébastien Fontaine, Pascal Jouquet, Jean-Christophe Lata, Jérôme Mathieu and Minna-Liisa Rantalainen, A Tale of Four Stories: Soil Ecology, Theory, Evolution and the Publication System, PLoS ONE, 2, 11, (e1248), (2007).
- Lev R. Ginzburg, Christopher X.J. Jensen and Jeffrey V. Yule, Aiming the “unreasonable effectiveness of mathematics” at ecological theory, Ecological Modelling, 207, 2-4, (356), (2007).
- Giacomo Tavecchia, Roger Pradel, Meritxell Genovart and Daniel Oro, Density‐dependent parameters and demographic equilibrium in open populations, Oikos, 116, 9, (1481-1492), (2007).
- , Literature Cited, Ecological Understanding, 10.1016/B978-012554522-8.50012-1, (207-223), (2007).
- Norman Owen-Smith and M. G. L. Mills, MANIFOLD INTERACTIVE INFLUENCES ON THE POPULATION DYNAMICS OF A MULTISPECIES UNGULATE ASSEMBLAGE, Ecological Monographs, 76, 1, (73-92), (2006).
- Marc Lange, Ecological laws: what would they be and why would they matter?, Oikos, 110, 2, (394-403), (2005).
- Mark Colyvan, Probability and Ecological Complexity, Biology & Philosophy, 20, 4, (869), (2005).
- P F Góra, Population explosion suppressed by noise: stationary distributions and how to simulate them, New Journal of Physics, 7, (36), (2005).
- James R. Bell, THE EMERGENCE OF MANIPULATIVE EXPERIMENTS IN ECOLOGICAL SPIDER RESEARCH (1684–1973), Journal of Arachnology, 33, 3, (826), (2005).
- Luis Acerenza and Hugo Fort, A model for the relationship between the interaction pattern of ecosystems and their fate, Ecological Modelling, 184, 2-4, (203), (2005).
- Norman Owen‐Smith, Incorporating fundamental laws of biology and physics into population ecology: the metaphysiological approach, Oikos, 111, 3, (611-615), (2005).
- R. B. O'Hara, The anarchist's guide to ecological theory. Or, we don't need no stinkin’ laws, Oikos, 110, 2, (390-393), (2005).
- Alan G. Hildrew, Guy Woodward, Julie H. Winterbottom and Stuart Orton, Strong density dependence in a predatory insect: large‐scale experiments in a stream, Journal of Animal Ecology, 73, 3, (448-458), (2004).
- James H. Brown, James F. Gillooly, Andrew P. Allen, Van M. Savage and Geoffrey B. West, TOWARD A METABOLIC THEORY OF ECOLOGY, Ecology, 85, 7, (1771-1789), (2004).
- Alan K. Knapp, Melinda D. Smith, Scott L. Collins, Nick Zambatis, Mike Peel, Sarah Emery, Jeremy Wojdak, M Claire Horner-Devine, Harry Biggs, Judith Kruger and Sandy J. Andelman, Generality in ecology: testing North American grassland rules in South African savannas, Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment, 2, 9, (483-491), (2004).
- Van M. Savage, James F. Gillooly, James H. Brown, Geoffrey B. West and Eric L. Charnov, Effects of Body Size and Temperature on Population Growth, The American Naturalist, 163, 3, (429), (2004).
- J. M. Elliott, Contrasting dynamics in two subpopulations of a leech metapopulation over 25 year‐classes in a small stream, Journal of Animal Ecology, 73, 2, (272-282), (2004).
- A.A. Berryman, On principles, laws and theory in population ecology, Oikos, 103, 3, (695-701), (2003).
- Mark Colyvan and Lev R. Ginzburg, The Galilean turn in population ecology, Biology & Philosophy, 18, 3, (401), (2003).
- Douglas W. Morris, Shadows of predation: habitat-selecting consumers eclipse competition between coexisting prey, Evolutionary Ecology, 17, 4, (393), (2003).
- M. Colyvan and L. R. Ginzburg, Laws of nature and laws of ecology, Oikos, 101, 3, (649-653), (2003).
- L. Hansson, Why ecology fails at application: should we consider variability more than regularity?, Oikos, 100, 3, (624-627), (2003).
- Patricio A. Camus and Facultad De Ciencias, Populations, metapopulations, and the open‐closed dilemma: the conflict between operational and natural population concepts, Oikos, 97, 3, (433-438), (2002).
- Mark A. Hixon, Stephen W. Pacala and Stuart A. Sandin, POPULATION REGULATION: HISTORICAL CONTEXT AND CONTEMPORARY CHALLENGES OF OPEN VS. CLOSED SYSTEMS, Ecology, 83, 6, (1490-1508), (2002).




